5 Most Under-Appreciated Current TV Shows

By Guest Writer /

Now that the Emmy nominations are out and we've had a little bit of time to digest them, I still feel that there are some great shows that aren't getting enough love for one reason or another. Sometimes the shows are critical hits, but the audience isn't there; other times, the shows are largely ignored by critics, but loved by the audience; still other times, the shows are loved by critics and the audience, but are ignored by the award committees. This list is dedicated to those shows that seem to under-perform in some capacity, despite each of the shows being incredibly strong and entertaining. If a show that you love is so under-appreciated that it does not even feature on my list of under-appreciated shows, leave a comment with the reason why you love it and others don€™t!

5. Parks And Recreation

Under-appreciated by viewers and awards committees. Parks and Rec started off poorly. Nobody denies that, including those involved in the creation of the show. It was a spin-off from The Office for all intents and purposes €“ although it had nothing to do with The Office, it was a virtual carbon-copy of the show. And it was a poor attempt at mimicry as well. From the 2nd season on, however, Parks and Rec has been phenomenal. The character development has, generally, been extremely rich. Amy Poehler has been incredible, and she has been recognized for her performance by being nominated for an Emmy for 4 straight years. The problem, though, is just that €“ while Poehler has been nominated 4 times, and Parks and Rec has been nominated once (another travesty, as it should be more than that), the show has not won anything of note. Furthermore, the ratings of the show have been borderline-awful. The show has fallen from almost 7 million viewers for the series premiere in 2009 to not even 3 million viewers for the 5th season finale in 2013 €“ this, all while the show has been going from strength to strength. One wonders if NBC would have cancelled the show, had they had any other options for shows to replace it. There€™s a disconnect between the show€™s extremely positive reception, the terrible viewership, and the refusal to give what is a fantastic show the awards that it deserves, and that is why Parks and Rec makes the list as an under-appreciated show.

4. New Girl

Under-appreciated by awards committees. I've been a huge fan of Zooey Deschanel since watching Elf when I was 13, and I once spent a summer during college watching her entire filmography. So, obviously, I was going to be a huge fan of New Girl when I heard that it was coming out on Fox. The first season of the show was pretty good, and it was definitely enough to maintain my interest in the show. Critics and the awards committees felt that the show merited multiple award nominations, with Deschanel joining Max Greenfield in Emmy nods. The show also commanded a large audience €“ the series premiere received over 10 million viewers, and it maintained its popularity throughout the season. Season 2, however, is when the show really hit its stride. If you disregard the minor lull that the show experienced around the middle of the season, right after Nick and Jess kissed for the first time, the second season was even stronger than the first. There was emotion in this season €“ the will-they-won€™t-they dynamic between Nick and Jess was well-written and well-acted, and Jake Johnson€™s performance in the episode when he returned to Chicago for his father€™s funeral was nothing short of magnificent. Yet, the show received zero Emmy nods this year. Not a single nomination. Not even in the relatively weak Lead Actor category (I honestly didn't even know Matt LeBlanc was still on TV) or Supporting Actor category (I love Modern Family, but with nods for 3 actors from one show, they€™re being Emmy-hogs). The show has the support of critics and fans, yet it continuously fails to receive the award and accolades that it deserves. Hopefully season 3 brings a bit more respect.

3. Arrested Development Season 4

Under-appreciated by critics and €œfans.€ My second article for this website was about Arrested Development (which you can read here), and if you continue reading my stuff, I€™m sure my love for the show will only become more evident. I just read that AD€™s Mitch Hurwitz and bosses at Netflix have a mutual interest in continuing the series, and I€™m as giddy as could be, because, unlike many €œfans€ of the show, I loved the 4th season. And, unlike many professional critics who wrote about the show, I decided to wait until I watched it from beginning to end (twice) before commenting on it €“ I€™m looking at you, Mike Hale of The New York Times. I can understand people being turned off by the structure of the new episodes. Yes, some episodes tended to drag on a little bit, and the plot was extremely convoluted. But that€™s almost exactly what was promised when the new season was announced. We knew that it wouldn€™t be possible to get the entire cast together to make a show that was similar to the original run on Fox, so the focus on one character every episode was the only way for this story to be told. And, personally, I enjoyed the way that the story played out, and I enjoyed the structure of the episodes €“ so much so that I watched it again about a month later. I€™m not advocating for AD to have had more Emmy nods like I did with Parks and Rec and New Girl. The part about AD Season 4 that frustrates me is that it has become a punching bag for €œfans€ to slate it, because that's the cool thing to do nowadays.

2. The Newsroom

Under-appreciated by critics. Critics were decidedly mixed on it during the first season, and it€™s really hard to see why, other than yet another case of popular-thing-bashing like Arrested Development. The show has the ability to bring in a multitude of audiences. You have Aaron Sorkin fans, obviously, who are going to watch anything that he writes. But you also have Jeff Daniels fans, who have enjoyed his maturing from playing Harry in Dumb and Dumber to becoming an incredibly talented and diverse actor; you have fans of Olivia Munn, who have watched her on the G4 network and The Daily Show, and have enjoyed her acting skills and flawless beauty; you have fans of Sam Waterston, and you even have fans of the news in general. It€™s kind of a perfect storm. The show does seem to bring in those audiences €“ every person that I talk to watches and loves The Newsroom. And, yet, the show still disappoints critics. The biggest problems that critics have with the show is that it feels false, and that it is simply a platform for Sorkin to provide his opinions on all-things political. I would agree with them that the quick and witty lines of dialogue seem a bit forced at times. But, at other times, the show evokes the types of emotions in the audience that only a truly good show can manage to do. The Newsroom is a very good and enjoyable show, which provides an insight into what the nightly news should be like, and critics should try to look deeply at the show instead of trying to grab a quick moment of popularity by slating something that is popular.

1. Parenthood

Under-appreciated by viewers and awards committees. Parenthood is one of the only shows that I've ever seen that has gotten better with each passing season without ever hitting a lull. Through strong writing and even-stronger acting performances, the show has forced its audience to form very close connections with the characters on the show. The show is emotional, but it avoids sentimentality and melodrama, and that€™s much harder to do than one might think. While the show has gone from strength to strength over the years, it is difficult to meet another person who watches the show. Perhaps that is because of its odd time slot €“ 10 PM on Tuesday nights €“ or perhaps it€™s due to the length of the show €“ 45 minutes instead of 22. This upcoming season will be an interesting experiment, as the show will move to Thursday nights, alongside the aforementioned Parks and Recreation. Furthermore, the show has not managed to score many award nods. In fact, Jason Ritter's nomination for his guest work in season 3 is the only Emmy nomination that the show has received. To me, that€™s very strange, especially since the show relies so much upon its strong acting performances. It is difficult to argue with the Emmy nomination committee not including Peter Krause in the Supporting Actor in a Drama category, with the likes of Aaron Paul and Jonathan Banks from Breaking Bad and Peter Dinklage from Game of Thrones headlining the nods. If there were 7 spots instead of 6, Krause would have to be included in that incredibly strong group. I would argue, however, that Anna Gunn from Breaking Bad should have been replaced with Monica Potter in the Supporting Actress in a Drama category, given Potter€™s incredibly strong performance as a cancer patient in this past season of Parenthood. So maybe next year will be the year for Parenthood to get the award reception that it definitely deserves. We€™ll just have to see.