10 Worst Star Trek Moments In 2025
It was a year that started with a whimper, but what were the biggest Star Trek misses of 2025?
Star Trek had an interesting year in 2025. Among losses and confusion, there were moments of joy and levity. There were ups. There were downs. There were those glasses of Guinness. This year has been a ride.
Much of the conversation around Star Trek focused on the uncertainty over the Paramount and Skydance merger, which finally concluded in August after (checks notes) 84 years of preamble. The deal is done, the new bosses are in place, and Trek was suddenly in an even less certain position.
Arguments raged online over the inclusion of inclusion, while diversity seemed to just as suddenly get the backs up of a very vocal group of people on social media. Star Trek has never been political, some people shouted. Belle and Lokai would like a word.
In a year that has grown increasingly menacing as the evenings have grown shorter, there is still Star Trek to guide us back to the light. There may have been a few bumps in the year, but this isn't our first list like this. Trek's part of the furniture, but who hasn't wanted to change the lamps from time to time?
None of this is to say that there haven't been quite a few examples of fun and upbeat things in the final frontier this year. We even saw some Trek royalty return to the franchise, while others made surprise appearances to stoke some very excited fires. There will be a list breaking down the best moments of the year.
This is not that list. With massive thanks to Brandon Meece, with whom we collaborated on this list, let's dive in.
10. Chaos, But To Who's Benefit?
She may be a bad bitch, but Michelle Yeoh's ex-Emperor Georgiou walked a very fine line of being just, well, bad in January of 2025. Star Trek: Section 31 arrived at the end of the first month of the year and kicked things off with a whimper, earning the ire of many Trek fans along the way.
No project is entirely without merit, and it is clear that, while the result may have been a bit of a flop, this streaming movie had a long and storied history. It began as a series and then, with the arrival of a certain gold statuette, evolved into a stand-alone story. The trailer dropped in 2024, leaving people a little bit confused. Was this Star Trek, or was this Guardians of the Galaxy? As it turned out, it wanted to be a little bit of both and ended up being a lot of neither.
Some of the humour managed to land, and Omari Hardwick and Rob Kazinski's Alok Sahar and Zeph managed to steal the screen for the time given, but the film suffered from pacing issues, mixed tones, and an overall toothless feel.
The time setting did little to help, teasing the audience with the Lost Era but delivering something closer to Lost in Headlights. Quippy dialogue is fun and welcome, but here it felt included for quip's sake, leaving character building on the floor for someone else to tidy up.
The entire affair came and went without much fanfare, despite decent viewership numbers on Paramount+. Later in the year, Paramount's new head of streaming, Cindy Holland, seemingly killed any hopes (we're sure there are some) of a sequel, ensuring that the audience understood that "streaming movies are not a priority" for her.
Considering how much ragebait this straight-to-streaming release generated both before and after it arrived, one has to wonder - what was the point after all?
9. Money Doesn't Exist In The 24th Century
Money may not exist in the 24th Century (despite literally dozens of examples where it does) but that cannot be said of the 21st. Paramount and Skydance finally completed the merger this year to form Paramount: A Skydance Corporation, in a deal that numbers in the billions. One may assume with all that bread, things would move quickly forward?
Well, they did, and they didn't.
New CEO of Paramount, David Ellison, is certainly making his presence felt at the company and in the industry. He arrived with a mission to bump up the company's theatrical releases (more on this later), which was not good news for Section 31 fans. Might this mean an influx of cash for Secret Hideout to channel into the Star Trek universe?
It is more than possible, though recent developments have suggested that money is focused elsewhere. Rather than consolidate their position at the company and begin to build, the new leadership almost immediately launched a bid to purchase Warner Bros., swooping in after a successful bid by Netflix. This bid initially included money from several Middle Eastern countries, along with President Trump's son-in-law, Jared Kushner (though his support has now been withdrawn), which afforded Ellison $108.4billion to offer.
This hostile bid has, at present, seemingly been stopped, with Warner Bros. urging its shareholders to stick with Netflix. However, it is unlikely that this will be the last attempt to gain a huge hold over the entertainment industry, so it remains to be seen what this ultra-capitalistic mindset may bring to the Star Trek universe.
8. A Bit Of Bio-Essentialism On A Thursday
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds' third season was quite the mixed affair, arriving after a lengthy hiatus between the second and third years. The Writers' Guild Of America Strike in 2023 pushed all production back, giving fans a two-year gap between the cliffhanger and its resolution. Was the wait worth it?
The season was mostly impressive, with some true stand-out moments along the way. While the second and penultimate episodes were particular highlights, the same cannot be said for the seventh and eighth ones. What Is Starfleet? and Four And A Half Vulcans were ill-judged affairs, though the latter was the more egregious by far.
The former's greatest struggle was the uncertain tone of what exactly it was trying to do. Presented as an in-universe documentary about the famous space-faring organisation, it instead devolved into a one-man hit piece, a wildly fence-sitting statement about Starfleet's involvement in alien conflicts, and a horrendous revelation about Spock's childhood.
