Newcastle's second pre-season match saw them go down 2-1 to Mexican side Club Atlas as defensive problems blighted yet another Magpies game. Atlas' Gonzalo Bergessio managed to get himself in behind Jamaal Lascelles, only for the ex-Nottingham Forest defender to scythe the forward down in the box. The late challenge showed naivety and a rawness that will take time to draw out of Lascelles - and Bergessio punished the big defender by calmly slotting the penalty into the left-hand corner. Then, just seven minutes later, Yoan Gouffran played an awful ball back from midfield that was intercepted by Atlas Cristian Tabo, who lofted a precise pass over a poorly-positioned and hesitant Mike Williamson. Bergessio then ran on to the ball and smashed a lovely finish over Krul and into the net. Remember Marco Van Basten in the Euro '88 final? This was better (maybe). Moussa Sissokos finessed finish right on half-time gave Magpies the momentum heading into the second 45, but Newcastles inept first-half display ultimately proved to be their downfall - and this result will leave McClaren, Ian Cathro and the rest of the backroom staff in no doubt that serious groundwork is still needed to rid this Newcastle side of their rotten habits. Once again there were plenty of positives to take from the game, so Magpies fans shouldn't be downhearted by the result. It is still very early days in terms of Steve McClaren's reign and United's pre-season schedule after all... Here's everything WhatCultureNUFC learned from the performance...
Advertisement
17. The Word 'Friendly' Doesn't Appear In The Spanish Dictionary
While Newcastle were treating this as an exercise, this game appeared to be the Champions League final for Club Atlas. The Mexicans were up for the fight and took no prisoners when it came to challenges on the pitch. They left a number of United players, most notably Moussa Sissoko and Ayoze Perez, in crumpled heaps as well as goading Jack Colback into receiving a yellow card in a friendly... They even resorted to time wasting during the second half when Newcastle were very much on top. That's how much it meant to them. There will be a few bumps and scrapes in the United camp when they wake up on Wednesday morning over in Milwaukee.
16. Michael James Williamson Needs To Get Out Of Toon ASAP!
Let's get the elephant in the room out of the way... We've known this for well over three years now, but this game confirmed that not even Steve McClaren is suited to get any sort of Premier League class out of Newcastle's number six. Willo had one of his customary shockers over in America on Wednesday morning. He was caught out for Atlas second goal as he managed to turn slower than a bottle of milk As well as proceeding to give countless balls away, panic under pressure and just make a complete mockery of the more attractive style of play McClaren is trying to implement. There's no other way of saying this, he needs to leave.
15. Steve McClaren Wants To Play A Certain Way And There's Nothing That Will Change That
United found themselves 2-0 down pretty quickly over in Milwaukee, but even the threat of being embarrassed by a team that is perceived to be far inferior to Newcastle didn't see the new head coach show any signs of desperation. McClaren's new look black and whites continued to keep the ball on the deck, trying to build things up from the back rather than pumping it long like they would have undoubtedly resorted to under the basic tactics of both Alan Pardew and John Carver. The centre backs continued to split every time either Tim Krul or Karl Darlow got the ball while Vurnon Anita was their first port of call every single time. It was great to see Steve keep his council and look at the bigger picture of developing an identity for his new charges rather than just a pre season game's result. And on the balance of play in the second half, The Magpies can count themselves unlucky not to have snatched a draw or even a win after such a dire first half. Newcastle won't win every game next season, but when they do inevitably go down to a defeat, they will do so in style.
14. Newcastle Need At Least One Central Defender ASAP!
Some would say they should have had one top class replacement over the line and in for Willo yesterday... It is something we have known for well over a year really, possibly longer. The baffling decision to allow Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa to leave the club last summer almost cost United when a lack of options at the back inevitably raised its ugly head towards the end of the 2014/15 campaign. And the fact that both Willo and Lascelles had to play the full 90 after Fabricio Coloccini was left out of the match day squad tells you everything you need to know. Whether it be Joel Matip, Ron Vlaar, Nicolas Nkoulou or someone else, seemingly anyone would be a step up in class on poor old Iron Mike.
