10 Moments Wrestlers NEVER Recovered From
Career-halting nightmares from WWE, AEW and more. These wrestlers NEVER recovered.
Pro wrestlers are often at the mercy of overworked creative teams who can make or break their careers. Of course, the folks actually on TV doing this stuff take some responsibility too, but sometimes they're fighting an impossible battle to make what's on the booking sheets work.
For example, it's anyone's guess why those who write WWE television would think outright calling a wrestler rubbish is the best way to make money. That happened though. The same could be said for AEW penning one of the worst segments in living memory - even a relative rookie told Cody Rhodes it'd be a bad idea, and figured fans would dump all over it.
He was right, and yet he's the one who suffered most.
These moments totally tanked careers. Some never had the chance to recover before retiring from the ring. Others have a shot at redemption, but things are looking less and less likely on that front the longer time rolls on.
Prepare for dreaded on-screen burials, gimmicks workers blatantly didn't fancy, and more creative misery than an episode of WCW Nitro under Vince Russo's pen.
10. Lance Storm Is “Boring”
Steve Austin had the power to veto this woeful creative.
He didn't. So, on the 16 June 2003 edition of Raw, then-GM 'Stone Cold' literally brought out a pillow and snored during Lance Storm's match vs. Garrison Cade. This was all part of a campaign to encourage fans to view Storm as painfully snooze-worthy, and nobody's quite sure why it was booked at all.
Lance might not have been The Rock verbally, but he was a rock solid technician between the ropes. Surely leaning on his strengths rather than any weaknesses would've been the way to go, but no - WWE campaigned to have fans change the channel from their own show whenever Storm was on air.
Unsurprisingly, this failed to do anything for Lance or authority figure Austin. It was a complete waste of TV time. Storm didn't get the chance to put things right either, because he retired as a WWE full-timer in 2004. Let's hope he hurled abuse at creative on the way out.
9. Rick Bognar Is “Razor Ramon”
It may seem strange to fans who only know the man for guff cosplay, but 'Big Titan' Rick Bognar did have value in the mid-1990s. He'd enjoyed a decent run in Japan and popped up on ECW's radar, then the WWF came calling in late '96. In retrospect, Bognar probs wished they hadn't bothered.
'Hey No' instead of 'Hey Yo' might've been the answer if he knew what was waiting.
On the 23 September 1996 edition of Raw, Rick was drafted in to play the ‘Fake’ Razor Ramon, and it was a disaster. The gimmick also immediately neutered JR’s promising heel turn, made Bognar look like a joke, and fans hated it all anyway. Mercifully, at least Vince McMahon cut it short.
Bognar’s final televised WWF match was a short spot in the 1997 Royal Rumble. The fed binned him after it (aside from one house show appearance in February), and that was that. Rick's once-fledgling career was never at pre-"Razor" levels again.
8. Anthony Ogogo's Weigh-In Hell
AEW's Anthony Ogogo once called his weigh-in segment from the 28 May 2021 edition of Dynamite "f*cking dogsh*t, mate" during a chat with interviewer extraordinaire Chris Van Vliet. Ogogo had reservations ahead of time, because he figured the complete lack of action would be far too Lance Sto...sorry, boring for a wrestling show.
Cody Rhodes disagreed, and so did everyone else behind the scenes.
What resulted was a torturous waste of precious TV time on AEW's flagship broadcast. Paul Wight couldn't get the misfiring scales to work properly, and Ogogo blasted him in typical heel fashion. Unfortunately, due to his accent, the word "can't" sounded like something else entirely. Clue: That other word replaces the 'a' with a 'u'.
Cody vs. Ant at Double Or Nothing the following week was nothing to write home about either, and Ogogo's AEW career has never got back on track. Technically, he's still contracted to the promotion until 2025, but hasn't worked a match on TV since Dark vanished.
7. Keith ‘Bearcat’ Lee
Current AEW man Keith Lee looked borderline embarrassed when he squashed Akira Tozawa in just 35 seconds on the 27 September 2021 Raw. He'd been re-dubbed 'Bearcat' by creative, and...nobody liked it. Few were even willing to give the gig a chance either, probably 'cause everyone could see it was never going to pan out.
Follow up squashes didn't do anything to improve things. Then, having clearly thrown the towel in themselves, WWE cut Lee from the roster in November less than two months into their own repackage job. Hopes were high that Keith would rebound in AEW quickly.
He hasn't.
Granted, the man has battled through health problems aplenty, but he still seems lost creatively. The star power Lee once carried in NXT has disappeared, and he might never get it back. Tony Khan doesn't seem to have a clue about how to book Keith as a top star; otherwise, he'd have surely done it by now.
6. Rikishi “Did It For The Rock”
This was a bad idea for a seemingly 'Bad Man'.
On 9 October 2000, Raw was rocked with the bombshell that thong-wearing comedy act Rikishi had mowed down Steve Austin back at Survivor Series 1999. Why? Well, as the man himself explained, he "did it for The Rock". Going further, albeit briefly, the WWF tried to make the attack racially motivated.
