10 Most Forgettable Doctor Who Episodes

How did an adventure crisscrossing Peru, Hong Kong, Madagascar and underneath the Indian Ocean completely bypass us?!

By James Colbourn /

With modern Doctor Who nearing the 200-episode milestone, we can forgive ourselves for forgetting the odd one or two, or more.

Advertisement

These stories aren't necessarily bad. Some are actually fairly good on rewatch but simply got lost within the Underverse of our memories, with some sandwiched in-between excellent two-parters and unforgettable blockbuster series finales.

Conversely, it then reminds you of why you had a neural block on some episodes in the first place and haven't revisited them on multiple occasions. This can be for various reasons. The plot wasn't memorable or had too much plot that didn't stick (here's looking at you, Flux). Had duff side characters (here's looking at you, Whatshisname). Or perhaps it didn't emotionally resonate – yeah, RTD1 easily knocks RTD2 out the time vortex on that front.

Much like middle child syndrome, these episodes sit between the void of the absolutely fantastic and the burping bin of absolute rubbish. So let's turn the Atraxi eyeballs to the Doctor's meh, mediocre, and in some cases misunderstood adventures...

10. Boom Town

Having spent a considerable amount of the Series 1 production budget on The End of the World and with an epic two-part finale to come, money had to be saved somewhere.

Advertisement

And that somewhere was Boom Town.

Reactions after the episode's broadcast were decidedly mixed but retrospective reviews have been much kinder.

The story is classic RTD1 combining slapstick comedy and dark pathos. We get a glimpse into what life is like in-between the dangerous adventures throughout time and space, with the Doctor and his companions laughing and joking in a restaurant about previous escapades.

The absorbing 'last supper' scene with Nine and Margaret tests the Doctor's moral compass in truly gripping fashion, as Margaret implores that she's changed by recounting how she stopped herself killing the journalist Cathy.

It's a very strong episode but just isn't one that springs to mind when considering the highs of NuWho, or even the highs of Series 1. It's not helped by its low-key story, nor the fact that it gets completely dwarfed in-between bonafide classics The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances and Bad Wolf/The Parting of the Ways!

9. The Robot Revolution

Despite being the big opener to Season 2, The Robot Revolution somehow feels bizarrely bland. Even Belinda's reaction to massive robots smashing through her home seems oddly muted.

Advertisement

Thankfully, there's a welcome bit of spice between the nurse and the Doctor when he tests her DNA without her permission. Just imagine her response if she found out that he was responsible for cutting the power out at the hospital she works at!

The story surrounding toxic relationships and coercive control is solid enough, albeit it's delivered as subtly as the clunky bright red Missbelindachandrabots. And the special effects are impressive when the Doctor, Belinda and antagonist Alan experience a 2001: A Space Odyssey-esque trip full of psychedelic colours and lots of schwupping during the final showdown.

But other than that, what exactly happened in this episode? What were the side characters called? What were all the memorable scenes, speeches and one-liners?

What's that? There weren't any? Oh, well, um... that figures.

At least Space Babies was memorably terrible – it's arguably worse that The Robot Revolution is so completely and utterly bland and forgettable.

8. The Power Of Three

Chris Chibnall's Series 7 episode embarks on a curious narrative where millions of small cubes arrive on Earth overnight, and we see what everyday life is like when Rory isn't dressed as a Roman. Plus, it's always a delight to see Rory's loveable dad Brian involved.

Advertisement

Eleven becomes deeply frustrated waiting for the cubes to do something, and passes the time painting a fence, mowing the lawn, vacuuming the house and doing five million keepie-uppies. All in an hour. That's a dreamboat househusband right there!

The Power of Three is a strange episode though, in that it's basically a stop-gap before the big Pond-killing finale, and it very much feels like it. When the Doctor spends half the time moaning about being bored it's not exactly the most riveting drama Doctor Who has produced, while the lack of any sort of decent villain robs the story of tension and stakes.

Speaking of which, the episode's payoff is pitiful, with the Shakri doing absolutely nothing and the Doctor solving everything by waving his sonic about. It's no surprise The Power of Three fades into the memory when the lasting impression it leaves is one of such utter disappointing mediocrity. It's not an offensively bad episode or anything, it's just sort of... inoffensively there.

Bonus points if you remembered those weird henchmen with grilles for mouths. Yeah, they were in this episode too!

BBC Studios

Do they have names? What do they actually do? Honestly, couldn't tell you.

