Mass Effect 4: 10 Characters Who Must Return

There's no way at least one of these doesn't make a cameo.

It's rare that you come out the back end of a 60-plus hour experience filled with love, adoration and genuine glee (for the vast majority) feeling almost completely empty. Not to go on about the horrific ending to ME3, it must be said that it really was a spanner of Titanic-proportions, lodging itself into the hearts of many a devoted fan and forevermore scuppering their view when looking back on what should be one of the most fondly revered series' since Zelda. So it is though, that you just have to push past that notion of the endgame crippling everything else you loved, and look to what worked flawlessly in Mass Effect; the characters. It's something that Bioware more than acknowledged in the Citadel DLC, their downloadable 'apology-pack' that let you literally just hang around with any and everyone you loved from before, replete with new dialogue, some great in-jokes and a genuine feeling that the developers were on their knees, screaming to the heavens for forgiveness, realising where they'd gone so wrong. Well, it worked. ME3's ending isn't going anywhere, but Mass Effect in general is. As 2015 kicks into gear and the games industry finds its footing all over again thanks to one of the weirdest years' in decades, titles like Bioware's sci-fi epic are exactly what's needed to restore faith worldwide. And the first step to building hype for a new release? Handpicking the best characters who still have a few jumpers worth of tantalising plot threads in need of clearing up.


10. The Catalyst/Starchild/The Intelligence

Woah there, ease up, there is method to this madness. Although most people's reaction to the name 'Starchild' is to envision their entire invested game-time bursting into flames as Mordin's cheerily-animated face crumbles and cries alongside, the biggest complaint that came with the end of ME3 was that (in the original version anyway) there just wasn't enough explanation of what was going on inside the Citadel's coding to make sense of this childlike AI. This overly-dictating plot device is the biggest reason tens of thousands took to their keyboards to make liberal use of caps lock, but instead of about-facing and running away from their original creative decision, Bioware should embrace the controversy and face their critics head on. By including this AI system once again they could make sure every single facet of its conception and execution in-world is explained and interactive, without falling back on the established 'Well most of it was in the DLC' hogwash.

9. Kasumi

Over to a really cool character that was severely underused, but mainly because she came as DLC with part two and wasn't a necessary staple of the plot going forward. Many thought after the end of ME2's credits rolled there was no way Bioware would be able to keep track of the amount of potential beginnings ME3 would have, as a result of the staggering amount of actions and options you took throughout the finale. And they were right, characters you'd previously dedicated an entire game to romancing - like the biotic-bottomed Miranda for example - were relegated to side roles in 3, with the game's focus on making your custom Shepard into a 'proper' character taking precedent over whatever you'd done in the past. Kasumi's prowess as a badass sci-fi space-ninja made for an incredibly enjoyable side-mission in the first place, and should she be made available for a larger role, more espionage-by-way-of-conversation-options as she does her cloak n' dagger thing in the background would make for a brilliant variation on core gameplay.

8. Liara T'Soni

Depending on which character you romanced throughout the trilogy, the very whisper of Liara's name might currently be making you swoon. Even if she wasn't your lovebug-of-choice though, her spectacular arc as a former prisoner who ends up commanding a network of shadow-spies and crime-rings is one that desperately needs expanding on. Naturally in what's become a very Bioware fashion the origins of her position were seen in the DLC, 'Lair of the Shadow Broker', but aside from being an important point in her narrative it was more an excuse to finally show fans what the mysterious Broker looked like in the first place. If ME4 ends up being a sequel, Liara's fate as the keystone of crime in a galaxy potentially starved of it could be a very interesting angle for her to take - not to mention factoring in the time for a relationship with whoever you're playing as too.

7. Jack

Jack's arc as an uber-powerful Biotic who can become one of your most trusted companions is a masterstroke of writing and game design, but you might have completely ignored her thanks to an introductory sequence that paints a picture of at any moment your ship being imploded by a single thought. Still, if you scratched away at that surface layer built up from years of isolation and rejection, the hard-edged warrior could become an extremely loveable and trustworthy companion. She's all but missing from part three regardless of your interactions beforehand, and depending on your feministic frequency you might hate the idea that the 'reformed' Jack is more in line with a 'hot biker chick' aesthetic than as an extension from what she was in part two. Regardless, Jack has Star Destroyer-felling levels of power at her finger tips, and in the exploration of all things that are universe-altering, she could be the linchpin for a major upcoming story arc.

6. That Journalist (Khalisah Al-Jilani)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AP2FfsV1x4Q A slight joke entry, but one that would provide the best sort of callback to the original trilogy if Bioware decide to take on a Shepard-less sequel. Lamping al-Jilani came across as hilarious just out of the sheer unexpected nature of the interaction - you literally saw the command prompt on the screen to "Shut up", and the next thing you're watching a badly-animated swing deck the poor journalist in one hit. Naturally it became a running joke across the trilogy, with each time she shows up providing a reference to the last. Overall it is a bit questionable that punching a woman square in the face is a 'Mass Effect thing', but the point is that you're reacting to the invasive nature of the mainstream press as you become an intergalactic celebrity, rather than anything offensive on the part of the developers.

