10 Ups & 7 Downs For AEW In 2020 (So Far)

AEW is still working on changing the world, though the industry is better for having them.

By Andy H Murray /

AEW

As with the WWE edition of this column, only AEW's creative output will be considered here. It's unfair to rip on the promotion for factors outwith its control, such as the restrictions imposed by the ongoing global health crisis, so those and other behind-the-scenes matters are best discussed elsewhere.

Advertisement

AEW's half-year has veered back and forth in terms of quality. The promotion audaciously left viewers hanging for two weeks after the universally-panned Dark Order angle of 18 December, leaving themselves with much goodwill to recover as 2019 rolled into 2020. They did so through January and beyond, building to the celebrated Revolution with a masterful run of episodic weekly television before the global health crisis caused a nosedive. Just 30% of AEW's roster was available to them for their first few Empty Arena Era tapings. Things got drab without the likes of The Young Bucks, Hangman Page, and Nyla Rose, but Dynamite is swinging once more - at least creatively. Television ratings remain in the toilet across the board.

It'll take a while longer than we want it to, but things will get back to normal eventually. Here's hoping AEW spends the rest of 2020 adding more Ups than Downs until then...

Advertisement

Let's light the fuse...

Downs...

7. Dark's New Format

AEW

It should never be a chore to watch a show once pitched as a quick, digestible web series designed to showcase and highlight wrestlers not fortunate enough to make it to the A-show in quick, snappy pseudo-squashes, but such is the general state of AEW Dark in 2020.

Advertisement

Cramming the show with 9-12 matches and stretching the runtime to upwards of 90 minutes has been to Dark's detriment. The real problem, however, is the lack of variety between bouts. These are not full-on squashes but more balanced enhancement scraps with near-identical layouts, as the enhancers last 4-6 minutes against more established wrestlers, mounting several comebacks before inevitably falling.

Wanting to build the likes of Lee Johnson and Alan Angels up as more than jobbers is a noble endeavour, though watching the same match several times on the same show is tiresome. The few matches that do break the formula stand out as a result.

Advertisement

Dark isn't all bad every week, though it is now a long, long way from its roots, and desperately needs turning up if it is to become AEW's second weekly show on TNT.

6. Mike Tyson

AEW

While Mike Tyson's AEW appearances have attracted coverage from websites outwith the professional wrestling bubble, that his confrontation with Chris Jericho lost viewers on AEW Dynamite's 27 May episode negates the argument that the former Baddest Man on the Planet is driving business in any meaningful way. That the segment was so shambolic compounds this: Tyson, once the most ferocious fighter boxing had ever seen, couldn't even tear his t-shirt open.

Advertisement

'Iron Mike' is expected to return to continue the Jericho feud, possibly resulting in a match with 'Le Champion.' It will be incredibly difficult for AEW to justify booking a convicted rapist in the wake of the #SpeakingOut movement. They shouldn't even try.

Double Or Nothing's belt-handover spot was enough. A relationship concluding with Tyson handing Cody the TNT Championship, then knocking somebody out, would have been a good bit of business, but nothing more. His questionable reputation aside, the guy isn't a big enough draw to justify continued use (and expense, presumably) in 2020.

Advertisement

5. Jake The Pest

AEW

Jake 'The Snake' Roberts has been a net positive to Lance Archer. 'The Murderhawk Monster' is a functional talker himself, though Jake, craggy voice and all, is one of the greatest of all time and gives his charge's act an injection of genuine evil to compliment his brutishness.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, that evil manifested in the most tasteless way prior to Double Or Nothing. Roberts became a full-on botherer. Resorting to cheap misogyny and simulated sexual harassment, he symbolically dropped a snake on Brandi Rhodes, slithering all over Cody's wife himself, before cutting a copy, outdated "women belong in the kitchen" promo the next week, drawing more eye-rolls than heat.

