Every HBO Comedy Ranked From Worst To Best

52. 1st & Ten

One of HBO’s very first attempts to be taken seriously as a purveyor of comedy, the 1984-debuting 1st & Ten attempted to win laugh seeking viewers from the networks by virtue of the freedom their premium network could boast. Here you could curse, blaspheme, and indulge in all manner of naughtiness the advertiser-led mainstream TV couldn’t stomach.

Advertisement

Unfortunately that was about all 1st & Ten could offer. Once you got past the potty mouth, this was a down the line conventional sitcom with the same repetitive trappings of most things on TV. Set in the world of American football, the characters were a ragtag bunch of jocks and the team’s unscrupulous owners who’d time and again come close to winning the big one only to fall achingly short.

Its main point of interest to the modern audience is the presence of one Orenthal James Simpson, who joined in the second season as a player turned coach. Naturally, a certain mid-'90s murder trial saw 1st & Ten gain relevance for the first time in a long while.

Other than the curiosity factor, there’s little of interest here. HBO was still finding its feet as a content creator, and the best was of course yet to come.

51. Not Necessarily The News

It’s perhaps a little unfair to grade Not Necessarily The News from a 2021 perspective. By its nature, the name of the game was to satirise and spoof current events. Accordingly, a lot of its material hasn’t aged well, relying on a recollection of specific news stories from the mid to late ‘80s that can easily leave a modern viewer baffled.

Advertisement

Taken on its own merits, though, the show is something of a mixed bag. It relied on a wackiness and whimsy where many satires go for the jugular. This could yield great results, like Rich Hall’s sniglets (made up words which spawned a book series), but at times could feel a bit weedy, unwilling to take genuine swipes at worthy targets.

Not Necessarily The News was an early gig for many talented comedians, including Conan O’Brien, Greg Daniels, and several other Simpsons writers alongside Hall, but really that’s the programme’s lasting legacy. It wasn’t meant to stand the test of time and so its low position does seem a bit cruel, but those are the breaks when producing topical comedy.

50. The Boring Life Of Jacqueline

A true HBO curio, this show about an aspiring actress was never really given much of a chance by the network who, in 2012, had an overstuffed schedule to say the least. Shot in a cinema verite style, this was a show shot on the cheap and tucked away on HBO’s fledgling digital streaming zone.

Advertisement

In the era of HBO Max and a focus on net presence, The Boring Life Of Jacqueline could have found the audience it probably deserved. It’s heavy on the quirkiness, as is much of the work of director Sebastián Silva, and even with its short runtimes, episodes rarely felt as though there was a great deal packed in.

But for those who like that sort of thing, the show definitely had potential. Jaclyn Jonet’s spacy, disconnected performance was great fun and the show utilised cameos well, including frequent Silva collaborator Michael Cera as himself. This could have been a weird show beloved by those in the know; instead, it sputtered out all too fast.

49. The Baby-Sitters Club

This is a true HBO outlier - instead of a cynical comedy about showbiz or a riveting, bloody crime drama, we have a teenage comedy about some girls forming the titular childminding organisation. This is hardly a show we could recommend an adult reader suddenly gets heavily into, but for younger viewers or those who were there at the time and fancy a nostalgia trip, The Baby-Sitters Club is a fine proposition.

Advertisement

Its key strength is its casting, with the lead girls getting across a genuine and natural camaraderie rarely seen in actors of any age bracket, let alone young kids. This is a low risk proposition with little in the way of peril - most episodes centre around schoolyard crushes or petty theft.

As an adaptation of a beloved book series, though, it does a bang up job, and is commendable in its refusal to speak down to its young viewers. Not necessarily your next box set recommendation, but for what it was, it’s worthy of mild praise.

48. Hardcore TV

Another entry from the list of shows that once seemed quite wild but have dated like milk, Hardcore TV at least lays out its stall early doors. From the title alone you can just about guess what you’re going to be getting: a form of sketch comedy that, the producers would have you believe, simply wouldn’t fly on mainstream telly.

Advertisement

As this is the early ‘90s, this basically means there’s swearing, a bit of sex, and some boundary-pushing un PC content that’s a little jarring to watch these days. In terms of actual, transgressive material, though, you can rest easy - Hardcore TV’s grit comes entirely from its presentation rather than the targets of its humour.

Its opening salvo sums it up nicely, a skit in which Wayne and Garth from Wayne’s World are beaten to death. Mildly amusing, sure, but unlikely to shock and appal even NBC’s most dedicated fans.

Some recurring sketches were fine, others (eg “Rastapiece Theatre”, in which an elderly Jamaican gent read from a storybook) were pretty lazy, but the whole show is a forgettable if mostly adequate time capsule.

