10 Horror TV Shows That Deserved Another Season
Don't go into these shows expecting an ending!
There are plenty of scary as all hell things in the world of horror TV. You've got relentless monsters, creepy killers, paranormal activity, and plenty more. Still, all of those pale in comparison to the boot-quaking, gut-wrenching, heartbreaking word: cancelled!
Whenever you start an epic new series, you want to see it go on for as long as possible so you can get the most out of it. This is particularly true for scary shows, as a strong/successful horror series is quite rare to come by. Sadly, dreams like that often don't come true.
The sad fact of the matter is that TV is a business. As much as everyone would love to believe a good show can get by on its artistic merits alone, there are a crowd of producers and executives who think differently. If a series can't make decent profit, then it's destined for the chopping block.
That unfortunate fate befell all these horror shows, as although they had a lot to give, they were (like a slasher victim) cut off from life prematurely. If only they'd gotten one more season!
10. The Passage
Vampires! Everyone knows them, and everyone loves them. Even the worst of the blood-sucking creatures tend to be successful, with critically panned projects *cough* Twilight *cough* still making bank at the box office. That's what makes it so disappointing when a series about the beasties is cut short before it gets a chance to find its footing.
This series explored the fictional Project Noah, a secret government experiment that accidentally turned a collection of death row inmates into vampires - well-done guys. It followed a young girl (Amy) who got dragged into the experiment and the Federal Agent (Brad) who became her guardian.
It's safe to say The Passage was far from flawless, as the compelling premise was hindered by the relatively weak plot and unbalanced tone. Still, the series had promise, especially in the visuals and leading performances from Saniyya Sidney and Mark-Paul Gosselaar. There was a lot to love about it, and another season could have given it a chance to find itself. But sadly, it was cancelled after only one.
The show was based on a trilogy of books, meaning there was a wealth of material to be adapted. Still, at least that means you can find some closure if you liked this vampire thriller.
9. Scream Queens
Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuck are the kind of TV creators you either love or hate. They've got a pulpy and vibrant style that (somehow) manages to work for both their hit musical - Glee - and their anthology horror series - American Horror Story. The infamous horror/comedy Scream Queens felt like a bridge between those two, and love it or hate it, it's a shame it didn't get a third season.
Scream Queens was a semi-anthology series that followed an all-star cast (including Emma Roberts, Abigail Breslin, Jamie Lee Curtis and more) as a serial killer hunted them in differing locations. The first was a sorority house, and the second was at a hospital. This setting change helped make each season feel unique, and fans were keen to see what would happen next. Then, Fox axed the show after its second season.
While Scream Queens gave viewers plenty to groan at - such as its worship of celebrities and the typical jarring tone expected from Murphy/Falchuck - it still had a popcorn horror vibe that was easy to sit through, which is what made the cancellation so disappointing.
Still, despite being off the air, Murphy has stated that he's still working on making a third season happen, so fingers crossed for the Queens!
8. Lovecraft Country
This cancellation really hurt, as Lovecraft Country gave you a horror experience that's few and far between. It was a juggling act between shocking cosmic horror and realistic historical implications, combining the (unfortunately close) world of racism and Lovecraft in a fascinating mesh. Then, naturally, it got cancelled. *Sigh*.
The series followed a group of African-Americans as they ventured across Jim Crow era America in search of the lead's father. Along the way, they struggled against the terrors of racism and Lovecraftian monsters.
It's not just that good Lovecraft projects are hard to come by; it's that the focus on 50s segregation allowed for leeway to explore some of the legendary author's abhorrently racist beliefs. This allowed you to appreciate and enjoy Lovecraftian horror while tackling the author's issues head on - it was a win-win.
The reason for the show's ending isn't entirely apparent, as multiple reasons have been touted. One is that the show was too expensive to make, another stated that there wasn't a clear enough vision for the next season, and another claimed a toxic work environment created by the showrunner, Misha Green.
Unfortunately, it's the kind of thing fans will likely never get a full answer on, and that's almost as sad as never seeing more of the fantastic show.
7. In The Flesh
It's pretty uncommon to stumble across horror on the BBC, as it's a channel that tends to look more towards drama than genre shows. Still, decent ones can be found, such as Inside No. 9, Being Human, 2020's Dracula, and - rather predictably - In The Flesh. Sadly, although this show was great, it didn't get the chance to reach season three.
In The Flesh followed a teenager called Kieran Walker as he attempted to return peacefully to his hometown. Why was that a struggle, you may ask? Well, because Kieran was a zombie taking part in a relocation scheme to re-enter the undead back into everyday life. Now that's a tough gig.
The series began with three hour-long episodes, then a traditional nine-episode second season. It was a compelling watch that explored zombies more intimately than the likes of The Walking Dead or World War Z. The story also really geared up the action, drama and intrigue, with season two leaving some big questions for the future.
Unfortunately, the series got caught up in the BBC budget cuts of 2015 and BBC Three's transition into an online-only service. This timing resulted in the show not being renewed for its (much deserved) third instalment.
6. The Exorcist
It's easy to groan and roll your eyes when you hear of a famous horror property being adapted for TV, as many of these shows turn into cheap attempts to capitalise on a long-dead franchise (looking at you The Purge). Still, Fox's The Exorcist might be one of the best examples of pulling something like this off - at least, until it got cancelled.
The show acted as a sequel to the original (and iconic) 1973 movie, readjusting the canon and forgoing the sequels. It followed a pair of exorcists as they investigated cases of demonic possession, including the hauntings of an unlucky family and a foster home.