7. The Ghost Monument

A dangerous interstellar race at the final stage and down to two fierce competitors, both of whom will stop at nothing from winning the prize of 3.2 trillion krin. Oooh! Thirteen and her fam get caught up in Angstrom and Epzo's final showdown on the planet Desolation, and none of these words are ringing a bell for you, are they?

Advertisement

The Ghost Monument just doesn't deliver the gripping spectacle you'd hope for. It's an episode that you might actually think you're remembering wrong, because surely something happens in it? It's a trip across a planet that is described as being incredibly dangerous, after all.

However I can confirm that you aren't remembering it wrong, and that nothing really does happen. Seriously. Nothing.

We get Sniperbots in desperate need of practice at the firing range, and some dirty sentient rags that mumble a few ominous words. That's it. There's some good location work during the TARDIS reveal at the end, but by then you'll be too zoned out to care.

Perhaps the real reason we've suppressed this episode into a Time Lord fob watch is because it mentions the Timeless Child for the first time. Curse those all-knowing pieces of fabric!

6. Planet Of The Dead

With the much darker Waters of Mars and the 'everything plus the kitchen sink' The End of Time to come, David Tennant's farewell tour as the Tenth Doctor kicks off with... something a lot less memorable.

Advertisement

Nomming on Easter eggs and enjoying some flirty banter with the charming thief Lady Christina is just what the Doctor ordered following the heartbreaking departure of Donna. Had Planet of the Dead leaned into its fun characters and had a bit more of a laugh perhaps it would've amounted to more, but instead it finds itself stuck in a bizarre middle ground where it takes itself far too seriously, and ends up falling short as a result.

For proof of just how forgettable this episode is, can you remember what the fly aliens are called? Or any of the characters on the bus, or their backstories? The Tritovores (those aforementioned flies) are actually very impressive creations so it's crazy that nobody remembers them at all. And bloody Daniel Kaluuya was in this one! An Oscar-winner! How did none of this stick?!

It's largely because the Tritovores don't really do anything, and nor do any of the characters on the bus. It's Doctor Who by numbers, and though Lee Evans is quite entertaining as enthusiastic scientific adviser Malcolm, this is easily one of the most skippable episodes in the modern series.

5. Cold War

Mark Gatiss' Doctor Who stories are generally hit and miss.

Advertisement

With Cold War, he hit the right temperature and delivered one of his better episodes, but like pretty much all of Series 7B, Cold War is in this strange wormhole where it doesn't actually feel like it exists, that odd empty void between the massive events of The Angels Take Manhattan, and the shocking cliffhanger of The Name of the Doctor.

Credit where it's due though, as this is a solid submarine escapade full of claustrophobic suspense. Cold War is all about the triumphant return of the Ice Warriors – or more accurately, an Ice Warrior – following a 39-year absence since their last appearance in the Third Doctor serial The Monster of Peladon.

Encased in ice for 5000 years, Grand Marshal Skaldak is brought aboard a Soviet sub then defrosted by an impatient member of the crew. Cue total carnage with Skaldak running amok in a sinking boat. Whether he's stomping around in his seemingly impenetrable armour or moving around stealthily in his true form like a Xenomorph, Skaldak proved to be one of the show's genuinely formidable threats. Heck, he's that respected that his enemies carved his name into their own flesh before he killed them! Talk about gigachad energy.

BBC Studios

Skaldak aside though, Cold War doesn't do itself any favours with a ridiculously bloated cast that had no chance shining through in a tight 45-minute runtime.

Honestly, you could put almost any episode from Series 7B on a list like this, and it would be fair game. It's not that they're all terrible, it's just tha-'

Wait a second, John Hurt is the Doctor?! Woah! Cool! What does it mean? What just happened in the last few episodes? Eh, can't have been anything too important, bring on the 50th!

4. The Curse Of The Black Spot

Hugh Bonneville as a pirate! A pirate! So why, me hearties, does The Curse of the Black Spot reside in Davy Jones' Locker of forgotten Doctor Who episodes? Many reasons, that's why. Arrrr.

Advertisement

Though sporting a great big bushy beard, Bonneville doesn't overly convince as the honourable naval officer turned ruthless pirate, Captain Henry Avery. For a man who's gunned down a thousand innocent men, he oddly comes across as Henry Brown from Paddington playing dress-up pirate. Which makes it all the more frustrating as Bonneville excelled in playing an against-type character as the repugnant Hector Blake in 2022's thriller I Came By.

And apart from Amy swinging a sword near the start, there is also a disappointing lack of swashbuckling shenanigans throughout.

