11 Ups & 3 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (24 Sept)
Bryan and Reigns unite in the face of chaos; Shane McMahon puts it all on the line.
The SmackDown Live on USA Network era is dead; long live Friday Night SmackDown on FOX.
Last night saw WWE set their blue brand off on its bold new voyage with a fun, breezy show typical of SD over the past few years. It was a fitting season finale in that regard. While nothing within these two hours touched last week's highs, almost every match or segment worked, the flaws were borderline nitpicks, and it established a number of new points for the FOX debut and Hell In A Cell to pay off.
The ongoing Daniel Bryan and Roman Reigns vs. Erick Rowan and Luke Harper continued with the babyfaces getting the upper-hand after last week's destruction. Speaking of destruction, Brock Lesnar was nowhere to be found, meaning Kofi Kingston was restricted to a pre-recorded interview segment. Elsewhere, we got Sasha Banks going after Becky Lynch, a couple of effective squash matches, The Kabuki Warriors' return to television, and Shinsuke Nakamura vs. Ali.
Let's break it down...
(Author's note: after two-and-a-half years in the saddle, this is my last SmackDown Ups & Downs column. Another writer will take over following the move to Friday nights and I'll be covering AEW Dynamite going forward. Thank you for reading, commenting, and following this generally good weekly show with me.)
Downs...
3. Closing On A Whimper
No regular WhatCulture column celebrates deviations from formulae like this one, but WWE's decision to close last night's SmackDown on an interrupted backstage promo didn't quite pay off.
Becky Lynch was in the guts of the building, talking about her Hell In A Cell match with Sasha Banks, when 'The Boss' jumped her. 'The Man' tried to fight, but was overwhelmed almost straight away. Banks peppered her with strikes, tossed her off a wooden board, pressed her face against a steel mesh fence, then called Becky a "nobody," not relenting until Lynch was rolling around in pain on the floor.
This would have come off a little better elsewhere in the show. The beating wasn't emphatic or brutal enough for this spot, meaning that SmackDown went off the air without any kind of "oh sh*t" factor, and that WWE dim the crowd noise during skits like this didn't help either. This production choice meant the show closed without as much as a murmur from the muted audience, and it felt weird.
2. A Fire Extinguished
It was great to see the Kabuki Warriors back on television last night. It looked like they'd been cast into oblivion following manager Paige's neck surgery, having not wrestled on SmackDown since 16 July, but they're too talented to be left sitting on the sidelines. Their re-emergence versus Fire and Desire was a welcome one.
It's unfortunate, then, that the match wasn't all that. This was a clunky, awkward affair that successfully put Mandy Rose's character over as she paraded around with her Maxim magazine cover, but accomplished very little else. Fire and Desire and the Kabukis had little demonstrable chemistry and there were moments when it felt like they were a split-second apart, resulting in an ineffective bout that totally failed to hook the crowd.
The Kabuki Warriors scored the victory following Kairi Sane's beautiful elbow drop. It looks like Fire and Desire are on the slide nine days after challenging for the Women's Tag Team Championships.
1. In Which Elias Makes A Bunch Of Height Jokes
Nope.
(In all seriousness, this was well-performed by Elias... but change the bloody script already. Stop hindering Chad Gable's ability to get over by highlighting his most obvious flaw every week, please. Last week's beatdown of Baron Corbin should have been the end of this.)
Ups...
11. Spirit Crusher
Ali vs. Shinsuke Nakamura is an odd one to review as the match was more than good enough to finish as an Up, with the former 205 Live standout entering a spirited performance against the Intercontinental Champion, though the booking doesn't make a lot of sense.
The 30 July episode of SmackDown saw Ali pin Nakamura in a non-title match. It looked like WWE were heading towards a title fight at the time, but they dialled back, sending Ali back into the shadows while 'The King of Strong Style' focused on other things. Then, last week, the storyline was seemingly revived as Nakamura and Sami Zayn battered Ali, leading to this: a non-title singles match that the former Mustafa lost.
