10 Most Unique Star Trek Episodes
What makes a Star Trek episode stand out from the rest when a normal week features warp drive?
Star Trek is at its best when its pushing boundaries with its storytelling. That is not simply limited to the actual stories it's telling, but also the means by which it delivers them. The Original Series was famous for its morality plays, and the clever use of the relatively small budget it had to work with.
The Next Generation fared slightly better in some respects, but even when it tried to cost-cut, it could actually deliver some of the most powerful moments in television. Trek could delve into murky, morally dubious places, and could rise to the highest heights, shaking the ceilings of every theatre Broadway has to offer.
Across all of the series and nearly sixty years of stories, these are the ten most utterly unique episodes from The Cage to Hegemony, so see if your favourites are anywhere on the list, and let us know over on socials if they're not.
10. The Menagerie
The Menagerie, also known as the episode where the crew get together to watch a movie, was significant in a number of ways in 1966. First, it was the first and only two-part episode in The Original Series' entire run. Second, it consisted heavily of footage that had been reused from The Cage.
Though Jeffrey Hunter did not return to reprise the role of Christopher Pike, Sean Kenney sat in his place. From there, a tale of loyalty and Vulcan subbornness plays out over both parts. It would be easy to write this episode off as filler - and, to be fair, there is a large amount of time dedicated to watching Pike's adventure on Talos IV - but the framing is what truly makes it stand out.
The Cage, though it hadn't been aired at that point, showed the audience a very different Spock, along with a different atmosphere on the Enterprise itself. Though William Shatner's Kirk and Hunter's Pike never shared any scenes, it is fascinating to see the juxtaposition of their command styles, with Commander Spock serving as the intermediary. The Menagerie also offered us the iconic bleep-boop chair, as well as those beautiful Original-style dress uniforms.
9. Assignment: Earth
Assignment: Earth serves as the season finale for The Original Series' second year, while also trying to serve as a backdoor pilot for a new spin-off series that Gene Roddenberry was thinking of. Robert Lansing's Gary Seven may never again have appeared on our screens, despite the certainty of Kirk and Spock, but the episode is a fun romp all the same.
That is to say, it was fun from this side of the viewing experience. Actor Teri Garr had such an unpleasant time, thanks primarily to Roddenberry's hyper-focus on the length of her skirt, that she swore off ever returning to Star Trek, and generally doesn't enjoy discussing it at conventions.
Though this has somewhat tainted the episode's legacy, the guardians saw a return in Star Trek: Picard's second season. Talinn, an agent stationed on Earth, listened to Picard talk to her about Gary Seven's adventure, confirming that he was, in fact, part of her organisation. That may be the most that Trek will see of Seven, and of course the iconic Isis, but for a stand-alone show that effectively had very little to do with the Federation, Assignment: Earth rises above its environment.
8. Cause And Effect
A confession: as a younger person, this writer watched this episode and thought 'wow, they managed to save time and money here, repeating that act four times.'
I never claimed I was smart.
Cause And Effect is unique in that the first act and the final act are almost identical in structure (throw in the middle acts as well). The Enterprise is stuck in the rift, the Bozeman emerges, they impact, chaos on the bridge.
Despite the new Soyuz-class ship introduced here, itself a redress of the old Miranda-class, this episode truly is a bottle show. Yet it works perfectly, repeating the events just enough to evoke that sense of déja vú in the viewer, allowing the audience to start to figure things out as the characters begin to understand things have gone wrong.
There was almost a cheers reunion in this episode. Kelsey Grammer guest starred as Morgan Bateson, while just behind him stood a dark-haired officer. Perhaps this is something of an urban legend, but the theory is that it was originally supposed to be none other than Lt. Saavik standing there, a role originated of course by Grammer's Cheers co-star Kirstie Alley!
7. The Inner Light
Morgan Gendel must have smiled when this script made it to air. Here was a simple story about a probe, and a flute, and a bit of sunshine. What it became is one of the most impactful, emotional, and outstanding episodes of The Next Generation, even if the Enterprise-D only features in a small portion of it.
Picard's encounter with the Kataan Probe is one of those events that managed to stay with him, long after the credits rolle. In the 90s era of Star Trek, this was still quite a taboo thing to get away with. Even, at the time, Picard's assimilation by the Borg was effectively dealt with in The Best Of Both Worlds and Family, then it would take some time to rear its head again.
This ended up being an experience that would cross over into the real world, as the tune that Kamin's son plays, featuring a guest performance by Daniel Stewart, Patrick's actual son, would go on to form the basis of the theme tune for Star Trek: Picard.
6. Necessary Evil
Moving now to Deep Space Nine, this second season episode was the first noir crime drama, told in both present and flashback, given to the audience via snippets of Constable Odo's logs. It gave us some of our first views of Terok Nor, the terrifying ore processing station that would go on to become the eponymous Federation outpost.
Odo's time as head of security under Gul Dukat would be revisited again in such episodes as Things Past, but it is here that the hard-boiled nature of the Changeling is truly on display. Coupled with this is his initial meeting with Kira Nerys, leading to the reveal of a hidden crime all of those years later - something that affects both of them deeply.
While The Next Generation and The Original Series had flirted with darkness, this felt like a mission statement for the new show. René Auberjonois is fantastic as the Carver-esque detective, trying to solve a murder across two time-frames. It is perhaps a shame that it wasn't a genre that we spent more time in while the show was airing, but that also only serves to highlight the strength of this outing.
