Star Trek: 10 Greatest Genre Episodes Ever

When Star Trek does comedy, it's a laugh riot. When it does horror, do you join in the screams?

By Sean Ferrick /

Genre episodes can be a fun departure from a standard episode of Star Trek. As the franchise is so rooted in SciFi overall, veering away from that, or at least altering the genre to fit another trope, can break up the flow of a season - something that Strange New Worlds is taking to the bank at the moment.

Advertisement

In that show alone, we've seen a musical, a zombie infestation, a role-playing D&D-inspired episode, alongside animated team-ups and some good old-fashioned time travel, if indeed we count time travel as a genre.

Yet Star Trek has experimented with form for decades, peppering its ongoing series with frights, laughter, and weeping. The Original Series had both incredible freedom and the restraints of '60s production limits, to play with this. Still, it had many examples of various genres, including some properly frightening moments.

The Next Generation and Deep Space Nine also continued this trend, though of course every iteration of Star Trek has its opportunity to break the actors out of the technobabble-of-the-week. Naturally, comedy is something Trek has visited on many occasions. There is something about those tight space suits and the arched eyebrows of the Vulcans that lends itself to farce. On the flipside, tragedy has just as many examples in Trek's history.

For this list, we are concentrating on the televised portion of Star Trek, so we will visit the movies at another time. For now, it's a director's dream as we dive into the list of genre highlights across the years.

10. SciFi: Schisms

For our first entry, we had to ask ourselves: what constitutes Science Fiction? Further to that, how could we pick the best example of it within Star Trek itself? First, the definition, from Britannica.com:

Advertisement
Science fiction, a form of fiction that deals principally with the impact of actual or imagined science upon society or individuals.

In choosing Schisms, we have used the Solanogen-based lifeforms experiments upon the crew of the Enterprise-D, as well as the threat of alien abduction in general, to guide our choice. Science fiction, as broad a term as it is, often deals with things like technological advancements, as well as body modification - both of which are on show here.

In the spirit of full disclosure, there are many examples of science fiction as a genre in Star Trek, which is as obvious as it is challenging to pick any one example to rise above the rest. Time travel, as we indicated in the introduction, may appear on another list as its own genre, so many of the options for science fiction will be up for consideration there.

For the episode here, there are several moments that help it stand out as an example of science fiction. Riker's missing time, that chilling scene on the holodeck, poor Ensign Hagler's fate, and the climax in the aliens' realm all combine to tell one of the most enduring, disturbing stories in Trek. The Next Generation undertook many experiments during its run, with Schisms skirting the line of scifi and horror carefully. 

For the close encounters element of this episode, it is our choice for science fiction - and we have all been in that room before, haven't we?

9. Western: A Fistful Of Datas

Per Britannica.com:

Advertisement
Western, a genre of novels and short stories, motion pictures, and television and radio shows that are set in the American West, usually in the period from the 1850s to the end of the 19th century.

There really was only ever one clear winner in this genre, though Star Trek has experimented with westerns a number of times. In The Original Series, Spectre Of The Gun offered audiences a view of the O.K. Corral, while Star Trek: Enterprise visited a modern frontier in North Star. While A Fistful Of Datas may blend a couple of genres (looking at you, comedy), it is a western at its core.

You probably know the story: Worf's latest attempt at hiding from Alexander takes him, in the guise of spending time together, to Deadwood, a lonely frontier town in which he will play the Sheriff. Thanks to a computer hiccup, Data begins appearing in the most inopportune places, while director Patrick Stewart rolled the camera with glee.

Considering the comedic nature of the episode, it makes every effort to capture the feel of those spaghetti westerns of yesteryear. Brent Spiner is having a ball as he swaggers through town, revolver on his hip, while Marina Sirtis embodies the lone drifter, here to help the Sheriff. Even little Alexander gets something to do as the kidnapped deputy. 

In other words, it captures all of the tropes of the genre (we see you, piano player closing the lid before a gunfight. We see you) and lovingly recreates them on the holodeck. It may not be the most original take on westerns, but it remains Star Trek's premiere offering in that genre to date. 

8. Romance: The City Of The Edge Of Forever

Romance, literary form, usually characterised by its treatment of chivalry, that came into being in France in the mid-12th century.

The City On The Edge Of Forever is considered the height of romance in Star Trek, despite its sci-fi and time travel leanings, because there is simply no denying the chemistry between William Shatner and Joan Collins. Though the story ends in tragedy, that too is baked into the fibre of romance, so much so that the story itself tells you it must be so.

Advertisement
Edith Keeler must die.

From Spock's lips to our broken hearts, this was a doomed romance from the beginning. Having said that, Kirk's obligation to see history set right may break the code of chivalry, but would saving her have really given her a better life? After all, her movement led, however indirectly, to the Nazis winning the war. What sort of future would that look like?

One could (easily) argue that the real romance of The Original Series was between Kirk and Spock, or even Kirk and the Enterprise (for further details, see Gene Roddenberry's novelisation of The Motion Picture), but in terms of pure, episodic romance, it must be the tragedy of Edith Keeler, James T. Kirk, and a well-meaning Leonard McCoy. 

