Xbox Series X: 4 Ups & 4 Downs After 4 Months

Microsoft are playing 4D chess right now.

By Scott Tailford /

Microsoft

In an insane turn of events - something that's only made manifest across February and March 2021, after a sluggish launch period for the consoles themselves - Microsoft are currently playing a masterful hand.

Advertisement

Seemingly content to sit back and let Sony and Nintendo worry about attracting consumers through exclusive titles and brand loyalty, they've instead shot for the sun... and largely nailed it.

I'll break everything down as we go, but the likes of Game Pass - a service offering you a selection of titles for a consistent monthly fee, including new first-party releases and entire developer back catalogues - is simply a ludicrously good value proposition.

Advertisement

It single-handedly reframed the conversation around Xbox's marketing strategy, and now we're left looking at an opening generation salvo that might not be generating as much interest as a State of Play livestream reveal, but is arguably hitting home more reliably.

Going forward it's still all to play for, but already this has been a fascinating generation to watch unfold.

Advertisement

--

Honourable Mention: Stock Unavailability

Playground Games

As mentioned in the PS5 version of this article, both Sony's machine and Microsoft's latest powerhouse are in far fewer hands than the companies would like. It's an issue stemming from a variety of factors including record-setting demand and a global semiconductor shortage, and sadly it doesn't seem like this will meaningfully change across 2021.

Advertisement

Still, at least you have the perfect excuse to finish off your backlog.

Ups

4. Game Pass

Xbox

It's easy to forget how much Xbox moulded the current gaming industry. Without them there'd be no console push for online multiplayer, as Xbox Live lead the charge. They then put their foot in it at the start of the 8th generation, suggesting an end to physical discs and a push for digital ownership across a variety of access points, but look where we are now.

Advertisement

Game Pass is an all-digital library of must-plays accessible across Xbox, PC and cloud streaming, comprising multiple generations of titles and only seeing bigger deals being made behind the scenes.

Microsoft stumped up $7.5 billion to lock down Bethesda as an Xbox exclusive, and it was only to help promote Game Pass, both now and going forward.

Advertisement

Most notably, another deal was struck with the notoriously money-hungry Square Enix, to bring brand-new cross-platform release Outriders to Xbox on day one, as part of Game Pass. On PlayStation it's still full price, marking a notable shift in "what you're getting" if you stick with team Xbox.

Going forward it'll be interesting to see if Sony bolster PlayStation Now to keep up, throwing money at publishers to further lock down content - like they did with Avengers' Spider-Man DLC.

Advertisement

Is Game Pass the next Xbox Live? Maybe. For now it's simply obscene value for money, and combined with what I'm about to get into, the reason to own a Series X.

3. Insane Upgrades - Essentially Free Remasters - For 20 Years' Worth Of Games

Bethesda

So you're getting a library of games for a monthly fee. Cool. That's been the case since Game Pass launched.

Advertisement

Where Microsoft went one better - and where it really gets pretty magical in spots, to be honest - is how much work the Series X does under the hood, to improve any game you play on it.

Go back to everything from Oblivion to Brutal Legend, Brothers in Arms to Dead to Rights and you'll see everything boosted to crisp 4K resolution, with HDR enhancing the lighting and contrast of visuals themselves. The vast majority of titles all but eliminate load times and automatically boost frame rates too, with some games natively landing on 60 or 120fps, and developers returning to patch specific titles first-hand.

Advertisement

It sounds like quality of life upgrades, and they are, but these are celebratory tweaks to established libraries that make them feel entirely valid in the new generation. Where so many companies charged full price for resolution and frame rate-boosted remasters across the 8th generation, Microsoft are now doing it all at the system level, and it makes everything look incredible.

2. Smart Delivery Wipes The Floor With Sony's Save System

Activision

"Why would that matter?!" we thought, as Xbox claimed they were working on a way to make sure any saves made on 8th gen games would carry across to new systems. "Surely the new consoles will just read my save files and that'll be that!"

Advertisement

Oh, how painfully wrong we were.

On PS5, clearly Sony weren't thinking of cross-gen save support whatsoever, and the "solution" to getting saves across has been surprisingly amateurish. As developers are left without infrastructural support like on Xbox with Smart Delivery, Spider-Man, Crash Bandicoot 4, Tony Hawk's Pro Skater and Avengers (to name four) have all seen bizarre, inside-the-game cloud uploads from their PS4 versions, that you then replace with the PS5 edition and hope your file appears.

Advertisement

Trophies then all awkwardly trigger at once in the corner of the screen, with some per-game issues occurring as not everything will show up for everyone.

Even when playing PS4 games on PS5, the system doesn't auto-pull your progress from the cloud - it's something you have to go looking for in a terribly organised, un-searchable list, every.single.time.

Advertisement

On Xbox this general sense of unity across all games and save data was part of the plan from day one, and your progress is ready and waiting - with the latest next-gen upgrades applied - the second you boot up.

I'm honestly surprised Xbox hasn't done a viral "This is how you transfer save data" video to get back at Sony's "how to share games on PS4" video from 2013, because it truly is night and day.

