10 Wrestlers With The Most Breakout Star Potential Right Now
Roman Reigns, CM Punk and Sasha Banks are the true needle-movers. Who replaces them?
Who in wrestling has the most potential to break through into the elusive "superstar" bracket?
This isn't necessarily a list premised on who might one day become the best wrestler on the planet, though this obviously informs that question to a significant degree in this modern era. The working standard is so high that a bad wrestler with the potential to not be sh*tty won't even get a look in. This is compounded by the fact that, in a digital age wherein virtually every indie is filmed and accessible to all, there's no hiding - only exposure, in the best and worst definitions.
John Cena in 2022 would be written off as a mechanically rotten worker who couldn't get through a five minute NXT 2.0 match without people saying he isn't and probably won't ever be ready in a cursed system. Cena's "workrate" isn't what made him a star. He impressed Stephanie McMahon on a tour bus with his freestyle ability, which informed his breakthrough 'Doctor of Thuganomics' character.
But would he even make it on the bus now?
A star nonetheless has to project star quality, they have to make fans interested in what they do the next week and the week after that, they have to impress in 18-49 quarter hours, they have to - to use a succinct reference point - do that which MJF has done since October 2019.
Who's going to move the needle?
10. Ricky Starks
Jim Ross had an old maxim he was fond of using when b*llocking wrestlers who weren't getting over in his old, fondly-remembered Ross Report column.
A charming haven of clichés and euphemisms, Ross used to write "[X Wrestler] needs to add a little "sizzle" to their "steak"", which was was a barely polite way of conveying "This feller is as dry as a nun's tw*t, and if there's any charisma in there at all, he better locate it very soon, quite frankly".
He also used to write "[X wrestler] needs to maximise their minutes", which was Oklahoma code for "This one has slightly more potential, but he's squandering it by being lazy and or thick".
Ricky Starks maximises his minutes.
He's a great visual storyteller, even in short backstage segments, because he knows the currency of the GIF. He doesn't just wear shades because they're a shortcut to looking cool; when he takes them off, to register how appalled he is when his threats are bantered off, he knows he'll shortly appear in Twitter replies. He's a great in the ring - one of few wrestlers to grasp how to do cool showboating work in character - and he sold Jungle Boy's Snare Trap finisher by literally scratching and clawing his way towards the ropes.
"Make sure they remember you" is the most valuable and difficult lesson on the wrestling curriculum. Starks has learned it, and he's not even the babyface everybody wants him to be yet.
9. HOOK
HOOK isn't just a meme, though AEW is potentially flirting too heavily with that aspect of his popularity by programming him alongside Danhausen.
Of course, Danhausen's presence acts as a deliberate contrast to HOOK's, who is meant to look even more like a serious, ass-kicking proposition stood next to the comedy act. Regardless of your perspective on the development - too cute, or fun and undeniably over - it is a temporary diversion designed to deepen HOOK's babyface appeal and slowly flesh out his character. The fans want to cheer him. They are now being encouraged to cheer him. It makes sense, even though it's also a weird continuation of a slightly wonky AEW device. Within the stable-heavy narrative framework, certain wrestlers barely appear alongside their stablemates (FTR, HOOK, Danhausen etc.)
HOOK is more than a meme because he isn't enjoyed ironically for a brief period of time before everybody moves onto the next thing. People don't invest in memes, and HOOK at one point late last year out-sold record seller CM Punk on Pro Wrestling Tees. Another strong indication of HOOK's staying power lies in those Rampage reactions. These crowds are exhausted, so much so that AEW has taken the bleak option of sweetening their reactions - and they still go opening-match apesh*t for HOOK.
So athletically gifted and fast that he seems to glitch into phases of awesome judo-inspired offence, HOOK has fused that with his smouldering pin-up disposition to become wrestling's next big thing.
8. MJF
The man himself would be appalled at his inclusion here.
Potential?!
He has realised his breakout star potential, arguably more than any "in-house" AEW talent. That description is always open to interpretation, so for the sake of clarity, read it as "wrestler with no prior WWE nor top-level NJPW experience who evolved from act with a following to bonafide draw via objective metrics".