Though the quality of the work sees this bout slide into the Ups by a fanny hair, situations like this are why WWE's creative team get so much flak. They should be doing better.
10. Big Creepy Otis
Too weird to live and too rare to die, Otis needs to be treasured.
The backstage segment in which he and Tucker perved over Mandy Rose's Maxim shoot was accidentally hilarious. Mirroring his creepy social media form, Otis asked for a selfie, got one, flicked through the pages, then did intense Otis Things as his Heavy Machinery tag partner got involved, endorsing Dozer's oddness.
This was complete nonsense, really, but it's entertaining... sooooo, screw it?
9. Brevity Is Key
Keeping the Kevin Owens/Shane McMahon People's Court segment short was a wise move. With many fans burnt out on the angle, stretching their back-and-forth for 15-20 minutes would've killed any remaining anticipation for their forthcoming showdown, even with the promise of Shane's departure in the event of a defeat. Props to WWE for that, and the performances were on point as well.
McMahon came out with a gang of lawyers, saying that he'd keep KO in court for years for his "frivolous" lawsuit and drain him financially. The former Commissioner gave his rival the chance of a keen slate if he dropped said lawsuit, but Owens declined, called Shane an idiot, and said that while he hates going legal, he hates McMahon's presence even more. It's not about money, but getting rid of a tyrant.
This led to Owens throwing down the ladder match challenge for next week's FOX debut and Shane's silent acceptance. Finally, we're getting a resolution. Here's hoping it's concrete and not another swerve.
8. Shane's Microphone Taps Out
Hands up who caught Shane McMahon trying to accept Kevin Owens' ladder match proposal after his microphone had been switched off?
Big lols.
7. The "B" Stands For "Battered"
The B-Team got their heads kicked in by Big E and Xavier Woods as SmackDown crawled through its second hour, and it was everything it needed to be.
Bo Dallas and Curtis Axel got a couple of spots in. Woods got grounded and briefly worked as the face-in-peril leading to a B-Train around the ring, which E cut off by joining the party then clobbering the goobers. Back inside, E got the tag, Woods hit the top rope, and the Midnight Hour finished the jobbers off.
Big E and Woods needed a little heating up after taking the loss in their last two-on-two bout. They accomplished it with minimal fannying around here, and while brief, the squash was entertaining enough.
6. Talk Sh*t, Eat Sh*t
Speaking of squashes, here's Chad Gable battering Mike Kanellis in less than thirty seconds.
The sequence of events that culminated with Kanellis tapping out to the ankle lock began with Gable hitting the ring for promo time. He spoke about Baron Corbin and the constant barrage of "lol you're short" jokes, claiming that he'd proven his credibility in the ring, where it matters, and that the new King of the Ring knew this. Out came Kanellis with a few barbs of his own and the bold claim that he was there to show his wife that size does, indeed, matter. Cool.
Mike's destruction came quickly, with a suplex and Chaos Theory preceding the submission. Chad looked great, Kanellis looked like a dope, and the world keeps on spinning.
5. Minimal Fuss
One of two things was going to happen when Carmella and Charlotte Flair vs. Bayley and Sasha Banks was put together:-
1. A screwy finish to maintain enough heat for a transition into Bayley vs. Carmella for the SmackDown Women's Championship.
2. 'The Princess Of Staten Island' taking the fall.
'Mella did end up taking the fall, but to Sasha Banks. This should mean a potential clash with Bayley is still on the table, as it's unlikely that she was thrown into this group of wrestlers for a two-week filler storyline, though you never know with WWE's booking.
The match itself was short and functional and Flair not taking the fall protects her for her own title fight, if that's where the company choose to go next. Her Figure Eight was countered out of late on, before Carmella tagged in, ran wild, and took out the interfering Bayley, allowing Sasha to take advantage of her divided attention with the Banks Statement and the 1-2-3.