Advertisement

1. Almost Every Third-Party Game Performs Better On Series X

IO Interactive

It's not just older games that benefit from increased performance and visual flourishes.

Advertisement

Microsoft have long touted they have "the world's most powerful console", and although the race against PS5 is more neck and neck than PS4 vs Xbox One last generation, the Series X routinely comes out on top when splitting hairs with anything third-party.

Hitman 3 runs in native 4K60 on Series X, whereas the PS5 drops that resolution to maintain its frame rate. Call of Duty: Black Ops keeps ray tracing on at a higher frame rate, while Titanfall 2 and Hellblade both see 4K60 automatic upgrades. The Witcher 3's load times are all but eliminated on Series X, and Rocket League saw a sizeable revamp on Xbox to enable 120fps, yet the PS5 edition simply doesn't exist.

Advertisement

Now, this doesn't apply to EVERY game, and we are going into the weeds at this point to discern differences, but in more cases than not, the Series X does outperform PS5.

Downs

4. Clunky UI Hides Valuable Features

Microsoft

I don't know how many more times Microsoft needs to be told this, but nobody likes the tiled "Windows Phone"-style interface.

Advertisement

For as much as you can argue having dynamic tiles for games and various storefront options spread across a dashboard is "clean", the reality is that navigating can feel like pot luck.

Things like "Games With Gold" or "Game Pass" flash in and out of featured tiles on the home screen, and features like FPS boost are buried in per-game options menus, if you want to see what's enabled. The pop-up Xbox home screen is very much still an offshoot of the "Snap" menu from last generation, and a far cry from the simplicity and clarity of the 360's Blades overlay.

Advertisement

In terms of pinning achievement trackers to the screen, using Spotify without leaving a game, seeing which titles are hanging in Quick Resume or just making sure HDR is set up properly, the Xbox UI does a bad job making sure every user is aware of everything their systems can do.

3. More Of The Same

Microsoft

For as much as Xbox slowly removed every poisonous part of their early eighth generation identity, we've ostensibly had the same UI and approach to gaming for a decade now.

Advertisement

Starting with aesthetics, 2011's "Metro" update on Xbox 360 went even further away from the Blades dashboard we knew and loved, as the "New Xbox Experience"'s cascading set of tiles was replaced with the "Windows Phone" look that's remained ever since.

It was the beginning of Xbox "chasing the living room" with the Kinect, and as all of that had to be reworked, apparently there was no room left for exclusives or meaningful reasons to invest in the system, other than the brand itself.

Advertisement

2013-2020 was almost totally devoid of exclusives worth buying the system for, save for Forza Horizon 4 and the Ori games, as Xbox devoted everything to the Game Pass and backwards compatibility-fronted marketing blitz we're still enjoying today.

Still, though the Series X will run your library best, an Xbox One X can mostly scratch that itch anyway. All Xbox exclusives other than The Medium have been released on last-gen so far, and that brings me onto the next point.

Advertisement

2. Only ONE Exclusive (And Nothing Planned Until Halo)

Bloober Team

At some point you have to wonder just what the hell Xbox were doing across the last 8 years - though Phil Spencer saying Microsoft almost canned the brand altogether likely took a LOT of meetings and specific plans to fix.

Advertisement

Still, that turnaround has focused on dynamite hardware with various automatic improvements for your library of games, and a monthly value proposition literally no one can argue with.

What Xbox DON'T have, and now we're over a decade into the conversation on, is a roster of must-play exclusives.

Advertisement

They have exclusives to come, don't get me wrong, but they're still "another Halo", another Forza" or "another Fable". Even Perfect Dark is coming back, rather than new studio The Coalition work on a fresh IP.

If nothing changes, 2021 will remain a totally barren year for Xbox, with Halo Infinite eventually releasing in November. Game Pass subscriber numbers are almost at 20 million so there's no big reason to alter course - but that also means if you already own the titles being given away and don't care about 4K, HDR and frame rate upgrades, there's little reason to invest.

Advertisement

1. You Still Don't Need It

Microsoft

Even Microsoft are weirdly acknowledging the fact you don't "need" an Xbox Series X. In various interviews approaching and since launch, Xbox head Phil Spencer has championed the "Xbox ecosystem" more than any specific console sales numbers.

Advertisement

He's formerly said the brand's main competition is more Amazon and Google than Sony and Nintendo, and it speaks to a wider mentality of Xbox being the brand in video game playing - like Netflix for movies - rather than a medium-specific battle for superiority.

Microsoft are thinking big with Xbox, and they actively don't care which version of the system you buy. Everything IS best on Series X, the same way a £1000 smartphone has faster refresh rates and smoother app transitions, but the time for exclusives and traditional reasons to invest will come later.

Advertisement

Right now, the Game Pass, all-financial options welcome, "Just look at all these games"-style approach is working wonders. The future should bring new Bethesda IPs, first-party exclusives and titles that take full advantage of the console, but that won't be for at least another year.

For now, the Xbox Series X gives you everything and nothing to play, simultaneously.

Advertisement