Hangman Page's pay-per-view business is deeply impressive, but MJF was far less-known on January 1, 2019, and who really drew that outstanding number for Revolution 2021?
The match that went on last, blistering though it was, wasn't the main event.
MJF however has the potential to break through into an even higher stratosphere. The most complete wrestler in the game, MJF has managed something that has eluded every other wrestler this century. Not a single week of his programmes feel inessential. Through the lens of his manipulative character, a man who will only wrestle big matches on his terms but is so detestable that all of his rivals accept, MJF with his "stipulations" is must-see TV all of the time.
Quite how this all works if and when he's wrestling every week on RAW because that's how WWE works is another matter - but he's so good that he'll get over anywhere. He only gets better, too. Those under the belief that he's merely cosplaying as a heel are wavering now. He's undeniable.
Will he join the man who coined the phrase in WWE?
In any event, he's either getting pushed big on the biggest stage or will be the final boss of his current promotion.
7. Julius Creed
The usual take is that Bron Breakker is set to lead WWE into some transformative new era; that Bron Breakker is "can't miss".
There's a problem with that take, in that WWE is already missing his potential. Bron Breakker is an awesome prospect who WWE books like 2003 Goldberg because 1998 Goldberg isn't in their "playbook". Of course, he'll only learn the playbook by selling for prolonged periods, but does that flatter him? And must WWE matches follow the same virtually identical structure?
Already, Breakker has shown an inability to transcend sh*tty material, which he'll have to do if he wants to succeed on the main roster. His ongoing programme with Joe Gacy is risible in the extreme. Breakker is already on his goofy early '90s Ultimate Warrior trajectory, and he's never even approached his WrestleMania VI moment.
There is a breakout guy with amazing old-style jock energy in NXT, and his name is Julius Creed. Breakker is actually better right now, but Creed's performance in a recent Tag Title gauntlet match doubled as glimpse into his future; he emoted at a true TV level and to the required WWE standard after going an impressive distance with his brutally physical pop-friendly power game.
6. Yuka Sakazaki
Yuka Sakazaki has genuine Ace potential.
She is an enchanting, inordinately sympathetic babyface with an ability to dodge moves with a unique and witty counter game, graduate through story beats to make a respectful exhibition feel like a war down the stretch, and, given her frame and aesthetic, she is fantastic at wrong-footing the audience. To look at her, you might think her offence would look flimsy or that her act is too fun and wholesome to really get over at a main event level. This isn't the case; she's a very well-rounded worker.
The evidence for the argument is slight, but that almost works in her favour. She has appeared in front of AEW fans just twice in two years - versus Penelope Ford at AEW Fyter Fest 2021 Night 1 and against Riho on the May 6 Rampage - and on the second taping in particular, she drew a big reaction from an exhausted crowd that hadn't seen her in a year.
The Magical Girl is an irresistible act. Two of the biggest TV franchises of all time, Game of Thrones and Breaking Bad, were sold on the captivating premise of the unexpected badass. Yuka Sakazaki isn't going to seep into the mainstream consciousness like Anya Stark nor Walter White, but AEW has an enchantress on their hands.
A longer spell is surely all she needs to make magic.
5. Jade Cargill
Jade Cargill is already a star.
She's a star because she is a star. She possesses that which can't be taught: presence, intangible charisma, an incredible, striking look. She also possesses the most underrated promo game in the industry, having evolved from the promising albeit pause-ridden opening shot to Cody Rhodes in late 2020 into an economic, withering cut-down style that just oozes an aloof quality that serves her dominant character wonderfully.
But she's still not exactly complete in the ring. Her power-based offence is convincing and crowd-friendly, but she still gets lost in there and her downward elbow strikes and the standing position from which she unloads them still look awkward, and unnatural, like she's still learning the craft. And that's because she is, having only worked 32 matches.
Under the tutelage of Bryan Danielson, already, there are signs of significant improvement. Two of those 32 matches were triumphs; against Anna Jay in particular, Jade told a smooth, dramatic and focused story of outrageous hubris that was nearly her undoing, which informed one electrifying near-fall that required awesome body control to get over.
