10 Worst Simultaneous WWE Heavyweight Champions

For when the titles don't make the men...

By Michael Hamflett /

"It's bad enough that there's two titles in the first place", so sayeth older fans that were raised on the importance of the lone (and often beautiful) belt the men without trousers fought for in perpetuity, as was their modus operandi. But WWE's two dalliances with split brands since 2002 have just about justified the need for straps on both shows for the most part.

Advertisement

But then there are the dark periods.

Not to be confused with spells in which lifelong fans simply take wrestling breaks (something your writer perhaps should have indulged in a sanity-saving exercise once or twice over the last 30 years or so...), the dark periods in a two-title system cast shadows bigger than the ones left by bulky wrestlers themselves, and are substantially worse than when one sh*tty champion drags down the show.

Two top titles both being held by wrestlers not operating at the peak of their powers is effectively wrestling's saddest timeline, though it does at least create a window for the Superstar that steps in as a saviour.

It's the most subjective of debates, too. These forum views, for example, reflect that of the posters and most definitely not WhatCulture.com, but posit a hugely divisive pairing as a jumping off point. Let's analyse those first...

10. Kofi Kingston (WWE) & Seth Rollins (Universal) - 2019

Kofi Kingston and Seth Rollins are, as per the aforementioned forum posts, "dog sh*t". The same poster notes that "Seeing Seth and Kofi as champions is making WWE feel more like a high school indie company than ever before. Both "champions" are horrifying bad. Awful in every single way imaginable."

Advertisement

The take is immediately countered with a number of individually horrific titleholders (some of whom are still to come in this list), but most opposing views fail to address the original criticisms of the 'Dreadlocked Dynamo' and the 'Beastslayer'.

"High school indie company" is the sort of rhetoric spouted about the wrestling world outside WWE by those that don't watch it. A vision of the industry's subsect as curated by the market leader to undermine potential threats to the bottom line, no matter how small. But how much does it apply to Kofi and Seth?

Both are drenched in WWE's branding and build, discounting everything they'd done before signing with the organisation. Booked into corners they've bravely fought their way out of over long and arduous runs on the main roster, the title wins were arguably more important than the reigns, especially when early indications suggest they'll always be in the shadow of the Roman Reigns/Brock Lesnar superhero/villain archetype Vince McMahon will never abandon.

The jury's out, but the charge regretably isn't as baseless as it may first appear.

9. CM Punk (WWE) & Sheamus (World) - 2012

In stark contrast to the catharsis of Kofi Kingston and Seth Rollins topping the card, mid-2012's versions of CM Punk and Sheamus were babyfaces the audiences could have adored had they not been given reasons to rapidly lose faith.

Advertisement

CM Punk's needlessly complicated programme with Chris Jericho had made a Sports Entertainment oaf out of the 'Voice Of The Voiceless'. F*cking around in booze-based banter with 'Y2J' on Raw appeared to be the price they paid for putting forth a disappointing WrestleMania match that had initially been focussed on just who exactly was the "Best In The World". The contest delivered the answer - neither of them.

It took Daniel Bryan to rehabilitate Punk's run, after he'd inadvertently hijacked Sheamus' World Title Win by virtue of his relationship with the crowd. Audiences couldn't forgive or forget the booking of the infamous 18-second switch at the 'Show Of Shows', and vented their frustration in subsequent scuffles between the 'YES Man' and the 'Great White'.

An outstanding Extreme Rules rematch didn't linger as long in the memory as the original squash, and - like Punk's own feud with Bryan later that year - wasn't remotely considered worthy of going on last.

8. The Big Show (WWE) & Shawn Michaels (World) - 2002

The good will felt almost entirely isolated to the hallowed halls of Madison Square Garden when a Shawn Michaels unexpectedly scooped a final World Title win in the second of his two impactful 2002 return efforts at November's Survivor Series.

Advertisement

It was easy to be cynical - despite these strong showings, Michaels' comeback wasn't yet fleshed out as the real deal, and the glad-handing of Raw's top prize between Triple H and his best buddy (at the expense of a roster 'The Game' had started to systematically destroy at the time) overpowered their programme in the end.

SmackDown was at least a welcome distraction to some of the horsesh*t on Raw. Astutely penned by Paul Heyman and his team, the blue brand offered up slabs of banter so broad that Vince McMahon was too heart-eyed to notice the quality pro wrestling taking place elsewhere under his banner. Brock Lesnar was front and centre of the uprising, but his undefeated streak's termination at the typewriter-hands of The Big Show felt entirely unearned.

