10 Times WWE Couldn't Repeat Success

Rey's successor was so naff he needed his own.

By Benjamin Richardson /

There are a great many idioms which don't make a whole lot of sense when you consider them for a few minutes - or even a few seconds, for that matter - but there's one as true as it is trite which goes: "you can never go home again".

Advertisement

This is not a literal comment on, say, a global health crisis restricting movement to the family home, nor a cautionary tale about a lost bus schedule, but a maxim which warns that the past is the past, and attempts to relive it will leave you feeling bereft.

It is, as you may already be acutely aware, not a phrase by which WWE lives. The company has spent the best part of two decades almost purposefully trying not to make new stars, to the point where it relies on selling nostalgia to a dangerous, unsustainable degree. The passage of time makes the past a better place in most of our memories; WWE continually remind their fans that the promotion's best days are behind them.

There's obviously a time limit on wheeling out the legends though, either through disinterest, infirmity, or death. So they do the next best thing: try to recreate the good times, with inferior ingredients.

It rarely works. Because you can never go Hogan again.

10. The Undertaker

I think we can say with some assurance that, a year after debuting and with a catalogue of horrors eclipsing the Argos Halloween range, Bray Wyatt's Fiend is not the natural successor to The Undertaker (or at least, not a good one).

Advertisement

Sure, there's been the odd moment of creative sparkle, but the suggestion the stripey-trousered demon will prove an enduring, timeless gimmick whose appeal transcends generations for the next thirty years is clearly so far from the mark that mark's feeling lonely. Indeed, it's patently clear that The Phenom is simply irreplaceable - which explains why he's been annually trundled out despite being held together with sticky tape for the best part of the last decade.

That hasn't stopped WWE trying though, and The Fiend isn't their first attempt. Back in 2004, Kevin Fertig was being measured for The Undertaker's duster, as an all-white alternative 'Face of Fear' before even Husky Harris was a blip on Bray's radar. The elevator pitch proposed a sort of occult pope, the negative inverse of 'Taker very much in the mould of Hakushi. As with the 'White Angel', the seemingly inevitable Undertaker feud never materialised. Jinsei Shinzaki had been held back by the culture of the company; Fertig on the other hand, was simply crap. By comparison, The Fiend is the Fienom.

9. The 'New' Anything

There's something of a marketing truism, infamously canonised by the Coca-Cola company's disastrous failed experiment of 1985, that brandishing any product with the label 'new' simply won't work.

Advertisement

Though it's logical to assume that if people once loved something, then surely they'll also love a fresh version of it, this reasoning ignores the fact that a 'new' anything practically invites comparisons to the older, and almost certainly better original. Indeed, conspiracists maintain that the New Coke was an elaborate (and expensive) scheme by Coca-Cola to re-establish thirst for their legacy product in the face of stringent competition from Pepsi (it wasn't).

Perhaps that was the thinking behind WWE's spate of 'new' versions of classic tag-teams throughout the '90s, which saw dreadful revivals of The Blackjacks, The Midnight Express and The Rockers (albeit with the decidedly old Marty Jannetty). Except there was precisely zero chance of the likes of Lanza and Eaton showing up, nor of Shawn Michaels descending back to the prelims. Like New Coke, WWE fans had no taste for these teams, nor the 'New' Dream Team, New Foundation or LOD 2000 for that matter. What's that saying about things often imitated?

8. The Boneyard Match

With a thirty year tenure - and a high-profile, Network-selling four part documentary - yearning for the perfect conclusion, The Undertaker hand-picked the ideal opponent for his WrestleMania 35 swansong. Specifically, one who wouldn't drop him directly on his bonce.

Advertisement

'Taker's brain was assured, but then the world itself turned completely on its head. When it became clear the Showcase of Immortals would be no place for mortals, plans were hastily changed for the Deadman's valediction: this would no longer be a wrestling match played before silence, but a 'Boneyard Match' - whatever that was.

Turned out it was a supremely slick piece of wrestling cinema, a thoroughly entertaining send-off which burnished Undertaker's legacy better than a proper match ever could. Having happened upon a creative solution to the crowdless era's biggest problem - and emboldened by positive feedback rarely reserved for their shows these days - WWE channeled Yngwie Malmsteen by asking: "how can less be more?"

