10 Recent TV Moments That Made No Sense

These TV shows let nonsense take over.

By Jack Pooley /

TV shows are produced on such hectic schedules, typically involving large ensemble casts and thousands of moving parts going at a frantic pace, enough that it's little surprise mistakes and inconsistencies often slip through the cracks. No series is perfect, after all.

Advertisement

But sometimes the big issues come more at a higher creative level, where the showrunners and writers clearly haven't put sufficient thought into a story beat, character revelation, or plot twist. And fans being fans, they sure as hell notice.

That's certainly the case with these 10 TV shows aired over the past year, each of which did something that just made no damn sense at all.

No matter how beloved and acclaimed these series might've otherwise been - though some certainly weren't either in the slightest - these scenes and moments left the vast majority of viewers scratching their heads in disbelief.

From ultimately minor leaps in logic which have chipped away at fans ever since, to absolutely gigantic plot holes, ludicrous subplots, and everything in-between, these moments represent TV at its most nonsensical throughout the last 12 months...

10. Carmy Gets Locked In The Fridge - The Bear

The Bear's generally phenomenal second season concludes with an episode where Carmy (Jeremy Allen White) gets locked inside his restaurant's walk-in fridge when the handle breaks off.

Advertisement

It's a pay-off to the fact that Carmy has been meaning to get the handle fixed for a good while, yet being preoccupied with the restaurant's opening, he simply forgot to do it.

Except, as many, many viewers pointed out following the episode's airing, every walk-in fridge installed at a restaurant will have a safety latch on the inside, allowing anyone potentially trapped inside to easily free themselves in the event of catastrophe.

Yet, for dramatic reasons, this is curiously ignored in the episode, which concludes with the staff bringing in power tools to effectively saw the door open.

While the final moments of the episode show sparks flying inside the fridge as Carmy waits to be freed, this itself doesn't make much sense either - all a handyman would need to do is remove the screws on the door's hinges in order to get him out.

Granted, The Bear is a brilliant enough show - and categorically not a documentary - that it's easy to ignore most instances of dramatic license, though this one did feel more contrived than most.

9. Jocelyn Was In Control The Entire Time - The Idol

No TV show has proven quite so controversial this year as HBO's The Idol, which made troubling headlines months before its premiere due to extensive behind-the-scenes issues, resulting in a large bulk of the series being reshot.

Advertisement

It finally released to generally scathing reviews over the summer, despite some scattered praise for Lily-Rose Depp's performance as embattled pop star Jocelyn, yet ultimately saved its most WTF moment of all for the very last episode.

Throughout the show, the audience is led to believe that Jocelyn has been ensnared and exploited by sleazeball nightclub owner Tedros (Abel Tesfaye, aka The Weeknd), but the big twist reveals that this wasn't quite the truth.

Rather, it's implied that Jocelyn has been lying about her late mother's abusive behaviour in order to trap Tedros and win the sympathy of her legion of fans, effectively allowing her to become the cult leader which Tedros has been painted as over the course of the season.

It's an amusing idea which could theoretically come off as empowering for Jocelyn, yet given the overall storytelling deficiencies on offer here, it can't help but feel convoluted and manipulative in the worst way.

If Jocelyn lied about being abused, it ultimately raises a ton more questions about the internal logic of both the story and Jocelyn herself, rather than merely inviting audiences to rewatch the series within an intriguing new context.

8. Winston's Different Accent - The Continental: From The World Of John Wick

The Continental was a pretty good prequel to the John Wick movies, as long as you could get over the actually significant hurdle of accepting Colin Woodell in the role of a young Winston Scott - played so deliciously by Ian McShane in the films.

Advertisement

This isn't so much a knock against Woodell's physical performance as it is his accent, which settles simply for broadly American, making it a far cry from McShane's more distinctive transatlantic twang, broached firmly between English and American.

People certainly change a lot over 50 years, and that absolutely includes accents, but given that Winston resides in New York in both the movies and the prequel series, it doesn't really track that he sounds so different in the latter.

Series director Albert Hughes did at least address the issue head-on in interviews, telling Gizmodo that they opted not to have Woodell simply imitate McShane's incredibly distinctive accent, but rather try to capture the essence of the man's character.

