Remember pay-per-views? Those monthly wrestling events that you purchased before you got your subscription to the WWE Network? Whilst WWE has probably done the right thing by switching to a streaming/subscription service, PPV used to be a big earner for the company. That was before PPV buy-rates began severely decreasing in number and WWE hit the Network-shaped panic button. One of the criticism levelled against WWE these days is that they're stuck on autopilot because they know that, with the Network, people have essentially pre-paid for the next monthly spectacular. Back when the company relied on the PPV model to make money they actually had to try and convince punters to part with their hard-earned cash every single month for a series of fresh matches or big rematches. The success or failure of an event would be judged based on how many buys it did and the number of buys it did were attributed to the strength of the main event, usually. So WWE had a very real incentive to give their public a main event worth paying for. 2000 to 2010 boasts many epic, even classic PPV main event matches that people continue to champion. But during that time there were also some pretty awesome matches that have fallen under the radar. Do yourself a favour: fire up the WWE Network and remind yourself of these criminally underrated PPV main events from the 2000s.
10. Eddie Guerrero Vs. JBL Vs. Booker T Vs. The Undertaker - Armageddon 2004
JBL was an unlikely choice for WWE Champion. WWE had tried to elevate him to the main event in 2002 on Raw but abandoned the idea after a few weeks. It was clearly not working. Undeterred, WWE decided to try again in 2004 on Smackdown to cover the absence of Kurt Angle and the departure of Brock Lesnar. JBL shockingly relieved Eddie Guerrero of the championship at the Great American Bash in a bullrope match. 'Latino Heat' had cracked under the pressure of carrying the brand and was relieve to let go of the belt. For the rest of 2004 JBL feuded with The Undertaker and Booker T, inevitably retaining the title on screwy finishes. So at Armageddon 2004 Smackdown GM Teddy Long put Bradshaw in a fatal four way against the three men he had been screwing over for half the year. The match was very good. Four ways are hard to put together at the best of times but they did an admirable job here. The Eddie versus 'Taker exchanges were the best parts of the match (and the PPV for that matter). On the evidence of this match, it's a real shame that WWE didn't run with an Eddie/Undertaker programme in either 04 or 05. That would have been special.
9. Kurt Angle Vs. Brock Lesnar Vs. The Big Show - Vengeance 2003
The first (U.S.) Smackdown only pay-per-view was a doozy and demonstrated just how far ahead of Raw they were at the time. The event out-performed Raw's Bad Blood from the month before in the ring and at the box-office, generating 322,000 buys to the Raw shows 285,000. The card had a little bit of something for everyone. It started with a wrestling clinic between Eddie Guerrero and Chris Benoit in the United States Championship tournament final, had a wacky APA bar-room-brawl, a lost classic tag match between Billy Kidman and Rey Mysterio and The World's Greatest Tag Team and a couple of McMahon gimmick matches to boot (Sable versus Steph and Vince versus Zach Gowen). The event was capped off by a superb but seldom-championed triple threat match between Kurt Angle, Brock Lesnar and The Big Show. The match marked the restart of the Angle/Lesnar feud. Angle had been out for four months with a neck injury while Lesnar feuded with Show and Cena. Adding Show to the match made for an interesting dynamic. Angle and Lesnar did their usual water-right suplex based stuff while show brought his power game. Watching this reminds you just how good Lesnar, Angle and Smackdown was in 2003. Wonderful.
8. John Cena Vs. Bobby Lashley - Great American Bash 2007
If you want an example of two men who were hated by the IWC in the 2000s look no further than Bobby Lashley and John Cena. Both had large physiques and were perceived as being given preferential treatment and big pushes because of that and in spite of a perceived lack of 'wrestling ability'. Which was nonsense, of course. Cena had been involved in countless great matches since 2003 and Lashley had shown that he could deliver the goods in 2006 while working with the likes of Booker T and Finlay on Smackdown. The question was: would they be able to have a decent main event together at the 2007 Great American Bash? The answer was 'yes'. Lashley and Cena, whom some believed could only be carried by superior workers, had a great 1980s style power match. Both men deserve extra credit because they were both babyfaces going in (although the male contingent of the fan base treated both like heels) and didn't have that much of a storyline to work with. Unfortunately for Lashley, he suffered a serious injury soon after this and then left the WWE in early 2008. Had he stayed healthy and continued to deliver in main events like this, who knows where Lashley would be now?
