10 Awesome Ideas WWE Suddenly Stopped Doing

The times WWE struck gold, then instantly lost it.

By Michael John-Day /

WWE has been subject to many changes throughout the years, going through multiple names, eras, and rebrands. The promotion is constantly shifting and re-adjusting, which has naturally come with plenty of ideas that change the landscape of the company in both large and small ways.

Advertisement

For example, the first Royal Rumble started as just an idea, and now it's a major part of the wrestling calendar. Additionally, the use of theme music wasn't a widespread thing when it was first used. Instead, it slowly became the norm over the years. There are plenty more examples of this within the wrestling industry, as there are many creative minds at work. Sadly, just because an idea is good doesn't mean it will stick around.

WWE often comes up with amazing ideas only to abandon them with very little explanation. This can be incredibly frustrating, especially when the company refuses to let go of things fans hate, *cough* Matt Riddle's CG birds *cough*.

The following are some of the most egregious examples of this, as the promotion seemed to be on the brink of something brilliant before letting everyone down.

10. Women's Exclusive Premium Live Events

Claiming that women's wrestling has come a long way in the past decade is like saying Marvel Studios has done alright with their film universe. The division has clawed its way from Bra and Panties matches to incredible feats of storytelling and athletic prowess. The all-women's Evolution event was a massive milestone in this journey, so where has it gone?

Advertisement

As the WWE Women's Revolution (trademark Stephanie McMahon) raged on, fans got their wishes granted as they got to see more female-centered events. Royal Rumble, Money in the Bank, and Hell in a Cell, the wrestlers were finally getting their chance to show off, and the peak of this was Evolution.

This all women's show was a triumph that many thought would never happen. It certainly wasn't perfect, but neither was the first WrestleMania, so surely Evolution 2 would come along soon to iron out the kinks, right? Right?!

Well, no. The event has never received a follow-up, with different sources citing an array of reasons for not returning it. Even Triple H placed doubt on the show coming back in 2021 at the conference call for NXT TakeOver: In Your House, where he claimed an all-female event was "not a must-have at the moment."

Hopefully, this is something the company might explore again in the future, but don't hold your breath.

9. The Intercontinental Cup

Everyone loves a good wrestling tournament, and more so, everyone loves when a secondary belt is given a feeling of prestige. The Intercontinental Cup had the potential to achieve both of these in one go and could even have led to seeing more mid-card talent on TV. But, it made like a magician and completely vanished.

Advertisement

The Intercontinental Cup was advertised in 2013 as part of the Main Event television programme for Ion TV. It was advertised for a week, promising to include the likes of Kofi Kingston, Randy Orton, Dolph Ziggler, and more, with the winner getting a shot at Wade Barrett's Intercontinental Championship.

It was a perfect idea as it gave some purpose to the show and could give Barrett a great new opponent. However, Main Event came and went without any sign of the tournament. It was ultimately cut before it could begin, with WWE beginning a programme between Barrett and Bo Dallas instead - yeah, because that worked out so much better.

The company attempted to bring kayfabe into the Cup's sudden cancellation, with Barrett claiming he had convinced management to cancel the event in a Tweet. If heels could really cancel number-one contender tournaments just like that, then there'd be no hope for anybody.

8. Unique Stage Designs

This is definitely a point that many fans of the previous WWE generations lament, but there's a reason it is brought up so often. Losing out on unique set designs has made everything bleed into one homogeneous aesthetic, and fans miss the old days.

Advertisement

WWE used to have a great focus on the design of an arena. Whether it was an episode of Raw/SmackDown or a big PPV event, the company would create a stage that matched it. This often led to iconic imagery such as the SmackDown fist or (in the case of WCW) the Halloween Havoc pumpkin. A PPV meant spectacle, but that's not always the case nowadays.

Most WWE events now, including weekly shows and Premium Live Events, have the same LED screens plastered on a blank background. Some events switch the look up, but only once in a blue moon, and very few of them can compare to the glory days of the massive sets of the past.

This is, sadly, not something that is going to change anytime soon, as WWE's cost-cutting ventures won't allow it. Still, fans can always look back and remark on how things used to be.

7. The Royal Rumble Tumbler

The Royal Rumble is, without a doubt, one of the greatest ideas ever concocted by a wrestling promotion. It's an annual event that fans look forward to every year, but there's one minute detail in its presentation that is sorely missing nowadays, and that's the tumbler.

Advertisement

This object was a rotating cylinder full of 30 plastic balls with numbers ranging from 1-30 inside. The wrestlers entering the Rumble would take one at random in the build-up to the event, dictating their place in the match. It was a fun addition to the show, adding an aura of surprise and even fueling storylines before the PPV.

But, over the years, the tumbler faded away, instead making way to a non-specified order that usually reveals itself on the night. It has only made sporadic appearances in the past decade.

One of the most notable returns for the tumbler was a dire segment between Vince and Stephanie McMahon in 2016. In this, Stephanie filled each ball with the name Roman Reigns to force him to enter the Rumble at number one. Between the ham-fisted attempts to paint Reigns as an underdog and Vince's inability to open the balls, this segment truly didn't paint a good picture of the tumbler.

Still, it's a shame that it doesn't appear anymore, as it was a helpful part of building excitement for the match.

6. Cesaro Is A Paul Heyman Guy

The story of Cesaro is one of pure heartbreak for wrestling purists. Here was a man with astonishing in-ring abilities and a thrilling set of skills that helped to get him over with die-hard fans. But, there was always a barrier to his success, which Vince McMahon put down to a "lack of charisma" and "verbal skills" on an episode of the Steve Austin Podcast. Thankfully, someone had the great idea of pairing him with a manager who could carry this work for him. It's just a shame it didn't last.