13. Papiss Cisse REALLY Wants To Remain A Newcastle Player
It was abundantly clear once more than Papiss Cisse was playing for his Newcastle United future. The striker was full of running and was blatantly trying to get more involved with some of the intricate passing moves that the team were putting together, something he normally stays away from. The 30-year-old didn't have too many chances but after seeing a couple fail to trouble the Atlas goal, he had a header brilliantly saved by keeper Miguel Pinto when a spot of goal line technology could have come to Untied's aid. But there has definitely been a change in the style of his play that Ian Cathro especially, and his high press tactics, will have loved seeing over the past two games.
12. Tim Krul Still Can't Kick A Football
Being such an experienced Premier League and international goalkeeper as Timothy is, surely it would be a given that his kicking would be up to scratch. Sadly, it isn't. And there doesn't seem to be signs of any improvement. Apart from picking the ball out of his net twice, and making one comfortable save from an Atlas free kick, kicking the ball was all Krul had to do. And it's fair to say they went here, there and absolutely everywhere. Thankfully, Karl Darlow looks a lot more at home with the ball at his feet. Which could indicate the Dutch international could finally have some viable competition for his number one jersey...
11. Maybe Vurnon Anita Won't Be The Answer To McClaren's Style Of Play
Last Friday against Gateshead, quite literally everything United did going forward started off with one of the centre backs receiving the ball in wide areas before ferrying it onto Vurnon within three touches. Newcastle tried to do the same again on Wednesday morning, but the harrying style of Atlas meant Anita didn't have the time on the ball that he did at the International Stadium. This saw him lose the ball far too often, misplacing many passes as well as getting caught in possession in really dangerous areas. Pretty much what we have come to expect from the now former Dutch international during his three years on Tyneside. The little terrier simply needs too much time on the ball to get his head up and see the next pass to set the black and whites away on their next attack. Maybe the quick thinking and fleet-footed Georginio Wijnaldum is the man for McClaren's double six formation. Club Atlas' style, and higher level of quality of play will be a lot closer to what The Magpies can expect from the majority of sides in the Premier League, which indicates Vurn may not be the answer he would have hoped to be. The central midfielder has come out and claimed the style of 'hoof ball' played under Alan Pardew and John Carver didn't play to his strengths and meant we haven't seen the best of him so far. Now that Steve is playing the brand of football that apparently suits him to the ground, Anita has no room for failure.
10. If Lascelles And Williamson Start A Premier League Game Together, You Should Be Worried
Remember when Fabricio Coloccini and Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa played alongside each other away at Everton against Romelu Lukaku? Well this was similar in the way that two similar players, with very similar weaknesses, played against a front line that exploited them to the max... We're not saying Jamaal is in a similar class to Mike Williamson, only time will tell if he is just as out of his depth, but he and his partner are far too similar to be together in the same defensive unit. You get the sense that they could only cope with a front-line consisting of John's Carew and Hartson, or players of a similar ilk... But when's that ever going to happen? Half a yard of pace and Newcastle will be in trouble. Former Nottingham Forest man Lascelles would benefit from playing alongside a smaller, ball-playing centre half who isn't Captain Colo... (He's past it, isn't he?)
9. Maybe Steve McClaren Doesn't Have The Players To Implement His Passing Brand Of Football
The message is clear, but maybe the calibre of player Steve McClaren has at his disposal means Newcastle will never be able to play the brand of football the fans lust after. Club Atlas were everything that the former England manager wants his new side to be. They combined a fluid style of play with the effectiveness that made them a stubborn proposition to break down without the ball. Then again, their group of players have been together a lot longer than United's, so Steve could have that perfect blend in place by the time the season starts. However, as long as the likes of Mike Williamson and Yoan Gouffran start a match, you get the feeling Newcastle will never reach the standards their new head coach hopes they can. Neither of them are capable of implementing what their coach wants to see from them.
8. Yoan Gouffran Is Still As Pointless As Ever
Anonymous. He gave the ball away which led to Atlas' second goal while a couple of his long-range efforts sailed over the opponent's bar. Another pointless display.
