12 Things That Make No Sense In BoJack Horseman

12. Herb Kazzaz's Murder

When Bojack Horseman's old friend Herb Kazzaz dies from a peanut allergy caused by a car crash, his final wish was for Bojack's Horsin Around co-star Sarah Lynn to find what he had labeled "Herb's gold". This leads Bojack and his other costars to follow clues from their past, and discover that the hit tv show creator's death may not have been an accident.

The main piece of evidence they discover is a long voicemail left on Herb's answering machine, explicitly stating that his brakes were replaced and should not fail him unless sabotaged, leading the group to believe that his death was in fact murder.

But in the end, Herb's death is chalked up as a real accident. "Herb's gold" is revealed to be a personal memoir that was deemed so terrible, it would have ruined his reputation. However, the voicemail that Bojack and the others heard just doesn't fit in with the rest of the story. If there was no foul play, then why did Herb's brakes fail him, even though it was stated very clearly that they would not? Did someone actually sabotage the brakes, or was it just shoddy repairs? We may never know.