Ranking Every Final Fantasy Composer

Thousands of tracks. 28 major composers. How do they compare?

By Alex Antliff /

The Final Fantasy series has become renowned for many things throughout its storied history. Hugely immersive worlds and narratives, beloved characters and breathtaking visuals to name but a few. Special praise is often reserved for its musical scores.

Advertisement

Bar a handful of spin-off and mobile titles, every game in the series has been accompanied by an original soundtrack of anywhere from ten to two hundred tracks, depending on its scope. Each was typically the responsibility of a single individual from Square-Enix’s pool of composers, but collaborations have become the norm in recent years.

From high-octane battle themes and emotional character pieces to ambient background tracks and impactful scene music, almost every score has boasted a selection of instant classics (and plenty of duds for good measure), which are celebrated at events such as the Distant Worlds concert series and the annual Classic FM Hall Of Fame induction. Every composer has had their highs and their lows, some more than others, with each making valued contributions to a soundtrack collection that now numbers more than 5000 pieces of music overall.

How do each of them stack up against one another? Let’s find out!

29. Honourable Mentions

Given the immense scope of the series, there are plenty of instances where a musician has only been contracted to contribute a small number of compositions to a game predominantly led by others. As it would be unfair to compare such individuals to those who have crafted huge volumes of music, a cut-off point of 10 credited original tracks has been established to warrant inclusion on this list.

This therefore precludes six of the composers that worked on the recent VII Remake – Shotaro Shima (8), Yoshinori Nakamura (5), Yasunori Nishiki (5), Takafumi Imamura (3), Daika Ishikawa (2) and Keiki Kobayashi (1), as well as seven from XV – Mitsuhiro Ohta (3), Tsutomu Narita (2), Keiichi Okabe (1), Shota Nakama (1), Tai Tomisawa (1), Tomomichi Takeoka (1) and the renowned Dutch EDM artist Afrojack (2).

Other omissions include Ryo Yamazaki (6) and Al Yamashita (1) from the original soundtrack of XIV, Ayako Sasou (5), Kairi Ohkoshi (5) and Hayato Matsuo (5), who are accomplices to series mainstay Hitoshi Sakimoto, miscellaneous individuals such as Hayata Takeda (1 track for World Of), Keiji Kawamori (2 for Advent Children), Hiroshi Kaneko (1 for Lightning Returns) and the pairing of Junpei Fujita and Ryota Tomaru, who assisted in small doses on Brave Exvius.

Many of these have long histories as arrangers of the works of other composers. Some may well be future stars. They are celebrated regardless.

28. Bill Kiley

Works: XV: A King’s Tale

Advertisement

A King's Tale is one of the most obscure games in the series. A side scroller released as a bonus for players who pre-ordered XV from selected retailers, it can be completed in about two hours.

As a result of this small size, the game’s soundtrack is miniscule, coming in at just 12 tracks in total. All of them were composed by Bill Kiley, who was seemingly tasked with putting together something without hearing the work of or getting any assistance from the XV team.

The result of this was a fairly unique but unremarkable sound. The influences from yesteryear, which complemented the game’s old school sprite graphics, were clear, with the likes of ‘Title Screen’ and ‘Insomnia’ harkening back to classic Final Fantasies.

Given that few played the game, fewer still will have heard the soundtrack in full. Kiley has a limited discography and online profile, so it seems unlikely that he’d return for another project. He’ll always have the distinction of being the first Westerner asked to compose for a non-film entry in the series though.

27. Hidenori Iwasaki

Works: CC: The Crystal Bearers

The Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles subseries has been largely forgotten since its last entry eleven years ago. Made up of six games in total, its gameplay quality was average to poor in most cases, which had an impact on its soundtracks.

The series' lowpoint was undoubtedly its final entry, The Crystal Bearers, which Hidenori Iwasaki was brought in to compose for, putting together 70 tracks in total.

Some of his pieces, including ‘This Is The End For You’ and ‘The Awakened Beast’ are enjoyable listens, but all have drifted into obscurity over time given the mediocrity of the experience that they accompanied.

