10 Ways WWE In 2017 Could Have Been COMPLETELY Different

Open Universe Theory

By Michael Hamflett /

Was 2017 wrestling's best ever year? There are multiple metrics that suggest so.

Advertisement

WWE's traditional 'Big Four' model was reinforced with weekends of wrestling playing to cumulative audiences of over 100,000 people a time, thanks to arena residencies housing a mix of critical and commercial success stories with NXT TakeOvers, Raws, SmackDowns and the pillar events themselves. In the case of the Royal Rumble and WrestleMania, the company drew around 150,000 combined for the Sunday supershows.

When he wasn't reviewing those, Wrestling Observer doyen Dave Meltzer presumably spent the remainder of his time cruising through space looking for new galaxies to furnish himself with enough stars to adequately assess New Japan Pro Wrestling. Wrestle Kingdom, The G1 Climax and The Best Of The Super Juniors were widely considered amongst the best ever editions of each, whilst Dominion 6.11 in Osaka-jo Hall played host to possibly/maybe/if that's your cup of tea (delete as appropriate or don't, the match was f*cking fantastic and that categorically isn't up for debate) the best match ever.

WWE posted some of their best ever financials in Q3, and rewarded fans with some chaotic booking between October and November that saw returns to the ring for Kurt Angle and Triple H in a variety of dream match scenarios with today's best and brightest. In fairness to Vince McMahon, those winter months weren't outliers. The year progressed frantically (for better and worse), with more going on than could often be digested at the time. Between the bombast and bluster, what could have been?

10. Don't Call It A Comeback

Matt and Jeff Hardy's WrestleMania 33 return was for many the lone highlight of a bright-but-bloated Orlando supercard.

Advertisement

It was the type of night where a lot happened, but nothing was much of a happening. The thunderous pop that echoed around the Camping World Stadium wasn't merely born from nostalgia for the North Carolinian Attitude Era icons. It represented a return to form for the brothers, happier and healthier than they'd been in a decade and creatively thriving thanks to the #BROKEN Universe cultivated by Matt in TNA (more on that later).

Winning the Tag Team Titles in a ladder match on the night was a vote of confidence from WWE in their ability to carry the league through the post-WrestleMania lull, but what could have been had they remained with the then-renamed Global Force Wrestling.

Feuding with The Hardy Boyz made The Bar, who in turn made a rejuvenated Seth Rollins/Dean Ambrose combo that drove the reunion of The Shield in October. It was a chain of events completely triggered by their return, and may not have yielded such an entertaining tag division on the red brand without their on and off screen influence.

9. Flat Broke

A end-of-year treat after months of legal wrangling between the man himself and Impact Wrestling finally came to a close, the emergence of Broken/Woken Matt Hardy on WWE television was as big a gift to Bray Wyatt as it was the wider wrestling fanbase.

Advertisement

Unquestionably the biggest beneficiary though - and deservedly so - is Matt. Gaining renewed life on an even greater platform than the one he erected for himself in 2016, the character looks set to triumph yet again as an other-worldly delight in an company propped up by mundanity.

And really, what could those over-worked creative heads done for him that would have competed with merely a chuckle and deranged grin from his out-there alter-ego?

To Matt's credit, he'd never fully abandoned the character, if only for his own amusement. In hindsight, that was one of the smartest moves of his entire career.

After Jeff went on the shelf this summer, Hardy spent months working as the token tag partner of any performer WWE were heaping more focus on. He'd been a useful utility player once too often everywhere he'd worked - it was now or never for MEEKMAHAN to take a chance or for the gimmick to lose the great war once and for all.

8. Wyatt Family Values

Bray Wyatt was perhaps beyond saving when WWE finally put their top title on him at the climax of February's Elimination Chamber, but after unexpectedly riding a wave of renewed momentum alongside then-partner Randy Orton, 'The Eater Of Worlds' finally stood a chance of dining at the top table.

Advertisement

Like the bullied child at school, he was yet again left eating worms for attention. Almost literally after 'The Apex Predator' pounded his face into the mat with an RKO before the ten minute mark at WrestleMania 33.

A lengthy run for Wyatt in a similar...vein to the spell Jinder Mahal garnered could have implanted Bray back in an upper echelon he barely flirted with during his best spell with the organisation back in 2014.