5. Far Beyond The Stars
In a way, the inclusion of this episode is quite obvious. Here was Star Trek using, not simply allegory, but a full period drama to depict racial discrimination in America in the 50s. Though The Original Series debuted in the 60s, it bears remembering that it was born in times, and situations, like these.
For example, Nana Visitor doubles as both Major Kira and K.C. Hunter here, the only female writer on staff at the magazine. Her name is given in initials only so that the readers won't discover that she is, in fact, a woman. There are certainly echoes here of D.C. Fontana, one of the main writers on The Original Series, as well as becoming the showrunner on The Animated Series.
The bulk of the episode follows Avery Brooks as Benny Russell, the only Black writer on staff, and the one who suffers the most from the racism of the day. Russell writes his story, featuring a Black captain, and not only is the magazine pulped for that run, but he is fired.
The breakdown that Russell undergoes, played to perfection by Brooks - who was also on director duties - is harrowing. Star Trek had never shied from discussing issues of the day, but here was one of the most painful examples of real-world bigotry that had ever been shown, and Star Trek was never quite the same afterward.
4. Course: Oblivion
The premise for Course: Oblivion is a little silly. A ship full of goo-people think they're the originals, then things quickly begin to fall apart - literally. Some of the make-up effects can edge into the ridiculous during the episode, and some of the effects haven't aged very well. Now, that said, the episode offers one of the most crushing endings of any Voyager offering, before or after.
The episode follows this crew of not-Voyager as they go from celebrating the wedding of Paris and Torres to desperately trying to reach a Demon-class planet to regenerate. As the episode goes on, the audience discovers that they haven't been following the usual characters at all. These are all copies, born from the silvery blood on the Demon planet, a year before.
It's a shock to say the least, but things become even more grim as crew members start dying. A new propulsion system, much faster than the original, has been irradiating them to such a degree that they are beginning to lose cohesion. That's not even the worst part. When it becomes clear that the ship may not survive, all of the crew's logs are downloaded into a probe, so that at least some of them can be left for others to discover.
And then the probe is destroyed. And then the ship is destroyed, leaving nothing but a cloud of globules floating in space.
It is, perhaps, one of the cruelest twists in Star Trek's history, making this episode a stand-out example of a writer needing to be asked - who hurt you?
3. Pathfinder
On the surface, Pathfinder shares some similarities with Course: Oblivion, in that the Voyager crew seen for the most part aren't actually the regular characters, but merely copies - this time, holograms. However, Pathfinder stands out for its use of Lt. Barclay and Deanna Troi. In a way, this episode of Voyager serves as something of a side-episode of The Next Generation, post-First Contact.
Though Reg had appeared on Voyager before, this was his first big focus episode, as the audience follows him and his struggle to get the MIDAS array to work. We see him dashing through the standing sets/holographic recreations of the ship, while the others at Starfleet Command are rapidly losing patience with him.
Though Troi attempts to placate him and aid him to escape work for a while, the episode truly serves as an obsession, by a character from a previous Star Trek iteration, attempting to meet his heroes. That ending, featuring some of the most affecting moments in Star Trek's history, are both a true punch-the-air moment and a bursting into floods of tears moment as well. Janeway's last cry to Starfleet, asking them to keep a docking bay open for them, combined with Admiral Paris telling his son he loves him, breaks even the stoniest of hearts.
For an episode that features the main cast for all of five minutes, it's one of the most powerful, stand-out episodes of the lot.
2. Kobayashi
Star Trek: Prodigy offered, in its fifth episode, something of a glorious treat for long-term fans of the franchise. Kobayashi sees the return of Gates McFadden, René Auberjonois, Nichelle Nichols, James Doohan, and Leonard Nimoy to Star Trek - despite almost all of them having passed away by the time the episode was released.
In fact, writer Aaron Waltke revealed in an episode of the Clonestar Podcast that when the episode was originally pitched, both Auberjonois and Nichols were still in a position to record new dialogue. However, the nature of the Hollywood machine delayed it sufficiently and this never came to be.
So, in a way, the episode becomes something of a scrapbook for fans. Stock dialogue was used for Odo, Uhura, Scotty, and Spock's dialogue. While recording technology had evolved somewhat by the 90s, there was very little that could be done to make the recordings from the 60s sound as though they were as fresh as Dal's quips.
Hours and hours of research were done to source the words, and having the recordings exist in their original form is now a sweet coda to some of their performances. We dare anyone not to get dewy-eyed hearing those giants of Trek speak, one more time.
1. Subspace Rhapsody
Star Trek finally went and did a musical episode - and it was glorious! Now, love it or hate it, Subspace Rhapsody was a bold move on the part of the franchise. Of course, there had been musical moments in Trek before this, with the odd song here and there, or musical performances in the fourth intersect in Jefferies tube twenty-five, but never before had a full-scale spectacular like this been attempted.
It's an episode that works best when one gives oneself over to the sheer fun of events. Not every cast member will be taking home the Tony award, while some of the dancing could do with a polish, but that actually adds to the awkwardness of the situation - something that shows only too well on the face of the beleaguered Captain Pike.
Celia Rose Gooding is probably the strongest vocal performer in the episode, but for a cast who may not have been classically trained, they all give it their best, and the songs have stuck in our heads for weeks now - so Tom Polce and Kay Hanley have a lot to answer for in that respect.
After fifty-seven years, Star Trek is taking chances and boldly going to places it has never traveled before. That, in our opinion, is why it manages to stay unique.