Every Death In The Simpsons Ranked
The Grim Reaper has come to Springfield...
Death does not appear very often on The Simpsons, probably because it's quite hard to get much family-friendly comedy from it. That being said, The Reaper has made a few calls to Springfield over the years and we're going to decide which one of them was the best.
"Best" can mean a number of things in this scenario; it can mean the emotional impact a death had on the viewer; the storyline ramifications of the death; the way in which the death was done; or the lasting impact that it has had on the show's history.
We're not including any characters who died off-screen or whose deaths are merely mentioned but never seen. We're also not including any characters who seemingly die but whose fates are unconfirmed, so you won't be seeing Sherry Bobbins or Rex Banner in this list. We also won't be including any animals, so sorry to Snowball I and Pinchy, who will live on in our hearts forever.
Also, this list will mostly be light-hearted, but it will obviously be discussing death - a subject not everyone is comfortable with - and entries 21, 19,and 2 mention suicide, so read on at your own discretion.
With that out of the way, let's begin...
22. The Pit Master (Cue Detective)
Our first perisher comes from the show's twenty-seventh season which would explain why it's at the bottom of the list. Marge gives Homer a bag of cash and sends him to buy the family a new washing machine. However, she should have learned by now that Homer cannot be trusted to organise a booze-up in the Duff Brewery, as he returns home with a new barbecue.
He bought the "smoker" from The Pit Master, a mysterious old man whom he meets at the roadside. The Pit Master is played by Edward James Olmos, who has appeared in some pretty big movies including Coco and Blade Runner. Sadly, he didn't get much of a chance to display his experience in this episode, as he was only on screen for about three minutes.
After Homer's family is (understandably) angry at him for wasting their money, The Pit Master appears in the clouds and tells Homer to win them back using the power of the grill. He then adds "Oh, by the way, I died", bringing this character's less than impressive arc to a swift end.
A totally forgettable character whose death serves as nothing but a punchline - next!
21. Professor Huntington (Homer The Moe)
Back in Season 13, Moe returns to his old bartending university to rekindle his love for the profession. In doing so, he encounters his old lecturer, Professor Huntington, and well, let's just say things don't end well for him.
In a scene right out of a hard-hitting drama, Moe and Huntington are stood by a lake when the teacher confesses that he is dying. After rhetorically (and then sincerely) asking Moe if he has a cure for cancer, the Professor says goodbye and walks into the lake. Despite Moe mistaking this for him going "swimming", it's pretty clear what's really going on.
Huntington's death was confirmed when he appeared before Moe as a ghost, chastising him for converting his tavern into a swanky modern bar. Whilst this does prompt Moe to reach out to his former customers - who have abandoned him for a makeshift boozer in Homer's garage - this is pretty much the only thing the prof's death achieves.
Considering how harrowing his demise is, it is barely mentioned in the episode as it morphs into a story about Homer trying to shoot a turkey. A good idea badly executed, this death would not pass any university class.
20. Dr. Nussenbaum (Friends and Family)
In our most recent episode, Mr. Burns visits his psychiatrist, Dr. Nussbaum, in an attempt to deal with his anger issues. In true Mr. Burns fashion, he ends up getting so angry that the good doctor collapses and dies.
We find out at his funeral that Nussbaum was also The Simpsons' psychiatrist (not that this ever plays into anything) and that Mr. Burns has paid for the whole event. We know this because Nussbaum's tombstone has "Paid For By C. Montgomery Burns" written across it, which enrages the entire town.
This kicks off the episode's main plotline about how Burns hires The Simpsons to play his pretend family in VR (new Simpsons, don't ask). The Doctor's last words do drive Burns for some of this episode, but the episode quickly becomes about Homer's friendship with a neighbour that he didn't know he had (again, don't ask).
Nussbaum's death is pretty insignificant in the grand scheme of things, but at least it had some ramifications for the episode going forward. Dr. Nussbaum is a character that zero fans of classic Simpsons will know and even those who actually saw this episode will struggle to recall him.
19. Fred Kanneke (Million-Dollar Abie)
The episode "Million Dollar Abie" starts with Springfield trying and failing to get a pro football franchise and ends with Grampa becoming a matador, but not before trying to end his own life.
To give some more context - or any context really - it was Grampa who cost the town its football team and the resulting shame leads him to take this rather depressing choice. He visits a Doctor who hooks him up to a "diePod", but Chief Wiggum and the police break up the illegal procedure before it is complete.
Shortly before Grampa is plugged into the machine, his doctor tells him he'll be following in the footsteps of "Socrates", "Ernest Hemingway", and "Fred Kanneke". When Grampa asks "Who's Fred Kanneke?", the doctor replies "My last appointment" and a body is wheeled out on a gurney. If that wasn't funny enough, later on Wiggum remarks to the Doctor "I think you know my brother-in-law, Fred Kanneke?" Classic comedy, right there.
Fred's death adds nothing to the plot of this episode, but the weight of a man choosing to end his own life is a heavy one, even if the show used it as just a cheap gag.
18. Albert (Walking Big & Tall)
After Homer's weight gets him in trouble at a performance of Springfield's new town anthem, Marge begs him to join a weight loss group. However, as we saw with the "smoker" incident, Homer isn't very good at following instructions and ends up joining a group that embraces obesity instead. The group is run by Albert, a large man in a mobility scooter played by legendary voice actor Kevin Michael Richardson who actually became the new voice of Dr. Hibbert in 2021.
