10 Worst Excuses For Terrible Wrestling Moments
Times when WWE, AEW and WCW came up with the dumbest excuses imaginable.
More fans would've flocked to the building if only the weather had been better. TV ratings would've been higher had that basketball/ice hockey game not been on at the same time. People just didn't get what the writers were going for. Wrestling is full of excuses like that, but hey - if that's what it takes to help the folks in charge sleep at night, then fair enough.
Not all excuses are valid though.
Sometimes, companies like WWE and AEW just mess up but don't want to throw their hands in the air and admit it. So, they deflect blame onto someone/something else and pray fans are in a forgiving mood. Most of the time, they are. The biz hurls so much content at you that it's impossible to stay mad for long anyway.
It is, however, funny to look back on some of the excuses these promotions and their wrestlers have thought up over the years. On occasion, even those who seemingly don't have any skin in the game on the outside attempt to justify poor decision-making and pass clangers off as an easy fix.
That's wrestling 101. It's often hard to determine what's the bigger bluff: Action in front of the cameras, or all of the nonsense that goes on behind the curtain, in meetings and during interviews.
10. James Ellsworth Must Look Handy
What Happened: Enhancement worker turned full-blown member of the roster James Ellsworth wrecked the finish to WWE's first ever women's Money In The Bank match. During the 2017 pay-per-view, Ellsworth shimmied his way up the ladder, grabbed the briefcase and pulled it down before tossing it to main gal pal Carmella.
The Excuse: On TV, WWE explained away Ellsworth's involvement by having GM Daniel Bryan set up a rematch on SmackDown, but it was too little and definitely too late. It didn't sit well with fans that a male wrestler had effectively won the ladder match originally.
Sure, James needed to look effective as a gopher to Mella, but having him haul down the case sullied what should've been a historic moment for women's wrestling in the company. The idea that Carmella needed a dude to do the heavy lifting for her knackered the point of pushing women to the forefront.
Making Ellsworth look useful was more important than women's wrestling, apparently.
9. WWE Didn’t Write An Anonymous GM Conclusion
What Happened: WWE introduced an "anonymous Raw General Manager" in June 2010. The mysterious authority figure controlled Raw via an email system that saw Michael Cole read messages as they popped through. This idea was abandoned in 2011, but returned in 2012. Hornswoggle was then outed as the little prankster responsible, and nobody was thrilled.
The Excuse: Behind the scenes, WWE had to face up to a painful truth: Vince McMahon's creative team hadn't actually thrashed out exactly who would be revealed as this anonymous puppet master pulling strings like some wrestling GM version of The Wizard Of Oz. The braintrust was winging the entire story, and it showed.
Hornswoggle's reveal was a facepalm and a half.
It certainly isn't anyone else's fault that WWE couldn't be arsed to think this storyline through before putting it on live television. The way they announced lil' Horny then brought the gimmick back in 2014 without a satisfying conclusion yet again was hellish and just shouldn't have happened.
8. ‘The Fiend’ & Seth Rollins Need A Rematch Stip
What Happened: Seth Rollins was mentally pushed to the brink by Bray Wyatt's 'Fiend' hijinks, so he snapped and covered the masked gimmick in various weapons at Hell In A Cell 2019. Then, Rollins smashed Bray with a sledgehammer and the referee stopped the match. Problem? It was a Cell match, and there was no way fans would accept the stoppage.
The Excuse: Say hello to the worst kind of month-to-month booking.
WWE booked that finish for two reasons. One, they thought it'd protect Wyatt's 'Fiend' character. Two, it handed creative an easy route to a follow up match over in Saudi Arabia at Crown Jewel. The pre-match hype for that sequel claimed the bout "could not be stopped for any reason", which was confusing because they didn't add an "*except pinfalls" disclaimer.
In short, the bogus Cell finish no-one liked was seemingly only booked to get to this second helping of Bray vs. Seth. That was one seriously rotten excuse for smashing the HIAC structure's aura. Being honest, it'd been dangling by a thread due to the formulaic annual PPV format, but that finish was unforgivably sh*te, and following up with a rematch that acted as a halfhearted apology sucked too.
7. AEW Pins Poor Planning On Someone Else
What Happened: The explosive finish to AEW's Revolution 2021 stunt show between Kenny Omega and Jon Moxley was ruined when someone replaced the C4 with sparklers instead. Indeed, the fireworks on display were pyrotechnics that'd get parents in the bad books with the kiddies if they dared set them up in the back garden.
People booed. AEW should've been embarrassed.
The Excuse: All Elite pinned blame on the pyro team brought in to make sure the finish looked good, but Tony Khan really should've sorted all of this out beforehand. It was his pay-per-view spectacular, no-one else's. To make matters worse, Japanese veteran Atsushi Onita (who knows a thing or two about explosions) was literally used as a talking head during the build.
Why didn't AEW lean on his advice and ask Onita to help organise everything in advance? Passing the buck onto some unnamed group of folks who may/may not have been savvy enough to pull this off in the first place was WCW levels of bad planning from the All Eliters.
6. The Usos Blame A WrestleMania Time Cut
What Happened: A brother vs. brother battle pitting Jey Uso vs. his sibling Jimmy sucked the life out of some on WrestleMania Saturday in April 2024. The 'Mania 40 scuffle was a giant letdown, one that included far too many superkicks and never really got going before the finish. It...wasn't very good at all.
The Excuse: Jey would be the first to admit that this literal Bloodline brawl should've been better, but he's also talked about WWE cutting their time on the day during interviews. According to Uso, agents told he and Jimmy that another match earlier on the show had gone long, so they'd only be getting around 11 minutes bell to bell.
11 minutes is still long enough to tell a story and have a good match, lads.
