Doctor Who: Are The 11th Doctor And Clara Oswald in Love?

By Rebecca Kulik /

5. Double Speak, Foils, And €œHide€

I happen to quite adore Hide, flaws and all. For better or worse, I think it€™s designed as a shortened version of the Doctor and Clara€™s romantic story. Think about it: a man who has seen a lot of death, who has had trouble living after €œso much of the other thing.€ He holes up in an isolated location, brooding and looking for ghosts. A woman whose emotional intelligence is through the roof (and there the similarities between her and Clara end). When Clara is telling Emma that Professor Palmer€™s feelings for her are obvious, she says they €œstick out like a big chin.€ Remember "the nose and the chin"? Yeah, she€™s talking about the Doctor. She knows how much she means to him because it€™s really obvious. Every companion understands how important they are to the Doctor eventually, but this is different. Then there€™s this speech: €œEvery lonely monster needs a companion. It€™s the oldest story in the universe, this one or any other. Boy and girl fall in love, get separated by events€”war, politics, accidents in time€”he€™s thrown out of the hex or she€™s thrown into it. Since then they€™ve been yearning for each other across time and space, across dimensions! This isn€™t a ghost story, it€™s a love story!€ Talk about double-speak! And he does this all with his arm rather inappropriately wrapped around Clara€™s neck! Look, I know a lot of people didn€™t like the twist of the €œlove story€ in Hide, but it fits perfectly in an episode that€™s about how €œnot everything ends, not love, not always.€ What phrase would apply better to the strange experience the Doctor€™s had with Clara and her double-deaths? Finally, the line €œThis isn€™t a ghost story, it€™s a love story€ is especially important in the context of Clara and the Doctor€™s earlier conversation about ghosts. How could Clara not be a ghost to him, if she€™s died in front of him? Because it€™s not a ghost story, it€™s a love story. Clara the person is a mystery, as are all humans to the Doctor. We live, in spite of the weight of the universe.