'The Beast' was working hurt and needed babyfacing before WrestleMania the following year, but (as with 'HBK's own reemergence on the same show), thinking about the future shouldn't have (yet again) involved visions of the distant past.

7. Alexa Bliss (Raw Women's) & Carmella (SmackDown Women's) - 2018

Great on their own terms, neither Alexa Bliss nor Carmella needed each other to be the other show's Champion during their divisive reigns with the respective Women's Titles. Not least after bad booking and Vince McMahon living down to expectations had failed them both.

Advertisement

Alexa Bliss was scripted to bully and abuse Nia Jax in the run-up to the extended sh*tkicking she took at WrestleMania, but won the feud two months later after using a Money In The Bank briefcase she scooped earlier that night to batter the 'Irresistible Force' and 'Baddest Woman On The Planet' Ronda Rousey during their own spirited scrap.

She was also blonde. This becomes important later.

Meanwhile, Carmella's cash-in on Charlotte was intentionally cheap, but her victory over 'The Queen' was disconcertingly dominant. As were her ill-gotten victories over the newly-idiotic Asuka in the months that followed. 'The Princess Of Staten Island' wasn't crafted to become credible, but her opponents were suffocating under the strain of her reign.

She was also blonde. This becomes important later.

SummerSlam brought humongous change, setting all the wheels in motion for the historic WrestleMania main event between Becky Lynch, Ronda Rousey and Charlotte Flair. Between those two pay-per-views, Lynch became 'The Man', but still had the task of removing Charlotte and everything she represented from the company's summit.

She was also blonde. That was important, in the end.

6. AJ Styles (WWE) & Brock Lesnar (Universal) - 2018

There are times in wrestling when, for reasons it seems hard to parse in hindsight, the product suffers despite the best intentions of all involved.

Advertisement

Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels couldn't draw mainstream numbers despite their matches being simultaneously futuristic and futureproof. WrestleMania XIX's cavalcade of stars from every generation couldn't commercially deliver buys comparable to the eras that birthed them. Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose couldn't save shoddy booking with that shoddy, shoddy match.

Such was the case in Autumn 2018 after Brock Lesnar was infuriatingly selected to take back the Universal Title after Roman Reigns' devastating departure. 'The Beast' took the red belt back at Crown Jewel, a pay-per-view so abysmal it reset the standard for modern era sh*te that also featured AJ Styles boring the f*ck out of some Saudi Arabians with another middling match against Samoa Joe.

He was supposed to take on Daniel Bryan before the 'YES Man' made his intentions on not travelling to the event abundantly clear. Styles had held the title for nearly a year at this point, but like the sagging series with Joe, his multi-show programmes with Shinsuke Nakamura, Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens had woefully underperformed.

Bryan, ironically, was the dawn that followed the darkness. His shocking pre-Survivor Series win over 'The Phenomenal One' (and the heel turn that went alongside it) supplied an immediate dream match with 'The Beast' that relit his fire ahead of an enjoyable Road To WrestleMania.

More's the pity these two felt so stale. It couldn't have been any further from their fight the prior year...

5. Jinder Mahal (WWE) & Brock Lesnar (Universal) -2017

AJ Styles was hailed as something of a saviour throughout October and November 2017.

Advertisement

He flew from Chile to Minnesota to help out (and substantially improve) a Tables, Ladders and Chairs pay-per-view with a firecracker of a clash against Finn Bálor, then travelled to a Manchester SmackDown Live taping to relieve the dreadful Jinder Mahal of the WWE Championship to not only set up a fantasy battle with Brock Lesnar but remove entirely the prospect of 'The Beast's planned mutilation of 'The Modern Day Maharaja'.

The Summer of 2017 was perhaps the most depressing in recent headliner history for WWE. Jinder cracked wise (and incredibly f*cking stupid) with Shinsuke Nakamura on Tuesdays, whilst Brock went back to not really turning up as his maiden run with the red belt ran on and on and on.

A two-week spell between September and October was one of the darkest hours for either strap. Lesnar, immovable as the part-time solution to the company's biggest problem in decades was set to square off with experiment-gone-wrong Mahal before Styles swooped in and took the title with just weeks to spare.

4. JBL (WWE) & Triple H (World) - 2004

A tricky one to process, this.