Since 'Mania, cinematic matches have morphed from a rarely seen curio to a hit-or-miss monthly fixture. Though they haven't been universally terrible, not a single one has matched the quality of the Boneyard's literal barnstormer. It's a classic case of diminishing returns.

7. Austin Vs. McMahon

Austin vs. McMahon might be one of the greatest feuds in the history of professional wrestling, and one which hurtled WWE into its second Golden Era - arguably, its greatest ever period of relevance - but the company has been haunted by its shadow ever since.

Advertisement

It's not just the concept of an evil authority figure illogically holding back the promotion's most obviously popular star which has festered over the product for the past 22 years, but the very same actors. Since Austin shook hands with the devil himself, putting an end to that particular cash cow, McMahon and his extended clan have continued to wage war on whichever superstar riding a groundswell of support threatens to earn his company money.

The only time 'authority vs. unfashionable babyface' has came close to working again was Daniel Bryan's run in 2014 - a storyline which necessitated real life denseness towards his marketability to prosper. Nothing was taken from this: Roman Reigns, a noted company pick, was swiftly placed in the exact same role shortly after. No prizes for guessing how much sympathy that gained him.

6. Hulk Hogan

Before Vince McMahon stumbled into his second major success - that is to say, himself - he was ardently faithful to his original money-spinning method, that of the muscle-bound Real American hero. Hulk Hogan, in other words.

Advertisement

The first time McMahon failed to repeat the Hulkster's glory years was with Hulk Hogan himself. By 1993, Hogan's tan had been tarnished by the steroid scandal, and what's more a maturing crowd had started to reject the simplistic worldview of righteous good vs. absolute (nearly always foreign) evil. To say the Immortal One's WrestleMania IX gazumping of latest international bogeyman Yokozuna was unpopular outside a group of clueless Las Vegas day trippers would be an understatement.

By summer, he was gone, and McMahon was left with two 24 inch gaps to fill. Failing to recognise his own failing popularity was one of the reasons Hogan had shrewdly engineered his exit, a grasping McMahon sought to directly replace him. With one huge bodyslam aboard a boat, a Narcissist became a nationalist, as Lex Luger was sent on the ultimate coach trip across America to prove his babyface bona fides.

It didn't work. WWE fans already had their next hero, and ironically, he was a Canadian: Bret Hart. Luger's push was hardly helped by McMahon, despite the initial zeal, only putting one foot in the water with a useless SummerSlam '93 countout victory over big Yoko. Come WrestleMania X, the Lex Express had already broken down, and the Hitman was installed as the leader of the New Generation.

5. John Cena

If anyone actually has repeated the success of Hulk Hogan - in spirit and style, if not necessarily statistics - then it's John Cena.

Advertisement

Like Luger, Cena was never originally ordained a babyface hero, though his path to becoming one was the direct inverse. Rather than being handpicked through aesthetic admiration, Cena was staring down a listless WWE career before an off-the-cuff rap found him a fandom. The rest, as lazy journalists tired of repeating the same stories say, is history.

Away from the company bean counters, the defining characteristic of John's eternal run on top wasn't his t-shirt sales but his absolutely dislodgeable hegemony. Seemingly, Cena was in the tool shed for the shovel as much as Triple H before him. So by 2013 - having denied CM Punk his apparently rightful WrestleMania main event for a needless re-run - most over the age of 18 were desperate for change at the top.

A New Face was chosen to run the Place in 2015. With one eye on Hollywood, Cena was finally winding down, having been thoroughly mauled by Brock Lesnar as a visual conclusion to his arc as top dog. A new, bigger dog was being groomed: Roman Reigns.

At the previous year's Royal Rumble, he'd been cheered as the man - any man - to take Batista's pre-ordained place at WrestleMania XXX. Come 2015, the cat - or the dog - had skipped the bag. Reigns was WWE's new Golden Boy, and in an instant, he was just John Cena 2.0. His popularity ended right there.

4. The Rock Vs. Cena

'Twice in a Lifetime' is probably the most literal example of WWE trying to directly replicate success, a year on from their highest grossing pay-per-view of all time.

Advertisement

Fundamentally, it missed the point of why WrestleMania XXVIII had drawn such a huge volume of paying customers - even though it was baked into the sales pitch. The 'Once in a Lifetime' clash between The Rock and John Cena promised precisely that, and punters gladly ponied up to avoid missing out. Would they have been quite so eager to buy the show had WWE not made abundantly clear that this was, absolutely definitely, the only time these two icons of the industry would meet, having built the contest up since the previous April?