All the same, it's immensely distracting when you start watching the show, and immediately places a barrier between the audience and their acceptance of this character as Young Winston.

7. Nobody Hates Ashley For The Bridge Stunt - Squid Game: The Challenge

Squid Game: The Challenge has been the game show on everyone's lips for better or worse throughout the last few weeks of 2023, but the single moment that perhaps baffled fans more than any? The Ashley stunt on Glass Bridge.

Advertisement

The Glass Bridge game saw contestants attempting to cross a glass bridge while picking the correct glass tile to stand on - one tile being sturdy, the other sending them falling through the floor.

The 20 remaining players had 30 minutes to cross the bridge, with the group collectively agreeing to step on a single tile each, giving them a seemingly equally fair shot of making it to the end.

This was all well and good, until Ashley refused to play ball and leap to a tile, effectively holding the game up until Trey stepped up and took her place, ultimately leading to his elimination.

Yet in the wake of Ashley's decision, the episode shows the remaining contestants having strangely little ill will towards her, as proved confusing for large swaths of viewers dumbfounded by her selfish choice.

Furthermore, the fact that Mai was then villainised for nominating Ashley in the subsequent Die Test game comes across as further strange. Why wouldn't she nominate the person who wasn't being a team player?

Fans have speculated that Netflix's manipulative editing may have been to blame, because why else wouldn't the surviving contestants be absolutely fuming with Ashley?

6. Skrull Rhodey - Secret Invasion

We probably could've just stopped at "Secret Invasion" given how much of the show's storytelling and character work felt inconsistent with established facts in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, but by far the most polarising aspect of the series was the "Skrull Rhodey" debacle.

Advertisement

In the season's fourth episode, it's revealed that Rhodey (Don Cheadle) is actually a female Skrull in disguise named Raava, with the real Rhodey having been incarcerated by the Skrulls for an indeterminate period of time.

Though the twist was certainly an interesting idea, the execution was way off. A big part of the problem?

It was never clarified precisely when Rhodey was first replaced, and when director Ali Selim suggested that it occurred after Captain America: Civil War, that only frustrated fans more.

After all, the idea that the Rhodey we saw mourning Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr.) in Avengers: Endgame was a doppleganger robs that moment of its emotional power and just leaves a massively sour taste.

That's without even getting into the many nitpick-y reasons why the MCU actively contradicts the idea of Rhodey being a Skrull for many years.

Had Skrull-Rhodey been planned out further in advance then perhaps some seeds could've been sewn in the preceding films to hint at Rhodey's true nature, but given that this clearly didn't happen, it ended up feeling like an awkwardly deployed retcon.

5. Nate & Jade's Romance - Ted Lasso

Ted Lasso's third season made a number of head-scratching creative decisions which majorly divided fans, but perhaps the oddest of the lot?

Advertisement

Shoehorning in a romance between Nate (Nick Mohammed) and Jade (Edyta Budnik), the stern hostess at Nate's favourite restaurant, A Taste of Athens.

Despite Jade showing no romantic interest whatsoever in Nate and even appearing to have considerable dislike for him whenever he visits the eatery, mid-way through the season the pair rather suddenly develop a bond and become lovers.

If the writers were going for an "opposites attract" dynamic, it didn't really work because they never showed us why Jade would change her mind about Nate.

And more to the point, Jade is so underdeveloped as a character that she ends up feeling more like a prop for Nate's own agency than a genuine person in her own right.

As a result the whole setup felt incredibly forced, with the writers apparently believing that Nate's "redemption" arc absolutely needed a romantic component in order to fully succeed.

4. Aidan Dumps Carrie Because... Reasons - And Just Like That...

Though the second season of And Just Like That... marked a decent dramatic improvement in a number of ways, it all came hilariously crashing down in the season's final episode, just as Carrie (Sarah Jessica Parker) seemed destined to get her happily ever after (again) with old flame Aidan (John Corbett).

Advertisement

In the latter half of the season, Carrie and Aidan decide to move in together, with Carrie finally moving out of her beloved apartment into a lush house, but a major spanner is thrown in the works in the final episode, when Aidan's 14-year-old son Wyatt crashes his truck in a DUI accident.

This causes Aidan to realise that his sons need him, and so he tells Carrie he can't move in with her, instead deciding to head back to Virginia to look after his kids.

