10 Wrestlers Claudio Castagnoli MUST Face In AEW

Now that he's All Elite, it's time to get busy!

By Michael John-Day /

The time has finally come for wrestling fans across the world to rejoice. Claudio Castagnoli (formerly Cesaro of WWE) has finally made his debut in AEW. This has been a long time coming, as Castagnoli has been the most infamous under-appreciated workhorse of the wrestling world for years now.

Advertisement

While plenty of stars like Miro (formerly Rusev) and Malakai Black (formerly Aleister Black) were seen as missed opportunities from the land of Sports Entertainment, Castagnoli has topped almost every list of underused and underrated wrestlers.

The chance to create a new future for himself in the grassy hills of AEW has already gotten off to a fiery start, as he was the absolute centrepiece of the Forbidden Door event. But, now that the initial (but pretty predictable) shock of his arrival has cooled off, it's time to think about what he will be doing while he's in All Elite Wrestling.

With one dream match against Zack Sabre Jr. written off the checklist, it's time to start delivering on more. So, these are the AEW wrestlers who absolutely need to get a taste of the Swiss Superman.

10. Penta El Zero M

This is what happens when an indie darling gets taken off the independent scene and signed to WWE for a long period of time; a plethora of awesome matches get brushed off the table.

Advertisement

When Castagnoli first signed with WWE in 2011, Penta hadn't even made the jump from his long-term home promotion AAA yet. As the man with Cero Miedo rose through the ranks of the American independent circuit, Cesaro was living his life as a WWE superstar. So, now that the chance for this crossover is on the cards, AEW would be foolish not to take advantage.

Penta is a phenomenal and charismatic performer. His spot fest style going up against the technical skills of Castagnoli would keep their potential match varied and constantly exciting. Plus, his presentation is such a stark contrast to the newly All Elite performer that it would deliver a real clash of physical and visual styles.

You could imagine these guys tearing the ring up if they'd crossed over in PWG or MLW, so now is the time to make it a reality.

9. Ricky Starks

Castagnoli is a wrestler's wrestler, and as such, it'll be great to see him battling against younger performers to make them look good. Seeing a decorated veteran performer still in their prime tackling an experienced yet hungry upstart is a golden way to give both a big boost. One such candidate for Castagnoli has to be the current FTW Champ.

Advertisement

Starks is an incredibly watchable performer with a confidence that makes him melt right off the screen. He's quick, agile and smooth in the ring, meaning he can deliver an entertaining match with almost anyone he's paired with. Thus, chucking him in with someone notorious for being able to also put on a phenomenal bout with any opponent seems like a no-brainer.

If these two squared off, you could imagine the pacing of the match would feel like a pair of cheetahs pitting off in a 100-metre dash. It would be explosive, dynamic and fast, leading to a delightful experience for viewers and an excellent showing for this pair of wrestlers.

8. Orange Cassidy

When you think of Claudio Castagnoli, the first thing that comes to your mind is likely his technical in-ring wizardry. But, one thing people tend to overlook is his humour and creativity.

Advertisement

Vince McMahon once claimed he lacked "It factor", yet the man managed to make swinging people around one of the most over things in the industry. That's not just a sign of good wrestling skills but a showman who loves performing and having fun.

Even during his Forbidden Door entrance, he was goofing off with the camera guy, so why not give him a chance to clown around in an actual wrestling match? If you're going to do that, then there's only one freshly squeezed orange for the job.

Orange Cassidy is a wrestler like no other. His ability to tell hilarious and engaging stories is astonishing, and his Forbidden Door showdown with Will Ospreay is yet more proof of that.

If these two went at it, you could imagine them having a whale of a time. The spots would be creative, Cassidy could show off his underrated technical work, and Castagnoli could rub his comedy skills in his past employer's face.

7. Andrade El Idolo

And now, on this episode of wrestlers who should have met in WWE but never did comes Andrade El Idolo and Claudio Castagnoli.

Advertisement

Castagnoli and Idolo (both under different names at the time, of course) never got the chance to face off one-on-one on WWE television. The former Andrade Cien Almas spent most of his time on NXT, and even when he did break onto the main roster (and lost his surnames), he never got a televised dance in the ring with The Swiss Superman. The pair only shared one house show match in Zurich, so it's time to point the cameras at them.

Seeing them do battle in an AEW ring has all the potential to be a show-stealer. They're both great storytellers and have flashy styles that suit their individual personas. The pair could chuck out a bunch of ingenious maneuverers against each other, with feats of strength and agility bouncing all about the place and leading to a stimulating watch.

They're bound to have excellent chemistry and would no doubt put on one hell of a show.

6. Adam Cole

Poor, poor Adam Cole (Baybay!). This former Bullet Club member and winner of the Owen Hart Cup hasn't had the best of weeks. The insensitive comments about his body from Booker T got him off to a bad start, and his concussion during the IWGP Forbidden Door fatal-four-way dampened the ending to what was a really good match.

Advertisement

Things really aren't going his way right now. However, here's hoping he makes a speedy recovery for the sake of his health and to give him a chance to show everyone why he is so special in the first place. One good way to deliver on that once he's back in action is to put him in the ring with Castagnoli.

