Predicting What The Entire Wrestling World Will Look Like In Five Years

Will Vince McMahon still reign supreme? Will he still even be IN WWE?!

The Rock
WWE

Five years ago, nobody predicted what would become of the pro wrestling landscape - but certain things were starting to converge.

Kenny Omega propelled NJPW into a new stratosphere of critical acclaim after his ****** epic with Kazuchika Okada at Wrestle Kingdom 11. NXT was deep into its ritual humiliation of sister main roster PPV offerings. With the babyface Roman Reigns character on top, that main roster was haemorrhaging viewers and interest. But few predicted that this stylistic shift would actually amount to anything meaningful; Ring Of Honor often got in its own way with wildly overlong and excessive shows, whereas New Japan while revered to a near-unparalleled extent was hardly a fit for weekly episodic North American TV.

If five years ago you'd have predicted that a billionaire tape trader would revolutionise the industry and frighten the monopoly, you'd have been branded literally the biggest "mark" of the lot.

In the folklore of the locker room, where certain people close to the situation still believe Montreal wasn't a shoot, the fable of the "rich investor" is literally the one thing a pro wrestler thought was a work.

It was a shoot.

If you'd said that Jinder Mahal would be toiling in undercard nothingness after his WWE Title run, then of course you'd have been right. Some predictions are safe.

Others...

11. The General State Of WWE

Roman Reigns
WWE.com

It has been a decade since Brock Lesnar returned. A decade. 10 years.

It has been longer still since the Rock made his in-ring return, since the Undertaker started to wrestle the annual Streak match at WrestleMania, since the "part-timer" era began in earnest. Throughout that entire time period - over a decade, just to reiterate - many fans, your writer included for a while, thought this approach was counterproductive to long-term success. Untenable.

Throughout that entire time period, WWE has posted record revenues and future-proofed itself by striking unprecedented mega-money deals with USA, FOX and Peacock.

The fortunes of professional wrestling will coincide with the fortunes of the television industry, and its biggest existential threat, streaming services, are in slight decline. Netflix is showing signs of not insignificant trouble, and is cracking down on password sharing to stop the bleed.

WWE meanwhile has located a solution within the problem. John Cena has now evolved into a very strong part-time draw, and Roman Reigns, by 2027, may well follow the same path. Cody Rhodes has opened the real Forbidden Door, and since he's both a star and prospectus to potential AEW recruits, his signature represents another quick solution to the inevitable long-term problem that is the risible NXT 2.0.

WWE can't really make new stars, but don't discount Bianca Belair or the potential within Montez Ford. And if they don't work out long-term, how much does that matter?

While the mid level of interest in 'Mania this year was notable - they really struggled for that not-so-packed house - Cena and Reigns can operate as the new Brock Lesnar and the Undertaker.

In short, WWE never really changes, does it?


10. The General State Of AEW

Tony Khan
AEW.com

At this rate, there is really only one major concern facing the future success of All Elite Wrestling: burnout.

No wrestling booker is ever great forever. Bill Watts revolutionised an industry that remains in his creative debt, but by the early 1990s, his approach was ancient and prohibitive. Vince Russo created a new model, but he drowned in his own masturbatory impulses. Giant Baba's quest for epic perfection was almost too successful. Vince McMahon's heroic babyface model is an artefact that hasn't produced a new generation of fans since 2008.

Khan's tape-trading e-Fed vision has thus far proven itself a winner; he isn't bound to one stubborn process nor style, he listens to fans because he grew up as a fan, and, if anything, is almost too future-focused. If there's a sense that he spends too long developing new acts without pitting his top stars together in lengthy programmes, it will reveal itself to be an astute long-term plan in the end.

Besides which, he draws outlines and trusts his talent to apply the loving detail. His process isn't an intensive, micro-managed slog. This is a man who booked the inaugural TNT Title tournament in about half an hour under very suboptimal conditions.

His booking isn't basic, either; the Wheeler YUTA push was typically, beautifully intricate. It was worth the journey. He has broken every rule thus far. Wrestling can be wrestling again. Certain markets, like Pittsburgh, aren't inherently "quiet". Pay-per-view isn't a dying relic of a medium.

Is "No booker is great forever" as tired a maxim as "small guys don't draw"?


