Doctor Who: Every Sonic Screwdriver Ranked Worst To Best
Same software, different cases. But which of those cases is the best?
While preparing to shoot Fury from the Deep back in the late 1960s, production assistant Michael E. Briant noticed that one scene required the Doctor to use a screwdriver. Briant instead suggested that the Doctor should use a special “sonic” version instead, and over 50 years later, the sonic screwdriver is as much a part of Doctor Who’s DNA as the TARDIS and the Daleks.
It's gone through countless redesigns in that time, and while not every Doctor has carried one, there have been nearly as many models as there are Doctors. Most of these have stuck closely to the original, tubular design – the one exception being the latest iteration, which has abandoned it completely.
Along the way we’ve had ergonomic handles, sliding columns, and extending claws. We’ve had metal sections, leather sections, crystal sections, and lights in just about every colour under the sun. They all open doors, reverse the polarity, and resonate concrete. But which model is the ultimate sonic?
Before we dive in, an honourable mention must go to Romana's sonic screwdriver, Six's sonic lance, Sarah Jane's sonic lipstick and the Master's laser screwdriver, none of which quite made the cut!
13. The Second Doctor’s Sonic (1968 - 1969)
The sonic screwdriver was initially conceived as an alternative to a traditional screwdriver, but the original prop wasn't much more exciting than something you'd find in your toolbox.
The Second Doctor’s sonic was merely an off-the-shelf penlight, comprising a smooth silver tube with a light on the end – a remarkably uninspired choice by today’s standards.
What’s more, Patrick Troughton allegedly lost the intended sonic screwdriver prop on location while filming Fury from the Deep, forcing him to use the only thing he had to hand... a life vest safety whistle.
And you thought the Fifteenth Doctor’s sonic was a departure!
Credit where it’s due, the production team pushed the boat out slightly for the sonic’s second appearance in The Dominators, building a gun-like casing for it to sit inside. But it reverted to that plain old penlight for its third and final outing in The War Games.
Is there something to be said for having a simpler and stripped-back sonic? Perhaps. But ultimately, the Second Doctor’s sonic just isn’t very memorable – granted it wasn't used very much, but we can’t place it any higher than this.
12. The Fifth Doctor’s Sonic (1982)
Original model aside, the design of the sonic remained fairly consistent throughout the classic series. It still took the form of a silver tube, but now with a defined handle and circular emitter on top.
Within this there were a handful of distinct models, each with unique decoration. By far the least inspired of these was the sonic used by the Fifth Doctor, which was simply the Fourth Doctor’s with a very minor paint job.
It failed to make much of an impact – and intentionally so. By this point the sonic had earned a reputation for being a get-out-of-jail-free card, so much so that producer John Nathan-Turner decided to ditch it entirely.
As such, the Fifth Doctor’s sonic only appeared in a couple of stories, and in a cruel twist of fate, its most memorable moment was its fiery destruction in The Visitation.
It’s not the ugliest sonic ever (the white thumb grip is a nice, if pointless touch), and given how short-lived it was, you can see why they didn’t go for something more bespoke.
Still, it’s too much of a footnote to be a contender for top spot.
11. The Fifteenth Doctor’s Sonic (2023 - Present)
December 2023 was a big month for Doctor Who fans. The show’s 60th anniversary specials came to a close, with the return of the Toymaker, Mel, and Trinity Wells, plus the introduction of bi-generation.
If that wasn’t enough, the BBC then unveiled the Fifteenth Doctor’s sonic screwdriver – a pair of curved discs with a multitude of light-up sections, plus a slide-out analyser and pop-out emitter.
It’s the most radical redesign so far, by quite a margin. But it’s also a really cool prop, with some very neat touches like the Rwandan proverb engraved onto the central disc – not to mention all the colour variants we've seen so far.
And depressing though it might be to say, it does sort of feel like a sonic for our times, in the sense that you hold it like a mobile phone or a TV remote.
However it still feels weird to refer to it as a screwdriver. We’ve already had a sonic lance, cane, and trowel, plus the sonic sunglasses – so couldn’t this have been its own thing too?
As things stand, Fifteen's sonic is certainly very nifty, but it's also undeniably an outlier, and is frankly a bit too weird (perhaps even a little ugly) to be up there in the big leagues.
10. The Seventh & Eighth Doctor’s Sonic (1996 - 2013)
The Seventh Doctor never had a sonic in his own era, but when he returned in the 1996 TV Movie his question mark umbrella was gone and the sonic was back!
This new model was essentially just the standard classic series version with a gold handle ring, a red bullet, and no black detailing.
It’s more commonly referred to as the Eighth Doctor’s sonic though he barely uses it onscreen, save for examining Cass’ body in The Night of the Doctor. To make matters more confusing, Paul McGann’s Doctor uses a different and frankly much cooler model in some expanded media stories, with a steampunk design and blue crystal on top.
