Madden NFL 22 Review: 4 Ups & 5 Downs
Stunning leap onto next-gen consoles or just the same old Madden? Time to find out.
Technically, next-gen Madden launched last year, but series fans had their eyes on Madden 22 as the first "true" leap onto PS5 and Xbox Series X/S. EA's team has had a bit longer to fiddle about with the hardware and enhance their long-running NFL franchise.
Speaking of.
Franchise Mode has been upgraded for the first time in a decade or so. Is that enough to make 22 must-play? That depends on what type of player you are. Simulation-lovers will be able to squeeze more from the single-player/offline experience, but they're not really EA's main focus. Ultimate Team and other, more arcade-friendly modes like The Yard and Superstar KO still take priority; that's nowhere near as bad as it might sound to some. No, honestly.
There is fun to be had for the singletons out there though, and Madden's refined gameplay often makes on-the-field action more varied than it was before. Several key additions (literally) shake up each snap, and there's a better reflection of real-life stadium atmosphere overall.
Although not everything is perfect (or even ideal), this is an annual sports title - major innovations are rare in this world...
Downs...
5. Face Of The Franchise
Face Of The Franchise is the main story mode, but think of this year's version as a glorified tutorial that's designed to show you the ropes more than dazzle with player choice. It's a largely on-rails experience, but therein lies the problem: EA's need to craft a cheesy sports movie story strips FOTF of meaningful key decisions.
Any decisions made are inconsequential and only really determine where XP lands. That'd be fine if the whole thing wasn't presented as some deep, immersive banner feature. It's not all bad, in fairness - being able to play on the defensive side of the ball is a nice step. It's just...well, the mode feels rather hollow, and it pretty much turns into standard Franchise once your hopeful gets drafted.
Exactly none of the main characters are all that likeable either, which is a problem. Your player comes across as the flimsy 'outgoing jock with a heart deep down', and his backup cast (agent Jordan Wright and brand manager Zo) are equally as grating.
Also, there's a weird moment when you play a Yard-style pickup game with real NFL stars under the guise of some elite training camp.
4. Commentary
Man, change this.
Brandon Gaudin and Charles Davis are as charming as ever, but their banter is seriously old hat now. This player leapt right into the options menu to turn their in-game commentary off after just one exhibition snap. That makes it sound like the comms are crap. They're not, but they're definitely boring after years of same-y dialogue.
EA have to start thinking about adding in a secondary duo for the Playoffs or Super Bowl. Hearing Gaudin welcome viewers to the action using the same lines is dull, and it actually tricks one into thinking they're playing the exact same game as last year. Maybe there's a joke in there somewhere about annual sports games ("maybe"?!).
Someone give Tony Romo a call, for crying out loud. Hearing him break down key plays in championship games would add so much to Madden, and it's that statistical analysis that's totally missing. Games also move fast if you skip scenes in between plays, and the Gaudin/Davis duo never keeps up.
3. MUT Is Still MUT
Madden Ultimate Team didn't get a ton of changes this year. The mode is arguably easier to get into than it used to be, but it won't lure in those who view the whole exercise as a microtransaction-heavy slog that's only trying to prize open the pursestrings and get players to spend even more cash.
EA are pretty brazen about this.
The whole Madden suite is geared towards getting you onto MUT. Invasive pop-ups litter the main menus, and they come across as the gaming equivalent of buying a meal at a restaurant and having to pick carefully-placed pieces of cardboard advertising for other courses off before eating. That, as you'd imagine, is tiresome.
Enjoying the product you've already bought should be enough. EA don't need to pop their heads round the door during other modes and effectively say, 'Hey, glad you're having fun, but have you thought about giving Ultimate Team a go?'. Or, at least, they shouldn't do that.
2. Franchise Stories Need A Patch Or Two
We'll get to Franchise Mode improvements shortly - yes, they do exist.
This is admittedly something that EA can patch over the next few months too, so it's not the biggest complaint about this year's Madden. However, it does shatter any sense of immersion when your NFL coach gets asked to comment on things that never actually happened. Hmm.
FIFA's Career Mode faithful will recognise this gripe. There, it's not uncommon to be asked what you and your team will do now the league season is over...three games into the campaign. Madden's odd scripting isn't quite as egregious than that, but it does take one out of the moment when media-based cutscenes don't echo what's going on.
One of the most frequent bugs comes when you're about to play in wintery conditions. The press might ask you how the team will deal with that, which is great. Then, you get to game day and the sun is shining. It's all rather jarring.