Had that been the worst of the season, the overall score would be higher, but then came Four And A Half Vulcans. Unfortunately, the 'comedy' intended to fill this episode's runtime instead focused on one-dimensional portrayals of Star Trek's oldest alien races, jokes about smells and insinuation of mind-meld coercion, consent be damned.
By far the worst part of all was, one week after revealing that as a child, Spock attempted to 'cut the humanity out of himself' with a knife, this episode spent much of its runtime depicting 'Vulcans' who openly mocked and belittled him for being half-human. It was an offensive, upsetting episode that leaned into frat-style humour rather than any serious exploration of a new Vulcan identity.
Rather than any of the above, or lest we even discuss the hairstyle changes, let us instead remember Patton Oswalt's Doug, even if he was, in fact, too slow.
7. Renewal And Loss
Nothing can last forever, and this year the inevitable news came through: Star Trek: Strange New Worlds is coming to an end. While it isn't all bad news, as there are still two more seasons to come, many eyebrows hit the hairline with the timing of the announcement. Just before the media circuit for season three began, the renewal, and end date, were both released.
This then left the conversation in an odd place. While Hegemony, Part 2, kicked the season off with a bang, the questions were still focusing on how everyone felt about the news. Many diplomatic answers were given, most focusing on the five-year mission aspect (by the time it ends, Strange New Worlds will have had five seasons).
Added to this unusually timed announcement was the news that the final season would have a shorter run, delivering six episodes rather than the usual ten per season. This means that by the time it finishes, Strange New Worlds will have had one of the shortest runs of any Trek series, with Prodigy, Picard, and The Animated Series just edging it out.
Though a proposed Star Trek: Year One series, following Kirk in his early command of the Enterprise, has been touted, there is (as of writing) no confirmation of this. The show is wrapping production (again, as of writing), so an announcement would surely have to come soon. Otherwise, are the sets to be struck and destroyed, thus creating more budgetary issues for a new show set on the same ship to deal with?
They were quick to announce Strange New Worlds' ending, but they are being anything but when it comes to the future of that time period.
6. Prodigious Shafting
Another year, another loss, and Star Trek: Prodigy is about to vanish once again from streaming services. This time it's Netflix is giving it up, removing it from their streaming service on December 31st 2025. This means that Prodigy will be solely available on physical media, making it the only iteration of Star Trek not available to stream.
This is another blow to a show that has suffered so many setbacks in its short lifespan. Its initial release was marred by a confusing message about where and who it was for. Though the show was anything but, it never truly lost the Nickelodean-shaped millstone around its neck. To this day, people still refer to it as 'the kids' show,' despite it being accessible to all.
The news that it is now leaving streaming seems to be another nail in the coffin for a third season, which is beyond shameful. Prodigy did something important for the universe, which was to offer an entry point for newcomers without speaking down to them. While Star Trek: Scouts has its 'kids' show' moniker on its sleeves, it is aimed at pre-schoolers. Prodigy was for everyone, successfully blending legacy Trek with new ideas and new civilisations.
If this is the end of the road for this animated series, it will still have delivered two of the strongest seasons in Trek's long history, both of which are available to purchase. If that is the only way they can now be seen, then we implore you to pick them up. You won't regret it.
5. Bye Bye Bye 4
The Enterprise-A has seemingly been decommissioned, though this time, there's no one there to tell the bosses to 'Go To Hell.' In the push for more theatrical content, Ellison's company has given the keys to a new film to Jonathan Goldstein and John Francis Daley, one that is predicted not to have any ties to the Kelvin universe at all.
To be clear, the news of a new film is positive, and this writer is already excited to see what the men behind Spiderman: Homecoming and Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves can bring to Star Trek. The bittersweet side of this is that Paramount has reportedly 'moved on' from the Kelvin universe, finally killing the hopes of those waited with baited breath for a fourth adventure.
Chris Pine, Zachary Quinto, Zoë Saldaña, and Simon Pegg have all made statements over the years about their wish to return, with several potential sequel ideas pitched along the way. Pine felt that the film should be smaller in scope, while Quinto was seemingly just keen to put the ears and wig back on.
JJ Abrams and Justin Lin delivered three fun, exciting films between 2009 and 2016. If that's the end of that particular timeline (a certain temporal agent Betelgeusian notwithstanding), then these films can at least be praised for keeping the universe alive between shows. The Enterprise-A may have hung up her nacelles for the moment, but let's never say never. As Spock himself said while standing on another Enterprise-A:
I've been dead once before.
So too has Trek. Death is never the end.
4. That's Not Very Star Trek Now, Is It?
After the completion of the Paramount and Skydance merger, the future of Star Trek was thrown into further uncertainty with a rash of layoffs at the company. While that is sometimes nothing to consider when looking to the future of Trek content, at least in the creative process, these layoffs seemed to come with a particular slant.
Ahead of the merger, Skydance vowed to abandon all DEI initiatives at Paramount, removing any references to them from its internal messaging, websites, and training materials. This, along with a lawsuit settled with President Trump, secured the go-ahead from FCC Chairman Brendan Carr.