9. The General State Of NJPW

Minoru Suzuki
IMPACT Wrestling

Hopefully they'll calm down sufficiently to actually get coverage again.

NJPW is past its peak, and really, it was coming before the pandemic. The 2019 G1 Climax was an absolute joy of a tournament - Jon Moxley was sensational in every single criteria, and the Jay White Vs. Kota Ibushi final was as emotionally intense and objectively perfect as pro wrestling gets - but Gedo's worn booking pattern had begun to reveal itself by then. Repeated combinations, mandatory lengthy main events worked by men who wore the strain on their bodies, Wrestler X defeating Wrestler Y, winning a bigger match, being challenged to undo the defeat by Y a few months later: it was all very familiar.

The pandemic accelerated the decline. EVIL working 40 minute main events as the double champion in matches that artlessly sought literally impossible heat, the old headline crew working matches more worthy than electrifying, the wackiness of the King of Pro Wrestling title...beyond Will Ospreay and Shingo Takagi, the promotion was on its arse.

But the flaws will be obscured when crowds are able to roar once again, and when it feels normal, the AEW relationship, folding in the Strong crew and building up the immense Young Lion ranks will rejuvenate the promotion's fortunes.

Not enough to enter a period as glittering as 2012-2019, but enough to make it feel closer to that than this.


8. The General State Of The Wider Scene

Jeff Jarrett GCW Die 4 This
GCW

This is far more difficult to predict.

Impact Wrestling will live on in some form, shambolic or otherwise. The promotion has garnered low-flying raves in 2022, but this is an aberration. Ring Of Honor will exist exclusively as a streamed feeder league; if Khan can procure a TV deal for it, it's difficult to foresee it lasting. The market will become oversaturated, and AEW has significantly more prestige worth protecting in the inevitable event of everything feeling diluted and normalised.

The puro scene is enjoying a remarkable period of collaboration, but the old, isolationist impulses will be felt as time unwinds. This cyclical pattern has unfolded with such frequency that it is what it is. Before the collapse, every promotion of note will enjoy a renaissance of sorts as the clap crowds become a distant, bleak memory.

The North American independent scene will eat itself in some way. The annual Spring Break Clusterf*ck is more overlong indulgent mess than party atmosphere irreverence now, and the niche patter circuit in general has lost its charm, as all novelty trends do. A more serious hotbed will emerge from the ashes of the forced fun; look who made it in AEW after the super-indie era, and who didn't.

They'll be making documentaries and retrospectives on Game Changer Wrestling, which has stubbornly refused to dislodge its tongue from its cheek when on the precipice of garnering attention on a wider scale.


7. Who Will Be The Best Wrestler In The World?

Hangman Page
AEW

The obvious temptation here is to predict greatness for Wheeler YUTA.

He's currently wrestling's most promising breakthrough act, having successfully completed an incredible spreed run from prospect to star with his gradual grasp of fire, emotion and violence. There are several more viable candidates; HOOK has a presence as tremendous as his unique, explosive athleticism, Ren Narita fully embodies everything great and legitimate about New Japan, and if the big stage counts more than any other, Ms. WrestleMania, Bianca Belair, is on course to own it like precious few others before her.

There are two choices here, both of whom are already fantastic and neither of whom are approaching their primes: MJF and Hangman Page.

MJF is the most complete wrestler on the planet. "In the ring, on that microphone" there are none better at maintaining interest in their episodic direction. Every single time the man appears on television, he delivers a home-run of an angle.

But Hangman Page is the one; crafting a career-long arc comparable only to Kenta Kobashi's, Page's odyssey transcends the usual pattern, and his highly intelligent approach to in-ring storytelling is richer than most. He will be 35 - i.e., the wrestler's prime - in 2027, and it is staggering to think what the legend of the Hangman will look like by then.

What he's doing is art, an unreal continuing story of unparalleled depth, and it will continue to connect him with audiences on a level just as deep.

If it isn't Page, it will be somebody nobody has heard of yet. The young, unbelievably great prodigy is somehow an archetype now - YUTA, Lee Moriarty, Daniel Garcia - and that is because the wrestling curriculum has never been more vast nor accessible.