It certainly didn't have the same X-factor as the movie, but this series worked hard to give you pulse-pounding scares, compelling human drama and a slew of moments that got you sweating. Across its two seasons, it showed it had strong writing, acting and visual effects.
Sadly, the Exorcist became part of Fox's cull of shows in 2018, including other victims like The Mick, Lucifer and Brooklyn Nine-Nine. While the latter two managed to find new homes, The Exorcist was left disappointingly outcasted.
5. Invasion
Sometimes, the timing of a TV show's release can be a real dampener for its potential success. For example, you wouldn't want to watch a compelling horror series with rampant depictions of a hurricane directly after Hurricane Katrina, right? Yeah, that became uncomfortably accurate for this series as one of its major plots accidentally became a reality.
Invasion was a brilliant sci-fi horror series from 2005. It told the story of a small Florida town that was invaded by water-based creatures after being hit by a devastating hurricane. The plot also took plenty of inspiration from the classic Invasion of the Body Snatchers, as these invaders tried to take over the characters' bodies.
Of course, the show really got off on the wrong foot, as the unlucky link to the real-life tragedy made advertising challenging, and the imagery was difficult for many to handle. It's a massive shame, as the show boasted a career-best performance from William Fincher alongside actors like Tyler Labine, Alexis Dziena, Elizabeth Moss and a young Evan Peters.
The combination of its poor timing and low ratings meant that ABC didn't have much faith in it, and it became another sordid example of a show with so much potential dying before its time.
4. Santa Clarita Diet
Making three whole seasons of a series is nothing to scoff at, especially when the concept is as odd and bonkers as this one. Still, three just wasn't enough, as this Netflix horror comedy is yet another example of a show ending on a painful cliffhanger and not going out on its own terms.
The series followed a married couple of real estate agents, played by Drew Barrymore and Timothy Olyphant. Despite having great jobs and living in California, they didn't get to experience martial bliss, as Sheila (Barrymore) soon began to turn into a zombie. The pair worked to find a cure and survive the consequences.
Santa Clarita Diet had a lot going for it, with the biggest highlight being the chemistry between Barrymore and Olyphant. It was funny, witty and gorier than a piranha attack, which made it an effortlessly fun watch.
The third season ended with a big revelation that would have carried the show through a fourth (and possible even final) season. But, Netflix gave it the boot, as it wasn't deemed a profitable investment anymore.
So, you'll never see the final dish on this diet.
3. Spooksville
One thing that the entertainment industry is starved for is horror content for children. While letting your kids watch scary things seems about as bright an idea as an unlit match in a dark cupboard, it's an excellent opportunity for youngsters to test themselves, see what scares them and have fun at the same time. That's especially true for this appropriately titled spookfest, as it was funny, quirky and creepy all in one neat package.
This show gave viewers an episodic, mystery of the week format, with a new kid discovering that he has a big part to play in the strange supernatural events of the town of Springville (nicknamed Spooksville, woo). Each episode saw him and two friends investigating strange occurrences, including ghosts, time-travel, humans turning into cats, homunculi and plenty more.
Overall, Spooksville was a blast and had all the hallmarks of a children's TV show classic in the making. Unfortunately, the series was never renewed after the final episode of season one (which ended on a massive cliffhanger).
After The Hub Network transitioned into Discovery Family, it aimed to promote educational shows, which unfortunately left Spooksville dangling in the dark. There's plenty of fan-protest for Netflix to renew the show (as it owns the rights), but by now, it's probably too little, too late.
2. Archive 81
And now, introducing yet another wicked Netflix horror show that got cancelled after one season due to budgetary/viewership concerns; Archive 81 - come on down!
Archive 81 is the most recent addition to this list, having only been released earlier this year, meaning the wound is still pretty fresh for many people. It is safe to say the thought of not getting another season of this gnarly series will take some getting used to, as it was a thrilling tale that deserved another instalment.
Based on the podcast of the same name, this series followed an archivist and a young grad student filmmaker. This duo - Dan and Melody - sought to restore the latter's ruined footage from a documentary of her investigations into a cult. Naturally, supernatural hijinks soon occurred.
The show was a fascinating combination of mystery and thrills, with a slow build leading to some truly terrifying scares. Its plot also went from zero to one hundred, as things got perplexing and insane towards the end. That same trend would have likely continued into season two.
It's always a shame when a show ends before its time, but this one stings as there's more source material to cover and many unanswered questions.
1. Hannibal
This show's inclusion here is the same as a meal that would disappoint the legendary Hannibal Lecter, i.e. it's a no-brainer.
Hannibal's unjust cancellation might be one of the most egregious examples of a TV show being cut down in its prime, standing among the greats like Firefly, Pushing Daisies and Freaks and Geeks. It was a series that easily lived up to its iconic source material and did so with some gory as hell vigour.
The series explored the relationship between FBI criminal profiler Will Graham and the cannibalistic psychiatrist Dr Hannibal Lecter. It took stories from across Thomas Harris' novels, including Red Dragon and Hannibal, and was even set to tackle the infamous Silence of the Lambs down the line. Oh, what a sight that would have been!
Viewers were given every kind of horror treat they could have wanted, with an iconic/chilling performance from Mads Mikkelsen in the titular role, some compelling mystery, excellent writing/direction and, again, some nightmarish gore.
The show was ultimately cancelled due to low viewership, and fans have been petitioning for a fourth season ever since. It's not just fans who are thirsty for more Hannibal, as the creator (Bryan Fuller) has been pushing for a revival or a movie nonstop since it was cut short. Let's hope he gets his wish one day.