In the summer, Brendan Rodgers managerial stock couldnt really have been much higher if he had tried. The Northern Irishman had just guided Liverpool to within a few games of winning their maiden Premier League title, and he had got the Reds playing some of the most expansive, entertaining football in the clubs history. He was young, attacking and seemingly destined to be the heir to Bill Shankly at Anfield. Fast forward six months though, and the 41-year-old is now being tipped to lose his job at some point before next summer. Liverpool have endured an appalling start to the 2014/15 campaign, and the sale of Luis Suarez and loss of Daniel Sturridge to injury has hit the team hard. The Merseysiders find themselves in the bottom half of the Premier League, and Sundays 3-0 defeat to bitter rivals Manchester United was another low point in a wretched season to date. Rodgers is coming in for all sorts of criticism, whether it be because of tactical errors, man-management skills or a seemingly relentless quest to be footballs answer to David Brent. With the turn of the year approaching, the former Swansea manager has various parts of his management he needs to improve on. They are the following.
8. Stop Holding Grudges
One of the most bizarre aspects of Rodgers management so far this season has been his seemingly strange decision to freeze certain players out of the team for no particular reason. There have been several victims, and it makes no sense. Mamadou Sakho was disciplined was leaving Anfield before kick-off in the Merseyside derby back in September, having not been selected in the matchday squad. This was poor from the Frenchman, but he learned his lesson and apologised. Since then, however, Rodgers has barely played him. Admittedly, he has missed a fair chunk of action through injury, but he has been fit for a couple of weeks now, and he was only brought on against Bournemouth in the Capital One Cup quarter-final on Wednesday because of an injury to Dejan Lovren. Sakho is the best defender at the club, and if the Reds were thriving in that area, you could argue he has to earn his place back in the team. They are appalling at the back though, and he simply has to become a regular again. Fabio Borini is another who is consistently being given the silent treatment, and it appears as though its almost as punishment for not leaving Liverpool in the summer. Its all fairly childish from the Reds boss, and he needs to address it in the New Year.
7. Better Use Of Substitutions
Some of Rodgers substitution choices have left a lot to be desired so far this season, and time and time again you find yourself scratching your head at his odd decisions. There have been numerous examples to choose from, whether it be his inexcusable decision to bring Adam Lallana off at half-time against United when he was Liverpools best player, or making left-back Alberto Moreno one his changes when two goals were needed to keep the Reds in the Champions League against Basel. Last season, the 41-year-old had the luxury of a fresh, fit squad for much of the season, and his starting eleven almost picked itself week in, week out. Games were often already won by the time he chose to make a change, and it made little alteration to the eventual result. Now, he is having to change things in order to turn round a deficit or cling onto a lead, and he is being shown up. He is still young and learning, of course, but its an area of his development he needs to improve in.
6. Learn To Win Ugly
One of the most frustrating things about being a Liverpool fan is their inability to win ugly. It has always been that way during the Premier League era, with Gerard Houllier and Rafa Benitez succeeding slightly with it at times but not always. Rodgers simply cannot master it, and it is an art. United, Arsenal and Chelsea are the kings of it, and have 15 or 20 years of it behind them. Arsene Wengers side take a lot of stick, but think about how often they nick late goals in gritty matches. Last season, Liverpool were blowing teams away and fully deserving their wins, but it wasnt often they really ground out ugly wins like Manchester City or Chelsea did at times. There were hard-fought wins Fulham and West Ham, but in truth, its hard to think of more than a couple during Rodgers tenure. The Reds can quite often boss games, but then one error sees them fall behind and facing an uphill battle. You have to look no further than last weekends loss to United at Old Trafford. Liverpool had completely dominated the first 15 minutes or so, but Raheem Sterling missed a golden chance to open the scoring, the hosts broke away and Wayne Rooney clinically made it 1-0. It was ruthless; something Rodgers just cannot make his side. To win a game they have to dominate it, and its hugely frustrating.
5. Be Less Stubborn
All great managers have total belief in their ability, but they are also intelligent enough to realise that when things arent going well, you have to go with a Plan B. Rodgers clearly has a huge amount of confidence in his own talents, and genuinely believes he is the right man for the job, but he must stop refusing to change his beliefs even when the team is losing consistently. The Northern Irishman loves his team to pass the ball out from the back and believes strongly in death by football, rather than playing a more direct style. Thats all well and good, but when you have people as inept as Simon Mignolet, Martin Skrtel and Lovren with the ball at their feet, who keep losing possession and putting each other under pressure, its time to change things up a bit. Similarly, what is the point of looking for tricky, incisive passes into space for Rickie Lmabert? The Englishman is a targetman, and occasional the ball should be played long in order to play to his strengths. Its almost as if Rodgers believes that eventually it will come good, and that Mignolet, Skrtel and Lovren will turn into Manuel Neuer, Gerard Pique and Thiago Silva, playing the ball out from the back with consummate ease. It wont. He has to accept his system doesnt always work, and stop being so stubborn.