Cole and Castagnoli would surely deliver on something spectacular here as they're both incredibly charismatic wrestlers, dependable workers and real-life friends - as seen on the UpUpDownDown YouTube channel. There are also plenty of storytelling foundations here, thanks to their connections to ROH and the events of Forbidden Door. He's also yet another star Castagnoli never met in WWE.

Cole is a stunning professional wrestler, and this match would be a fantastic chance to ensure everyone remembers that.

5. Jungle Boy

Whenever a new face enters AEW, there's one opponent you always hope they get a chance to tangle with, and that's Jungle Boy. This pillar of AEW's homegrown talent is a fascinating performer, and seeing a veteran like Castagnoli go up against the future World Champion would be excellent for both of them.

Advertisement

In-ring-wise, Jungle Boy is a solid match for Castagnoli. He's small, light and quick, meaning he could jolt about the ring like a wild cat and dance circles around his larger opponent. But, of course, Castagnoli is no slow-poke himself, so seeing them tussle about the ring would be a real exercise in speed and precision.

Castagnoli could deploy the best of his uppercuts here, as Jungle Boy has no problem selling moves that launch him into the air. In equal measures, Castagnoli could make the real-life Luke Perry look like a million bucks by selling his strikes and giving the young man plenty of chances to shine.

There's no reason not to deliver on this, so AEW better not let everyone down.

4. Kyle O'Reilly

Next up on the list of wrestlers who totally could have had a dream match with Cesaro in WWE but never did comes the incomparable Kyle O'Reilly.

Advertisement

Castagnoli and O'Reilly are very much bred from the same cloth. They both made huge strides on the indie circuit, most notably in ROH, where they won plenty of accolades. By rising through the ranks and becoming legends of that promotion (and plenty more), they proved that they were destined for great things, and AEW could be the place to see their paths cross.

These two technically proficient performers would undoubtedly deliver a wrestling clinic, making purist fans foam at the mouth. Castagnoli and O'Reilly both have a solid understanding of old-school holds tied together with flashier strikes. Watching as they switch between grappling for dominance and beating the snot out of each other would be plenty of fun for casual and hardcore viewers alike.

With the right build, time and effort, this could be a classic ROH-style match-up but on a huge scale!

3. Sammy Guevara

Guevara is yet another one of AEW's pillars who needs the chance to face off against phenomenal opponents. Now that one has fallen into the laps of AEW, you'd better believe this showdown is going to happen.

Advertisement

Castagnoli is an excellent babyface, so going up against the cocky young Guevara would make for a perfect face/heel dynamic. Watching Castagnoli teach the young brat a lesson will make viewers jump in their seats, and it would be an ideal showcase for Guevara to run amuck.

The two are speedy, precise and explosive, meaning they're a flawless combo. Like Jungle Boy, Guevara is great at selling moves that see him flying across the ring, and this, paired with his lighter frame, would mean Castagnoli could have a ball with his impressive ability to lift opponents over his head.

As if to prove the money potential of this match, Guevara has already put the wheels in motion, sending out a tweet with the following message.

"I can't wait to beat up Claudio!"

Well, Sammy, fans can't wait to see you try!

2. Kenny Omega

V-Triggers vs uppercuts, which is going to come out on top?

Advertisement

The Best Bout Machine is also a Dream Match Machine, so squaring off with another of the same stock should be inevitable if All Elite Wrestling wants to put on a classic.

AEW fans haven't seen Kenny Omega wrestle since November of last year, and it's safe to say they're itching to see him return to the squared circle. Once Omega is back, he should set the promotion on fire again, delivering dream matches with CM Punk, Adam Cole and, of course, Claudio Castagnoli.

These two are considered some of the best in-ring performers in all of wrestling today, and it's hard to argue with that. They've got everything on their side, such as iconic moves, great stamina, storytelling skills and a boatload of talent. Putting them in the ring together would set the whole building on fire.

A match like this would be the perfect way for Castagnoli to prove that leaving WWE was the right call for his career. It's a once-in-a-lifetime pairing that fans never thought they'd get the chance to see, and it won't disappoint.

1. CM Punk

The currently injured AEW Heavyweight Champion has never shied away from telling people how big a fan he is of Claudio Castagnoli. He has been singing his praises for years, which shouldn't come as a surprise.

Advertisement

Punk is a pure bread ROH guy and a big fan of pro wrestling, both of which are golden ingredients for being a Castagnoli fanatic. So, with that kind of passion on one end of the spectrum and likely the same amount of enthusiasm on the other, you've got the makings of a match that will be filled to the brim with emotion.

Punk captures almost all the points from the previous entries and moulds them into one. He's another former WWE guy who never got the chance to wrestle Castagnoli one-on-one, has his roots in the independent circuit and is a phenomenal professional wrestler. All of these factors are the ingredients to a stellar, once-in-a-lifetime wrestling bout.

Fans certainly want to see Claudio in the World Title picture, so the thought of Punk vs Castagnoli also sporting some gold on the line seems like an easy PPV main event. Here's hoping it comes true.

Advertisement