It might seem like simple Gallows humour football banter to suggest that there is a genuine phenomenon at play when players mysteriously lose their skill under Alan Pardew's guidance, but there are too many examples at Newcastle alone that seem to suggest there might be something in the accusations. While he continues to say his team are fighting for him, and he is doing everything he can to drag his side up the league, it is painfully obvious that he is not the man to manage talents. This, remember was the same manager who couldn't get anything out of Carlos Tevez, and got himself sacked despite having the world class striker available to play. And this is the same manager who bought Javier Mascherano and left him out of the first-team entirely. To say he has a track record of mis-managing star players is the under-statement to end all under-statements, and unfortunately he's already worked his "magic" on at least ten of Newcastle's most talented players. This is not the place to talk about the youth talents, and supposedly big prospects who have failed to make it into the first team picture under Pardew - they are numerous and tragic, but it is far more interesting to look at the players who were already established and talented when they came under Pardew's control at Newcastle...
10. Demba Ba
It's fair to say that the Senegalese striker took some time to adapt to playing at Newcastle: when he signed on a free from West Ham he didn't find his feet straight away, thanks in part to the impact of Ramadan (or so fans said) and partly because the team took some time to gel with his more athletic style than Andy Carroll's purer target man mould. But then, Ba arrived with a bang and started hitting the net with aplomb, scoring 15 goals by the time he went off to the African Nations in January. Then Newcastle signed Papiss Cisse to play alongside him, and Newcastle fans started to dream about having a strike-force like Shearer and Ferguson again, with two names to scream out. Except, that's not how Pardew's brain worked at the time, and instead of playing the pair together, or entertaining the idea of letting the 15 goal hitman play in the position he'd scored 15 goals from, he changed system. Ultimately, the move to a wider attacking front with Ba on the left profited Cisse and helped Newcastle finish fifth, but it came at a cost. Ba was forced out of position and stopped scoring entirely, and his attitude seemingly changed, spelling the beginning of the end of his career. He was always very keen to be considered the star player, and once more Pardew misjudged the situation and compromised one of his most useful players because of his inability to juggle more than one talent.
9. Hatem Ben Arfa
The same system change that stopped Demab Ba from scoring, and helped Papiss Cisse have such an explosive start to his Newcastle career also took the reins off Hatem Ben Arfa and allowed him to put in the kind of attacking performances that made him an instant hero with Newcastle fans. On the right side of the front three, and not asked to defend (a grotesque suggestion for someone so gifted going forward), Ben Arfa flourished, and while Cisse's goals were important, they wouldn't all have happened if it wasn't for the progressive play of Ben Arfa. But then because he'd already p*ssed Demba Ba off once, Pardew followed up his unwarranted fifth place finish and Manager Of The Year award by completely changing the system and Ben Arfa's role in particular, and then castigated him publicly for not tracking back or playing for the team. He quickly ignored the fact that Ben Arfa had been a sensation the season before in a system that suited him, and rather than shaping his team around the talents he had, he built a new system that valued industry and was set up to favour Demba Ba (who already had one foot out of the door anyway), and then made Ben Arfa his scapegoat when things started to go wrong. The rest, as they say is history, and somehow Pardew remains at the club while Ben Arfa listens to Steve Bruce's attacking football philosophies down at Hull.
8. Shane Ferguson
By no means a talent on the same scale as Hatem Ben Arfa, the Northern Irish midfielder was classed as an up and coming prospect for a while before he was sent out into the No Man's Land of the loan market and basically forgotten about. It wasn't just that Ferguson was basically left to rot at Birmingham City - which he was even when Lee Clark dropped him from the first team and made his loan contract there pointless - it was that Pardew openly admitted in March last year that the club weren't really keeping track of his progress. Surely the point of a loan is for development, not just to get players away from the club so you don't have to pick them. And then even worse, Pardew did his usual trick of publically criticising a young player - he clearly believes in tough love for younger talents (hence his criticism of Paul Dummett and Sammy Ameobi recently), but it is a despicable thing to do, particularly when the player isn't at the club and he hasn't even been keeping a close eye on his progress. The fact that Ferguson is now stagnating at the club - possibly set for another loan before November - despite Joe Kinnear saying he was good enough to sign (the idiot) not so long ago, offers some indication of what those comments and the lack of developmental encouragement have done to Ferguson.
7. Vurnon Anita
What do you get if you cross a technical European footballer who isn't traditionally English in type, but is hugely gifted with the ball at his feet, and a manager whose idea of cultured football is swapping Yoan Gouffran and Moussa Sissoko's wings once or twice a game? You get the situation that Dutch wonder Vurnon Anita currently faces at Newcastle. Prized by Ajax as one of their most important midfield assets, Anita moved from left-back in Holland to a defensive midfield role that relied on his vision and passing ability rather than brute strength and sweat, and it worked marvellously, drawing the attention of Graham Carr amid comparisons to Clarence Seedorf. That comparison was nailed on - he was so key for Ajax that they dropped no points when he played in midfield: he might not be the bruiser that Cheick Tiote is, but he's strong, he passes wonderfully and he is hugely intelligent, the latter two aspects being the reason Pardew, and some brainless fans think he's too "lightweight" for the Premier League. As if kicking someone is better than passing progressively and turning possession into attack. As long as Pardew stays, I weep for Anita, who is the most misunderstood talent Newcastle currently have.
