Doctor Who: 6 Things We Learned In Kill The Moon

Big turning points for humanity and the Doctor and Clara's relationship.

By Baz Greenland /

Doctor Who gave audiences everything this week. In Kill The Moon we had scares, drama, a moral dilemma, gripping performances and a unique alien tale. There was a lot to love in this episode, which was arguably the strongest entry in series eight yet. This week we learned two things; a major turning point in humanity's fate and a massive turning point in the relationship between the Doctor and Clara. We've seen the Doctor being ruthless before but this was a whole other level and his actions have threatened to destroy his relationship with his companion. As for humanity's fate, Kill The Moon served as a prequel to all the wondrous things humanity has done in the future presented on the show. In the classic era and Nu Who, we've witnessed a mighty human empire that stretches across the stars. What we saw in this episode was an Earth that had endured the terror of countless alien threats and was ready leave the planet for something greater. So having enjoyed the thrills and scares that this very Gothic horror tale served up, let's look at the six things we learned in Kill The Moon and ask what some of them mean for the future of the show.

6. The Moon Isn't Actually A Moon

Kill The Moon took something that we know - the moon is an lifeless satellite orbiting the Earth - and turned it completely on its head. In true Doctor Who fashion, the moon was something else entirely; an egg containing a giant jellyfish-like alien creature. The spiders we saw in the trailer weren't aliens, though they did pose a deadly threat to the Doctor and his companions. They were bacteria, growing under the surface of the moon and like a nightmarish Demestos advert, were breaking out and killing everything in their path. Rather cleverly, the mystery of how the moon was still orbiting the Earth in the future was solved; the alien within laid another 'moon egg' in its place. Though you have to wonder whether it escaped the destruction of Earth in series one's The End Of The World.

5. Humanity Made The Wrong Choice

Kill The Moon may have ended with humanity on the verge or rekindling their interest in outer space but they almost never got there. Continuing the darker themes of series eight, this episode presented us humans who were fallible. From Hermione Norris's cold, bitter Lundvik, who had the fate of humanity on her weary shoulders, to a desperate Earth that would choose to let alien life die if it meant the tides destroying their coastlines ended. It was a believable choice too. The effects of the moon breaking up had already devastated parts of the planet; given that they did not know the true nature of what would happen - the moon would disintegrate and not break up over Earth - it is understandable that even Clara would have doubts over whether to save the alien within. Ultimately, turning off their lights in solidarity, choosing to blow up the moon and the alien with it was the wrong choice. But it had become a hard choice over one life over another. If the events of recent decades, from the Cyberman invading London in The Invasion to Daleks attacking Earth in The Stolen Earth, humanity would be far more wary of alien life when they encountered it. Is it any wonder they chose not to let the alien live?

4. The Moment That Sent Humanity To The Stars

Out of that almost-tragic decision came a moment of great beauty - an alien bursting out of the fragments of the moon and laying another egg in its place. Unlike the Daleks or Cybermen, this creature did not mean them any harm. It was this realisation that allowed humanity to embrace the search for new and alien worlds once more. The Doctor noted rather jovially (for his character) that looking up at this alien creature above them, humanity began to explore space, stretching out to become the mighty empire presented in every story from Frontier In Space to New Earth. There would be many stumbling blocks along the way - the events of Waters Of Mars take place just one decade later - but it was the moment when humanity embraced the stars once more. Kill The Moon established the moment humanity stopped being scared of the 'threat' of alien life and began to seek it out. That was a very important turning point in the humanity of the future the show has presented.

3. Courtney Is More Than Just A Bratty Teenager

Ever since she made her loud-mouthed debut at Coal Hill School, we've wondered just what impact Courtney might have on the show. Would she be just a real-life foil for Clara and Danny? Well, yes that's a given. But would she also become involved in the affairs of the Doctor? After last week's episode we wondered if one vomit-inducing trip on the TARDIS would be enough. Turns out the Doctor quite likes Courtney and is willing to let her accompany him in a trip to the moon. Surprisingly, Courtney has never veered into annoying territory. Certainly not Artie and Angie annoying. Capaldi's Doctor obviously has better judgement when letting kids venture onto his TARDIS than his predecessor. This week Courtney proved she made of sterner stuff, becoming the voice of reason when the debate raged over whether to kill the alien creature within the moon. Sure she had her moments of 'I'm bored', but she also portrayed a more mature, reasonable side that suggests another trip on the TARDIS might not be a bad thing. Given Clara's current anger with the Doctor, it's unclear whether he'll be making a trip to Coal Hill School again, or whether Clara will continue to travel with him. Perhaps there is potential for Courtney to become that replacement?

2. The Doctor Trusts Clara Implicitly

His judgement may have been misguided but the most important thing we learned about the Doctor this week was that he trusts his companion implicitly. Rather than helping Clara -and Lundvik - by explaining the moon would not devastate Earth when the alien hatched, he left them to make the moral choice themselves. It's all part of that ruthless nature we've come to understand and it almost backfires; humanity chooses to kill the alien and save themselves and Lundvik becomes the figurehead of that choice. But Clara too begins to waver and by the point he returns she is frightened and alone and at the point that she too is considering killing the alien to save Earth. Of course Clara presses the button in the end, stopping the bomb from killing the moon, but by then the damage is already done...

1. But The Doctor Has Pushed Clara Too Far

Last week Danny sowed the seeds of doubt in Clara's mind; don't let the Doctor push her too far. It didn't take long for Clara to realise that this Doctor's ruthless nature had taken her to her limits and put herself, Courtney and the alien being within the moon egg at great risk. Despite his assertions that he trusted in Clara's ability to do the right thing it was simply too much. In a spell-binding scene onboard the TARDIS, Clara turns on the Doctor with fury and despair over what he did. He has pushed her past her limit; she was ready to kill another life form. He made her do that by not giving her the courtesy of providing the information she needed to make that informed decision. Simply put, the Doctor put her and Courtney in mortal danger just to prove a point. From the despair and confusion of Deep Breath to that final scene between them on Kill The Moon, it has been a momentous journey for Clara and she has come to realise she cannot travel with this man the Doctor has become. It is a decision that is sure to have big ramfications for the show moving forward. Of course, the events of Kill The Moon leave us with questions too. Is Clara really done? Will Danny's wise words be enough for her to reconsder her actions? Could Courtney take her place on the TARDIS? Kill The Moon turned the series on its head and it will be interesting to see where it goes next.