Instead, the loss to Orton resulted in him 'getting his win back' in one of the year's biggest shambles before doing his best to end Finn Bálor's career with a pathetically poor series of matches and segments. The feud, much like Wyatt's aura, didn't end. It merely faded away thanks to an inconvenient disease.

When viral meningitis would top a '10 Good Things To Happen To Bray Wyatt In 2017' list (pitch pending), it's time for a career rethink.

7. Somebody Else's Guy

Jinder Mahal was the personal choice of Vince McMahon to take the fast-track from the outhouse to the penthouse in May, but what if vascularity and localisation weren't the primary rationales for a megapush?

Advertisement

WWE persistently fosters a roster chock-full of talents patiently waiting for an opportunity on the outside but feverish to receive it on the inside. It's a far cry from the ultra-heated days of the Attitude Era, where Head Of Talent Relations Jim Ross hired then nurtured a line-up of dogged and determined super-athletes desperate for the top spot. Bob Holly's p*ss funny 'HOW 'BOUT YOU GIVE ME THE BELT...AND THEN I BEAT EVERYBODY' booking idea in a locker room housing The Rock and Stone Cold Steve Austin emphasised the ardent self-belief and confidence it took to hang in the company's most competitive era.

McMahon castigating his young crop as 'millennials' on a 2014 Stone Cold Steve Austin podcast was a near-the-knuckle dig at the lot of them, but underboss Triple H presumably knew the...erm...pedigree of countless other alternatives when McMahon forged ahead with Jinder.

Might a similar marketing surge underneath Sami Zayn, Luke Harper or Mojo Rawley have yielded greater results than Mahal? We'll never know, and thanks to the failings of 2017's Plan A, it'll be a while before we get a chance to test the theory again.

6. Cleaning Up

Contrary to popular belief, it probably wouldn't be the best thing evah~~! if Kenny Omega did sign for WWE. Would the coolest and most relevant performer in the world today even survive in the bloated organisation, let alone thrive? On current trends, it's impossible to assess.

Advertisement

Though AJ Styles' tenure has so far set new precedents for incoming talents, like a 1980s Vince McMahon contract - there are still no guarantees. For every Styles there's the case of his own best mates. Karl Anderson and Luke Gallows went from lions to lambs in a matter of months and have since been reduced to WWE comedy while they presumably wait patiently to be reset.

Omega would have unquestionably shook WWE and the wrestling world in general to its very core had he joined up in January 2017 as rumoured, but the ability to maintain his aura on the weekly televised grind would have presented him with an even challenge than Kazuchika Okada did twice more later in the year.

The rumours will inevitably restart in 2018 following Omega's Wrestle Kingdom clash with Chris Jericho, but with 'The Cleaner' still a vital part of NJPW's global expansion, he may elect to remain a central figure than chance it all for the diluted disillusion of a modern-day 'WrestleMania moment'.

5. Blood Hounds

WWE were uncharacteristically patient with the 2017 reunion of The Shield, so much so that they effectively had 'The Architect' rebuild his original creation from scratch after shattering it to pieces nearly three years earlier.

Advertisement

It wasn't until Seth Rollins showed contrition for his treachery during his WrestleMania programme with Triple H that the fans finally latched onto the 'Kingslayer', with their newfound support helping reestablish a dormant bond with Dean Ambrose shortly before their SummerSlam Tag Team Title match with The Bar.

Their union ultimately resulted in glory, with the pair scooping gold and eventually linking arms with Roman Reigns to yet again assemble as the 'Hounds Of Justice'.

The conclusion to their triumphant trip back to the top may still be a long-pondered heel turn for Dean Ambrose, but WWE could have been particularly devilish with 'The Lunatic Fringe' had they pulled at that same thread when fans least expected it.

Turning on Rollins as he'd done on him all those years ago, Ambrose's unhinged side showing itself at SummerSlam would have generated a red hot return to an old rivalry for the remainder of 2017. A rivalry reborn by switched alignments, the story may yet be told in 2018.

4. Heavy Is The Head That Wears The Crown

As of press time, Neville is in stasis with WWE. Gone from television since the end of the summer following further degradation to the title and division he desperately tried to redefine, he remains on an island between creative satisfaction the unknown end date of his current contract.