Once Jade is as composed in the ring as she is outside of it, she could be the most valuable female performer in the U.S. - and the green version of Jade Cargill is already the Demogoddess.
4. Konosuke Takeshita
The puro landscape has shifted in recent years. Collaboration is key to it now.
That's not to state that this is a lasting change - the Japanese scene mirrors all of wrestling, in that it is cyclical - but before the borders are re-erected, Konosuke Takeshita will have established himself as a performer so undeniable that he will follow Shingo Takagi's route to stardom. Shingo was so unbelievable as a propulsive warlord with the unreal ability to sustain his stamina levels over the course of outstanding, detailed main event epics that NJPW broke from long, established tradition to push an outsider all the way to the main event A tier.
Takeshita is his natural successor: a colossal unit somehow capable of hurtling his massive from one side of the ring to the other quicker than a blink. He's a super-worker with a godly power game, and while he could be more accurately described as a hybrid worker, that might suggest he's a 7.5 in every department when in fact he's sensational at most everything.
Check out that cheeky strut on Rampage as well - there's a showman under that visually impressive exterior, too.
3. Isiah Kassidy
It felt for a time like Isiah Kassidy was trending towards also-ran territory.
What was more of an indictment is that Private Party stagnated or even regressed before AEW aggressively expanded its roster across 2020 and 2021, the new members of which brought into focus just how many core/original acts weren't quite ready for television. The story was similar for much of their output: a far more botchy echo of their breakthrough match against the Young Bucks. That breakthrough evolved quickly into the opposite of the intended result; if anything, it was a measure of how good the Bucks really were.
This year, Kassidy in particular has impressed with his tighter in-ring, expressive scene-stealing character work and more confident disposition. He's stealing scenes he's barely in, too. He is grasping how to catch the eye from its corner, which bodes very well for a profiled role as an über-cocky singles heel.
This isn't to suggest than Marq Quen is "the Jannetty" - which is a bad take anyway, since, at the time, Jannetty was actually the better Rocker - only that Kassidy is really making the smaller moments count.
2. Roxanne Perez
Astonishingly, the one women's wrestler who instantly settled into life on NXT 2.0 with eye-catching poise was an established talent who earned the position by getting over in a different, established company: Roxanne Perez, the former Rok-C.
A wrestler's appeal is more than can be condensed into a single GIF, but just look at this incredible GIF.
Most wrestlers struggle to execute a suicide dive that looks like an impact move when they are directing it towards one opponent with only the ropes acting as an obstacle. Perez is such a gifted and prodigious wrestler that she with unreal accuracy controls her body to burst through Wendy Choo's legs and the middle and bottom ropes, which had formed a very tight tunnel of sorts, and the speed was impressive enough before you consider that she has to adjust her arms and hit a convincing clothesline on two wrestlers.
Agile, pacy, hugely likeable, and boasting an ability to tie her opponents up in knots with a frenzied mat game, Perez will doubtlessly endure rubbish "It was her dream, Pat! SHE DREAMT OF THIS WHEN SHE WAS YOUNG, SHE TOLD ME THIS EARLIER TODAY!" squawking from Michael Cole at some point, but you can't imagine resenting her for it.
1. Paige Van Zant
Brandon Thurston recently deep-dived into Google in a bid to determine which wrestlers draw the most interest online, and in doing so, he discovered that, of all the wrestlers currently contracted to AEW, the most searched-for act hasn't even debuted yet: Paige VanZant.
There's a strange quirk to the data that means it doesn't necessarily indicate who is the most over, lucrative or potentially lucrative act, in that of all people, Paul Wight, who you forget even works there, lands at #2.
But there's more to it than this one isolated study; VanZant has a huge, loyal online following for Jim Ross cowboy hat emoji reasons, projects star quality, and has a sort of legitimacy stemming from her UFC career. She lost the big ones, but in a worked business, AEW can make her 8-5 record seem more impressive than it is. This is effectively what they already do with Dark and Elevation.
VanZant already looks the part, as shown by her brief physical cameos, and combat athletes tend to "get" wrestling so well. If VanZant is as marketable and promising as the early indications suggest, AEW has a real star on their hands - a real needle-mover.