This stuff absolute sucks. It doesn't garner pro-wrestling animosity in 2020, only genuine animosity, and the distastefulness is more likely to make viewers tune out than tune back in to see the babyface's retribution. It undermined the Archer vs. Cody storyline too, transforming it from one of the best-built matches in wrestling to marred midcard attraction.

Advertisement

4. The Wrong Guy

AEW

Call AEW's Jake Hager experiment a noble failure.

Advertisement

It was noble in that the promotion genuinely tried to do something with a real-life badass who may have had more to offer than his WWE run suggested, capitalising on his MMA credibility to present the former Jake Swager as the Inner Circle's big, dangerous bruiser. Hager's debut was electric and he played his role as Chris Jericho's heavy well. His offense had pop, snap, and stiffness to it and he excelled in squash matches, his overmatched opponents flying into him like bugs on a windshield.

It's a shame, then that Hager has been found wanting when moved into bigger spotlights. Revolution's well-built battle with Dustin Rhodes was slow and ponderous, suggesting that Jack Swagger still lived within Jake Hager. This was confirmed when he met Jon Moxley for the AEW World Title weeks later, their No Holds Barred clash going down as a plodding, tedious teeth-puller, though Fyter Fest offers a shot at redemption against Cody.

Advertisement

For now, big Jake is lacking. Turns out you can take the man out of WWE, but not the Swagger out of Hager.

3. A Total Nightmare

AEW

Though much of The Nightmare Collective's run went down in late 2019, that their misgivings bled over into 2020 warrants their inclusion here.

Advertisement

This was easily one of the worst things AEW has done since its inception. Brand Rhodes was rebranded with a theatrical goth-like gimmick out of nowhere, continuing her alliance with a past-her-best Awesome Kong. The duo starred in creepy vignettes too ham-fisted to be taken seriously, claiming locks of hair from unfortunate members of AEW's women's division, before adding Mel and Dr. Luther to the fold, expecting the audience to care about two performers many of them had never seen before without giving any good reason.

A complete disaster, the Collective's every act was panned by fans and critics alike, leading to the stable being ditched without proper explanation a few weeks into the year. Rhodes claimed that she "wasn't feeling it" during an interview on Wrestling Observer Live, though other sources claimed the reinvention was actually her idea.

Advertisement

2. The Dark Order's Stench

AEW

Brodie Lee's situation is unfortunate. Double Or Nothing's bout was a ghoulish violence-fest that revealed him an outstanding brawler and still one of the best big men in the sport, going down as his greatest singles match perhaps since leaving the independents to sign for WWE in 2012. His promo delivery is strong, he puts care into his act, and he is almost certainly more fulfilled here than he was at his last place of work, given his increased television time.

Advertisement

But The Dark Order's act still isn't working. Much of this is down to the gimmick's failure prior to his arrival, of course, though things like the old Vince McMahon jabs didn't help either. For the most part, the masked group isn't sufficiently removed from its horrible early days to be taken as a serious concern, even when Lee was tangling with Moxley, and there's a strong chance it'll never be truly salvageable.

The current Colt Cabana storyline conjures conflicting emotions: it's a believable, well-told story of Lee and the Order targeting another downtrodden roster member, but it isn't taking because of the damage done before. This must be addressed before the year ends.

Advertisement

1. The Women's Division... Still

AEW/Lee South

Significant work has gone into improving AEW's women's division, which is now several levels above the lacklustre scene it was last year.

Advertisement

Britt Baker is the best character in the company (more on her later). In Hikaru Shida, AEW boasts an elite worker capable of not only elevating lesser performers on Dynamite, but glueing the division together as a whole. Nyla Rose has excelled as an attention-grabbing powerhouse with awesome offense, despite some lingering greenness. Penelope Ford's character and in-ring work improve every time we see her.

Unquestionably, these are steps forward. They don't mean the division is fixed, though: the division still isn't where it needs to be, particularly when considering the quality of NXT's.