6. Will Vince McMahon Still Be In Charge?

Vince McMahon WWE SmackDown
WWE.com

Yes.

Vince McMahon is a self-professed workaholic who doesn't consider what he does work. You might think, watching his product, which more often than not is incredibly phoned-in - the upcoming WrestleMania Backlash is literally three quarters full of rematches premised on the lazy idea that the original match somehow "didn't count" - that he no longer gives a sh*t. WWE feels like the opposite of a passion project, a low-effort content farm, and yet, Vince McMahon is very passionate about the minutiae of every last scripted detail. As much as it seems easy to put WWE programming together in a matter of minutes - book a f*ck finish and then un-f*ck it the second or third go 'round, job done - it somehow takes a very long and intensive time.

He loves it. He's not going anywhere. He will be 81 years of age in 2027, but that doesn't matter. They say "never say never" in pro wrestling, but the sight of Vince sipping margaritas on the beach and skipping leg day is simply inconceivable. He will be joined in gorilla not by Bruce Prichard, who will take the blame for a ratings dip at some point, and be replaced by Paul Heyman. Who, of course, will take the blame for a ratings dip at some point, and be replaced by Bruce Prichard.

Now, there's always a chance that Vince apples his infamous work ethic - which somehow came as a surprise to half of the doe-eyed wrestling media on the Pat McAfee show - to another area.

But that would require WWE being sold...


5. Will WWE Get Sold?

Disney+ streaming service
The Walt Disney Company

No.

It is imperative that Vince McMahon work. Work is his life.

His other favourite pastime is a brutal grasp of control.

This means that he has to work, and under no circumstances will he work under anybody else. The idea of Vince taking orders from a besuited exec is incredibly amusing, but sadly unthinkable.

"Hey Vince, let's rap. Our analytics department has presented data indicating that various midcard championships are no longer considered of any importance by our consumer base. Now, here at Disney, we're very much reboot-focused, and we feel-"

"F*ck off, pal!"

That isn't happening, is it?

With this in mind, Vince McMahon would have to launch a new endeavour to occupy his time - and he's failed at every single one of them. The restaurant business, the movie business, the football business - all total failures or arms of his business that nobody gives a sh*t about. The XFL is no longer his to reboot, WWE Studios is virtually inactive, and he doesn't know anything else.

What's he going to do, launch a crypto coin or an NFT?

It's far more likely that those terms will finally make into a RAW script in 2027.


4. What Does Women's Wrestling Look Like?

Kris Statlander
AEW

Because it doesn't look particularly great now, in North American anyway. The joshi scene will continue to flourish. The popularity of the '80s and early '90s will never be recaptured, but the quality might just get bettered at long last.

In the US, WWE has established something approaching parity, but the division is mostly a mess in which everybody beyond the select, protected few is banished to the sh*tty 50/50 churn of a tag division in which it is law for the champions to lose every single non-title match.

Frankly, little will change; if anything, looking at the hyper-sexualised recruitment policy of NXT 2.0, in which Roxanne Perez and Cora Jade are rule-proving exceptions, the division will regress further.

Tony Khan books the women's division like he does the men's, and it absolutely doesn't work. The established star versus upstart competitor device is a failure in the former because the emerging acts aren't anywhere near as promising or refined, and that has everything to do with the historical internal misogyny of the entire industry, which is lucky to have as many women as it has willingly enter it.

A revolution is far more likely to happen in one company more than the other, and while it would appear that AEW has located several cheat codes to marginalise the time allocated to the division - the Jade Cargill squash, the Serena Deeb Rookie Challenge, the Owen Hart Tournament squash qualifier - the volume of complaints will become too loud, and Tony Khan, using Women of Honor in the background, will adapt his philosophy to book more all-star women's matches on a similar principle to peak NXT. This is very, very optimistic, on current evidence.

But something major will transform everything...


3. Will Wrestling Finally Get Over The Things Most Fans Are Bored Of?

OC Dive
AEW

Yes, is the short answer here. To an extent, anyway.

WWE will do what WWE does, and WWE likes to promote more ladder matches in a year than there are months. In general, long-suffering fans have complained about gimmick PPVs and the stilted byproduct of booking programmes on the basis of a calendar and not a story. They still exist. They have existed for over a decade.