This is another sonic that’s not really anything to write home about. The recoloured sections are nice enough, but feel like a reaction to previous designs rather than anything intentional. And having the gold ring on the handle (which is usually obscured by the Doctor’s hand) feels like a bit of an oversight.
Like the Fifth Doctor's device you can see why they didn’t go with something more original considering how briefly it appears. The core classic series design had definitely had its day by this point, so it’s a good job this was the last iteration.
9. The War Doctor’s Sonic (2013)
It’s no secret that The Day of the Doctor had a bit of a shaky development, due to Christopher Eccleston refusing to return as the Ninth Doctor. But in his place we got the wonderful War Doctor, a transitional incarnation who harked back to the senior Doctors of old while also looking forward to the future.
This sentiment was echoed by his sonic, which was essentially just the standard silver classic series model (again) with a light-up emitter (a feature which, canonically, wouldn’t be introduced until Rose).
Conceptually, the blend of classic and new series elements really works, and points must go to the production team for bothering to give the War Doctor his own sonic in the first place, when they could so easily have had him use an existing model.
On the whole, it’s a nice design, if a little simple (and by definition, not the most original sonic ever). It served its purpose, but it’s hardly an all-time great.
8. The Thirteenth Doctor’s Sonic (2018 - 2022)
Up until the arrival of the Fifteenth Doctor’s sonic, the Thirteenth Doctor’s was easily the most controversial. But it actually has a lot going for it.
It really fits the organic, crystalline aesthetic of both the Thirteenth Doctor’s TARDIS and her era more broadly. It may be less technological than other iterations, but those glowing amber stripes down the sides make it feel truly alive.
It also has something that most other sonics have lacked: a backstory. It didn’t spring out of the TARDIS ready-made, but was built by the Doctor’s own hands, forged from Stenza scraps and Sheffield steel. It’s a really cool idea that gives Thirteen’s sonic that extra bit of personality.
Overall it’s the sonic that feels most like an extension of the Doctor – partly because of its unique origins, partly because of its curved ergonomic handle and partly because of Jodie Whittaker’s trademark wand-style gestures.
All that said, it’s a little bit lacklustre compared to other designs, and although the more organic feel works for the Thirteenth Doctor, the move away from being a gadget with moving parts and other bells and whistles can’t help but feel like a downgrade.
7. The Fourteenth Doctor’s Sonic (2023)
As was the case with the War Doctor, David Tennant’s 60th anniversary incarnation was accompanied by a brand-new sonic screwdriver.
In concept, this model was the “ultimate” sonic, combining the claws and grip of the Eleventh Doctor’s model with the metal/ceramic casing of the Tenth’s. There are even echoes of the Master's laser screwdriver in the layered gold and silver end cap.
But in execution, the Fourteenth Doctor’s sonic was something of a mixed bag. Yes, it boasted cool new features like the ability to create holographic readout screens and forcefield shields, but no onscreen reason was ever given for its unique design, and cool though it was to have a sonic that paid tribute to lots of others, it can’t help but feel a tad over-designed (plus weirdly squat and chunky).
And did the claws really need to be that far down?
It’s a suitably special sonic screwdriver and looked great onscreen, but not quite top-tier.
6. The Fourth Doctor’s Sonic (1973 - 1981)
There are two sonics that could lay claim to being the greatest classic series model.
Just missing out on that accolade is the version introduced in Season 10, which was the first to include a black magnet on the emitter bullet. Otherwise this is basically just the Third Doctor’s sonic with a fully silver body and less black detailing.
Though commonly referred to as the Fourth Doctor’s sonic, this variant was actually first used by the Third Doctor in Frontier in Space.
It’s easily the longest-running and most-used sonic of the classic series, playing as integral a role in the Fourth Doctor’s era as his multicoloured scarf and endless supply of jelly babies.
And though not hugely extravagant, it didn’t need to be (especially when paired with a Doctor as eccentric as Tom Baker). The restrained silver colour scheme and minor embellishments work a treat here, resulting in a timeless, classy prop.
That said, it wouldn’t have hurt to add another feature or two, just to make this sonic that little bit more distinctive. And like the Fifth and Eighth Doctor models, it’s ultimately derivative rather than anything unique or original.
5. The Twelfth Doctor’s Second Sonic (2015 - 2017)
The Twelfth Doctor favoured a different sonic device in each of his three series. First came the Eleventh Doctor’s sonic (more on that later) and then came the sonic shades (which were certainly a thing that happened).
Then at the end of Series 9, Peter Capaldi was granted a sonic of his own – a beautiful blend of blue, silver and gold, with a top half that evokes both the TARDIS’ time rotor and police box exterior.
