Doctor Who: 10 Actors Who Could Or Should Have Been The Doctor

By Allan Johnstone /

9. The Second Doctor - Michael Hordern

When William Hartnell retired from the role, he declared that there was only one man who could take over the TARDIS - Patrick Troughton. It€™s likely this was just a face-saving move on Hartnell€™s part, as Troughton was by no means the only actor considered for the role. Amongst several big names in British character acting, the most interesting possibility is Michael Hordern. Hordern€™s rumpled appearance and scatter-brained demeanour were not a million light years from what the producers eventually settled on in Troughton. There are crucial differences between the two men, however. Where Troughton played the clown, Hordern€™s typical persona was diffident, distracted almost. Where Troughton brought an exuberant physicality to the Doctor, Hordern€™s sort of acting was quieter, more self-contained, and notable in large part for his wonderfully rich voice. For those reasons, it was Troughton that offered the stronger contrast with Hartnell, making him the obvious replacement. Despite not quite fitting the bill for Doctor #2, Hordern eventually found a role that would endear him to millions of young TV viewers, narrating the exploits of everyone€™s favourite ursine Peruvian, Paddington. Perhaps his defining performance, however, was the introverted, fussy Professor Parkin in the BBC€™s 1968 adaptation of Whistle And I€™ll Come To You. For that at least, fans should be glad that Patrick Troughton was the only man who could take over the TARDIS.