7. Randy Orton Vs. Ric Flair - Cage Match (Taboo Tuesday 2004)
Taboo Tuesday was certainly a novel concept. Not only did it take place on Tuesday and not the traditional Sunday night, but it was also the first interactive WWE PPV. Fans could vote for match stipulations, opponents and so forth. The event also saw a rare pay-per-view main event from 'The Nature Boy', Ric Flair. Flair began a mini feud with Orton after Orton's ill-suited face turn in September 2004. He cost Orton a shot at Triple H's World Heavyweight Championship and intimated that, until he could beat him, Orton couldn't consider himself a true 'legend killer'. Fans had the choice of voting for either a falls count anywhere, submission or steel cage match. They chose a cage match (like there was ever any doubt), a Flair speciality form the NWA days. He paid homage to the NWA days through the match and both men bled. It was a great old-school type match and did a lot of rebuild Orton after the Triple H series the month before. After the match both competitors shared a handshake, which many assumed would lead to a Flair face turn (it didn't). Flair would better himself a year later in a cage match with Triple H at the 2005 incarnation of Taboo Tuesday. That match should have really went on last, too.
6. Booker T Vs. Bobby Lashley Vs. Batista Vs. Finlay - No Mercy 2006
Smackdown produced another cracker at No Mercy 2006. The event had a bunch of great matches, including Chris Benoit's hard-hitting war with William Regal (Benoit's return after a four month long sabbatical) and a couple of really fun matches on the undercard. The main event pitted the ridiculously entertaining World Heavyweight Champion King Booker against his sometimes ally Finlay, real-life opponent Batista and the promising-but-still-green Lashley. It was an intriguing match, one that could have either completely fallen apart or been great. Thankfully, it was the latter. The four men had excelled in different combinations of singles and tag matches the entire year and showed that they could produce when put together in a pay-per-view main event. Finlay carried the action as the wild card of the match and it was nice to see a fresh face in the top-liner for a change. The home stretch, with everyone hitting their finishers amid a flurry of close near-falls, is excellent.
5. Brock Lesnar Vs. The Big Show - Stretcher Match (Judgement Day 2003)
With Kurt Angle on the sidelines with a serious neck injury, new Champion Lesnar was left with slim pickings as far as talent to work with on top. WWE was in a pretty sorry state in spring 2003. Judgement Day alone 'treated' fans to matches like Mr. America versus Roddy Piper and a knackered Triple H versus an equally knackered Kevin Nash. The show, minus a pretty awesome Eddie Guerrero and Tajiri versus Team Angle ladder match, had been a washout. It was up to Lesnar and Show to put on an entertaining finale and attempt to save the show. With no real history of great stretcher matches, fans didn't quite know what to expect. The two had a very inventive, hard-hitting match. Brock is such a physical specimen and it's never not fun watching him throw men the size of Show around at will. Show, to his credit, took some pretty hefty bumps, matching Lesnar every step of the way in that department. The finish was a memorable one: Lesnar disappeared towards the end of the match, allowing Rey Mysterio (who Show had injured at Backlash) a chance to come in an get revenge. Show got the upper hand on Rey when Lesnar came back into the arena driving a forklift truck. It was whacky Attitude Era, erm, era shenanigans at their finest. Lesnar used the forklift as a home-made stretcher to wheel Show out of the arena. You don't see finishes like that every day.