This is easily the fanciest sonic of them all, incorporating a ridged activation dial and plenty of other stylish details, from the ergonomic supports on the base to the intricate ornamentation on the sides. It’s also the largest and longest model, with the Doctor often balancing it between his fingers rather than holding it fully.
Like the Thirteenth Doctor’s sonic though, it could have done with one or two moving parts. And like the Fourteenth Doctor’s, it’s perhaps a little too elaborate. Arguably the biggest issue with this version is that it looks more like a museum piece than a practical, everyday device – but that’s hardly the most damning critique on this list.
Overall this was a fitting sonic for the Twelfth Doctor, and it’s a shame it only stuck around for one series.
4. The Ninth & Tenth Doctor’s Sonic (2005 - 2010)
As mentioned, the sonic largely stuck to the same basic template in the classic series before disappearing altogether in 1982.
That template changed when Doctor Who returned in 2005, with the sonic (like every other aspect of the show) receiving a complete overhaul.
The model we ended up with was the first to properly feel like a functioning tool, adopting a sturdy, streamlined design with unprecedented features – most notably, a sliding central column (allowing for ‘open’ and ‘closed’ modes) and a light-up blue emitter.
It was also the first sonic to slot into the show’s wider aesthetic, with the cracked ceramic handle cleverly evoking the finish on the TARDIS console and conveying the fact that the Doctor’s trusty device is, like his ship, an ancient piece of Time Lord technology.
In both these regards, it set the template for every variant that has followed. And unlike some of those later models it’s not too elaborate or overstated.
The only real complaint is that it’s a little on the small side, occasionally disappearing into the Doctor’s hand. No wonder the Doctor's eleventh regeneration, ahem, compensated.
3. River Song’s Sonic (2008 - 2015)
A number of sonic-adjacent devices appeared in the Tenth Doctor’s era, from the laser screwdriver to the sonic pen.
But the greatest of them all was the “future” sonic screwdriver carried by River Song upon her final meeting with the Doctor in Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead.
At the time, the idea of a future sonic belonging to some as-yet unseen Doctor was unbelievably cool. And the design fully played into this, taking the template of the Ninth and Tenth Doctor’s device and giving it a more distinctive appearance, with an alternative ‘red’ setting and various additional components. It was as if the Doctor really had taken his own sonic, augmented it and passed it on to River.
Of course, we now know that the reality was slightly different, but that doesn’t take away from this sonic’s most breathtaking feature – the neural relay chip that, in a wonderfully timey-wimey twist, allows the Doctor to save his future wife.
It’s a cool model as it is, but the fact that it’s also the Doctor and River’s relationship in a nutshell (and what makes it all possible in the first place) is what really earns it a place in the top three.
2. The Third Doctor’s Sonic (1971 - 1973)
Though introduced in the Second Doctor’s era, the sonic only really came into its own alongside Jon Pertwee.
He wasn’t granted a model of his own immediately (though we do see the Doctor and Liz use a suspiciously sonic-esque device to open doors in Inferno), but the one he did eventually end up with starting in Colony in Space was a huge improvement on the original – a proper, looks-the-part gadget with distinctive yellow and black stripes on the upper half and thick black detailing on the handle.
Admittedly, it was still part of the trend of the production team skimping on prop design due to using elements from Gerry Anderson productions as its basis – which means that the sonic screwdriver has technically featured in Thunderbirds.
But the design is so good that it doesn’t matter. And even if it wasn’t, anything would've been better than a penlight!
This sonic established the “silver body, ringed emitter and suspended bullet” template that would endure until the 2005 revival. It was also the first to be placed front-and-centre, not just being used to open doors, but to ward off monsters like Sea Devils and Drashigs.
It’s easily the snazziest and most iconic sonic of the classic era.
1. The Eleventh & Twelfth Doctor’s Sonic (2010 - 2015)
Matt Smith had big shoes to fill when he took over as the Doctor. As did the production team, which had the impossible task of improving upon the show’s iconography, including an immensely successful sonic screwdriver.
It's a brief they delivered on and then some, creating a whimsical new model that surpasses those that came before it and those that have come since.
The Eleventh Doctor’s sonic has everything – from a cohesive, stylish design, combining a copper and silver body with a leather grip and a green emitter, to thrillingly tactile extending claws. It’s both beautiful to look at and demanding to be picked up and played with – no wonder Eleven couldn't resist flicking it around every five minutes.
Like the previous sonic this one was also designed as an extension of the console room, and it successfully mirrors that more playful feel yet still looks sophisticated and elegant. It's a tricky balancing act but they pulled it off beautifully.
Of course, this sonic was briefly retained by the Twelfth Doctor but it undoubtedly worked best with the Eleventh, perfectly complimenting his first TARDIS interior and boundless personality.
It was a total triumph, and it’ll take something very special to knock it from the top spot.