Advertisement

Shida is a tremendous wrestler but lacks character beyond "fighting spirit babyface," with AEW putting little effort into developing her personality. This is a problem across the board. The likes of Kris Statlander are promising but frequently over-stretch themselves, resulting in botches, and the lack of depth beneath the title scene has been exposed during the Empty Arena Era, leaving underdeveloped acts fighting for opportunities.

There's still work to do here, though the upward trajectory is encouraging.

Advertisement

Ups...

10. The Doctor Will See You Now

AEW

Britt Baker's failed babyface run as the intended female ace of AEW could have left her buried, though the good doctor has since undergone a complete career reinvention, emerging as the most consistently entertaining character in the promotion since turning heel in January.

Advertisement

To watch Baker's material is to undergo a crash course in how to play a deluded villain. The turn has revealed layers of charisma invisible while Britt was playing face, with the 'Role Model' shtick turning Britt into the marketable, heat-drawing commodity the division desperately needed as 2019 rolled into 2020. Ridiculous, over-the-top, and so far up her own backside she can likely see her own tonsils, Baker is a treasure, and whether she's worsening Tony Schiavone's Stockholm Syndrome or getting lobbed in bins by Big Swole, she's killing it right now.

The caveat to all this is that the in-ring work isn't on the same level as the gimmick yet. This will come with time, though. For now, Baker is nailing things that can't always be taught, which is a lot more valuable in the long run.

Advertisement

9. Big Beefy Boys

Lee South/AEW

"All Petite Wrestling" is a tired joke regurgitated by uncreative Cornette cultists and simps who think "Oldberg" is a genuinely sick burn, though AEW's roster was unquestionably lacking in hosses when the promotion first came to life.

Advertisement

This is no longer the case.

Lance Archer is a sublime performer who marries traditional monster qualities with genuine menace, heel charisma, an incredible gimmick, and freakish agility, pulling off full-ring rope walks and absurd stunts like a man half his weight and age (43). 'Mr. Get My Sh*t In' is an appropriate nickname for mega-athlete Brian Cage, who has taken to AEW effortlessly since debuting at Double Or Nothing. Luchasaurus is a great crowd-popping midcarder with a unique offensive style. Brodie Lee, though hampered by his gimmick, is not only a great brawler, but also one of the most three-dimensional in-ring performers in the company. Then there's Wardlow, who is far from the finished article but already looks like wrestling's next great monster in the making thanks to immaculate presentation and raw-boned power.

Advertisement

AEW is no longer lacking in beef. They have addressed the early size concerns by snapping up the best big men available to them, meaning the roster is now more diverse than ever before.

8. Gimmick Shows

AEW

Fyter Fest goes down this weekend and while not as outlandish a concept as those AEW dabbled with earlier in the year, recent form suggests two shows above Dynamite's usual quality level.

Advertisement

2020's first few months saw the promotion gamble with all kinds of wild supershows. Bash at the Beach was not only an aesthetic delight, but one of the best examples of weekly television the sport has producer all year, while the Jericho Cruise episode was as charming as it was unique, even forcing the wrestlers to alter their styles on account of the diminished space around ringside. Elsewhere, Dynamite's Jacksonville homecoming and anniversary shows weren't as lovely to look at, though similar notes were hit.

Four annual pay-per-views is a sparse schedule, though these gimmicked shows help assuage any concerns. they provide more landmark events on the television calendar, give AEW increased opportunities to blow feuds and storylines off, and are usually good for popping a number in the Wednesday Night Wars. Long may they continue.

Advertisement

7. A Genuine Youth Movement

AEW

Creating stars takes time. Rarely is an instantaneous process, particularly when starting from the ground-up, meaning levels of patience not normally associated with today's wrestling fanbase are required.

