10 Wrestling Myths Debunked
It's still real to me, dammit!
I bloody love a good wrestling myth. They have been around arguably for nearly as long as wrestling itself. Whether it be the conspiracy theory that there were two Ultimate Warriors, WWE owning AEW in secret, or that Brock Lesnar breaking the streak wasn't planned, we all have our favourites.
Reddit user Belly Crawler recently sparked a discussion over on r/SquaredCircle about wrestling myths that need to be debunked after becoming frustrated with those arguing that John Cena was only pushed by WWE after Brock Lesnar left the company. In reality, Cena had been in numerous high-profile feuds and matches from the moment he debuted on SmackDown and became the catalyst for the Ruthless Aggression Era.
That theory is by no means the only wrestling misconception; some claim that WWE killed the likes of WCW & ECW, others that it was 'The Fingerpoke of Doom' that did for Ted Turner's company, and many insist that "This Is Your Life" is the highest rated WWE segment ever. All of these assertions are in fact, false. As you'll see as we debunk ten infamous wrestling myths...
10. "This Is Your Life" Is The Highest Rated WWE Segment Ever
A commonly held misconception by many wrestling fans is that the classic "This Is Your Life" segment hosted by Mick Foley for The Rock is the biggest drawing in the history of Monday Night Raw. In reality, it doesn't even make the top three.
Granted, this famous epic drew a huge 8.39 quarter hour rating, which is mind-blowing when compared to today's numbers, but three other events from 1999 actually beat it according to the Wrestling Observer's archives.
Unbelievably, The Stooges versus The Mean Street Posse did an 8.61 in May 1999. On the same show, in the main event we witnessed "the single most watched pro wrestling match in the history of cable television" at the time as Shane McMahon partnered with Triple H and The Undertaker to take on Vince, The Rock, and Stone Cold with Shawn Michaels as the special guest referee. That did a whopping 9.17 rating but still isn't #1.
That honour goes to Stone Cold Steve Austin vs. The Undertaker from the 28 June 1999 edition of Raw. The WWF Championship was on the line following McMahon family shenanigans at the previous night's King Of The Ring pay-per-view; The Texas Rattlesnake regained the title and the segment clocked a gigantic 9.5 rating.
9. Warrior No-Sold The Pedigree As Punishment For The Curtain Call
Pretty straightforward way of debunking this one...
The Ultimate Warrior def. Hunter Hearst Helmsley - WrestleMania XII - 31 March 1996.
'The Curtain Call' - Madison Square Garden Live Event - 19 May 1996.
The unforgettable 'Curtain Call' incident took place after Warrior beat the then Hunter Hearst Helmsley in 99 seconds at 'Mania after completely no-selling the Pedigree. Get your facts straight.
8. Hall & Nash Are The Reason Wrestlers Get Guaranteed Money
Scott Hall and Kevin Nash are often held up as the justification for many wrestling companies, WWE included, paying wrestlers a 'downside guarantee' - effectively a baseline income which guarantees a minimum amount they will be paid regardless of how they're utilised, with merch sales and bonuses on top.
This myth came about as a result of Hall & Nash's legendary leap to WCW during the Monday Night Wars. Diesel and Razor Ramon became The Outsiders and alongside Hulk Hogan formed the nWo to change the wrestling landscape forever.
Nevertheless, despite commanding ludicrous contracts with Ted Turner's promotion, the duo weren't the catalysts for wrestlers getting guaranteed money. That honour goes to Marc Mero, who went the opposite way to The Outsiders months before they headed down south. After a bidding war between WCW & WWF as Mero's contract with the Atlanta promotion was coming to an end, Vince McMahon offered the former Johnny B. Badd his first-ever guaranteed contract to join his promotion. WCW soon followed suit when touting talent to keep pace with the Fed, and subsequently scored the services of Hall & Nash. The rest is history.
7. The Fingerpoke Of Doom Killed WCW
There are many reasons why WCW died: Vince Russo, the mishandling of Goldberg, Vince Russo, overlooking talent like Chris Jericho, Vince Russo, putting the world title on David Arquette, and of course, Vince Russo. WCW went for the 'Death By 1000 Cuts' approach to going out of business. However, many fans would point to the Fingerpoke Of Doom as the death knell for Ted Turner's promotion.
In the main event of Nitro, World Heavyweight champion Kevin Nash faced Hollywood Hogan for the title, but instead of a classic match between the leaders of the nWo's opposing factions, Hogan lightly tapped Nash on the chest who sold it like he'd been shot, Hogan pinned Nash to become champ and the nWo reunited as the crowd pelted the ring with rubbish.
When you couple this godawful storyline with the inexplicable decision to announce that Mankind was going to win the world title on Raw, reports claim that 700,000 switched from Nitro to Raw that night. Regardless, the Fingerpoke Of Doom wasn't the thing that finished off WCW or even began the downward spiral, it was simply one in a seemingly never-ending spree of bad booking decisions that did for them. Kevin Nash even has the stats to back it up...
6. TNA Signed Every WWE Cast-Off
TNA developed a reputation over the years for signing whoever WWE released and immediately pushing them over their homegrown talent. We saw the likes of Christian, Kurt Angle, Booker T, and Jeff Hardy picked up just moments after Vince McMahon deemed them surplus to requirements. However, the argument that TNA would have been nothing without WWE stars is untrue, and claiming that they signed every WWE cast-off is a downright lie.
