10 Wrestlers WWE Must Not Rehire

Triple H shouldn't be tempted to bring ANY of these ex-WWE stars back.

The Hardy Boys Matt Jeff WWE
AEW/WWE

Triple H's WWE has done a much better job of giving most workers something to do across Raw, SmackDown and NXT. Some are still camped out in catering twiddling their thumbs, but that's something Hunter has lessened since assuming control of the company from his father-in-law Vince McMahon.

'The Game' has also become adept at lacing shows with 'B', 'C' and even 'D' stories that ensure even those lower in the rankings still have a clear purpose week to week. Even so, the boss shouldn't overstuff his roster - it's busy enough, and Trips must only look sideways towards Tony Khan's AEW to see where signing every pro wrestler ever gets you.

In other words, he shouldn't bring anyone mentioned here back.

They've all either had their time in the sun or flopped trying to bask in it. Some were released pretty recently, and others...others would play before diminishing returns. A few would even stink up the place and surely turn in embarrassing matches nobody needs to see in 2024.

These wrestlers can still earn good cash elsewhere on the wrestling map. WWE? That's a firm no!

10. Gable Steveson

Gable Steveson WWE NXT
WWE.com

This just didn't work out, did it?

Gable Steveson was likened to Brock Lesnar and Kurt Angle from the off due to his amateur and Olympic achievements. That was a mistake, one that quickly caught up with WWE execs once they realised Gable didn't quite take to their brand of wrestling like a duck might to water. Steveson started drowning.

His woeful match vs. Baron Corbin on NXT summed it up. Here was a dude WWE fully expected to be a natural, but he couldn't live up to the billing and was booed heavily. Unfair? Yes, but such is life. Gable has moved on to the NFL anyway, so he'll be fine long-term. WWE (and pro wrestling in general) just wasn't for him.

Lesson learned, or one that should be. Triple H cannot be tempted to bring Steveson back for another whirl if things don't pan out for him with the Buffalo Bills. There simply wasn't enough to his game to merit further patience - it's as cut and dried as that.


9. Shanky

Shanky WWE
WWE.com

Good lord, big Shanks was a painful watch! His awkward attempts at comedy were WWE under Vince McMahon 101. Despite playing before literal silence at times, Shanky was tasked with turning from menacing monster into a friendly giant who liked to goof off and have a laugh whenever he could.

The catch? He was the only one laughing.

Fans didn't care about Shanky when he was aligned with Jinder Mahal. They didn't care about the guy when he turned into the next coming of Kurrgan/Big Show/Lord Tensai/The Great Khali/any other number of big men who suddenly decided acting like fun-loving party boys was the way to win over people's hearts. They just didn't care full stop.

WWE cut the cord in September 2023, and they must never look back. Triple H doesn't seem as obsessed by circus-like attractions as Vince anyway, so there's probs no scope for Shanky to launch headfirst into a short mega-push on TV in coming years.

Never say never, and all that, but please say never.


8. Emma

Emma Tenille Dashwood WWE SmackDown 2022
WWE.com

There was a short (very short) period when Emma's return in 2022 made headlines. Some were legit thrilled to see Tenille Dashwood get another crack with the company, and everyone reasoned Trips would get the best out of her/turn her into a pillar of the women's division. Nope, didn't happen.

She slid down the ladder of importance within weeks, and that was that.

Emma's second stint at WWE was so listless that she's openly questioned her own future in the biz on social media. That's sad, because she is talented, but there'd be no clamour for a third run with the market leader. WWE's focus should be on fresher workers like Tiffany Stratton, Roxanne Perez, Kiana James and more.

Sure, every division on the books needs some depth, and it doesn't sting to have older heads act as occasional punching bags (Naomi, for example), but Emma would only suffer the same fate she did before if she came back. Let her do the veteran act elsewhere.


7. Jinder Mahal

Jinder Mahal
WWE

You've got to give Jinder Mahal something: His work opposite The Rock and Seth Rollins in January 2024 was well-worth seeing. Firstly, Jinder trolled fans pre-Rocky return on the New Year edition of Raw, and he held his own on the mic against one of the greatest to ever hold one. Then, Mahal turned in a fun showing vs. Rollins for the World Title.

That was one final roll of the dice from WWE - they sought that last little bit of value from somebody they'd truthfully given up on as a credible concern years ago. By April, Jinder was hindered and sent packing. Will he be back? Most likely, but WWE's decision makers should pause and seriously think about why should they ever consider it.

Mahal will never reach the heady heights of World Titles again, at least not in the E.

He's well-spoken, seems to have a good head on his shoulders and has been reflective during interviews since leaving WWE, but Jinder isn't somebody who'd rock the boat with a return. Being honest, this writer really likes his attitude, but this is business.


6. Top Dolla

LA Knight Top Dolla
WWE.com

A.J Francis can point to some fun interactions opposite internet darling Joe Hendry in TNA, and he's busy working for both MLW and the NWA, but there's a ceiling for the man. WWE's is far too high. His matches sucked when he was part of Hit Row the first time, and they were even worse between 2022-2023 during his second go-around.

Michael Cole was clearly working when ribbing Dolla on commentary, but there had to be some truth to his words. Cole has watched literally hundreds of pro wrestlers roll through WWE's doors, and anyone with working eyes could see that Top Dolla didn't have the basic fundamentals down.