Advertisement

He's bang right in his assessment of course, but it's easy to see why WWE are less than keen on releasing him into the wilds of the vibrant independent scene. Far, far lesser talents than the 'Man That Gravity Forgot' have gone on to achieve incredible things outside of the WWE bubble, with Neville being a particularly unique case in having a pre and post-McMahon fanbase due to a legacy that pre-dates his Stamford signing in 2012.

WWE's pattern of disrespect was callously reflected at WrestleMania 33, when Neville's Cruiserweight Title clash with Austin Aries was the best thing in the first half of the broadcast but not deemed worthy enough of inclusion on the American version of the DVD.

Pride and bank balances were bruised in equal measure enough to convince Aries to sharply exit WWE after less than a year on the main roster. If only the company had learned from that loss to preserve another valuable resource.

3. Have Mercy

WWE were oddly castigated by a section of the fanbase for providing such a loaded card at September's No Mercy pay-per-view, with audiences almost annoyed that the company would dare present a double header of John Cena Vs Roman Reigns and Brock Lesnar Vs Braun Strowman on a B-show.

Advertisement

Seemingly brow-beaten by the organisation, the dissenters were too short-sighted to consider that future big shows would force the creative heads to come up with something for a WrestleMania or SummerSlam, but they were partially right in asserting the importance of preserving the value of a first-time meeting, especially in the case of the Braun/Brock brawl.

The desperately boring battle came at completely the wrong time in Strowman's ascent up the card. Hotshotting Braun's first singles crack at Lesnar's title was completely reckless, unless 'The Monster Among Men' was set to win. Had they made it to WrestleMania together with Strowman's record still largely unblemished (outside of the long-forgotten defeats to Roman Reigns), the tense end would have justified the means.

Instead, a B-show pay-per-view had a C-show quality main event with a D-show payoff. Braun's just about impervious to hokey booking, but he's in much worse shape losing a legitimately competitive encounter.

2. Friends 'Til The End

If viewers learned one thing from the Kevin Owens '365' Network special, it was that WWE will convert the thoughts in a performer's head from lifelong dreams to day-to-day mind-f*cks. If viewers learned two, it was that Vince McMahon was not at all happy with 'KO's win over former best friend Chris Jericho.

Advertisement

On paper, you can't blame the mad old sh*t. As a match, it didn't remotely live up to what was hands down the best WWE segment of 2017. Playing out in a way Chris Jericho later confirmed was completely okayed by Vince himself, the 'Festival Of Friendship' had the makings of a Monday Night Raw classic before Owens cruelly put a bullet in their fragile union. Boasting inch perfect levels of light and shade, it was an exquisite payoff to lingering unease between the two that used the same package of comedy and violence that made up the bulk of their work together across the prior six months.

The angle was so good that it deserved top billing at WrestleMania. It had earned it. But that wasn't 'the plan'. Goldberg took Owens' Universal Title and contested an absolute rip-snorter with Brock Lesnar, leaving 'Y2J' and the 'Prizefighter' fighting over a United States strap that have never looked more secondary. The two may never come close to WrestleMania's show-closing pyro again.

1. Keep Talking

WWE's worst decision of 2017 even beyond the most diabolical Jinder-related calamities, the budget-driven cancellation of Talking Smack was infuriatingly short-sighted.

Advertisement

Binned alongside a host of other Network projects due to viewer figures apparently not justifying the production costs, the SmackDown Live! post-show was unceremoniously dumped without even affording a courtesy call to talented presenting partners Renee Young and Daniel Bryan. They openly mocked the Kurt Angle/Jason Jordan parental revelation in a one-off guerrilla edition 'Smacking Talk' a week after its unceremonious dismissal, such was the show's cult popularity and their chemistry on it.

Away from the legitimately hilarious meanderings of the hosts, the show was a bonafide star-maker. In the same way active roster members came across thousands of times better on Network documentaries, their long-form semi-improvisational efforts often outstripped the monotone monologues they were fed on the preceding broadcast. Jinder Mahal, Baron Corbin, The Usos, Mojo Rawley, AJ Styles, Kevin Owens and The Miz were regularly required viewing on the show. A less-than-successful appearance for Alexa Bliss left her red-faced but battle-hardened. She rapidly grew into one of the most confident speakers on either show - a testament to the power of the vehicle even when it went badly.

SmackDown Live!'s 2017 decline isn't all because its sister show left the scene. But the loss of the outlet is still clearly felt today.

Advertisement