Advertisement

2004 Triple H was as entrenched in his reign of terror then as he was during any point between his 2002 heel turn and 2005 trifecta of losses to Batista. Loathsome for better and worse on the blue brand, JBL was a complete sh*thouse as the heel steward of SmackDown, though his reign begged for a babyface of similar stature to bring him down from his unearned perch. John Cena answering that call on the night Big Dave first flattened 'The Game' helped WWE draw one of their biggest ever buyrates, so perhaps both of these boring b*stards objectively successful after all.

But try watching the weekly products they presided over on the WWE Network.

Like Superstars from 1992, Prime Time from 1988 and even Sunday Night Heat from 1999, every moment is captured and preserved on the service to be viewed as close to context as possible. Unlike all three of those other options, these editions of Raw and SmackDown are at times torturous. Ordinarily in wrestling the end justifies the means, but never before had a traditionally-babyface promotion relied so heavily on horrid, horrid heels.

3. John Cena (WWE) & Alberto Del Rio (World) - 2013

From boredom that at least bloomed on pay-per-view we traverse a decade on to the last days of the medium WWE killed before declaring it as dead.

Advertisement

WWE lumped every supercard on their new $9.99 Network service in an effort to literally bully viewers into abandoning the old fashioned method. It'd be dumb to pay five times the price, they had Michael Cole actually f*cking say, to watch all your 2014 favourites for the dollars they stole from your pockets just a year earlier. Only then did it force fans to reflect on what they'd actually been watching all this time.

Alberto Del Rio's 2013 heel turn wasn't unwelcome, but the match that triggered the switch unfortunately returned the World Heavyweight Title to his possession long after he'd proved himself unable to carry the load. Reclaiming it from Dolph Ziggler after concussion issues knackered 'The Show Off's only proper stint with the strap, Del Rio was no more or less over as a heel but at least got to use his smug expression for evil rather than good.

Not like anything mattered after one of the worst versions of John Cena took back over anyway.

His three-year arc with The Rock concluded with 'Big Match John' becoming 'The Champ' yet again, more confident that ever before. Dishwater dull dalliances with Ryback in the post-WrestleMania slump foreshadowed the frustrating reliance WWE still had on old habits too...

2. Randy Orton (WWE) & John Cena (World) - 2013

...especially when fans actively, powerfully protested the use of both John Cena and Randy Orton as the men fit to fight over unifying the titles after the end of the original brand split.

Advertisement

For two men relentlessly pushed and protected over a decade that became preserved in nectar in their latter years, 'The Champ' and 'The Viper were never the icons the organisation desperately wanted them to be. This isn't a subjective take from a Generation Y fan gifted the likes of Hogan/Warrior and Austin/Rock in his formative years. Their Royal Rumble 2011 staredown, two years before this supposed scorched earth decider, presented deafeningly silent evidence about audience disinterest. And all before Daniel Bryan.

Daniel Bryan. The Daniel Bryan John Cena handpicked as his SummerSlam opponent just four months earlier that had, in the wake of winning that exact match, become the biggest star in the world. The Daniel Bryan John Cena had to park an infamous go-home segment with 'The Apex Predator' to acknowledge due to the voluminous support from the live crowd. The Daniel Bryan that lost a handicap match on the show Orton and Cena were set to headline over who was the "true" Champion.

He wouldn't be crowned for months.

1. Sheamus (WWE) & Kane (World) - 2010

The state of your f*cking 2010, WWE.

Advertisement

Champions both because they avoided The Nexus before John Cena ensured none of them remotely posed a threat to anybody, Sheamus and Kane were beneficiaries of 'The Champ' being otherwise engaged with Wade Barrett's crew of losers for much of the summer rather than programmes with challengers that justified their continued dominance on either brand.

'The Big Red Machine' in particular lasted far too long on fumes - his reignited feud with The Undertaker barely caught fire at all save for some absurd twists in the middle involving Paul Bearer. Where once mythology had come to life in a genuine money-drawing Sports Entertainment spectacle, the pair had exposed how every trick was ever played through their advancing years and lack of creative spark.

That same lack of spark had long rendered Sheamus' first main event push utterly, utterly pointless. His second title reign in a difficult first year began with a fluke and culminated in a turgid three-match series with Randy Orton that ended in a defeat as boring as any of his tainted victories. Randy Orton's win didn't salvage a lost year either - a cash-in loss to The Miz was the first breath of fresh air the belt had experienced all year.

Advertisement