5. Thane Krios

The 'Ice Cold Cool' award could go to a number of brilliant characters across the trilogy, and although Thane more than proves himself out in the field, his off-kilter trance-inducing moments always made it seem more like he was about to snap and go on a rampage than help in bringing the mission to a close. Thankfully his twitchy-eyed cutscenes are only emblematic of his profession as an assassin, and although he bites the big one in part three regardless of your choices, if ME4 turns out to be a prequel, it'll provide the perfect opportunity to see him dropping targets in his prime. Thane's species of Drell apparently live for 85 'galactic years' giving the setting of part four a fair amount of leeway either side of three; either to have Thane as a more disconnected, efficient slaughter-machine, or to expand on his side mission subject matter where his son appeared to be taking on some of his father's traits. Either way the Drell are vastly underused, and as it looks like there'll be a huge number of new planets in the new game, having access to their homeworld and a whole score of these enigmatic characters is quite the enticing prospect.

4. Mordin Solus

Over to one of the biggest fan favourites, and someone who gets the best final line in the entire game when just before going on his own suicide mission, he remarks that it "Had to be me, someone else might have gotten it wrong". It was the perfect send-off to a character whose quirks and general nature were something that were a joy to interact with, even providing an unexpected franchise moment when Solus bursts into song. Naturally thanks to him being evaporated in ME3 there's nowhere left to go in the sequel stakes, but prequel-wise like Thane, Mordin has a huge amount of information and intelligence to share. Namely he was the key scientist that helped engineer the Krogan-killing Genophage virus; something that's talked about at length, but being there as its happening and playing a part in the discussions that go into its ramifications would make for some awesome dialogue options. At the very least its an excuse to take Mordin on more missions or hear his post-evaluation reports where he goes off on any number of tangents, walking that line of affectionate nervous rambling and Sherlockian over-analysation with ease.

3. Urdnot Wrex

One of the biggest moments in the first game that really cemented just how much of an impact Mass Effect was going to make on gaming history was choosing whether or not to down Wrex on Virmire. To this day it's a decision that splits gamers right down the middle, and as his subsequent appearances in the trilogy were then governed in either way by this potential outcome, in ME2 he appeared as a Warchief and in 3 as a final battle war asset. In terms of recruiting a big lumbering bruiser it doesn't get much better than Wrex. His reliability and devastating abilities in battle were what led so many people to sparing him in the aforementioned decision, and when it came time to 'replace' him with ME2's Grunt (himself a great character) Wrex ended up feeling a bit underused. As one of the Krogan's fiercest warriors and one steeped in the knowledge of his people, he's a fantastically diverse ally whose allegiances could be tested far further if he's encountered in a prequel-state of the universe, back when he was a bounty hunter. The applications as your team mate write themselves thanks to his skill-set, and if Bioware push the boat out when it comes to race-relations throughout the galaxy, his position as a sufferer from the Genophage in the face of defending his people could lead to some intense altercations.

2. Tali'Zorah

Until she was forever destroyed by a stock photograph resembling her face in part three, the manifestation (for guys anyway) of every shy girl you thought was secretly a total babe made for one of the most interesting and dynamic relationships in the trilogy. The fact that aside from Jack's subversion of expectation in that coming onto her directly led to being pushed away, getting involved with Tali had brilliant real-world implications for any who have ever been in a mixed race relationship, and all the clashing of ideologies and familial expectations that come with it. Her relationship was arguably the most maturely presented throughout, and as she had to research how to even breath the same air as you before you could go any further, this element of restraint made some of the most subtle physical interactions mean so much more. Going forward it's safe to say if Bioware allow for trilogy-wide save games to transfer across, nobody wants their relationship with Tali tarnished, but as she's one of the only crew members to make it out of part three alive, wherever she goes following these apocalyptic events could be very interesting.

1. Garrus Vakarian

Hands down, Garrus' reintroduction as 'Archangel' in part two is one of the best "Is it going to be? Is it?! YES!"-moments in any game (and yes, that's a category) as not only do you come across him as he's about to be taken out by a collection of warring gangs, but there's a great amount of preamble in how you hear about this illusive mercenary picking off different members, going only by the name 'Archangel'. When you finally happen upon his location and its Garrus, it's a moment for the franchise that's rarely topped - that perfect re-appropriation of every 'old friends reunite in a warzone'-action trope you know and love, filtered through Mass Effect's sci-fi filter. Going forward Garrus is one of the slot-machine inclusions that can emerge from the Normandy at the very end of 3, leaving his role in a sequel up for grabs too. Of course this randomly generated ending style means that only certain people saw him emerge at all, but like Tali at least his death isn't for certain like ol' dead-eyed Thane. Which characters do you think are totally wrapped up, and which would you bring back in either prequel or sequel form? Let us know in the comments!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.