10 Wrestling Gimmicks That Only Lasted ONE Segment

Blink and you'll miss it gimmicks from the archives that WWE quickly gave up on.

Doink The Clown Doppelgänger WrestleMania IX
WWE

"Maximise your minutes" has become a standard WWE-ism. Listen to any Bruce Prichard or Jim Ross podcast and you'll likely hear them echo the mantra every so often when discussing one-time federation pet projects or other short-lived stars. Making the most of time, no matter how short, is important to McMahon.

The men and women on this list had no choice but to try and make it work.

They only had one segment to convince the boss that they were worth TV time going forward. Apparently, none of them were, because WWE scrapped all plans to use these characters again - admittedly, a few get a pass. They were deliberately deployed as one-offs that wouldn't have worked as repeat performers again anyway.

There's also a ton of variety here. WWE presented bizarre, afro-sporting alter egos, lame magicians, even crappier men of the cloth, drug dealing miscreants, 'Deadman'-chasing Brits and more. They've also handed deities a company tryout, and resisted the urge to buddy up one of the most cherished cult gimmicks of all time with a surprise partner.

Say hello to this collection of misfits and forgotten faces.

10. Rufus “Pancake” Patterson

Titus O'Neil Darren Young Pancake Patterson
WWE.com

Might as well start off hot.

Five years before creating his own 'Slip N' Slide' at the 2018 Greatest Royal Rumble, Titus O'Neil introduced the world to Rufus "Pancake" Patterson. There, on the 18 March 2013 episode of Raw, he and partner Darren Young asked why John Cena was getting all of WWE's merch money instead of them.

Titus, as the goofy Patterson, sported an afro wig and wore some overalls for the night. WWE barely tried to give this alter ego any context whatsoever - the announcers actually acted like O'Neil had gone off-script to deliver this Cena-bashing promo. It was as weird a segment as it sounds, and it was "Pancake's" only one.

Patterson didn't return for a second go-around the next week, and has never been referenced again on television. Christ knows what Titus and WWE were actually going for here. The Prime Time Players didn't need this bizarre offshoot.


9. Phantasio

Phantasio WWE
WWE.com

You've got to give it up for Gorilla Monsoon. The longtime federation favourite did his able best to make Phantasio look like anything but a duff magician on the 28 June 1995 edition of Wrestling Challenge. Sadly for ol' "banana breath" (Bobby Heenan's words), fans tuning into the syndicated show could see that the gimmick was rotten.

Oh. So. Rotten.

There's a hilarious side note to Phantasio's story too; Bruce Prichard once revealed on his pod that the debuting trickster actually set fire to the backstage area whilst trying out some of his stunts. That didn't endear 'Tasio to the WWF crew, and his performance did nothing to offset the skepticism either.

The promotion's brand new illusionist was never seen again after this Challenge win over Tony DeVito (later of 'Da Baldies' fame in ECW). All presumable plans to call him up to Raw for some more magic were promptly cancelled.


8. Key

Key Vic Grimes
WWE

Technically, this is cheating.

Vic Grimes' short-lived drug dealing character did work a match on the 14 August 1999 episode of Shotgun, but...who was really watching Shotgun Saturday Night in '99? Seriously, it was perhaps the least-essential wrestling show of the era by that point, and that includes those dreadful Worldwide re-runs WCW ran on Channel 5 in the UK.

If you've spotted a digression, don't be surprised - Key didn't do much in the WWF. He showed up on the 26 July edition of Raw to confront The Godfather (a drug dealer feuding with a pimp, folks), and that was pretty much that. Somebody backstage must've pointed out that dressing a guy like he was covered in cocaine probably wasn't for the best.

Grimes' gimmick was shelved, Key was never seen again on flagship programming, and Grimes waltzed off to ECW. There, oddly, he became part of 'Da Baldies' with Phantasio victim Tony DeVito. Isn't it wonderful when things (kinda) work out well?


7. Everyone Charlie Haas Impersonated

Charlie Haas Jbl
WWE.com

Charlie Haas never doubled down on any of his fun impersonations between 2008-2009. That's a bit of a shame, because parodies of Steve Austin, JBL, The Great Khali, Carlito, Hulk Hogan, John Cena, Mr. Perfect, Jim Ross, Bret Hart, The Undertaker, Jimmy Snuka, Ric Flair and others were popular with fans.

Haas showed some serious personality here.

Typically, it did next-to-nothing for his WWE career. The company drafted Charlie to SmackDown in '09, and then proceeded to do bugger all with him. Turning him heel, and thus spurning the lure of more impressions was a mistake that hurt Haas' chances of remaining over.

Still, at least he and fans can look back on riotous one-offs like "Charlito", "CHL" and "Haas Hogan" with a smile. This, other than a run alongside Shelton Benjamin as Kurt Angle's amateur wrestling acolytes, was the highlight of Charlie's twin stints in the promotion.


6. The “Showster”

Showster Big Show
WWE

More impersonations? OK then.

The WWF clearly didn't know what to do with Big Show by mid-2000. He'd been a menacing heel, they'd tried him as WWF Champ, and they'd even stuck him with The Undertaker to try and give the giant some rub. Nothing seemed to work, so naturally he started ripping the p*ss out of old pal Hulk Hogan for the lolz.