1. It’s Not The Next-Gen Leap
There was a time when new hardware meant gamers could look forward to a significant jump up in terms of presentation and/or quality. Those days, rather sadly, appear to be gone. Madden 22 on PS5/Xbox Series X/S is the same core experience available on older systems only with a few new bells and whistles.
That won't be enough for some.
Is the pre-game presentation better on newer consoles? Yes, but only slightly. Player physics are improved too, albeit not to the level most Madden veterans demanded before launch. Various bugs and glitches still rear their ugly heads on the field, and characters do clip through one another (less so than before though).
To summarise, this year's Madden feels like another soft enhancement rather than a revolution for the series. It's a better game than Madden 21 was, no doubt, but the refinements EA have been shouting about might not convince those who crave something totally fresh.
Ups...
4. The Yard Has Its Own Campaign
Suggestion: Madden fans should grab some friends, perhaps a few beverages and give The Yard a whirl. Do so and you just might be charmed by the arcade mayhem on tap. This year, EA has added a story mode into their backyard-style football spin off too, so there's even something for single players.
It's short at just four chapters, but the story is a nice tour of everything The Yard has to offer. Besides, painting top-tier players like Patrick Mahomes as "final bosses" with their own unique capabilities is a neat touch, and it gives the mode some unexpected challenge once you're finished f*cking around with mates.
The sign of a good mode is one that brings people back for more. The Yard is best-sampled in bite-sized chunks, and with buddies before/after the credits roll on the story side quests. It does feel, however, like EA is starting to get more of a feel for what this arcade frenzy could be.
3. Franchise Mode Progress
Shout out to the Franchise folks.
Madden 22's changes might not be the complete overhaul they wanted, but EA's baby steps are finally going in the right direction. They've added in the ability to hire/fire offensive and defensive coordinators, went for it with pre-game planning (the risk/reward, simplified training suite is very nice) and more.
Balancing XP improvements with potentially-knackered players come game day makes one feel more like an NFL overseer. Saying that, it would be nice to see greater impact on squad morale and management structure if you repeatedly dump coordinators every season despite success on the field.
Another big change is the addition of coaching skill trees. Levelling up your staff actually makes sense for once, and there's a unique thrill that comes from focusing on one side of the tree knowing you'll be locked out of the other.
Finally, cinematic cutscenes (which will be familiar to anyone who has played FIFA over the past few years) do get tedious after a while, but they’re better than nothing. There’s also a much-needed scouting feature coming post-launch too.
2. Halftime Tweaks
It wasn't mentioned in the Franchise entry, but being able to pre-plan weekly strategies for upcoming opponents is another fun add-on to the mode. Elsewhere, EA has replicated this by allowing players to make logical halftime tweaks to their game plans, and they do affect how the second half plays out.
Say you're being burned bad by deep passes from Brady - it's now possible to quickly switch your defensive playbook so that it's geared towards stopping them. Or, maybe you've noticed that a rival struggles to stop the inside run. Strap that ball to big Derrick Henry and go, go, go!
This is genuinely the kind of feature EA should be shouting from rooftops about.
Sure, it was possible to alter plans at half time before, but one would need to trawl through drab menus to make it happen. Now, it's right there at the click of a button. Better yet, Madden has become way better at feeding live info about how opponents like to play.
That makes informed choices slicker.
1. Homefield Advantages
This right here might be the best reason to pick Madden up on PS5/Xbox Series X/S.
PS4 and Xbox One releases don't come with the 'Homefield Advantages' feature. What is it? Well, think about how tough it can be for real-life NFL squads to roll into enemy territory and hear their QB pre-snap. Stadiums should rock when their team is on top, and they should be quiet as mice when away teams steal all the momentum with one bold play.
This year, all 32 teams boast their own set of unique homefield boosts that hinge on how the game is going. Granted, it doesn't swing quite as wildly as NFL action does in reality, but it's a good feature and adds a new layer of tactical depth to the gameplay.
EA poached it from the old NCAA games, and it was about time. Offensive audibles stumble when you're away to the Chiefs, Packers' fans roar their rivals into submission and sap them of energy if Green Bay are winning, and more.
All of them mean every game has a chance to be different. That's a huge plus for Madden.
What do you think of this year's Madden? For more gaming, check out FIFA 22 Beta: 10 Hands-On First Impressions and WWE 2K22 Wishlist: 10 Things Fans NEED To See!