Advertisement

Cesaro, or Claudio Castagnolia as he is known outside of WWE, separated from his manager Zeb Coulter in April 2014 in favour of becoming a Paul Heyman guy. Fans were delighted as this seemed like a prime chance for the Swiss Superman to get a decent run and break out into the main event. Heyman is one of the best mic-workers in company history, so their combined strength should have made a megastar.

Sadly, a collection of losses started piling up, and a few months later, he shockingly broke it off with Paul E. WWE was as quick to abandon this storyline as AEW was to pick Cesaro up after he was released. Oh, how things could have been.

5. Cinematic Matches

Who could have possibly predicted the impact Broken Matt Hardy would have on the wrestling industry? Sure, matches filmed outside of wrestling rings didn't originate with the Hardy Brother, but he certainly helped popularise them with The Final Deletion. This strange wrestling endeavor became an eventual lifeline for WWE during the pandemic era.

Advertisement

It became surprisingly commonplace to see cinematic matches in WWE during the coronavirus pandemic, as it was a unique way to create thrilling matches that worked around the lack of a live audience. The Boneyard match between The Undertaker and AJ Styles at WrestleMania 36 was an instant classic, and John Cena vs. The Fiend at that same event also made fans happy.

Not only did cinematic matches serve to benefit rivalries, but they also played a part in major WWE events such as Money in the Bank. Still, WWE was quick to abandon the concept as soon as audiences returned to the fray.

Some might say that the Bloodline storyline is a hybrid of traditional wrestling and these movie-like experiences, as it blends acting/drama with in-ring work. Still, it's a shame there can't be a few more bizarre cinematic moves every now and again.

4. 8k Entrances

Like the previous entry, this design choice was a by-product of having to adapt to the pandemic era. WWE relies heavily on live audiences, meaning this tough period of isolation was sink or swim. The company mostly managed to swim with the introduction of the Thunderdome, but they also made a choice that was less swimming and more jet-skiing.

Advertisement

Using an 8k camera during wrestler ring entrances was a stellar idea as it gave the performers a whole new look. This camera made them appear massive and superhero-like, capturing the promotion's incredible production value and the prestige of its workers excellently. It also acted as a great way to distract viewers from the lack of live reactions, as the camera angle was solely focused on the star.

Fans utterly loved this addition. However, after the pandemic began closing shop and audiences were filtered back in, these 8k entrances were dropped. There was no discussion as to why they came to an end. All that fans knew was that their favourite new entrances were gone.

Most people want to leave everything that happened during Covid in the past, but some things should have lasted.

3. The Mae Young Classic

Here is yet another wrestling tournament that has fallen to dust, but unlike the Intercontinental Cup, fans were given a taste of this treat before the meal was torn away.

Advertisement

It's hard to believe there have only been two Mae Young Classic tournaments, as they played such a big role in the Women's Division. These bracketed contests brought plenty of fresh talent to the promotion, with the likes of Kairi Sane, Toni Storm, Rachel Gonzalez, and the current Women's World Champion Rhea Ripley making their WWE debuts in the event. Additionally, massive stars like Tessa Blanchard, Serena Deeb, and even referee Aubrey Edwards appeared in the tournament.

WWE seemingly struck gold with this one, as the tournament's legacy is one of great wrestling and progression for the company. Plus, it was an easily repeatable formula that could have boosted the Women's Division annually. So, why did it suddenly stop?

Sadly, there isn't an answer to that question. The third rendition of the tournament was, presumably, cancelled due to the coronavirus pandemic. However, the event failed to return the following year and has yet to receive any updates since.

Considering that the Classic was such a success, why doesn't WWE run it anymore? Fans may never know.

2. Titantron Entrance Videos

There was a time when a wrestler's entrance video was one of the coolest things about them. These edited visual packages were an awesome way to show off a performer's gimmick, skills, and personality. However, the entrance video is now a relic of the past.

Advertisement

While every wrestler used to get one of these unique videos put together to compliment their entrances to the ring, the vast majority of them nowadays don't. It's standard practice now to instead feature a static image of their name, logo, or a catchphrase during their walk down the ramp instead of a cleverly thought-out montage.

This was a gradual thing that many fans might not have even noticed, as some performers (such as Kevin Owens) still have glimpses of the classic wrestling staple in their entrance. However, this is very much the exception now, as almost all new wrestlers come to the ring with bland, mundane Titantron images.

Some have predicted that this, alongside the major loss of pyro, is a cost-cutting technique taken by the company. That could be the case, but it has definitely stripped a lot of personality away from the promotion and the wrestlers.

1. Taboo Tuesday/Cyber Sunday

The core appeal of Taboo Tuesday (eventually re-branded as Cyber Sunday) was that the fans got a say in the show. WWE allowed viewers to vote for aspects of the matches, such as stipulations, special guest referees, or even those who competed.

Advertisement

While this might have been a big headache for management, it did lead to some incredible moments. For example, when Shelton Benjamin famously won the vote to face off against Chris Jericho in an Intercontinental Championship match. He won the bout, but management never expected him to even enter the match as they assumed the public would vote for Batista, meaning they had to have the match on the fly. This kind of unpredictability and surprise is something WWE fans thrive on, and as such, it's bizarre to think that this practice is over.

The event was created during a time when social media was still in its infancy. Thus, if a modern lens was applied, it could make a massive impact on the show and the relationship between WWE and its fans.

The concept was re-explored in NXT 2.0's One-Year Anniversary episode, which allowed viewer votes to control the show. But, other than that, it has remained dead since the last Cyber Sunday event in 2008.

Advertisement