Predominantly employed as a synthesiser prior to the game’s release, Iwasaki’s efforts were hugely diverse in terms of genre even if they didn’t really hit the mark. He would’ve presumably been given the opportunity to keep working on Crystal Chronicles titles had the subseries kept going, having been given the call to oversee the remastering of the original game’s soundtrack this year.

26. Masahiko Satoh

Works: Legend Of The Crystals

Advertisement

One of the most obscure entries in the Final Fantasy pantheon is Legend Of The Crystals, an anime sequel to V. Only available on VHS in Japan and North America in limited quantities, its soundtrack was released only in Japan and is difficult to find even on the internet, let alone physically.

With 53 tracks in total, it was hugely excessive for an animation that only lasts a couple of hours in total. Many of the themes were rehashes of each other, particularly variants on ‘Elemental Travel’, which bore overly cheery Japanese vocals.

There were a few arrangements of tracks from V, such as ‘Return To Tycoon’, but given that V wasn’t a high point for the series from a musical standpoint (Clash On The Big Bridge aside), that’s hardly a selling point.

The full selection was put together by Masahiko Satoh, a Japanese musician with no other ties to the series. Known for his jazz music, he hasn’t worked on many projects since the anime’s mid-'90s release and is doubtlessly done with the franchise given the gap between its release and now.

25. Yukiko Takada

Works – XIV

Advertisement

Since XIV was relaunched as A Realm Reborn, which resulted in almost all of the tracks created for the disastrous original version of the game being dropped, it has grown and grown from a musical standpoint and currently boasts over 500 tracks in total.

The fact that almost all of those have been created by Masayoshi Soken is nothing short of superhuman. He has had some support, though it pales in comparison to the amount received by the leads on other games, with only one composer contributing more than a small handful of pieces.

That someone is Yukiko Takada, whose body of work on Heavensward, The Far Edge Of Fate, Stormblood and Shadowbringers is her only credited composition work to date, though she has worked extensively on arrangements of Soken’s pieces in addition to this.

Her tracks are unfortunately far from memorable. ‘Hyper Rainbow Z’ is perhaps her most upbeat, though ‘Parting Ways’ also makes for gentle listening.

Takada needs more opportunities to stand out, though given that XIV will likely remain Soken’s domain for the rest of its life, they might prove difficult to come by.

24. Ryuji Sasai & Yasuhiro Kawakami

Works: Mystic Quest

Advertisement

Final Fantasy Mystic Quest is a horrendous abomination of a game. Recently bestowed the dubious honour of being the worst spin-off in series history (by yours truly, admittedly), a couple of its music tracks were pinpointed as almost the only highlight of the miserable gameplay experience.

Chief amongst these is ‘Battle 1’, which is so delightfully over-the-top that it strides into ‘so bad it’s good’ territory and wouldn’t be out of place in a fantasy b-movie with bad special effects.

Ryuji Sasai and Yasuhiro Kawakami’s soundtrack is only 28 tracks long and three of those are bats**t crazy (and far superior) remixes of the titular ‘Mystic Quest’, a generic adventure piece on its own.

The music wasn’t remastered from the original SNES compositions until 2018 and that album cut the number of tracks to 25 (omitting the remixes). Not an official Square-Enix release, it brought the pair back, which was a nice touch given that such projects normally have somebody new do the remastering and rearrangement work.

Even cleaner versions of pleasant pieces like ‘Dungeon Of Ice’ and ‘Beautiful Forest’ do little but bring back painful memories of the game, however.

23. Tsuyoshi Sekito

Works: VII Remake, VII: Advent Children, XIV, Explorers

Advertisement

Now that it has been over a decade since Square-Enix opted to use just a single composer on a major release (XIII), it would appear that the use of a large body of musicians is a given. Look at just how many, major and minor, musicians were utilised for XV and VII Remake

One of the many individuals roped in to put together the soundtrack for the latter was Tsuyoshi Sekito, who has been with Square-Enix since 1995. Aside from contributing a single track to Advent Children (‘Materia’) and XIV (the light-hearted ‘Into The Adder’s Den’), his experience had been solely as an arranger until he got the call to score Explorers.

