With a slew of awesome rumours alluding to Commander Shepard's child being the hero alongside the return of the Mako, it's safe to say gamers are pretty excited for Mass Effect 4. To be honest, following the end of ME3 although it was a cataclysmic failure of Star Destroyer-felling proportions, Bioware's sci-fi opus had built up enough goodwill in the previous 100-odd hours that it shouldn't be thrown away quite so easily. So hop aboard the hype train - you'll find it to be quite comfortable, as although some key members of the team have departed, the developers are pulling out all the stops to make sure they deliver a solid sequel this time. And that's not to mention the overwhelming amount of community feedback they're working with that will surely be applied to all areas of their most ambitious project yet. However, to get a good idea of where the series should go, you need only replay the previous titles in sequence, as that's when you'll start noticing just where things went a bit sour. Starting essentially as an RPG with enough shooter elements thrown in to get you through - that direction was completely reversed by part three, as Shepard now had a dedicated charging melee attack and access to Gears of War-style combat-rolls. Looking at both Dragon Age: Inquisition and Shadow Realms it seems Bioware are focussing on world-building and atmosphere, which is something that ties perfectly into the fact that they're apparently constructing an entire galaxy to explore. However, fans are only going to spend hundreds of hours doing so if the core foundations of gameplay are rock solid.
Advertisement
10. Numbered Visualisation Of Damage
Something Mass Effect has dabbled sightly with but never made a core component of gameplay is never really thinking about how much damage you're doing, or which special ability will work well against specific enemies. Instead it's all too easy to blast the holy hell out of everything, ducking behind cover and waiting for your shields to recharge in between. Sure you've got plenty of shield-bursting powers you'll deploy at the right time, and you're told certain powers or ammo types work well against synthetics or organics, but in terms of planning your moves out and noting exactly how much damage you're doing, it's an RPG staple that's sorely missed. Outside of menus, a Destiny/Borderlands-style visual indicator (that can be toggled off for those who don't like this sort of thing) displaying numerical values would be perfect, as although it might not sound like a worthwhile inclusion, seeing your pithy one-digit pistol change into the quadruples as you bust out a modified laser-rifle is perfect kind of progression this sort of RPG desperately needs.
9. Custom Character Face-Quality Matches The Actors
Take away the fact that in ME3 it made no sense you could fully customise Shepard's face again despite no world-altering event or ME2-style resurrection. Instead, there's been a problem with the Commander's customisation since day one. Put simply, it's because only the default 'box art-version' of Shep is based off a real-world actor, who's been scanned in; the model, Mark Vanderloo. This makes for every other 'custom Shep' look that little bit 'off' by comparison. Going forward Bioware need to either move away from having a definitive Shepard appear on their promotional materials, or make sure everything from hairstyles to mouth shapes looks as natural and laboured over as an actor who's been scanned in and modelled for days on end.
8. Different Enemy Types That Force You To Adapt
Building on the idea of using your powers in specific ways, there's plenty scope to create enemy types that'll actively not go down until you employ some specific tactics. This is one thing Destiny got spectacularly wrong, as nearly all the bosses in that game are literal bullet-sponges, staring you down and trading fire until a war of attrition finally defeats either you or them. For Mass Effect there's so many powers to choose from, and factoring in your class ability into combat would work a treat too. Why not have hulking mechs that if your power is stealth, must be cloak-stabbed to take out? Or for the Vanguards, use the Biotic charge to trigger a stagger animation that you'll then have to command your team to finish off? Considering the wealth of options available to you in combat, Bioware haven't even begun to scratch away at the surface of how to apply them.
7. Make Teammate Roles Essential
Speaking of combat variation and the 'forcing' of you to adapt to certain situations, part of that also extends to the crew members themselves. How often did you take Miranda out with you, just because she was the one you were furthering a romantic lead with? Or Garrus because he could provide a Concussive Shot? That's not knocking the characters at all, but aside from in the loyalty missions you never got the sense that certain people could have an impact on a mission. If their particular skills could open up a different path through a level or converse in a meaningful way with an NPC, this would go a long way to making it feel like your entire team was fighting the good fight. There are snippets of contextual audio recorded for your companions to chime in with every now and then, but it lacks an overall purpose that could really enhance the teamwork aspect of the experience. ME2's Suicide Mission was one of the best in the whole trilogy, utilising everyone's strengths whilst also playing on the fact you needed to know fairly well who was confident with what - a perfect template going forward.
6. Refine And Polish The Cutscene Animation
Something easily noted in Dragon Age: Inquisition thanks to its astonishingly good graphics in comparison to Bioware's seemingly hand-animated style, is just how prominent motion-capture and the use of actors has become in gaming. Bioware have used motion-capture extensively in the past, but if you compare something like the facial expressions and body movements of the cast in The Last of Us to Dragon Age or Mass Effect's stilted puppet-esque animations, you'll immediately get a feeling for just how big of a leap is needed in the future. When the sudden 'turn to the side and walk away' ending to nearly every interaction becomes a defining trait of the series, it's more than an indication that things need to change. Although this sort of thing wasn't too noticeable in the past - even the original Metal Gear Solid's head-nodding conversations got by unscathed - photorealistic visuals bring with them the need to make cutscenes essentially play out like short films.