At Backlash that year, Hogan's old WCW enemy romped out as "The Showster" to wild cheers from the Washington masses. His opponent, Kurt Angle, did everything in his power to fend off the laughs, and the pair worked a short squash bout that actually worked well to break up the pay-per-view card's more serious bouts.

After that, Show went on to team with Rikishi as "Showkishi" on several shows, but his Hulk rib was never spotted again; at least, Paul Wight never dressed up like Hogan. He did, however, impersonate his voice once or twice in coming years.


5. “God”

Vince McMahon God
WWE

Ahem.

Vince McMahon has never been the kind of promoter who shies away from controversy. In fact, he subscribes to that old Eric Bischoff quote (which was also the title of Bisch's book): "Controversy Creates Cash". This was never more true than at Backlash 2006.

Six years on from tarting Big Show up like Hulk Hogan, Vince decided that he should annoy the living sh*te out of the religious community too. WWE promoted a tag bout pitting Vince and Shane McMahon vs. Shawn Michaels and "God". Yes, as in the deity Christians believe created the entire universe.

Is it really any real shocker that people were miffed?

"God" turned out to be a spotlight that "walked" down the ramp live on pay-per-view and gobbled up box office dollars like some cruel rib on the audience. This was supposed to lampoon Shawn's born again Christianity, but it just wasted everybody else's time.


4. Emmalina

emmalina debuts
WWE.com

Yes, Emmalina did receive numerous vignettes in late-2016 into early-2017. However, the character only made one in-person appearance on Raw, and it's totally worth talking about. She belongs here, basically, if only because WWE screwed the pooch big time with their lack of concrete planning.

Emmalina was a star reborn. She was supposed to be a vast improvement on the "plain old Emma", and finally debuted (following months of false starts) on the 13 February 2017 edition of WWE's Monday night flagship. Then, Emmalina told the world that she was reverting back to her old self, and teased the "makeover" fans had(n't) been waiting for.

That was another empty promise. Emmalina, who had been promoted heavily for months, lasted a grand total of around two TV minutes before ditching the glam and going back to her old ways. What was that about WWE wasting everybody's time?


3. Friar Ferguson

Friar Ferguson
WWE.com

You know you're f*cked when Vinnie Mac's idea of an upgrade is to present you as a slovenly glutton who revels in his own disgusting nature. That was the fate of one Mike Shaw back in 1993 - he debuted as the "Mad Monk" Friar Ferguson on the 12 April Raw, then quickly changed to Bastion Booger.

Bastion Booger.

It's worth repeating something here. The WWF believed that naming someone after snot was preferable to their original gimmick. That's how much of a flop Shaw's early man of the cloth persona was. He got one televised squash match win over jobber Chris Duffy before McMahon changed his mind on the jovial Friar.

Ferguson ditched the monk robes, shaved his head, squeezed into a singlet that Hornswoggle would've struggled with, and off he went. Booger was born, Friar was yesterday's news and the company never name-dropped their religious brother again.

These may be the worst back-to-back gimmicks in wrestling history.


2. Hade Vansen

Hade Vansen WWE
WWE.com

Friar Ferguson was overt, cartoonish religion-into-wrestling, but this was somewhat darker and more obscure. In fact, "obscure" is the perfect word to describe it. Hade Vansen's one-off promo on the 12 December 2008 SmackDown was lost to the sands of time almost immediately.

He was never heard from again after firing in this creepy, Undertaker-baiting speech.

Vansen, a star of the UK indy scene in the early-to-mid-2000s, showed poise and promise as a talker, so it's a bit of a shame that WWE cancelled any follow-up. Maybe they didn't think Hade had the physical stature to tear down 'Taker, or maybe Vince just didn't dig what he saw from this promo.

Why air it at all then?

Also, nothing screams "festive period" like some sinister dude promising to annihilate company legends, does it? Seriously though, who knows what would've happened had McMahon stuck to his guns and given Vansen a proper push.


1. Doppelgänger Doink The Clown

Doink The Clown WrestleMania 9
WWE.com

Say hi to your new favourite tag-team that never was.

Doink The Clown was already well on his way to becoming a cult favourite by the time he wrestled flopping babyface Crush at WrestleMania IX. Fans loved the ominous presence of Matt Borne under the greasepaints, and they popped huge for this doppelgänger fun in the Nevada sun.

Steve Keirn, who'd go on to assume the gimmick on house shows once Borne checked out, was drafted in to play Doink #2 for the night. The ex-Skinner worked a memorable mirror image skit with the original clown after helping him win. Meanwhile, fans in attendance lapped it all up.

Bruce Prichard was once asked if the WWF ever considered making these double Doinks a full-time tag. He suggested that it was briefly considered, but never seriously. That's a bit of a missed opportunity, although Borne did leave the company several months later.

What other wrestling gimmicks only lasted one segment? For more WWE, check out 18 Things You Probably Missed From WWE Raw (April 26) and 10 Forgotten WWE Cameos From Major Stars Before They Were Famous!


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.