Hell, The Curse of the Black Spot is so forgettable that it even forgets itself, with the character of the Boatswain literally vanishing from the episode around 20 minutes in, only to reappear at the end with zero acknowledgement or explanation. He did have extra scenes that were removed during the edit, which explains the problem. The Doctor Who crew probably thought nobody would notice, or care. Well, we did notice, so ha! Never underestimate the pettiness of a list-writing Whovian.

In a word, it's just fine, isn't it? The Doctor and Avery make for a decent duo (and Bonneville looks right at home at the TARDIS console controls, it must be said). Lily Cole is enchanting as the Siren, and Rory dies again. Certainly not one you'll be itching to rewatch.

3. The Idiot's Lantern

Another one from Mark Gatiss, however The Idiot's Lantern presents us with a mixed bag of an episode from the versatile writer.

Advertisement

The plot itself sounds intriguing enough on paper. An escaped alien parasite extracting people's faces via television so that it can regain its corporeal form, and a serious subplot involving a family with an abusive husband and father.

Unfortunately, the execution doesn't transmit successfully onto the screen. The brilliant Maureen Lipman is horribly wasted as The Wire, making you want to tune out altogether with her constantly irritating cries of "Hungryyyyyyyyyyyy".  With a villain caught between the Cybermen in Rise of the Cybermen/The Age of Steel and the Devil in The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit, The Wire never really stood a chance in capturing our attention.

BBC Studios

Indeed, The Idiot's Lantern resides in that strange mid-series space where many a forgettable episode goes to be forgotten. Just think about it. The Long Game. The Lazarus Experiment. 42. The Unicorn and the Wasp. Why do so many uninspiring episodes end up here? It's Doctor Who's equivalent of a Jason Statham movie in January.

The Idiot's Lantern probably has the least going for it out of all of those, with its dull, low-key plot and lack of memorable moments for the Doctor and his companion. It doesn't help that Rose is written out partway through and the narrative loses all its zip, but hey ho, at least the Doctor's quiff looks cool!

2. Praxeus

If anyone can remember what the hell happens in Praxeus, then we'll do what Ten did for Donna and gift you the winning lottery numbers. Heck, we'll even give you them if you know which series this episode is in! The plot, the subplots, the characters, it all just disappears into the cracks of the universe.

Advertisement

The scientist Suki was tasked with finding an antidote to the mutated alien pathogen called Praxeus, which devastated her homeworld by targeting the microplastics in the body. Suki discovered Earth was full of plastic and therefore saw it as the perfect petri dish. There's also an astronaut infected with Praxeus.

Ring any bells? Thought not?

A big problem Praxeus couldn't eradicate was that it followed hot on the heels of the head-spinning events of Fugitive of the Judoon. Let's be honest, Ryan's weird subplot next to a rubbish dump and guys with laser guns attacking Yaz, Graham and co. partway through – more lottery numbers if you remembered either of those details, by the way – simply melt into nothingness against the return of Captain Jack, the Fugitive Doctor reveal and her buried TARDIS!

There were far bigger things going on in Doctor Who at this point, and Praxeus simply got swallowed up. It's another case of mid-series syndrome only infinitely worse, because the episode itself is just bad. With a capital B.

1. The Eaters Of Light

Ah, so that's what happened to the Roman Ninth Legion – the vast majority were slaughtered and literally left a shell of who they were by light-devouring beasts that shoot bioluminescent tentacles from their mouths. Just imagine if millions of them got through an inter-dimensional portal, they would've eaten the sun and all the stars in the universe!

Advertisement

Sandwiched between the return of the iconic Ice Warriors in Mark Gatiss' final Doctor Who episode and the incredible two-part finale World Enough and Time/The Doctor Falls, The Eaters of Light never stood a chance.

It's a decent enough adventure, with the hauntingly beautiful setting of Aberdeen in the 2nd century, Twelve at his funny best insulting Kar and her tribe, Nardole ingratiating himself with said tribe, and the evolving dynamic between the Doctor and Missy. And it's lovely having a returning writer from the classic series in Rona Munro, who wrote Survival, the final serial before Doctor Who was taken off the air in 1989.

BBC Studios

But when the most memorable thing about your episode is who wrote it, that kinda says it all. The eyes glaze right over The Eaters of Light in the Series 10 lineup with the Monk trilogy, the introduction of Bill in The Pilot, and the Twelfth Doctor's looming regeneration hogging all the limelight.

The episode itself lacks anything iconic or particularly brilliant, instead hitting all the beats you'd expect before a rushed climax that feels comically lacking in jeopardy.

Turns out that coming right before one of greatest finales ever, featuring the return of John Simm's iconic Master, Bill's cruel conversion into a Cyberman and the First Doctor cliffhanger, won't do you any favours.

Advertisement