That fell flat, so the company pivoted to out Triple H as the true mastermind behind everything. He'd orchestrated the attack on Austin, then Rikishi carried it out. Erm...what? Overnight, Rikishi went from beloved mid/upper carder to a heel who lacked any direction to speak of.
WWE later tried to revitalise the old Too Cool vibes of before, but it was far too late for that. The fanbase had moved on, and no amount of soft apologies from the writers could change things back to the way they were.
Oops. What a mess.
5. The Shockmaster Stumbles
Admit it, you knew this one would be here.
It couldn't be left out, because The Shockmaster's fate has become iconic. Poor Fred Ottman had modest success as Tugboat and Typhoon in the WWF, but ol' Shocky was supposed to take him to the next level when he jumped to WCW in 1993. What happened next was a meme before such things existed.
The Shockmaster debuted at Clash Of The Champions XXIV during a 'Flair For The Gold' segment. He was supposed to burst through a hastily-assembled wall in his sparkly Stormtrooper helmet and change the game. Instead, Ottman tripped over a piece of wood that'd been awkwardly hammered to the base of the frame, fell over and lost his headpiece.
People laughed (including some of the other wrestlers on set), and there was no coming back for Ottman. He was rethought as a bumbling-but-lovable fool who played up to his error-strewn ways and had a heart of gold. The glittering Star Wars head gear went back into storage.
4. Madusa Bins The WWF Women’s Title
You might be staring at this and thinking, 'Huh? Madusa was inducted into the WWE Hall Of Fame in 2015!'. Yes, yes she was, but the woman herself has repeatedly stated that hurling the WWF Women's Title into the trash on WCW's dime "ruined" much of her pro wrestling career from that moment on.
The WWE HOF was a brief bit of respite after 20 years of struggles.
Vince McMahon ditched Alundra Blayze and the entire women's division in late-1995, so Alundra (as Madusa) literally binned his belt live on the competition's flagship show Nitro. Looking back, it was another bid from Eric Bischoff to dig McMahon in the ribs, but it affected Madusa's career prospects terribly.
She wasn't welcome back in the WWF/WWE fold once WCW vanished, and even bagging regular autograph/meet n' greet gigs proved troublesome for one of the most revolutionary female performers of her generation. Madusa wishes she hadn't done this at all.
3. Dr. Death Loses In ‘Brawl For All’
Reportedly, the WWF had high hopes that Steve Williams would become heel foil for top star 'Stone Cold' in either late-1998 or into 1999. Their plan? Have 'Dr. Death' maul the competition in a special toughman tournament called 'Brawl For All'. The whole tourney was going to be a shoot, but known hard nut Williams would surely triumph.
He was knocked out by Bart Gunn early on.
All plans to have Death challenge Steve Austin were scrapped instantly, and his reputation was left in tatters. Furious (even though it was their fault; the WWF set Williams up for failure), the promotion also dumped eventual winner Bart following his loss to Butterbean at WrestleMania XV.
In short, 'Brawl For All' had been a ridiculous idea that didn't even have any payoff anyway. Somehow, federation top brass forgot that bringing Death in and having him win carefully laid-out squashes would be pro wrestling 101.
100% better than having him fight for real then get humbled.
2. Bret Hart Leaves The WWF
Fun fact: Wrestling writers get a kickback from the Canadian government any time they mention the 'Montreal Screwjob'. OK, obviously not, but it has become one of the biz's most overanalysed topics since 1997, and that may never change. Regardless, it's definitely valid for a list like this.
Leaving the WWF generally changed Bret Hart forever.
He was never the same in WCW. The 'Hitman' was visibly disinterested in being there, and the fire that burned within him to be the best pro in the industry had gone out. It'd be genuinely hard to pinpoint more than a handful of good-to-great matches Bret had under the WCW banner - his heart had been ripped out, so to speak.
Health issues then plagued the legend from late-1999 onwards. By the time he was ready to forgive Vince McMahon, Shawn Michaels and everyone else connected to Montreal, Hart was a shadow of his former self. The way his career fizzled out will always frustrate this lifelong fan.
1. Vader Irks Shawn Michaels
SummerSlam 1996 was a nightmare for Vader.
He'd been brought in earlier that year and presented as the WWF's new top heel. The ex-WCW man should've nailed that spot and produced the goods against a super worker like Shawn Michaels, but HBK didn't want to play ball with an increasingly-clumsy big man. So, the shine came off Vader pretty quickly.
Michaels audibly chewed him out on pay-per-view at SummerSlam, and Vader's career started to nosedive. He did enjoy some main event moments after the '96 show, but one of the best big men in wrestling went from hot property to washed up afterthought within the span of two short years.
By '98, he was even calling himself "a big fat piece of sh*t" on air, and was checked into a weight loss clinic behind the scenes. Irking Shawn and struggling away from the ring did Vader zero favours in the WWF. His run there is roundly considered a miserable failure, especially considering expectations from fans and critics before he arrived.
Which other moments wrecked wrestling careers? For more WWE, check out 10 New Directions For WWE In 2024 and 10 Things WWE Raw: Day 1 Told Us About WrestleMania XL Season!