Doctor Who: Ranking The New Who Openers From Worst To Best

12. New Earth

David Tennant had a tough job, given he was the first new Doctor within the revived era of Doctor Who. This was made especially difficult since Christopher Eccleston bowed out from the show after just one series, dropping such a significant change to the formatting relatively early on in the revived eras run. Plus, the Tenth Doctor was bedridden throughout his first outing, which definitely didn't help out with first impressions.

This is why a lot was riding on New Earth to really give the audience a full sense of what David Tennant could do, and if the show could continue with the same success as Series 1. But unfortunately, more questionable creative decisions blocked him from achieving this. Although New Earth has some juicy elements, such as instilling some mystery (and connection) around the Face of Boe, and having the Sisters of Plenitude experimenting on human guinea pigs. in order to discover the cures for humanity's illnesses.

Even the return of Lady Cassandra could've been a welcomed element. Frustratingly, the episode is turned into a badly constructed comedy routine, with Lady Cassandra hoping back and forth between Rose and the Tenth Doctor's bodies, creating some cringe worthy moments. Plus, it still feels as though David Tennant is getting used to the role, with his performance feeling inconsistent, as his full potential tries desperately to come out. Sadly, the script just wasn't helping.