Granted, it surely hurt to learn their match would be shorter than expected, but still - did The Usos really need to stuff so many superkicks in there? Their accidental tribute to The Young Bucks fell way short of what people had hoped to see, and the timing issue stands as a poor excuse for that.
5. WWF ‘Couldn’t Get’ WCW’s Big Names
What Happened: Numerous big name WCW stars chose to sit on fat AOL Time Warner contacts instead of cutting them short to accept lesser deals with the WWF. That was entirely justified post-WCW demise. As a result, Vince McMahon's invasion angle lacked necessary star power to really make it worthwhile to fans.
The Excuse: Guys like Bruce Prichard and even Jim Ross have opined that the WWF couldn't match the money guys like Hulk Hogan, Ric Flair, Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, Goldberg, Sting and others needed to break off their guaranteed deals and come back to work. That's really hard to believe.
WWF business was monstrous by 2001, and it kinda sounds like everyone's blaming the WCW lot for choosing to rake it in rather than accepting less cash to wrestle. DDP did that, and things didn't work out well for him in the fed at all.
Running the invasion regardless meant top WWF stars like Steve Austin and Kurt Angle had to switch sides so the Alliance had bigger stars. If anything, McMahon should've sat on WCW for a while and planned things out properly. Jumping the gun without WCW's best turned the angle into a sh*tshow.
Then, hilariously, the WWF brought guys like the nWo, Hogan, Flair and Goldberg in eventually anyway.
4. Nobody Would Predict David Arquette
What Happened: Actor David Arquette shockingly won the WCW World Title on the 26 April 2000 episode of Thunder. Arquette pinned Eric Bischoff in a hastily-arranged tag-team match to win his partner DDP's belt. The entire wrestling world was shocked, and this might've been the last straw for some viewers who were exasperated with WCW's rubbish output.
The Excuse: Vince Russo gets full blame for Arquette winning the gold, but that's not totally fair. It was actually Tony Schiavone who hurled out the pitch in a creative meeting; Schiavone might've been half-joking, but Russo was listening and liked what he was hearing. So, plans were put in place for Dave to hold the big gold.
Arquette himself questioned the wisdom of this. He was a wrestling fan, and he knew fellow fans would hate every minute of it. WCW went for it anyway. It's widely accepted that this decision left many people disillusioned with the product. Ratings and pay-per-view buyrates were already in the toilet, but they'd get worse later in the year.
It was a swerve, bro. Nobody would ever see it coming, bro.
3. Cody Rhodes Needed Better Facials
What Happened: Royal Rumble winner Cody Rhodes sensationally announced that he wouldn't challenge Roman Reigns to a rematch at WrestleMania 40 on the 2 February 2024 edition of SmackDown. No, valiant babyface hero Cody would willingly step aside for The Rock and let him challenge for the WWE Title instead.
The Excuse: Ex-WWE writer Brian Gewirtz went on record to semi-blame Cody for the moment falling flat. He desperately asserted that Rhodes being legit p*ssed off and thus failing to properly sell "uplifting" excitement with his facial expressions contributed to fan annoyance.
That's dumb.
People were flabbergasted and annoyed because Cody stepping aside for someone else made no sense. Why would the Royal Rumble winner be chuffed to let someone else scoop his glory, title match and 'Mania payoff? Someone ask Gewirtz to explain that one. It'd be an impossible script to write.
Excusing WWE's terrible decision and pointing the finger of blame at Rhodes was stupid. Triple H quickly saw the error of his ways and corrected the mistake around a week later, so there's no way Cody smiling some more would've eased fan unrest on SmackDown.
2. Tony Khan Wants To Call CM Punk's Bluff
What Happened: Tony Khan aired grainy behind the scenes footage of CM Punk scuffling with Jack Perry at All In London in 2023 on the 10 April 2024 episode of Dynamite. This was supposed to clarify comments Punk had made during an interview with Ariel Helwani and vindicate AEW's position/Tony saying he'd feared for his life.
The Excuse: Showing the footage backfired spectacularly.
The Young Bucks introduced the segment, and it...proved that Punk had been telling the truth about his part in things. Basically, this was a major own goal from AEW and Tony. It wasn't the "gotcha" moment he presumably thought it'd be beforehand, and it led to shaking heads all over social media.
Airing the Punk footage backfired for two distinct reasons. Firstly, bolstering a current WWE star's claims was a terrible misuse of precious TV time on AEW's flagship show. Second, the moment suggested new badass heel and Elite member Jack Perry couldn't stand up for himself. If this was meant to make Perry look like a star, then it failed.
Good lord. What were they thinking?!
1. Vince ‘Wanted To Give’ Melanie Pillman Time
What Happened: Grieving widow Melanie Pillman was interviewed on the WWF's flagship show Raw just 24 hours after finding out her husband Brian had died in a hotel room. Vince McMahon pushed and prodded Melanie on-air for details about Brian's death during the 6 October 1997 episode, and even wondered how she'd cope going forwards.
People were disgusted by this sensationalistic approach towards recent real-life tragedy.
The Excuse: Bruce Prichard has implied via his podcast that McMahon genuinely just wanted to give Melanie a chance to tell her story. That's called brainwashing, folks. It's definitely difficult to swallow the idea that Vince put Melanie on television so soon after Brian's death because he was trying to help her out. Come on now.
This was blatant exploitation of a grieving widow, and the Raw segment was booked in seriously poor taste. Shoving a camera in Melanie's face whilst she was coming to terms with Brian's passing was awful. Just awful. No amount of federation spin could change that.
Sorry, it couldn't.
What other poor excuses were given for terrible wrestling moments? For more WWE, check out 10 Wrestlers WWE Must Not Rehire and Wild Sh*t Wrestling Did You’ve TOTALLY Forgotten About!