Albert encourages Homer to embrace his size and even gets him arrested when the group protest outside a clothes store. When confronted by a worried Marge, Albert attempts to prove that he doesn't need his scooter and stands up on his own. Sadly, this leads to Albert having a heart attack and dying - nice one ,Marge!
Albert's death is pretty much the end of the episode aside from his funeral which contained a few fat jokes and the shocking revelation that he was only 23-years-old, but at least his death proved a point and was actually used as a narrative device. Dying from standing up though? Hardly the most glamorous way to go.
17. Viktor the Gangster (The Falcon and The D’ohman)
In 2007, The Simpsons did a parody of the show 24 called "24 Minutes" featuring Kiefer Sutherland reprising his role as Jack Bauer. Clearly, this wasn't enough for Kiefer, as he decided to come back and voice a different spy on the show four years later.
Playing Wayne - an ex-CIA operative seeking a new life in Springfield - Sutherland reluctantly befriends Homer only for his past to catch up with him when the Simpson patriarch is kidnapped by gangsters. The leader of the gang is called Viktor and his character basically boils down to "Gang Leader."
In the episode's dramatic finale, Wayne rescues Homer from the mobsters and kills Viktor by throwing a shard of ice into his throat. Remember when The Simpsons was a cute little short on The Tracey Ullman Show? How far it's come...
Viktor is a pretty decent villain in this episod just the right mix of threatening and humorous and with great chemistry with his hapless kidnapee, Homer. His death is the natural conclusion to this episode and it happened in a pretty cool way, even if it was a bit more graphic than most others on this list.
16. The Callibricis (The Mook, The Chef, The Wife And Her Homer)
In an episode with a title way too long to repeat, Lisa becomes friends with Michael, son of local mob boss (and list future entry) Fat Tony. Michael isn't keen to follow in his father's footsteps and dreams of becoming a chef, so Lisa vows to help him achieve his goal and stand up to his dad. Unfortunately, this ends pretty badly as Michael ends up using his cooking to murder a rival gang.
The Callibricis (or Calabresis going by some spellings) try to take Fat Tony out earlier in the episode by gunning him down with a helicopter. Nobody ever said the mafia was subtle. They do this after seeing Michael baking soufflés and deciding that he isn't tough enough to exact revenge on them if they kill his old man.
Unfortunately for the mobsters, their plan fails on two accounts. Not only does Fat Tony survive, but the entire gang is wiped out when Michael serves them a poisoned meal, shocking Lisa in the process.
The Callibricis death was a great end to an episode-long narrative, but considering we never see them or Michael ever again, their deaths mean very little in the grand scheme of things.
15. Frank Ormand (The Twisted World of Marge Simpson)
Head of the "Pretzel Wagon" franchise, Frank Ormand convinces Marge to invest in the bready snack to go head-to-head with The Springfield Investorettes and their "Fleet-A-Pitta". Unfortunately for Marge, the business flops harder than an uncooked pretzel. Even more unfortunately for Frank, he dies in car crash.
Upon seeing Marge upset at her business failing, Homer tracks down Frank and talks to his wife. When he asks to see the franchise owner, his widow informs him that Frank and the executor of his estate both died in the same off-screen wreck. Out of answers, Homer turns to Fat Tony and the mob for help, which sets up this episode's final act.
Frank was a good character considering he was barely on screen - almost certainly down to the fact that he was voiced by Hollywood legend, Jack Lemmon - but his death was mostly played for laughs. It's not particularly tragic or emotive, but rather a gag that's used to pivot the story towards the mobsters.
Could Frank Ormand's death have been more impactful if the writer's had given it more thought? It's hard to say? Was this an end befitting a two-time Oscar winner? Definitely not.
14. Red Barclay (Maximum Homerdrive)
In Season 10's "Maximum Homerdrive", Homer and Bart discover that all truckers have been secretly using self-driving vehicles to avoid doing any work. If that plot doesn't excite you then don't worry, it didn't excite many people at the time either. But how did the Simpson men get themselves into such a wacky scrape? Because somebody died of "beef poisoning" of course!
Before his adventures in haulage begin, Homer challenges a trucker named Red Barclay to a steak-eating contest at a new restaurant. Homer is defeated, but it is he who has the last laugh as Red stuffs his face so much that he passes away then and there. Homer decides to make amends to his recently-deceased friend by completing his final delivery.
Again, this is a death that is mainly used as a joke. The idea of dying of "beef poisoning" is laughable and the fact that Red's character boiled down to "eats steaks and drives trucks" makes it hard to get attached to him in his short time on-screen. Still, he kicked this episode's plot off, which counts for something at least. It's just a shame that plot was mostly awful.
13. Max The Ice Cream Man (Ice Cream of Margie (With The Light Blue Hair))
Homer starts off this Season 18 romp being chastised by Mr. Burns when an ice-cream truck passes the power plant. Unable to contain his desire for the sugary treat, Homer runs off and Burns fires him on the spot. Homer catches up with the truck and talks to its owner, an old man named Max. Max and Homer are good pals - seemingly through years of the latter keeping the former in business - but it Max's friendship with the big yellow oaf that is ultimately his undoing.
Homer uses a $100 bill to pay for a 25c ice cream (in 2006? not likely) and counting all of the change causes Max to have a fatal heart attack. Homer attends Max's funeral - which actually contains some pretty funny ice cream jokes - and buys the truck from his widow, also setting this episode's main plot in motion.
Max and Red Barclay die in very similar ways to each other, so they really could have been interchangeable on this list. However, for the ice cream jokes alone, Max gets the cherry on the top of the morbid sundae in our opinion.