Why must romance so often be combined with pain? Harlan Elison, who hurt you?

7. Noir: Suspicions

Film noir, style of filmmaking characterized by such elements as cynical heroes, stark lighting effects, frequent use of flashbacks, intricate plots, and an underlying existentialist philosophy.

Suspicions, the sixth season episode of The Next Generation, offered a compelling mystery for both Dr Crusher and the audience. The narrative structure plays with time - we are brought into the story at roughly the mid-point, while Guinan helps excise the exposition from Crusher.

Advertisement

Though the episode doesn't fully utilise the tropes of film noir (it's thin on the ground with dramatic lighting), following the doctor's mission via both flashback and misdirection helps it land here. The episode also plays on the audience's assumptions. How could a Ferengi be interested in scientific research? Surely the Klingon must be the violent one. 

In doing so, the eventual reveal about Jo'Bril lands. Crusher's desperate attempt to clear her name, despite the hesitation from Picard and the rest of the crew, helps make her the hero the story really needs to hit those final tropes. Having the dead man hide in the shuttle's closet is the cherry on top - it's an episode that keeps on giving. 

A particular highlight is Ogawa's role, who is, of course, played by the late, great Patti Yasutake. Here, she is the investigator's 'man on the inside', so to speak. This, too, is a trope that benefits from years of backstory. Ogawa and Crusher have worked together for years. Even if the rest of the crew are slow to help, there is always one plucky person, ready to tackle the case.

Suspicions is not just a riot, but also a great example of investigative noir played in the 24th century. 

6. Action-Adventure: The Way Of The Warrior

Action-Adventure is a genre of film, according to Merriam-Webster:

Advertisement
Featuring characters involved in exciting and usually dangerous activities and adventures.

Star Trek is no stranger to the genre. When technology began to catch up with the imagination of the franchise's writers, larger set pieces began to appear. The Original Series did an incredible amount of action with the limitations of the day, while The Next Generation used it sparingly, preferring to centre much of the action around conversation.

Along came Deep Space Nine, and things began to change.

While action appeared in the pilot, it was the destruction of the Odyssey and the Cardassian-Romulan invasion of the Gamma Quadrant that spurred the show into new heights. The Way Of The Warrior took every trick the show's production team had learned and depicted the new direction for the show: the Klingons going nuts.

The fourth season opener is a feast for the eyes, though it has a compelling story to go with it. Worf's introduction is handled with care, while the arrival of Avery Brooks' bald head signalled a new direction for Star Trek. 

It's all about the attack on the station and Deep Space Nine didn't disappoint. A fleet of Klingon ships began its bombardment, followed by hand-to-hand combat on the Promenade, Ops, and the habitat ring. Almost every supporting character gets something to do, including some truly hilarious moments between Garak and Dukat.

A common refrain among Star Trek fans is that the fourth year is where Deep Space Nine really took off and, with exploding Vor'cha class attack cruisers and the arrival of General Martok, it's impossible to disagree with them.

5. War: The Siege Of AR-558

War, as a genre, is a little harder to pin down. According to OxfordReference.com:

Advertisement
The war film is generally (if somewhat arbitrarily) regarded as featuring scenes of combat that are dramatically central and that determine the fate of the film’s principal characters—hence the other commonly used term.

Much of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine and Star Trek: Discovery depict the horrors of war in their run, with both examples delivering enormous space battles, as well as ground assaults. One might consider Sacrifice Of Angels for this entry, with that particular episode being a strong contender for the previous action-adventure entry, but the true, greatest example of the war film is The Siege Of AR-558.

When Star Trek confines itself to space battles, however exciting they are, they lose that personal connection to the characters. Yes, consoles will explode and people can and do die, but it is often a cold, detached depiction. The Jem'hadar assult on the Starfleet forces in The Siege Of AR-558 is brutal, deadly, and devastating. Though Starfleet wins the day, there is no real victory here.

Nog becomes the heart of the episode as he goes from a naive, bright-eyed ensign to a badly injured, shell-shocked officer. We are introduced to characters who, in a lesser episode, may have been consolidated to red shirt status, but here are given room to breathe and emote. When Vargas is killed, it means something. When Kellin dies protecting Ezri, it means something.

This, combined with Paul Baillargeon's haunting score, plays on the audience's discomfort and horror at what they're witnessing. It remains one of the darkest episodes in Star Trek's run for exactly that reason.

4. Comedy: The Trouble With Tribbles

This genre is one of the most straightforward ones on this list. According to Britannica.com, comedy is a:

Advertisement
Type of drama or other art form the chief object of which, according to modern notions, is to amuse.

The Original Series took itself quite seriously, despite adding in the occasional jokes (often at Spock's expense) for some of the early episodes. It was still establishing what Star Trek was, so dipping into the comedy pool too early could have thrown the writers for a loop. By the time that The Trouble With Tribbles aired, Star Trek knew exactly what it was - and the episode shines because of it.