That might be harsh, but the eyes don't lie.

His bouts were clunky, and a few notable botches gained eyeballs online for all the wrong reasons. There are far better in-ring workers who don't get a look-in on mainline WWE television - Dolla is better off where he is. Who knows? Maybe he'll surprise everybody by honing his skills and having killer matches someday, but it won't be under Triple H's watch.


5. Paul Wight

WELLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL it's Paul Wight
AEW

There were some wild takes when Paul Wight joined AEW. 'I think Tony Khan can get more from him', some said. Wight himself even seemed game for it; he openly pitched matches against Kenny Omega. In retrospect, it's a good thing that wasn't inflicted on the wrestling world in 2021.

In March 2023, Paul said he had two years remaining on his All Elite deal. So, WWE would be able to bring him back in March 2025 if he sees out the duration of that contract. They shouldn't. Look, bringing Big Show back as some sort of ambassador is fine, but that's it.

He's a spent force physically, and hasn't really cracked it on commentary either. Some appearances have been better than others behind the desk, but Khan hasn't shown full trust in 'Paul Wight: The Wrestling Announcer Years' as of yet. What does Show have to offer WWE's future?

That's the question everyone should be asking once he's a free agent.


4. Matt Riddle

Matt Riddle
WWE.com

Sorry to any fans of the 'Bro' out there, but Matt Riddle is more trouble to WWE than he's worth.

The man himself has admitted that during interviews since being scrapped in late-2023. Riddle comes with a lot of poor PR baggage, and that might never change. He's a walking law unto himself away from the ring, and Triple H doesn't need those sorts of headaches given everything else that's been looming over WWE post-Vince McMahon.

Here's a worker who really should've gone on to main event pay-per-views (possibly even WrestleMania) and win countless World Titles. In-ring, Riddle is ace. On the mic, he's quirky and an engaging loose cannon. On the road? That's a different story. Matt brings far too much trouble to WWE's door.

There are others who can work the high quality bouts he does, so that isn't enough to offset all of the other bad bits. WWE showed patience with Riddle when he maybe didn't deserve any, and they weren't rewarded for that in the end either.

Patience ran out.


3. The Hardy Boys

The Hardy Boyz Matt Jeff AEW
AEW

This fan was there at WrestleMania 33 when Matt and Jeff Hardy's WWE return brought the house down. It was pop of the night, which is really saying something when stars like The Undertaker, Randy Orton, Seth Rollins and countless others were on the same card. People were legitimately buzzed to see The Hardys.

A lot has changed since 2017.

Their duel AEW runs flat out sucked. Let's not pretend that Matt or Jeff could be considered some great loss to Tony Khan's weekly product. They weren't capable of producing top notch matches against The Young Bucks (or other teams influenced by the brothers) that All Elite chiefs badly wanted them to.

Recently, Matt has been posting a lot about the potential for he and Jeff to benefit from WWE's alliance with TNA. They'd get a decent (albeit smaller) pop, but what comes next? NXT doesn't need The Hardys in-ring, put it that way. Other teams already on WWE's books deserve those minutes more.


2. Goldberg

Goldberg WWE SummerSlam 2019
WWE.com

Featuring Bill Goldberg on lists like this really stinks for an old WCW mark like the fella writing this piece. In fairness, WWE did the Goldberg revenge tour well at first - his matches vs. Brock Lesnar in 2016 and 2017 were exactly what they needed to be. Wheels fell off the wagon after that.

The company put too much faith in Bill and had him mow down stars like Kevin Owens and Bray Wyatt en route to Universal Championships. That was a step too far for many, and the quality veered wildly between fun (matches vs. Bobby Lashley) to downright awful (that Undertaker match) between 2017-2022.

No more, please.

Goldberg could pop back up for a cameo spear in the future, but nobody needs to see him wrestle in featured spots ever again. The less said about those AEW rumours the better too. He'd be the worst fit imaginable for Tony Khan's in-ring centric "dream match" factory.


1. Shane McMahon

WWE WrestleMania 39 Shane McMahon
WWE.com

Speaking of names linked to AEW, it's Shane-O Mac!

Yes, people have been discussing the likelihood of Shane signing on the dotted line with AEW and continuing his power trip trend somewhere other than WWE. Hell mend them if All Elite agree to that, because McMahon has been a menace for years now. Some of his work has tortured the fanbase.

Shane laughably became "Best In The World" by winning WWE's World Cup back in 2018, and that led to a run as one of SmackDown's top heels. It was so-so. Y'know what wasn't so-so? His disastrous back-to-back showings at the 2022 Royal Rumble and at WrestleMania 39 the following year.

McMahon was fired by his own father after trying to assert dominance in the Rumble. Then, at 'Mania 39, a match vs. The Miz was hastily changed to Miz vs. Snoop Dogg (?!) when Shane tore his quads. That should be a wrap on any desire to see the ex-'Boy Wonder' in-ring ever again.

Don't do it, Hunter!

Which other wrestlers should Triple H's WWE avoid? For more like this, check out 10 On-Air WWE Moments You Weren't Supposed To See and 10 Most Popular WWE Matches On YouTube! 


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.