10 DUMB WWE Name Changes (That We Didn't Want To Admit Were GENIUS)

Yeah, pro wrestling fans were WRONG about these "stupid" and "ridiculous" WWE name changes.

By Jamie Kennedy /

Changing a wrestler's name is always risky business.

Advertisement

WWE became the kingpins of this practice, typically owing to Vince McMahon's need to own everything. Of course, even Vince knew that some things were best left alone, and that's why he kept the Samoa Joe moniker instead of calling him something like "Joey Samoey" (shout out to 10 year old memes) on NXT.

The list of company name alterations that made fans cringe is legendary, but...what about the times when WWE got it right and received flak for it anyway? If most are being honest, us pro wrestling fans can be a tough bunch to please at times. Almost every decision is met with scepticism, and everything is hyper-analysed to the point of exhaustion.

Sometimes, as a community, the wrestling daft throngs out there need to admit that they got it wrong. These name changes are proof of that, because all of them worked out well in the end following a whole bunch of scoffing, raised eyebrows and (in latter years) gnashing of teeth on social media.

Many might not want to acknowledge it, but they were improvements.

10. Rey Mysterio Jr > Rey Mysterio

It might seem strange to imagine now, but there was a fair amount of wailing when WWE inked a deal with Rey Mysterio Jr and dropped the "Jr" portion of his name. In fact, this writer remembers one magazine article that wondered if Vince McMahon was deliberately needling the now-defunct WCW one last time by gently renaming Rey.

Advertisement

Yeah, erm...no, no he wasn't.

If anything, WWE were attempting to move Mysterio away from the idea that he was a young boy-esque underling who paled in comparison to family seniors. Long term, it worked - fans ditched the "Jr" part of Rey's name quickly, and embraced McMahon's vision for the high-flying star.

This is mad to think about, but that aforementioned magazine article even suggested that WWE putting Mysterio back under a mask WCW had taken off him was a bid to divert attention away from the soft renaming. Again, there was a bit of overthinking going on here!

9. A-Kid > Axiom

A-Kid had become a popular name on the UK and European independent wrestling scene by the time WWE came calling in 2019. The tag-team star (as one half of Team WhiteWolf alongside Carlos Romo) had turned enough heads to score a spot on the NXT UK roster. Once that brand disappeared, Kid needed something new.

Advertisement

Enter Axiom, and cue some chortling online.

'Oh, here we go again', several mumbled. WWE were wrecking a once-promising indy standout by putting their own awkward stamp on him in 2022. Axiom was a masked character, and immediately drew comparisons to greats like Rey Mysterio by default. That's always slightly unfair, but admittedly unavoidable.

Nearly two years on from the renaming and repackage job, Axiom is doing well. He even took his WWE main roster bow on an episode of SmackDown in November 2023, and has received rave reviews for his ring work. The remodelling allowed A-Kid to build his career within WWE without leaning on his independent past.

8. Carlito Caribbean Cool > Carlito

Psst! Remember when recent returnee Carlito debuted on the main roster back in late-2004 and was handed the rather lengthy Carlito Caribbean Cool name? That's what the then-newbie referred to himself as during promos, and announcers followed suit by repeating the name in full every single time they went to talk about him.

Advertisement

Someone shorten that to 'Triple C', for crying out loud.

Seriously though, the name was cumbersome. Within months, WWE's creative team had started to shorten the name to simply Carlito, and it was an inspired change. For example, hearing commentators hesitate to take a breath before saying something like, 'Carlito Caribbean Cool is beating up John Cena' was a little much; Carlito was more than enough. It was snappier.

The second and third parts of Carly's original ring name will never make a return, and with good reason. Some folks were a bit snippy about it back in '04 though, probs because the name change happened so swiftly following his debut.

7. Eli Drake > LA Knight

What did you think the first time you heard that ex-TNA and NWA man Eli Drake had been renamed LA Knight in early-2021? Be honest here. The name sounded like a TV show Vinnie Mac had watched back in the 1970s, and didn't seem to be a neat fit for the once-proud NXT brand.

Advertisement

Shade thrown at LA Knight's name change was wrong in retrospect.

Obviously, there's a caveat here. WWE rebranded Knight a second time as Max Dupri when they called him up to the main roster, and the dude had to fight hard to shed that moniker so he could return to LA (so to speak) and start showing his worth. Thank God he did, because Dupri certainly wasn't wrestling for World Titles on PLE.

Looking at things with the benefit of hindsight makes it clear that LA Knight is a far sexier name than Eli Drake. The unique thing about this one is that Drake is probs the kind of brand WWE chiefs would've come up with themselves.

Nah, Knight is a huge improvement.

6. Big E. Langston > Big E

Time for another one that's kinda funny looking back.

Advertisement

WWE changed Big E. Langston's name somewhere between Royal Rumble-Elimination Chamber 2014. He had the Langston surname in the Rumble, but was called Big E by the time he wrestled Jack Swagger for the Intercontinental Title at Chamber. So, what's funny about it?

