10 Great Wrestling Matches That SUCKED Live

WWE, WCW and more matches ruined by live crowds, production and self-indulgence.

By Jamie Kennedy /

Have you ever jealously gawked at your TV during a hot wrestling match and thought, 'Damn, I'd love to be there to see that in person'? The live crowd were rowdy that night, some of your fave performers seemed to be on top form and everything just clicked to make the bout a thrilling spectacle on screen.

Advertisement

Listen a little closer.

Sometimes, live wrestling crowds are noisy for reasons that actually hurt the match for others in the arena. Of course, blaming audiences for a poor display is silly, but that's not the focus here; what about those clashes that were technically sound, featured dazzling aerials or worked tirelessly to tell a good story? They must've been hard to savour live when some fans in the stands had another agenda.

Rebellious crowds are only one issue though - the dismissal of in-arena viewers by production (who favour those looking on from home instead) and the arrogant self-indulgence of wrestlers themselves can spoil things for many who stumped up cash for a ticket.

These matches all had merit, but they were best enjoyed on telly...

10. Rey Mysterio Vs. Ultimo Dragon

Where: WCW Hog Wild 1996

Advertisement

The Match: Rey Mysterio and Ultimo Dragon was a breathtaking example of everything that was right with WCW's Cruiserweight division. It had the stunts, it had a killer international flavour and it opened the pay-per-view presentation wonderfully well.

Why It Sucked: A biker rally in Sturgis was not the right place to take in high-flying Cruiser action.

Fans in South Dakota revved their engines, sank some beers and generally greeted Rey vs. Ultimo like two kids putting on a dance routine. Basically, they politely watched, but didn't seem to grasp the in-ring wizardry that was on offer - that's what WCW get for promoting shows in front of folks who didn't watch week-to-week.

Any hardcore WCW fans who did make the trip to Sturgis might've felt out of place for loving every second of this opening scorcher. That's a damn shame, but at least it looked great on TV.

9. The 'Fiend' Vs. Daniel Bryan

Where: WWE Survivor Series 2019

Advertisement

The Match: Recently-turned babyface Bryan gave it his best shot against the still-fresh 'Fiend'. The match (at just over 10 minutes) was short, but it was a fun sprint through more offence than fans had seen from Wyatt's opponents since his alter-ego debuted.

Why It Sucked: The red lighting killed this stone dead.

That was a problem with The 'Fiend's' early showings, and it's something that WWE didn't seem to give a toss about. Actually seeing what was going on became a chore for fans in arenas live, and so most of Bray's bouts played before apathetic silence. People in Rosemont weren't able to appreciate the snappy exchanges both men had here.

OK, so calling this a "great" wrestling match might be stretching it, but this was the best 'Fiend' collision yet at that point. Amazingly, Bryan and Bray would go on to top their efforts at Royal Rumble too; they did so sans-pesky red light.

8. Roddy Piper Vs. Goldust

Where: WWF WrestleMania XII

Advertisement

The Match: A fired-up Roddy Piper stepped in for a WCW-bound Scott Hall to bounce Goldust around on a movie set at WrestleMania. Then, fans were treated to a little live action exposé in-ring that revealed that Goldie was wearing lingerie underneath his gold jumpsuit.

Why It Sucked: The majority of this 'Hollywood Backlot Brawl' was taped in advance the day before, meaning fans inside the Arrowhead Pond in Anaheim watched the thing on archaic monitors. Unfortunately, trons back then weren't nearly as large or crystal clear as they are today.

WWE were still rocking those old 'video wall' screens back in 1996.

The upshot was that footage was grainy and too dark - it was fine for folks watching at home though. They could see the full picture, but fans in Arrowhead only really reacted for the tiny portion that played out in front of them in-ring. No wonder.

7. AJ Styles Vs. Randy Orton

Where: WWE WrestleMania 35

Advertisement

The Match: AJ Styles brought his super-worker boots to 'Mania 35 for a showdown with WWE icon Randy Orton. Motivated to meet him halfway, Orton also did everything he could to make this undercard scrap look big time. The cutting shoot-style comments from both during the build up definitely helped.

Why It Sucked: Check out the pic above for a little refresher.

An entire side of the vast audience inside MetLife Stadium couldn't see the ring at all due to the blinding yellow light that p*ssed down upon them. This baffling decision by the lighting/production crew killed the match for approx 30% of the crowd. It was so terrible that Randy and AJ apologised to those who couldn't see on social media afterwards.

That was a bit of a Homer Simpson "D'oh" moment from WWE. Their lighting rig is there to enhance the presentation, not destroy it for those who have maybe paid thousands for floor seats.

6. Dolph Ziggler Vs. Seth Rollins

Where: WWE Extreme Rules 2018

Advertisement

The Match: Known workhorses Seth Rollins and Dolph Ziggler torched the competition by weaving a captivating 30-minute 'Iron Man' match for the Intercontinental Title. They headlined the pay-per-view, were clearly proud of their efforts and put on quite the show.

Why It Sucked: A ton of folks camped out inside Pittsburgh's PPG Paints Arena decided to be rebellious for absolutely no reason. They sabotaged Rollins and Ziggler by counting down from 10 before every minute had elapsed, then honking like the classic Royal Rumble horn.