Elsewhere, we're already seeing a slow stylistic shift. Virtually everybody hates the outstretched arms welcoming dive spots. Even those who appreciate the pulsating rhythm of a great spot-fest can't sanction the glaring cooperation of that spot - but how often do you see it in AEW in 2022?

The arrival of CM Punk and Bryan Danielson, and the slow-burn push of those positioned to one day replace them, has illuminated the bad habits of certain members of the roster. These habits are now fading. Long for the sake of long matches are dying out too; since Double Or Nothing 2020, no match on any AEW PPV has exceeded 30 minutes in length. Lessons have already been learned from the histrionic excesses of the latter days of the TakeOver era.

Wrestling will continue to react to the marketplace and style itself accordingly, even if it takes a while.

Expect more gnarly head-scraping violence in 2027.


2. What's The Wildest Thing That Could Happen?

Sasha Banks
WWE.com

A new cable TV competitor forms.

Its founding member, the most vocal advocate for change, jumps right back.

CM Punk returns to wrestling.

Something unfathomable always happens in wrestling within a five year cycle...

...so what happens between now and 2027?

Sasha Banks jumps and moves the needle in AEW's favour in the key 18-49 demo battle.

The list of talents WWE has squandered in this modern era is endless; appropriately, this very website has compiled endless lists on that topic. Modern WWE is practically defined by its piss-poor handling of incredible, un-f*ck-up-able talent.

But Sasha is the one.

Sasha Banks is a vicious wrestler who is fantastic at transitioning between chains of offence with a sense of poise and fury in perfect balance. She sells moves like death. She gets GIF'd heavily for her - how to put this without appearing too much like one is wearing a cowboy hat? - displays of body language. She has no right to appear as cool as she does within the WWE system. And, if you disagree with all of that, it hardly matters. This wrestler has a following that is absolutely devoted to her. It's not as if WWE has to spend a dreaded few months to build her up consistently: she has an obsessed base that frequently make her the quarter hour draw in all of wrestling, and most of the time she's working nothing tags.

Imagine how much more popular she could be if she was pushed, consistently, as the focal point of the division without sh*tty, careless booking?

She has fallen out of love with WWE before, and gauging by her under-reported 2019 Japan tour, she doesn't live in the bubble.

Sasha Banks is the last needle-mover, or at least, the very best version of Sasha Banks is. We've not seen that version since 2015. This - WWE placing second for the first time in 24 years - would be massive. But it's not quite earth-shattering.

The next prediction is...


1. Will There Be A THIRD Major Promotion?

Triple H NXT
WWE.com

Yes.

Consider the landscape.

WWE has finally abandoned its sign-everybody-in-blind-f*cking-panic recruitment strategy. AEW's roster is beyond over-sized. The free agent talent pool is deep with the potential to expand even further, given limited opportunities in the latter promotion and Nick Khan's fondness for balancing the budget. Rights fees are projected to become yet more astronomical and in the meantime, as mentioned, the culture of binge-watching is showing early signs of fatiguing the consumer. Both WWE and AEW rank higher on cable than virtually anything beyond major sporting fixtures and the news, when something seismic happens. The stigma of wrestling as a lurid low-rent hobby for "the poors" is evaporating.

Nothing ever did come of the Domino's Nick Gage "furore", did it?

So who heads up this third major league, which Dark Twitter rumours suggest might already be in the process of forming?

Triple H is an easy pick; his NXT product didn't fare well on television, but he has significant name value and has fallen afoul of WWE's corporate structure. His health likely precludes him from fronting such a high-pressure venture.

Paul Heyman is well overdue his typical acrimonious exit, and while his Executive Director stint manifested in painfully dull gauntlet match theatre, he too has name value - and more credit in the bank these days, following his acclaimed input into the Tribal Chief character.

Jeff Jarrett, Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff are all much too carnified in 2022.

Who has a movie career that has seen better days, is suddenly a bit more apprehensive about his previously expressed political aspirations, is now more interested in business ventures, absolutely loves lots of money, knows a thing or two about wrestling, and is close friends with a former wrestling writer?

The Rock.

Rock and Brian Gewirtz doing sports entertainment right: it's a wild bet, but that's wrestling for you.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!