4. Spend Better In The Transfer Market
When Suarez left in the summer, everybody knew Liverpool were losing arguably the third best player on the planet. He was always going to be a huge loss, but Rodgers still had a huge amount of money to spend in order to make up for El Pistoleros exit. It would be harsh to call his summer spending disastrous, as a lot of the new players are very young and cant be judged properly yet, but he simply didnt bring in enough experienced, established stars. The likes of Moreno, Javier Manquillo, Emre Can, Lazar Markovic and Divock Origi are all either 22 or younger, Balotelli is 24 and unpredictable, and even 26-year-old Lallana is a young 26 who hasnt been at the top level for long. He needed to sign three or four players between 25 and 30, who had played regular Champions League football or at least regular football in one of Europe's major leagues. Its not too much of a surprise that virtually all of the purchases have failed to impress so far, barring possibly Lallana, and Rodgers made a big mistake in going almost solely for youth. He has to learn from this mistake in January and next summer, and also improve his general activity in the transfer market. Theres an argument to say that, of the 20-odd players Rodgers has signed since taking over at Anfield in 2012, only Sturridge and Philippe Coutinho have been genuine success stories. He has to improve markedly in this respect.
3. Know His Own First-Choice Starting XI
The secret behind every top class, in-form side is that they invariably have the same team week in, week out. Of course, injuries and suspensions can come into play, but there should always be seven or eight players playing the majority of matches. Just look at Chelsea so far this season, whose first-choice starting eleven you could virtually rattle off without stopping. The same applies with Real Madrid and Bayern Munich. This season, Liverpools team has changed an unbelievable amount, and it really is impossible to gauge what on earth Rodgers strongest possible line-up would be with everyone fit. Would it be Glen Johnson or Manquillo at right-back? Does Sakho come in for either Skrtel or Lovren? Is Steven Gerrard a guaranteed starter? Is it Lucas Leiva or Joe Allen? Do Coutinho and Lallana get in, or just one of them, or neither? It really is a mess. It almost looks as though Rodgers has tried to impress too much with the constant juggling of his squad, with the addition of Champions League football, and because of it there is no cohesion about the team. The defence are all over the place, and a huge reason for that is because, barring Skrtel, nobody else has a clue if they will start each week. No doubt the former Reading boss would claim he knows exactly what his best team is, but that seems very doubtful at the moment. Hes trying all sorts of formations, playing Jordan Henderson and Markovic as wing-backs, for example, and it all looks a bit clueless.
2. Use Steven Gerrard More Wisely
So much has been made of both Gerrards form and future this season, and there can be no doubting that, on the whole, the skipper has been a shadow of the player he was last season. While the 34-year-old deserves to shoulder some of the blame for his poor form, it is Rodgers who needs to take the bulk of it for playing Gerrard so much. It is clear that the Liverpool legends pace, fitness and general influence is not what it once was, and that he should be rested more in order to get the best out of him. Sir Alex Ferguson did it with Paul Scholes and Ryan Giggs, Jose Mourinho and Manuel Pellegrini have done it with Frank Lampard, and it has paid dividends. Why Rodgers hasn't taken a leaf out of their book is baffling. Perhaps he doesnt trust the other midfielders to perform without their talisman alongside them, but then that goes back to the earlier point about his effectiveness in the transfer market. Gerrard is still a class act on his day, and he can still be an effective player for the Reds for a few more years to come, but the time has come where he cant play three games in a week. Rodgers seems to think he can, and it is having a detrimental effect on both the captain and the whole team. He needs to be rested for the odd Premier League game here and there, or it will hinder Liverpools progress further.
1. Focus On Defence More
Liverpools magical attacking football last season was a joy to watch, and they scored over 100 goals in the league. The only problem with this was that it masked some extremely average defending throughout the campaign. They let in 50 goals in their 38 games, which for a team challenging for the title, is very poor. They were conceding two or three goals fairly often, and their pathetic capitulation against Crystal Palace in May, in which they surrendered a three-goal lead, summed it all up. There is a nagging feeling with lots of Rodgers detractors that he simply doesnt take the defensive side of things seriously enough, and its clear to see why people think that. Liverpool have no defensive coach, which is surely a major error, and the general cohesion at the back has been embarrassing at times this season. Time and time again the Reds concede from set-pieces, with slack marking often the issue, and they also make far too many individual errors. Even little things like Coutinhos woeful tracking of Rooney last weekend have to be blamed on Rodgers. There is absolutely no way in a million years Mourinho would allow one of his midfielders to be so negligent of their defensive duties. At the moment, there seems to be no sign of Liverpool improving defensively, and that is all because of Rodgers. Even if Sakho and a new goalkeeper come into the side, it will only paper over the cracks. Until the Northern Irishman starts focusing on the defensive side of things as much as the attacking aspect, his side will continue to struggle. Hiring a defensive coach is paramount, for starters. Sami Hyypia would tick all the boxes, if he were to lose his job in charge of Brighton. Its the most important of all Rodgers things he must improve in 2015. Let us know your thoughts on Brendan Rodgers in the comments section.Follow Henry on twitter: @HenryJackson87