6. Moussa Sissoko
Moussa Sissoko was Newcastle's most creative player last season by a country mile. He was also probably the most criticised midfield from the Gallowgate, and fans continue to claim he is terrible despite fine performances for France and stats that indicate that he is being held back by something at Newcastle. The answer to the question of why Sissoko cannot recapture his France form for Newcastle is that his manager doesn't know what to do with him. Remember, Pardew is the manager whose simplistic concept of attacking is letting Gabriel Obertan run in a straight line down the side of the pitch to confuse defenders who've been dazzled by 75 minutes of sideways passing and long balls over the heads of the attacking players who like the ball at their feet. So it's no wonder Sissoko puts his head down and runs - it's exactly what he's being told to do. Doing that, he's unable to link up with the strikers or midfielders in the way he does for France. He's forced to try and take the man on with power and hard-work (the pillars of Pardew's misguided philosophy) and inevitably, he runs into a brick wall more often than not.
5. Davide Santon
From the new Paolo Maldini to Newcastle's third choice left-back, behind Paul Dummett in a matter of years. Yes he is right footed, as every Newcastle fan over the age of 35 points out as if it's his gravest crime, and yes he was somewhat unpolished when he signed for Newcastle, but you don't earn that sort of comparison from someone as astute as Jose Mourinho without having something special about you. It is utter garbage to say that Paul Dummett is better than the Italian, whose positional sense and attacking play both strip the Geordie by absolute miles, and it is simply not true that opposition players exploit his right-footedness by taking him on on the outside. How many teams now play with old-fashioned wingers? Santon should be a lot closer to first choice than he is when he is fit, and the sorry fact is that when Newcastle do give up on one of their left-backs (3 is too many at any club) it will likely be him who is forced out.
4. Yoan Gouffran
Though he wasn't exactly prolific at Bordeaux, Gouffran was essentially signed as a forward, and quickly became a victim of his own willingness to work hard, which clearly pricked up Alan Pardew's ears and filled his heart with that admiration he only gets when players fight to the death for his cause. Because he would run back and help cover defence, Gouffran was increasingly dropped backwards and moved further away from being the striker he had been in France, drying up his goals - despite a reputation as an astute finisher with both feet. Under Pardew, Gouffran is now little more than a wide midfielder, encouraged to run as much as possible, but not too far forward as to expose the defence to counter-attacks, and he has been badly saddled by Pardew's obsession with industry. He might start in an advanced role, but with the responsibilities he has to cover the entire flank (especially when he plays in front of the usually immobile Paul Dummett) he is nowhere near as effective as he once was.
3. Sylvain Marveaux
There's something about talented French attacking midfielders that just doesn't mesh well with Alan Pardew. Ask the manager and he'll probably say it's all down to the attitude they show: Sissoko will work hard, so he's in, Gouffran will run forever, so he's in, but Hatem Ben Arfa wouldn't change the way he played to fit a system that didn't suit him, so he was pushed out, and Sylvain Marveaux likewise didn't suit Pardew's vision so he was jettisoned. The greatest trick Pardew has pulled in both of those player's cases is to convince Newcastle fans that neither were particularly good in the first place because they never worked hard enough. By that logic, David Ginola and Laurent Robert would never have been allowed near the first team under Pardew. The truth is that Marveaux is a very gifted attacker - deft of footwork, possessing great vision and with the key to playing in the traditional attacking midfield role that Pardew has struggled to understand since he came in. Rather than playing Marveaux through the middle in the hole - where he should have - he's play him wide, or in central midfield, which is like getting a formula one car to plough a field. And yet we all seemed to go along with the assessment that he had a bad attitude and was lazy - kudos to Pardew on that front.
2. Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa
If you believe Alan Pardew's assessment that Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa is not good enough for the Premier League, you should probably have your right to form opinions revoked. The defender is not "too lightweight" for English football - he is the same height as Coloccini and weighs more - and nor is he the wrong style of player: he is a cultured ball-playing stopper who can tackle firmly and has the vision not to just hoof the ball out of play. In fact, he's a little like Fabricio Coloccini, who was given far more of a chance after a ropey start to his Newcastle career than the Frenchman ever was under Pardew. While Pardew was happy to send the defender out on loan - and scrap him as a transfer error - he's playing in the Champions League with Roma and being selected for France. So who is wrong? If the right sort of centre-half is Mike Williamson, I'm not sure I want to like football any more.
1. Papiss Cisse
Yes, he has scored four goals this season, but the tragedy of Papiss Cisse is that he doesn't even realise that Alan Pardew is the reason he has struggled to score goals since his incredible break-out half-season. When he came in, he was a bundle of raw energy, instinctive and arrogant enough to try shots like the one that went in against Chelsea. He would shoot first and think later, and wouldn't worry about playing on the shoulder of defenders as his instincts would work him into goal-scoring positions. That's why he exploded onto the English scene with a raft of goals. But then Pardew had a whole pre-season with him, and thanks to the grumbles of Demba Ba changed his system to accommodate the grumpy scorer. He also seemingly taught Cisse to forget about instinct, and to try and be a fox in the box style finisher, rather than a roaming striker, because he needed discipline to accommodate both Cisse and Ba. That compromised Cisse's style and spirit, and made him embarrassingly prone to offsides, and his confidence suffered so much that he has never quite recaptured the form of that first half season again. Which other Pardewed players do you think belong on this list? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.