4. Kofi's Confidence
WWE's sit down interview segments are rarely anything less than good, and last night's saw Kofi Kingston, who's on top of his game right now, tell Michael Colle that he is, indeed, on top of his game right now, and he's ready to face Brock Lesnar on next week's FOX debut because he's on top of his game right now. Turns out the WWE Champion loves that phrase.
This format works because the pre-recorded style makes it easy to protect less-than-convincing talkers, who can reshoot any flubbed lines. With a good-to-great talker like Kingston, they're just as effective, and Kofi conveyed supreme confidence as he spoke about the upcoming Lesnar clash, claiming that while most think 'The Beast Incarnate' is there to have his way and walk out as champion, he has faith in his ability and is ready to walk out with the gold on 4 October.
As flawed as Kingston's reign has been at times, WWE have done a tremendous job of presenting him as a spirited, fighting champion, and his confidence growth has been handled naturally. It's nice to see a modern Sports Entertainment babyface with a deep understanding of just how good he is but never comes off arrogant.
3. Hey, Rowan Can Talk Now
Remember Erick Rowan's last singles run? That experiment was a disaster. This one most certainly is not, and his strong presentation continued in a solid SmackDown opening segment.
The show began with a well-edited video package that felt as crazy as whatever's going on inside Rowan's head at the moment. Last week ended in disarray as Rowan and Luke Harper destroyed Daniel Bryan, Roman Reigns, and ringside, and the highlights reflected this, as WWE not only recapped the scene in effective fashion but set the table for Rowan's promo.
Big Erick stomped down soon after. He sounded more assured than ever before on the microphone, saying that while some people paint or song, what he does is annihilate, and he drew great heat throughout. The fans were already pouring vitriol upon Rowan before he opened his mouth, but his "I create a violence that commands respect" spiel played out to loud "you suck" chants showing, definitively, that this push is working.
Fiery babyface Daniel Bryan came out in his wrestling gear, challenging his former partner to fight him there and then - and fight they did...
2. Rowan, Elevated
Daniel Bryan is the perfect opponent for any wrestler WWE are trying to elevate because the man is absolutely selfless. He'll eat all kinds of sh*t if it means getting his opponent over as he's devoid of ego, understands his role perfectly, and is one of the few people on the roster who can believably be called a wrestling genius, with Kofi Kingston, Heavy Machinery, and now Erick Rowan all on the long list of wrestlers who've benefitted from working with him this year.
Rowan and Bryan worked a strong opening match with a classic David vs. Goliath format enhanced by Daniel's evasiveness, as the former WWE Champion slipped out of holds and tried to chop the big tree down. He sold like crazy for the brutish big man and Rowan, to his own credit, looked menacing throughout, though he's still growing into his role as a singles wrestler.
The finish came when Harper stood on the announce table for the distraction, allowing Erick to drag Bryan back into the ring and hit the Iron Claw, only for Daniel's leg to get trapped in the rope. This enhanced the brutality. Finally, after untangling Bryan from his coil, Rowan hit another finisher for a strong, strong victory.
1. Brawl For All
Everything about the Roman Reigns and Daniel Bryan vs. Luke Harper and Erick Rowan storyline delivered last night, with the post-match angle the best thing on the whole show.
Rowan and Harper assaulted Bryan after the bell. They readied the announce desk to put Daniel through it, only for Reigns' music to hit. Out came 'The Big Dog.' He was typically explosive as he went after the former Bludgeon Brothers, nailing a Superman Punch on Rowan, then fell to the numbers game, only for a fired-up Bryan to jump right in, help Roman take care of business, and clear the ring.
Afterwards, Reigns offered Bryan his hand. Daniel swatted it away. Instead, he got up of his own accord, grabbed a microphone, and said that all he wanted was a one word answer: "do you want to see me and Roman kick their disrespecting asses?".
Cue: massive "yes!" chants.
Bryan not just taking Reigns' hand and suddenly being his pal after almost a year as one of the most obnoxious heels in the company was a smart move. It's more believable that way, though it could result in a miscommunication finish at Hell In A Cell.