In TNA's defence, the Raw and SmackDown superstars they signed were designed to attract more wrestling fans to the product in a way indy stars simply couldn't due to name recognition, and Angle, Hardy et al. certainly did that for a period. Granted, for every former world champion there was an Orlando Jordan or Black Reign, but TNA also developed talents like AJ Styles, Christopher Daniels, and Samoa Joe.
In simple terms, whilst TNA was perceived to be living off Vince McMahon's scraps, they had a phenomenal non-WWE roster and passed on guys including Carlito & my best friend Wade Barrett. Just because you came from The Fed didn't mean you were guaranteed a job in TNA... unless you were a legend of course.
5. WWE Killed WCW/ECW/TNA
The claim that WWE killed off these three companies merits far greater detail than we're going to go into here, but in the most basic terms none of them died as a result of WWE's actions.
The simplest one to tackle first is TNA. If they had ceased to exist the only company to blame would be Total Nonstop Action for their dreadful decision making. Thankfully, they simply metamorphosed into Impact Wrestling which they exist as to this day. WWE can't kill what isn't dead.
Whilst WWE (and WCW) did consistently raid ECW's roster and Raw eventually took their TV slot, ECW went out of business because of a lack of money (the PPV company owed them a huge amount of money when their doors closed) combined with the inability to secure another national television deal.
Finally, WWE unquestionably contributed to WCW's demise and commandeered its stars and tape library after it was done, but when Time Warner merged with AOL and the higher ups at Turner Broadcasting decided it was no longer a place for professional wrestling, that was the final nail in WCW's coffin.
4. DX Were WWE's NWO
If you believe WWE's version of events, D-Generation X were simply WWE's version of the nWo. Triple H and his gaggle of bastards were basically the same as Hulk Hogan, Kevin Nash, Scott Hall et al. That just isn't the case. This is the purest example of history being written by the winners of the Monday Night Wars.
Granted DX, like the nWo, were a cool, rebellious stable with epic entrance music, captivating colour schemes, and iconic catchphrases. However, that is where the comparisons end. The stable may have become a bloated mess but the New World Order featured far more world class wrestlers who won 30 world titles to DX's 22.
Furthermore, although WWE would have you believe the New Age Outlaws riding Trip's tank* to invade Nitro basically won the Monday Night War (it didn't), the nWo were the driving force behind WCW's 83 week streak whereas DX were bit-part players in WWF's revival, which was down to Stone Cold Steve Austin.
* - Whilst we're at it, it wasn't a tank, it was a jeep with a cannon on it.
3. WWE Gave Up On The Lockbox Angle
Heading into WrestleMania 32, WWE concocted a preposterous storyline whereby a returning Shane McMahon threatened to reveal a secret hidden inside a lockbox and ended up facing The Undertaker inside Hell in a Cell with a potential GM role & the lockbox on the line... oh and The Undertaker's retirement. In the end, 'Taker emerged victorious at 'Mania, Shane had to surrender the lockbox to his father who inexplicably gave him a quasi-GM role, and WWE forgot about the whole thing in a matter of weeks.
The myth that fans perpetuate to this day is that the company "gave up" on the lockbox angle; that the mystery surrounding whatever Shane was holding over Vince's head to convince the Chairman to put the position of Raw General Manager up for grabs was discarded. In reality, the contents of the lockbox were merely a way to set up this headline match for The Show Of Shows. I'll admit it's incredibly underwhelming for it to be a plot device and whatever the lockbox contained never to be revealed, but they didn't drop the angle. WWE simply concluded it by keeping the secret a secret because Vince's guy won... and on the Raw after WrestleMania McMahon announced he'd destroyed the lockbox's contents so now we'll never know.
2. If You Can't Talk, You Can't Main Event
Batista.
Rey Mysterio.
Sid.
The Ultimate Warrior.
Kofi Kingston.
Jeff Hardy.
Lita.
The Great Khali.
Lex Luger.
BROCK LESNAR.
Every single one of those names has been a world champion despite their perceived inability to talk, and even WWE golden boy Roman Reigns has struggled on the stick in the past. Despite Vince McMahon's best efforts, in-ring talent eventually shines through for most superstars and even if you're not a great talker, you can still main event. Well, unless you're small.
1. Bret Could've Shown Up In WCW As WWF Champion
The Montreal Screwjob is a legendary incident of controversy in wrestling history. Although arguments about how and why it went down persist to this very day, the general consensus is that Earl Hebner, on the orders of Vince McMahon and with the involvement of HBK, called for the bell during Bret Hart versus Shawn Michaels during the main event of 1997's Survivor Series despite Hart not submitting to Michaels' sharpshooter. The justification for these actions was to take the prestigious WWF Championship away from Hart who was on his way to the WWF's rivals, WCW.
The myth that needs debunking here is not whether or not the Screwjob was a work, but that Vince had to take the title off Bret so he didn't show up the next night on Nitro with the belt. Fans will claim that The Hitman would've caused a PR disaster less than 24 hours after Survivor Series and embarrassed his former employers by taking their most prized possession to their arch-nemesis just like Alundra Blaze did.
In reality, WCW were already in court for that incident due to belts being considered IP of the company and wouldn't have risked another lawsuit. Plus, Bret was still contracted to the WWF the night after Survivor Series and even offered to drop the title on that night's Raw originally. So, in the words of Vince McMahon himself, there's absolutely no chance in hell Bret Hart could've shown up in WCW as WWF Champion.