Star Trek has promoted diversity, equity, and inclusion from its earliest days. This pledge by the new owners of Trek to excise DEI initiatives from within its own company frightened many Trek fans, while drawing support from some conservative viewers and an army of right-wing bots online.
Robert Picardo, our favourite Emergency Medical Hologram, took to social media to assure fans that DEI isn't going anywhere when it comes to Star Trek. As he stated on X (formerly Twitter):
For Star Trek, DEI is in its DNA. It was WOKE for 1966, but 1966 was a long time ago. If our concept of diversity has changed a lot in 60 years, who's to say what it will look like 800 years from now?
While there will always be those people who support a homogenous, uniformity in the shows they watch, at least from within Star Trek, it looks as though there is still hope to be found.
3. Utopia? Utopia? Wherefore Art Thou, Utopia?
What Is Starfleet? is a frustrating episode of Star Trek. The conceit is a good one. An in-universe documentary examining the fundamentals of Starfleet sounds fascinating, and frankly, some of Starfleet's core tenets could do with a little challenge from time to time.
The inspiration for this episode seems to have come from other franchises like Stargate SG-1, Babylon 5, and even M*A*S*H*. Having the documentary made by a young filmmaker was also an interesting approach, as some wide-eyed naivety could help to skew the programme in a certain way. Instead, this shortened episode served to splice interviews with clearly disengenous filmmaking, designed to be edgy, and serving mediocrity.
The framing story of the Enterprise's intervention, or lack thereof, in a clearly one-sided war parallels certain countries' lack of action in certain ongoing conflicts in 2025. The conflict between the Lutani and Kasar easily evokes images of Russia's invasion of Ukraine, or Israel's ongoing genocide in Gaza. Rather than attempting to offer a positive, hopeful future, or even to show the crew agonising over the conflict ahead of them, the episode instead focuses on the abuse of a Jikaru.
This was a clear symbol for weapons of mass destruction, further muddying the message. Pike elects to help the creature die rather than be used as a weapon of war, despite having previously been ordered to transport it to Lutani VII for their use in their war.
Why was Starfleet involved at all? Once involved, why did Starfleet agree to transport weapons? In the end, and echoing Picard's actions in Symbiosis nearly forty years earlier, Pike simply takes away the weapon without any offer or commitment to help in the long run.
If Star Trek is to present a utopian future, one where Starfleet at least attempts to do the right thing, even without always achieving it, then What Is Starfleet? is a very good question indeed.
2. [Insert Audience Groan Here]
It is, of course, that time of year again where we bemoan the lack of Star Trek: Legacy, which at this point feels farther than ever from being greenlit. The upcoming debut of Starfleet Academy, combined with the news of Strange New Worlds' ending with no confirmed sequel series in sight, feels as though this era of Trek may be coming to an end.
That is not to say that Starfleet Academy won't blow everyone out of the water (more on this in the next entry), but this remains an uncertain time for Star Trek's future. Confirming development on Legacy would go quite a long way toward allaying fears, even if there were other plans in the air.
The more time that passes (Star Trek: Picard came to an end almost three years ago) makes the arrival of Legacy, or a series following the adventures of Captain Seven and the crew of the Enterprise-G, less likely. Salaries, set construction, showrunning, writing - these things take time to figure out. At the time of writing, there could already be plans in the background, yet another year passes without any news, one way or the other.
Perhaps a statement confirming that it isn't happening would help, in its own way, like a splash of cold water. It may never have been on the cards, outside of a discussion that Jeri Ryan had with Paramount after Picard ended. If that is the case, then we are simply glum about another year without Star Trek: Legacy.
1. One Breen Hill Meets Star Trek: 90210
Full disclosure: this writer quite likes this poster for Star Trek: Starfleet Academy. As the show is seemingly aimed at a teen to young adult audience, this poster feels both earnest and tongue-in-cheek at the same time, deliberately evoking memories of other teen dramas like Beverly Hills 90210 and One Tree Hill.
However.
Some of the worst moments, for Star Trek, in 2025 have come not from the franchise itself but the discussions surrounding it. When this poster was debuted, it sparked a flood of complaints, with increasingly nasty comments about the tone and feel of the show. These were built on the ongoing and tiring tirades against a show that hasn't even aired yet, with anonymous ranters doing their best to make those who are excited feel ashamed.
This mirrors the same kinds of behaviour that were seen before Section 31 was released. Whether that ended up appealing to the masses or not, some were never intending to give it a try, regardless. We are seeing this again and again, with this year being particularly bad for it.
There is not one thing in the world that can or should force a person to enjoy something, nor has anyone the right to tell someone they are wrong for disliking it. In an increasingly weaponised space, as social media is becoming, it would do well, however, to remember that Star Trek is for everyone, and its appeal won't always be universal.
So as not to end this list on a downer, it should also be noted that, as always, the community contains some of the best, friendliest, most loving and caring people in existence. Perhaps Star Trek may change in shape and form as time goes on, but good people are good people, and there are a lot of them out there.
Some of them even wear TrekCulture t-shirts.