It's impossible to say, but what is certain is that interest in the rematch was notably cooler. Although 'Mania 29 set a live gate record - helped by 80,000 fans who would have flocked to the wrestling institution regardless - it trailed 2013's buys by nearly quarter of a million. Less a case of 'U Can't C Me', and more 'U Already Saw Me'.

3. Rey Mysterio

When WWE eventually optioned on ex-WCW man Rey Mysterio, over a full year after buying out the defunct company, they reasoned there'd been enough distance to reverse the abysmal decision of his former employees to de-mask and de-monetise the lucha legend.

Advertisement

Turning the clock back on Mysterio's Lucha de Apuestas record might have been highly non-traditional, but it proved extremely profitable. Rey had stood out from a crowd of similarly-styled cruiserweights in WCW, but their lack of marketing savvy would never see him a star where the big boys played.

Ordinarily, playing with the big boys would have undermined Rey just as much in his new home. Though the question of his size inevitably became part of his arc, he was simply too over to deny.

Unfortunately, the style which made him such a star came with a consequence. Injuries began to mount up on a body bulked up for Stamford success, and it became clear King Mystery would one day need a successor. The first attempt came in the shape of masked man Mistico, rechristened 'Sin Cara'. The man with no face proved to equally have no hope, repeatedly botching moves before failing a Wellness Test.

In fact, such a washout was Mysterio II that he needed his own. The former Hunico took up the mask after Mistico was fired, springboarding into a seven year stint of no consequence. Along the way, he was joined by Kallisto - another clear Mysterio expy - who, talent notwithstanding, simply could not inspire like the original.

Eventually, WWE did happen upon a perfect replacement for Rey Mysterio - and it was a returning Rey Mysterio himself.

2. The NWO

Vince McMahon should have known from WCW's repeated attempts to reverse their fortunes by bringing back the boys in white and black that, by 2002 - some seven years after their inception - the nWo were definitely no longer '4 life'.

Advertisement

Perhaps it was a not unjust confidence he could do a better job of a revival than previous nWo necromancers Bischoff and Russo that led to the gang's return ahead of No Way Out. Or maybe, given how things transpired, it was a desire to present WCW's biggest success story as a bust - or, say, a poison that could sink an entire promotion.

In any event, they had a much better chance pared back to the essentials, comprising just the original trio and none of the bloat which had ultimately diluted the group's strength. And for the first few months at least, it worked, culminating with the iconic showdown between The Rock and Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania X8.

Only, Hogan had masterfully timed his return just in time to catch the nostalgia train, and WWE were left with little choice but to turn him after the Canadian crowd welcomed him back to their hearts. Sans leader, the nWo began to fall apart in typical fashion over the following months. Hall requested his release to combat personal issues, and Nash once more found himself sidelined through injury. Come summer, the group took on an unrecognisable form, featuring Shawn Michaels and The Big Show amongst its ranks. The faction was disbanded shortly after, and besides the odd nostalgic cameo, WWE wisely kept the black and white shirts in the cupboard from then on.

1. WWECW

WWE actually did manage to recreate the success of ECW. It's just - as per the pay-per-view's name - it lasted for just One Night.

Advertisement

Technically, they caught the barbed bolts of ECW's late-'90s lightning in the unlikeliest of bottles twice. 2005 and 2006's ephemeral extreme revivals understood and renewed the raucousness of Paul Heyman's defunct pioneer perfectly, suffusing them with modern interlopers which only added to the 'us-against-them' spirit of the hardcore original.

Crucially, the royal 'they' of the previous paragraph was Paul Heyman himself. Helmed by their creator and proprietor, the two specials were an overwhelming, surprising success - to the extent that a permanent comeback on weekly TV became a reality.

And that's when the good times ended. ECW was never birthed to become a 'brand'; designating it as such gradually diminished any of the appeal. The new version was slowly sanitised until it became just another WWE show, Metal with a different ring skirt. There were some highlights - it begrudgingly made a star of CM Punk ahead of Bobby Lashley - but otherwise it shambled along like the debut episode's incongruous zombie. WWECW was finally put out of its misery in 2010.

Advertisement