Advertisement

Everything is atomised in 2020 and attention spans are at an all-time low, leading to criticism when hot up-and-comers aren't immediately thrust into the same spotlights as the Jon Moxleys, Codys, and Chris Jerichos. This is unwarranted. Throwing a Sammy Guevara, Darby Allin, or MJF in at the deep end, when they weren't ready, could have drowned them, with AEW's slower, more meticulous star-building processes the smarter choice for long-term gains.

The aforementioned prodigies are all under 30. Each has made immeasurable gains since signing with AEW, but again: this time takes time. Guevara vs. Allin will be a pay-per-view headliner a few years from now. MJF, meanwhile, is well on his way to becoming pro-wrestling's greatest old-school heel. Give him another year or two and he'll be ready to replace Jericho forever.

Advertisement

Filling out the youth movement are the likes of Private Party, Jungle Boy, Sonny Kiss, Kris Statlander, Penelope Ford, Ricky Starks, as well as more obtuse talents like Wardlow and Austin Gunn, whose ceilings aren't as clear. Yes, Jon Moxley and Cody are on top now, but AEW is doing an outstanding job of gradually building the next generation, using the existing stars to hold the fort and draw money until they're ready.

Just be patient.

Advertisement

6. Dynamite Hits Its Stride

AEW

Though peppered with flashes of excellence in 2019, AEW Dynamite didn't truly hit its stride until early 2020, when the wonderful Revolution pay-per-view build saw Tony Khan and co. refine their storytelling and structural techniques to create a monster.

Advertisement

January and February were tremendous. Dynamite will never be perfect, of course, but stories like MJF vs. Cody, The Inner Circle's war on Jon Moxley, and the year-best Kenny Omega and Hangman Page vs. The Young Bucks saga unfolded beautifully. Smart, logical, and entertaining, AEW was on fire, though the onset of the global health crisis saw quality levels nosedive in March, leaving the promotion reeling with just 30% of the roster available for us.

Things have since returned to normal, with AEW perfecting Empty Arena Wrestling since Dynamite. Noise levels are now comparable to a mid-level indie promotion thanks to the gathered masses at ringside and the writing is back on point, with angles, segments, and matches dovetailing into one another with grace and fluidity. Khan pens these shows like he's been doing it all his life and each one flows like water, making Dynamite wrestling's easiest watch.

Advertisement

5. 10 Lashes

AEW

Cody's brand of melodrama occasionally yields disappointment. Double Or Nothing is the prime example of this: his bout with Lance Archer wasn't bad, but was overbooked in the extreme, blighted by its excessive bells and whistles where previous 'American Nightmare' matches have been enhanced. It could have done with some trimming, both in terms of length and layout.

Advertisement

No, Cody isn't a perfect pro-wrestler: but he is capable of crafting perfect moments, as witnessed in the 10 lashes segment with MJF.

This was an angle without flaw. It was a brutal, gutwrenching, and torturous ordeal, during which the viewer felt the full weight of every snapping blow from MJF's belt. The villain was mean and overbearing; the victim was in hell. Cody's emoting, selling, and sense of struggle as he writhed in agony and continue struggled to his feet, never once backing down, evoked unreal sympathy, and the end result was the most emotional segment the sport will produce all year.

Advertisement

4. Double Or Nothing

AEW

A middling build left several of Double Or Nothing's matches lacking meat on their bones, though the pay-per-view ended up a resounding success across the door - and came at just the right time for a sport close to buckling under the weight of the global health crisis.

Advertisement

DoN 2020 felt like the party at the end of the world. Fan and frantic, bold and brash, big and colourful: this was a rollicking celebration of everything professional wrestling is supposed to be, and a much-needed shot of pure escapism, particularly in the main event. The Stadium Stampede was the wild, weird ride it needed to be. An absolute riot from start to finish, it was dumb in all the right ways and capable of putting a smile on even the most curmudgeonly face.