4. Shawn Michaels & John Cena Vs. The Undertaker & Batista - No Way Out 2007
Considering who's involved in this one, it's very surprising that it's barely mentioned. Why is that? Is it because it took place on an overall forgettable show? Or because the four contestants had better matches the next month at WrestleMania? Were fans disappointed in the match? They shouldn't have been, because it was great. It also had built-in intrigue because it had the two WrestleMania World Championship matches teaming up. The question was not if Cena and Michaels or Batista and Undertaker would turn on each other, but when. The match was like watching a greatest hits tape of four of the biggest superstars in the history of the WWE. They got plenty of time and there were several interesting match-ups to be had. It wasn't very often that fans were treated to Michaels versus Batista, Undertaker versus Cena and Undertaker versus Michaels back then and the people inside the arena lapped it up. Leading up to the show and throughout the match it was teased that it was likely going to be Shawn turning on WWE Champion Cena but they swerved us and had Batista turn on The Undertaker instead. It was an intriguing ending to a very good match. Come on, it's Batista, Cena, Michaels and The Undertaker. How could you go wrong?
3. Eddie Guerrero Vs. Batista - No Mercy 2005
Not many people in the Smackdown locker room liked Batista when he jumped there from Raw in the summer of 2005. 'The Animal' had offended pretty much everyone with comments he had made to UK newspaper The Sun earlier in the year where he accused them of being lazy and having no passion. That was a mistake on Big Dave's part and not a smart thing to do with a locker room full of grizzled veterans like Hardcore Holly, Booker T and JBL. One of those grizzled veterans, Eddie Guerrero, sympathised with Batista and lent him his support and love when he was struggling to make friends and draw houses. Eddie'd had a strange 2005. He was as good as he'd ever been in his feud with Rey Mysterio but his body was falling apart at an alarming rate. Prior to his death, Eddie did not have a good night's sleep for two weeks because of the constant pain in his hips, back and joints. But, as beat down as Eddie was, he was still a hell of a performer and knew how to put on a pay-per-view caliber main event. Eddie squared off with Batista in the last match at No Mercy (on his 38th Birthday). Despite the size difference and dodgy 'is he a good guy or is he a bad guy?' story line, the two had a great, often overlooked match. A superstar worker until the end, Eddie fought through the pain and gave his all for the fans.
2. The Elimination Chamber - SummerSlam 2003
The second Elimination Chamber match ever is not fondly remembered for the simple fact that Triple H retained his World Heavyweight Championship in it. Fans wanted Goldberg, who had a rough start to life in WWE but recovered over the summer, to take the gold instead. It was an admittedly deflating and nonsensical finish. Triple H was going into the match with a banged-up body and was limited as to what he could do. Triple H felt that when Goldberg won the belt it should be after a chase and a long, twenty minute match, which isn't exactly Goldberg's speciality. You know what is Goldberg's speciality? Smashing through people with high-octane power moves in record time. And that's exactly what he did in the Chamber. After some decent action between Randy Orton, Shawn Michael and Chris Jericho (and, to a lesser extent, Kevin Nash) Goldberg came in and tore through everyone as the fans went ballistic. 'Da Man' spearing 'Y2J' through one of the plexiglass pods as a particular highlight. In the end it came down to Triple H and Goldberg. What happened next was gob-smackingly poor from WWE but that doesn't take away from the quality of the match. An underrated entry in the Elimination Chamber canon.
1. The Rock Vs. Kurt Angle Vs. The Undertaker - Vengeance 2002
As good as the Big Show versus Brock Lesnar versus Kurt Angle match was at Vengeance 2003, it paled in comparison to the show closer at the previous year's event featuring Angle (him again), The Rock and The Undertaker. The WWE hadn't produced a great pay-per-view main event for months. The Undertaker was responsible for one of those, having an unbelievably poor match with Hulk Hogan at Judgement Day. Thankfully, at Vengeance, 'Taker, Rock and Angle grafted and produced a phenomenal, show-saving match. Angle (wearing an awesome red, white and blue camouflage singlet) carried the action. It beggars belief just how smooth Angle was. The Undertaker brought the big moves and The Rock brougth...well, he's The Rock. You know what he brings. The match was expertly laid-out and allowed for all three men to shine equally. The sequence at the end, with everyone hitting their finishers, was top class. Catch this one at your earliest convenience. It really is as good as you would imagine.