Explorers was a dreadful game and Sekito was limited to the production of just 33 tracks, with efforts like ‘Neverending Journey’ and ‘Rainbow Skies’ amongst the few highlights. His contribution to VII Remake was then limited to just two tracks, one of them being the glitzy ‘Scarlet’s Theme’.

Sekito’s best work is outside of Final Fantasy, playing guitar for the Black Mages and scoring the underrated Brave Fencer Musashi, but he remains a dependable pair of hands to support whoever is in vogue from a musical standpoint.

22. John R. Graham

Works: Kingsglaive

Advertisement

Given that a box office bomb bankrupted Squaresoft (forcing their merger with Enix) and led to Final Fantasy creator Hironobu Sakaguchi being booted from the company, it was certainly eyebrow raising when they announced the release of another film to accompany XV. Kingsglaive is almost unwatchable dross, but annoyingly it needs to be experienced to understand certain plot developments in the game itself.

Rather than efficiently tie the music of the two properties together, Square-Enix hired an American composer, John R. Graham, solely for the film. This resulted in a huge disconnect between his work and the music put together by Yoko Shimomura for XV, with her music used only in a few scenes.

Graham’s tracks are far from bad. Many, like ‘Our Hope Goes With You’ go through the dramatic and emotional range that would be expected of a Hollywood production, though others just feel off, such as the barely comprehensible ‘Calling For Rain’

With 39 tracks in total, far more than a two-hour film requires, the soundtrack was ultimately overstuffed, with many tracks only hearable on a CD release that few would’ve purchased given the poor reception to the film.

21. Tadayoshi Makino

Works: VII Remake, XV

Advertisement

Across the last three decades, there has been a considerable overlap between Square-Enix and their fellow Japanese developers Capcom from a musical standpoint, with composers switching to and from Final Fantasy from franchises like Resident Evil and Monster Hunter.

Tadayoshi Makino was one of the leads on the most recent epic in the latter franchise, but found time either side of its release to become another of the many contributors to the XV and VII Remake soundtracks.

His work on the former could be considered a trilogy, given that he scored three tracks apiece for the Comrades, Episode Ignis and Assassin's Festival expansions. Tension is seemingly his modus operandi, with all but one of these tracks, ‘Captive In Cobalt’, sufficient at keeping the listener on edge. The best is ‘A Daunting Challenge’, an operatic piece befitting of a lengthy boss encounter.

He broke his pattern for VII Remake, contributing five tracks in total, including the eerie background music for ‘The Drum’ and the chaotic ‘Airbuster’.

Freelancing between companies seems to be the norm in the world of gaming these days. Makino would benefit from a wider exposure to Final Fantasy in the future for sure.

20. Elliot Goldenthal

Works: The Spirits Within

Advertisement

Elliot Goldenthal has an Oscar, which does set him apart from everybody else on this list.

Admittedly he won it for Frida, which he scored after his work on Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within, but he came into the project with considerable Hollywood pedigree. He certainly wouldn’t have come cheap, though money was seemingly not an object to the film’s development given that it clocked in as one of the most expensive movies ever made at the time. How nobody foresaw the financial disaster that it caused was baffling.

Goldenthal’s soundtrack was made up of 18 tracks in total and is certainly one of the high points of the underwhelming film, though it was rather formulaic in places.

The film is a predominantly pessimistic affair and the score certainly reflects that, though credits vocal track ‘The Dream Within’ is an uplifting affair and the unimaginatively named ‘Music For Dialogues’ hits a number of notes throughout its runtime.

Goldenthal had probably never played or even heard of Final Fantasy when he took the job. His work is certainly distinguishable from his counterparts on this list as a result, but not necessarily for the better.

Advertisement