Elsewhere we got a madcap ladder match highlighted by Brian Cage's debut, old-school excellence as MJF wrestled Jungle Boy, the inaugural TNT Champion's coronation, Hikaru Shida besting Nyla Rose in one of AEW's best women's matches to date, and the brutal, violent war between Jon Moxley and Brodie Lee. Not a perfect show by any means, though Double Or Nothing still delivered in spades.

Advertisement

3. The Tag Division

AEW

There isn't a tag division in the world that can compare to AEW's right now. It's a low bar, admittedly, as WWE and NJPW rarely book their divisions well and Impact (outside of The North and Rascalz) and ROH provide little to write home about either, though Tony Khan's promotion is still lightyears ahead of everyone in every regard.

Advertisement

Hangman Page and Kenny Omega quickly went from loose Elite associates to Best in the World contenders through their fluid, cohesive teamwork, outstanding chemistry, and brilliant long-term storyline with The Young Bucks, who often eschew the spotlight but are never found lacking when they don't. The Lucha Brothers and Santana and Ortiz are tenured, world-class tandems just waiting for their turn at the top. #FTR, the most old-school of old-school tag teams, are in Jacksonville now, already imposing their Brain Busters-influenced will on the scene. SoCal Uncensored, Best Friends, and Stu Grayson/Evil Uno are established veteran units ready for any role. Sonny Kiss/Joey Janela, Private Party, and The Butcher and the Blade come laced with potential.

That there's more than we can mention here shows the outrageous depth of this scene and the booking is on point, too, with the titles booked as one of AEW's biggest prizes, not midcard novelty straps. The situation is fantastic across the board, and the best part? It feels like the division is just getting started.

Advertisement

2. The Rebirth Of Hangman Page

AEW/Lee South

Hangman Page's situation is similar to Britt Baker's, though his character's revolution hasn't been quite as drastic. Page didn't turn full-on heel after bottoming out as a babyface but rather adjusted his character, replacing the generic good guy of old with a beer-swilling man of the people following a televised identity crisis, and his stellar work between the ropes is ultimately what separates him from the good doctor.

Advertisement

AEW has accomplished something remarkable with Page. Positioned against Chris Jericho early on, he was supposed to be their guy in a main event scene largely populated by wrestlers who'd made their name in WCW. He could have plummeted when the act didn't take (and would have if not for the adjustments), but has instead soared by distancing himself from The Elite when it was clear the stable wasn't working for him anymore, cutting loose, and rediscovering who he is, ensuring he now stands tall as the most rugged, organic, and natural babyface in the promotion.

Exemplary tag matches alongside Kenny Omega have played a huge role in Page's resurgence, though he has never been better placed to become the company's true ace. That'll come with time. For now, Hangman will keep crushing it in a role he was seemingly born to play.

Advertisement

1. Revolution

AEW

The greatest pay-per-view in AEW's young history went down in February, with the upstart promotion somehow outdoing Double Or Nothing 2019's first-show feel and everything that has come since then, with only the mediocre Nyla Rose/Kris Statlander and Jake Hager/Dustin Rhodes bouts blighting its excellence.

Advertisement

Darby Allin vs. Sammy Guevara was a blitzkrieg spring to the finish between two guys who'll take their rivalry all the way to the main event over the coming years. MJF and Cody was an old territory-style clash bells and whistles as well, while the over-as-f*ck Orange Cassidy met the perfect, torturous villain in PAC, delivering the year's starkest clash of characters. The main event provided genuine catharsis as Jon Moxley freed the AEW World Championship from Chris Jericho, too.

But the biggest highlight was, of course, the Tag Team Title bout, as Hangman Page and Kenny Omega bested The Young Bucks in a clash worth six of any swole wrestling critic's stars. Was it the best tag team match ever? No, such assertions are daft, particularly in a world where Kobashi and Kikuchi vs. the Can-Am Express exists, though it was magnificent. Richer in storytelling and psychology than any other match to take place this year, it was leagues beyond the expected state-of-the-art athleticism.

Advertisement

What a pay-per-view.