They were popping themselves, but visibly irking the wrestlers and some who did want to invest in the match. The atmosphere was uneasy, and things only worsened when WWE (looking to stop the defiance) removed the clock from the screen.

That got booed and didn't seem to work either. Both Seth and Dolph also seemed rather rattled by the response, which ruined the bout's flow a little.

5. The Undertaker Vs. Mankind

Where: WWF SummerSlam 1996

Advertisement

The Match: New 'Taker foe Mick Foley grabbed the wrestling world by its balls by convincingly portraying the lunatic nature of his Mankind gimmick. The dusty 'Boiler Room' showing he had with The Undertaker at SummerSlam '96 went down in history as one of the most rugged brawls fans had ever witnessed.

Why It Sucked: Prep for another rant about ancient technology.

SummerSlam's 'Boiler Room' rammy was another match that had a so-so 90-10% split between pre-taped backstage work and live action. Much of Mankind and 'Taker's fight was shown on those creaking old screens the WWF were rocking in the mid-90s, and that didn't do much for the live crowd.

They couldn't really feel the same kind of visceral intensity that fans at home could, so much of the match was lost on them. Bruce Prichard also said (via his pod) that the company tried some new stuff by wheeling out more monitors to ringside, but that still didn't appease the near-17,000 in attendance.

4. Seth Rollins Vs. Finn Bálor

Where: WWE SummerSlam 2016

Advertisement

The Match: Finn Bálor's big night was noteworthy for three things. Firstly, he and Seth Rollins worked well together in the main event. Second, Bálor won the new Universal Title, but only got to hold it for around 24 hours before injury robbed him of a proper reign. He had to vacate the thing on Raw the next night.

Why It Sucked: Thirdly, fans at SummerSlam scoffed at WWE's new red 'World Title' belt. There was a gasp when Stephanie McMahon and Mick Foley unveiled the thing shortly before Bálor and Rollins went to war for it, and that's all people in Brooklyn's Barclays Center could focus on for the rest of the show.

Chants like, "That looks stupid" sullied an otherwise-fine headliner. In retrospect, it was a bit of an own goal to show off the divisive title pre-match. Thankfully, fans watching at home didn't get nearly as much of the title-hating atmos as those who were there live.

3. The Original WarGames

Where: NWA Great American Bash 1987

Advertisement

The Match: The Road Warriors, Paul Ellering, Dusty Rhodes and Nikita Koloff vs. The Four Horsemen inside a double steel cage structure was the selling point for the NWA's 1987 Great American Bash tour. Thus, WarGames was born, and it proved to be one of wrestling's most timeless gimmicks.

Everyone worked hard to make it special.

Why It Sucked: Unlike fans watching on closed circuit (a precursor and occasional alternative to pay-per-view), fans live in Atlanta would've had a tough time following everything that was happening. Put it this way: NWA attendees had no less than 10 wrestlers to keep an eye on across multiple rings.

Being at ringside, for example, would've given one a sore neck; following WarGames might've been more like watching a tennis match than a wrestling bout. Those in the arena didn't have the luxury of carefully-chosen camera angles to make sure they didn't miss any big spots or moments either.

It was surely messy.

2. Kurt Angle Vs. Chris Benoit

Where: WWF Backlash 2001

Advertisement

The Match: WrestleMania X-Seven enemies Kurt Angle and Chris Benoit reconvened for another winner at Backlash. Technical wrestling enthusiasts licked their lips at the prospect of a guaranteed 30 minutes of back and forth submission superbness in this 'Ultimate Submission'-meets-'Iron Man' battle.

Why It Sucked: Nobody in the stands had any clue how much time was left in the match or what the score was. Incredibly, the WWF failed to put a clock or scoreboard on the big tron in the arena, and that meant this one was tough for fans to follow.

It also eliminated any chance of tension when Angle, who was ahead on the scoreboard, stalled to try and see out remaining time. Kurt has spoken about this match in-depth on his podcast, and even he thinks it was a blunder not to clue people in with the same timer and scorecard that fans watching at home got on their screens.

Oops.

1. Shawn Michaels Vs. Bret Hart

Where: WWF WrestleMania XII

Advertisement

The Match: Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels considered this the chance to create their own magnum opus that'd go down in the annals of time as a bonafide classic. Their 60-minute 'Iron Man' encounter was a slow-burning epic that didn't include one decision during the first hour - it went to overtime instead.

That's where Shawn's "boyhood dream" came true when he bagged the WWF Title.

Why It Sucked: Fans in Anaheim were either burned out by earlier action on the pay-per-view or just felt like 60 minutes was too long to give a sh*t. By halfway, most seemed to click that Bret and Shawn were going to wrestle the entire hour without one pinfall or submission on the board.

Some fans left before the 60 minutes had elapsed too. Ample rest-holds and the deliberate nature of the match didn't do it for those who wanted a 20-25 minute blockbuster. People fleeing the building before the finish proves that.

It couldn't have helped that fans at ringside didn't have the benefit of commentary to help tell the story.

What other great TV matches sucked for fans who were there live? For more wrestling, check out 19 Things You Probably Missed From WWE Raw (May 3) and 10 Wrestling Gimmicks That Only Lasted ONE Segment!

Advertisement