5. More Fluid Combat Movement
ME3 clearly took a few pages out of Gears of War's book of third person stop n' pop cover system shooting, as aside from the obvious visual difference, the two titles played near-identically. This wasn't anything new as ME2 also embraced this style of play, and it's no bad thing when done well. The tipping point was when you embarked on a mission to retrieve some Reaper artefacts, only to find it was a boxed-in arena-style level, where you'd be darting from checkpoint to checkpoint, blasting everything in sight. It couldn't have felt more 'un-Mass Effect' if it tried, and only served to show how limiting this very basic third-person combat feels when the pressure is cranked up. The elements are in place for an experience that'll let you dominate the battlefield - you're free to dive out from corner-cover or pull guys over something you're hiding behind - it's just a case of making the player feel confident when deploying them, without the cumbersome unresponsive feeling of moving, shooting and evading that's evolved from the first game.
4. Dialogue Options For Everything
Why on earth this went away in ME3 is still something that grates when you replay it, but the decision to limit your options in any given conversation only highlighted ME3's story was one that didn't rely on your actions anywhere near as much as part two did. Bioware reportedly stated they wanted to develop the Shepard character and tell a more personal story - except that really doesn't work when you're shoehorning it into the third instalment of a series whose narrative has been authored by the player. It was especially jarring if say you'd played Shepard to be a no-nonsense killing machine who'll lob a guard out a window for the sake of it, only to suddenly be losing sleep over the death of a child he met only seconds beforehand. Cutscene direction and dialogue had changed to allow for Shepard to say more, except what came out of his/her mouth wasn't decided by you. Shepard was now A character, and not YOUR character - a big differentiation that must be applied to whoever we're playing as in the next instalment.
3. Player Class Impacts The World
Essentially, the only thing choosing whether you were a Soldier, Infiltrator, Adept etc. dictated was what one button's action then became. Some of the abilities were immensely fun - like the Vanguard's zip across the battlefield before ramming full-force into an enemy and following up with a finishing shotgun-blast - whereas others like the Infiltrator's cloaking abilities were ultimately pointless. When every showdown is comprised of trading fire, the idea of sneaking behind enemy lines is tantamount to suicide. One game that took the idea of class-based play and iterated on it perfectly was Deus Ex, with latest instalment Human Revolution still upholding series' traditions in that you'd be journeying through a level only to notice another path and note that if you had a certain ability, that's a direction you could go. Outside of combat and world-exploration there should be scope for your class to impact dialogue options, reassuring certain quest-givers that you can rescue a hostage safely if you're a soldier, attempt a stealthier approach if you're not, and have NPCs be more wary of your reputation in the field if you've become known for blasting the ear lobes off everything in sight.
2. Narrative Branching And Impactful Choices
It's worth pointing out that two of the biggest choices in the entire trilogy are from the first game - choosing Ashley or Kaiden, and whether or not to shoot Wrex. Following that for ME2 you'd be making minor choices throughout, but nothing as story-defining as those two, at least not until the Suicide Mission, and even that barely factors into ME3 as many of the characters were reduced to side roles. Telltale's Walking Dead proved you can create a world that appears to live and breathe off the choices you make, much like Mass Effect, producing an end product that every player feels was individual to them - something that was the biggest issue with majority of ME3. When you were deciding something like whether or not to save the Council in the first game, there was a huge amount of weight behind every decision, and whether or not Bungie are writing a bigger, galaxy-altering tale for ME4 or a smaller character-focussed narrative, they really need to let their dialogue and writing stand centre stage. It might mean they're devoting time to in-game assets that some players won't even see, but choices that get under your skin and really making you question whether or not you did the 'right thing' are the ones that end up defining the franchise overall.
1. No Turret/Action-Heavy Sequences
Hopefully Bioware know what they've got with Mass Effect going forward, and what the series means to long-time fans. Nobody is playing ME purely for action-heavy spectacle or the combat itself, instead the heart of Mass Effect has always pulsated to the rhythm of incredibly well-written characters and an entire galaxy's worth of space sociopolitical interactions to get stuck into. Mass Effect 2 had just the right balance of plot development and action, something that the likes of being stuck in a groan-worthy turret sequence on Palaven or the dodging of a Reaper's beam near the close of ME3, uttered more responses of "What the hell is this?" as oppose to any remotely air-punching. Saying no to all prolonged action-heavy sequences may be too much, as it's not like big set-pieces should be ruled out if the situation calls for it. But when you consider the battle you had with Saren at the close of ME1 - one that if your Paragon score was high enough you could talk him out of, for a time anyway - versus ME2's giant Reaper-baby blast-a-thon, it's clear that firefights fuelled by motive and plot are far more memorable and affecting in the long run. What specific tweaks do you want to see implemented or changed up? Let us know in the comments!