But that's not quite the end for the pair - they agree to a five-year relationship pause, by which time Aidan's kids will be over the age of 18 and he claims he'll return to Carrie.

Beyond being a pathetically transparent way to drag out the series' drama just when Carrie had a happy ending in sight, this was so ridiculous that some fans quite understandably believed that Aidan hatched the whole scheme as a means of punishing Carrie for her cheating on him during their initial relationship decades prior.

And even if you don't buy into that theory, it's completely absurd. No fifty-something person is wasting five years of their romantic life waiting on the hook for their beloved, and to even ask someone to do that is just... maddening.

Plus, just because your kids are adults once they turn 18, it's not like you just turn the parent part of your brain off.

If Aidan's kids are still troubled in adulthood, it's tough to believe that he's just going to keep living his life with Carrie in New York. Nothing about this makes any sense.

3. The Noticeably Aged Cast - Sex Education

Sex Education is a wonderful comedy series which had an, er, less-than-wonderful conclusion earlier this year.

Advertisement

Though the primary issues were creative ones, many fans also couldn't help but point out the distractingly large chasm between the ages of the central characters and the actors playing them.

This isn't a new issue for any TV show centered around school or college-age characters, yet given that Sex Education's four seasons were released over almost five years and yet covered just two years of narrative time, it's little surprise the actors' ages began to lose credibility.

The most egregious examples among the cast are 30-year-old Ncuti Gatwa, 29-year-old Aimee Lou Wood, 28-year-old Kedar Williams-Stirling, 27-year-old Emma Mackey and Connor Swindells, and 25-year-old Mimi Keene.

It simply wasn't easy to accept that these performers were still playing teenagers in 2023, and while there's little practically that can really be done about it - horrid digital de-aging be-damned - it is nevertheless something that ultimately became tough to ignore.

2. Everything About Amanda - Hijack

Apple's Idris Elba-starring thriller series Hijack was a pretty taut and entertaining ride for the most part, though took a wild left-turn in its penultimate episode.

Advertisement

The show takes place onboard a hijacked passenger plane during its flight from Dubai to London in more-or-less real time, and at the end of episode six, one of the plane's largely unseen passengers, Amanda (Holly Aird), suddenly pulls out a gun, executes the plane's pilot, and locks herself inside the cockpit.

The final episode subsequently reveals that the hijacking was arranged to crash the stock of the plane's airline, Kingdom Air, because with the villains short-selling against the stock, they stood to profit from the company's stock price plummeting.

As for Amanda? She's blackmailed into flying the plane in order to prevent the bad guys from killing her daughter, and though she initially believes she needs to crash the plane into London in order to secure her daughter's safety, she's eventually persuaded against it by negotiator Sam (Elba).

Moreover, Amanda rather conveniently secures an agreement with the authorities that she won't be arrested upon landing the plane, and indeed, she simply goes free at show's end.

There's just so much silliness here. First, did Amanda really need to shoot the pilot dead rather than simply disable him?

And secondly, would the cops really honour a flimsy immunity agreement? Nothing was signed, and considering she both murdered a man and almost killed hundreds of people by crashing a plane, would anyone really care if they swiftly reneged on it?

The thought of Amanda just going home and returning to her regular life without any blowback whatsoever is just totally laughable.

1. Freddy Gets Smart When He Gets Drunk - Frasier

Now to be completely fair to the recently concluded Frasier revival, it was actually a good deal better than most were expecting - especially considering the absence of Frasier's (Kelsey Grammer) brother Niles (David Hyde Pierce).

Advertisement

But the series did occasionally get a little too sitcom-y for its own good, as evidenced by its eighth episode, where it's revealed that whenever Frasier's firefighter son Freddy (Jack Cutmore-Scott) gets drunk, he ditches the working class facade he adopts in order to fit in with his co-workers and gets incredibly erudite, pontificating on highfalutin subjects much to his colleagues' amusement.

It's certainly a fun idea, albeit one that's shown a little too cartoonishly in the episode, as if to suggest that poor Freddy has quite literally sublimated his "real" personality when sober and is basically playing a "character" for most of his right-minded life.

It's more depressing than funny, honestly, and stretches the credibility of his character close to snapping point, especially as this revelation is rather soundly ignored in the series' two remaining episodes.

Advertisement