People were a wee bit p*ssed to see the Langston name vanish, that's what. Yep. A decade ago, the name Langston was apparently very important to fans. This sweeping outrage wouldn't last too much longer though. Big E worked better for the future New Day man, and there'd be similar anger if WWE brought the Langston part back today.

Perhaps this can be explained away as folks just not really liking change, but it's strange that there was so much concern with the lack of Langston on the end of the man's ring name. Injuries aside, things worked out very well for the future WWE Champ.

5. Bronson Rechsteiner > Bron Breakker

A lot of traditionalists out there were looking forward to the next coming of the Steiner name in WWE. Rick's kid Bronson already looked like a can't-miss physical specimen coming out of college, and the McMahon family happily signed him in February 2021. Months of paying his dues followed pre-debut.

Advertisement

When that debut came, the Steiner name was nowhere to be seen. Nope. Bronson Rechsteiner (the guy's real name) had been changed to the WWE-ified Bron Breakker, and that led to some serious debate on Twitter/X about what kind of things folks were smoking in the writer's room at WWE HQ.

If one stops to think about, sidestepping the Steiner name completely was a genius move by WWE. They lifted pressure from Bron's shoulders instantly, and gave him the chance to carve his own path in the biz without too much chatter from old NWA/WCW fans about how many suplexes he'd perform per match.

People knew his family ties anyway, so there was no need to beat them over the head with it and put an unfair burden on Breakker.

4. Nick Nemeth/Nicky > Dolph Ziggler

"Hi, I'm Dolph Ziggler!".

Advertisement

Various wrestling magazines, websites and forums discussed the chances of this twin handshaking gimmick and name change being a rib on the former Nicky of Spirit Squad fame back in 2008. After all, Dolph Ziggler sounded like an appalling bit of branding that'd possibly nuke a promising career completely.

Instead, being called something so stupid put spotlight on Dolph straight away. People were intrigued by the bleach-blonde Dolph Lundgren and Dirk Diggler amalgamation, and everyone wanted to see if Ziggler's natural talent could overcome such an in-your-face burial job from WWE's creative team.

Recently, there was a lot of fanfare about Nic Nemeth's (where did the 'k' go?!) debut in TNA. That wouldn't have been possible without his stunning body of work under the Ziggler name. By 2010-ish, fans were over the ridiculousness of it all, and had embraced Dolph as one of the best young stars of his generation.

3. Paul Wight > Big Show

WCW calling Paul Wight "The Giant" during his near four-year stay in the promotion was both a nod towards Andre The Giant and a straightforward bit of presentation. The man was gigantic compared to most human beings, so it fit. Then, he joined the WWF in 1999, went under his real name for a spell and...weeeeeeeeeeeeell...

Advertisement

...it's the Big Show!

People did not take to that name. Some were confused as to what it even meant. To them, the "big show" was WrestleMania, so was this ex-WCW man coming in as a walking, talking representation of the annual spectacular. If so, why not just go to the whole way and call him "Showcase" as a tip of the cap to "Showcase Of The Immortals".

The above was a real-life discussion this writer had with friends at high school back then. It was a simpler time. Again, like several others on this list, Big Show grabbed attention without much effort. It made Paul Wight a curious beast, one fans wanted to learn more about.

2. Prince Devitt > Finn Bálor

Select hardcore fans hit keyboards harder than Nigel McGuinness hit clotheslines when WWE signed celebrated New Japan stalwart Fergal 'Prince' Devitt in 2014 and redubbed him Finn Bálor. The name was soaked in Irish mythology, but it caused a meltdown or two on socials at the time.

Advertisement

WWE were clearly ruining yet another top pro wrestling star with their annoying need to McMahon-ify everything in sight! That was a common argument in 2014, and it wouldn't go away for a few years. Christ, some even argued that the Bálor name was responsible for Finn's struggles on the main roster in 2017/2018.

In 2024, it's hard to imagine Finn as anything else.

He made the name work, and it rolls off the tongue nicely. In fact, Finn Bálor sounds a hell of a lot better to some than Fergal/Prince Devitt ever did, and that's saying something considering how grand the 'Prince' moniker sounded when Ferg was winning IWGP Junior Heavyweight Championships.

1. WALTER > GUNTHER

You just knew this one was gonna be number one.

Advertisement

Time for a bit of context. Part of the discord about WWE changing WALTER to GUNTHER wasn't exclusively on a name change. No, people were baffled that the company originally planned to call the Austrian star Gunther Stark, which meant he'd share a name with a well-known Nazi U-boat commander.

Mercifully, WWE didn't fight against this and quickly realised the error of their ways. GUNTHER stuck around though - some were mad enough about that. The wrestler himself embraced change after an awkward promo on the 18 January 2022 episode of NXT, and many agree that GUNTHER is actually superior to WALTER now.

GUNTHER has gone on to become the longest-reigning Intercontinental Champion of all time. He's an example of somebody who uses talent to rise above WWE stupidity, and he might ride that name change all the way to the top of the industry.

Good for him.

What other WWE name changes seemed stupid but actually worked? For more wrestling, check out 10 Moments Wrestlers NEVER Recovered From and 10 New Directions For WWE In 2024!

Advertisement