47. Encyclopaedia Brown

HBO’s other major attempt at kids’ TV finishes a couple of spots above The Baby-Sitters Club because it succeeds much more as a supplier of laughs. Based on the beloved series of books, Encyclopaedia Brown lasted only seven full length episodes and left little of an impact on the culture, but it’s an interesting and often amusing curio in HBO’s esteemable catalogue.

Advertisement

These are warm and family friendly mysteries that keep to the spirit of the books in their encouraging of the viewer to get involved and crack the case themselves. The titular detective is played by Scott Bremner but, deliberately or otherwise, he’s somewhat of a non-entity here, allowing the viewer to immerse themselves into the case as the lead detective by merit of either smart direction or Bremner’s less than vibrant performance.

It’s pretty routine stuff, with the formula all but exhausted even after its brief run of seven entries, but there’s a decent amount to enjoy here, even if it’s not going to be winning any awards.

46. The No. 1 Ladies’ Detective Agency

This is a lightweight, easy watching show of moderate entertainment, capable of producing smiles and the odd laugh. If that sounds like damning with the faintest of praise, well, it sort of is. ​​The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency is pleasant TV, but for the most part entirely unexceptional.

Advertisement

The impressive parts: it’s one of the first major pieces of entertainment to be filmed in Botswana (where the books and the series are set), and the cast are fantastic, particularly Anika Noni Rose and the multi-talented Jill Scott. As the titular detectives, they’re immensely charming and charismatic, everything you could want in a procedural detective show.

Because ultimately this is what The No. 1 Ladies’ Detective Agency becomes. The Africa of this show doesn’t seem to reflect reality, using the continent’s lush scenery as a backdrop rather than attempting to say anything interesting (possibly a result of the all-English creative team).

Perhaps this series could have taken its unique perspective and terrific cast and made something incisive or at least memorable; instead, it’s pleasant fluff.

45. Entourage

Had Entourage capped at three seasons, it would likely be a lot higher on this list. The first three installments of the show offered a punchy if immature look at modern Hollywood through up and coming actor Vincent Chase and his gang of hangers-on. It was funny, glossy, fast paced.

Advertisement

Then it went on for another five years, and absolutely nothing changed or progressed in any measurable way. Every season sees Vince hoping to nab a part in a dream movie project. Somehow he messes it up. Then everything works itself out. Lather rinse repeat.

By season seven, they gave Vince a drug problem to spice things up a bit, but he kicked this with ease and went back to being rich and successful. No conflict, no plot development - no real plot.

Add to this some of the most loathsome characters in telly history (namely manager Eric Murphy) and an immensely regressive view of women (who might as well be an alien race in the lad-centric Entourage universe) and you’ve got an absolute mess. The first three seasons are genuinely worth watching; the rest will make you despair.

44. The Brink

An oddball comedy with a star studded cast, The Brink feels as though, with the right tailwind behind it, it could yet find a cult audience. It’s an uneven satire that doesn’t quite live up to its lofty goals, but as a curio at the very least, it’s worth a look.

Advertisement

Jack Black and Tim Robbins star as a foreign services officer and the US secretary of state respectively as the nation lurches into crisis. War with Pakistan seems imminent, and the fate of the country is in the hands of Black’s doofus operative, Robbins’ out of control politician, and a skeezy, drug dealing soldier played expertly by The Wire’s Pablo Schreiber.

The content is rarely as clever as the producers would like to think it is, with the satire on the basic side and the jokes frequently lapsing into crude material, but the strong cast keeps it afloat, and it’s genuinely funny in places.

It doesn’t quite work, and the notion of subsequent seasons focussing on new crises was swiftly kiboshed, but it’s an intriguing production.

43. Unscripted

Acclaimed director Steven Soderbergh remains a frequent producer of content for HBO, and while his ideas are usually innovative and cool, they’re also quite often not all that good. Case in point: his 2005 comedy Unscripted. As the title suggests, this was primarily improvised by the cast, with all the pitfalls that so often entails.

Advertisement

The show stars three young actors playing themselves as they traverse the pitfalls of Hollywood - acting classes, auditions, attempting to reinvent yourself after being judged primarily by your looks. The verite-style shooting and overlapping improvised dialogue has a loose, natural feel, but at times one can’t help but wish the whole thing was a little more focussed.

Unscripted often seems a little insider, with a laser focus on what life is like for the unknown, grafting actor. If you, the viewer, fit this description, you’ll no doubt nod and empathise at the trials and tribulations. If not, you may feel a little lost here.

Advertisement