The Klingons had been established. Kirk and Spock's relationship had been established. Audiences knew what to expect when a rogue trader came into town. Starbases were often spots of bureaucracy and tedium. Mix all of these, and one gets the perfect outcome: a funny episode that elicits laughs almost sixty years later.

Almost all of the principal cast appear (George Takei was unavailable as he was filming the Green Berets) and they all get farcical parts to play. Uhura and Chekov introduce the Tribbles to the Enterprise, McCoy analyses them, Spock fawns on them, and Scotty gets into a fistfight with a Klingon. William Shatner shines as the put-upon captain who would rather do anything else than deal with the squabbling of directors and delegates, though maybe not if it meant standing under more of those storage units.

The episode works so well that it was revisited in tribute to the franchise's thirtieth birthday. The comedy is so well done that the joke works twice, and Trials And Tribble-ations is just as much fun to enjoy.

3. Horror: Wolf In The Fold

Horror film, motion picture calculated to cause intense repugnance, fear, or dread.

For The Original Series' dip into horror, author Robert Bloch (of Psycho fame) created a story that has both aged well, in that it still manages to elicit scares today, and badly, in that some of the logic is as far from logical as it's possible to be. 

Advertisement

A spectral version of Jack the Ripper is a truly terrifying idea, one that has been revisited in the years since. Haunting, possession, murder - Wolf In The Fold plays with each of these tropes, helping to build the oppressive atmosphere that Scotty finds himself in almost at once.

Bloch, writing in Psycho, touched on revulsion and confusion, particularly in how Norman Bates deals with women. Unfortunately, shortcuts were taken in the script for Wolf In The Fold, which don't gel with the rest of Star Trek. McCoy's worry - that Scotty was in an accident caused by a woman, so may grow to hate all women - is nonsense, and only serves to place the finger of suspicion on the engineer.

However, the true dread of the episode works in the spooky, misty streets, the things that go bump in the night, and the endlessly terrifying voice of John Fielder, swapping his joyous Piglet-era tone for an evil Ripper one. The story may be a reuse of one of Bloch's earlier ideas, but in large part it works - not least because of the enduring image of James Doohan standing over a corpse, bloody knife in hand. 

2. Heist: Badda-Bing, Badda-Bang

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine appears again as we discuss heist as a genre. According to Masterclass.com:

Advertisement
A heist movie centers on the planning and execution of a robbery.

There is a simple, easy example of the best heist in Star Trek, and that is Badda-Bing, Badda-Bang from Deep Space Nine's seventh season. Not only is it a tremendously fun episode, it is also the last episode in the show's run before the final Dominion War arc kicks off.

In Vic's lounge, something is wrong. The program has glitched, gangsters have appeared, and things look grim for everybody's favourite crooner. Rather than reset the program and risk permanent damage to Vic, the crew decide to play things out within the confines of the holosuite. That is to say - they're going to rob the casino, force the gangsters out, and give Vic his home back.

It's a riot from start to finish with almost all of the major players joining in. Worf may sit this one out, but watching Sisko toss stacks of dollars into the air is worth the price of admission alone. The clock is ticking as Nog tries to crack the safe, while Kassidy does her best to distract the guard outside. 

Bashir plays his Bond fantasy, Kira plays footsie under the table, and Odo does the 'neck trick' to great amusement. Not even a poisoned 'Bobby' Reilly can spoil the day, and the heist goes off without too much of a hitch. 

High-stakes at the casino are low stakes in the Alpha Quadrant, but Badda-Bing, Badda-Bang is easily the greatest heist in Star Trek - and that includes the theft of a Jem'hadar fighter than followed mere episodes later.

1. Fantasy: Qpid

Though Star Trek may delight in science fiction, it owes a debt to fantasy as well. Fantasy is, per Britannica.com:

Advertisement
Imaginative fiction that relies on strangeness of setting (such as other worlds or times) and of characters (such as supernatural or unnatural beings).

There are many examples in recent years of Star Trek using this genre of storytelling. Strange New Worlds had its Elysian Kingdom, and Lower Decks was visited by the Hysperians in Where Pleasant Fountains Lie. Both of these examples owe a debt to Q, Vash, and the Sheriff of Nottingham.

Worf may not have been a merry man in QPid, but many of us in the audience were merry watching him shatter Geordi's lute. Poor Data ended up with an arrow in his chest, but it barely dented him. To be fair, he could take a hail of bullets and reply with 'Greetings!', so we're not that shocked.

The trip to Sherwood Forest may have been an ill-advised gift from Q, but it was another example of Star Trek using comedy, and now fantasy, to break up the standard when it came to the series. The Next Generation could take giant swings when it needed to, and Little John Riker may very well have done so with that staff, but when they landed, they landed well. 

It may not have come with an accompanying Bryan Adams tune, but this tale of Robin and his band of merry men was fantastic, and one for the ages. 

Advertisement