7. Rolando Aarons Looks Fitter Than Ever
Those who saw the winger play at Gateshead last Friday would have been left underwhelmed, but Rolando bounced back with a bang after being introduced in the second half. The England U19 international showed the Atlas right back a clean pair of heels on a number of occasions, as his introduction jolted a bit of life into United's display. Hopefully his fitness edges closer to 100% over the remaining two games of the American tour so we can finally see what a fully fit Rolando Aarons can do. Remember, he didn't do too badly when he was half fit last term... The potential partnership between Rolando and Massadio Haidara is looking more and more promising as pre season wears on.
6. United's Free-Kick Routines Are Still As Unimaginative As Ever
Newcastle United need to spend the rest of pre-season making sure they can score a goal from a set-piece next season. Nothing has changed in this area of the game from the Alan Pardew era, which saw The Magpies go over three years without netting from a corner. Things got so bad that Newcastle even resorted to the horrible sight of a long 'hoof' from deep aimed for the bonce on Mike Williamson. Needless to say the big centre-half didn't win his duel. Things need to change and quickly. Maybe Georginio Wijnaldum's creativity can spark something in United's game next term..
5. A Little Bit Of Pace Baffles United's 'Double 6' Formation
Newcastle will be playing a 4-2-3-1 formation, also known as a double 6 on the continent, next season. This will see a lot of emphasis put on the two holding midfielder in the side. As solid a structure that may seem, the speed at which Atlas turned their defence into attack showed United can't deal with individual nor collective pace. They were 2-0 down very early on thanks to this, with the second coming as a result of Yoan Gouffran giving the ball away in a poor area. You would hope that the more Newcastle play this formation than the more resilient they will become. If they don't, far quicker teams than Atlas, with far cleverer players, will have a field day between Newcastle's rigid looking lines.
4. Massadio Haidara Finally Looks To Be Making The Left Back Slot His Own
He gets better and better by the game. Let's hope one of his all too regular injuries doesn't get in the way of his development. Massadio was arguably United's man of the match for the second game in a row. If the Steve McClaren effect is rubbing off on anybody than it's the left back. He spent most of the game camped in Atlas' half and was Newcastle's main outlet in attacking positions. How mouthwatering does the potential partnership between the Frenchman and Rolando Aarons look?
3. Moussa Sissoko Is Still Integral To Everything Newcastle Do
United's biggest threat going forward over in Milwaukee. Same old from Moussa who went on a number of lung-bursting runs to haul his team up the field before failing to find that final ball that would have seen Newcastle get the draw they more than deserved on the night. The French international did get a lovely finish to his name on the stroke of half time to half the deficit, as he kept his composure to slide the ball under the advancing keeper. He is still the focal point of everything The Magpies do. And whether you rate him or not, his potential departure this summer would be a huge blow.
2. The Players Are Still Adjusting To The New Formation
One thing that was painfully evident during the first half was the gap between striker Papiss Cisse and the rest of the midfield. Siem de Jong, who did show a few bright touches during the 90 minutes as well as coming painfully close to the equaliser, was lost for large spells and failed to do his job of offering plenty of support to Newcastle's number nine. Hopefully an understanding will develop over the coming weeks, if Papiss remains at the club of course and if the Dutchman's lungs don't explode before the start of the season... Newcastle did get better after the break as their hold on the game became a lot stronger, and that fluidity Steve McClaren wants to see should come as the players get to know each other a lot more.
1. No One Needs To Panic After This Result
Yes Newcastle could have found themselves 5-0 down at half time, but they more than sorted themselves after the break and had enough chances to win the game. The style of play didn't waver, certain members of the squad got more individual minutes under their belts and the players as a group got another 90 minutes under their belts to get to know each other. Even though they did lose to what many will look at as a far inferior side, it wasn't that all bad... Although things should only get better from here on in. Still plenty of positive signs for United fans to live off until Newcastle take on Sacramento Republic in three days time. CLICK HERE to read the match report from Newcastle's 2-1 loss to Club Atlas on their US Tour.And CLICK HERE to read the player ratings from the game too.For all the latest NUFC News, Views and Transfers make sure to follow whatculture.com/NUFC on Twitter and Facebook.