12 Burning Questions For WWE Payback 2016

Will Finn Balor debut? Will Shane continue to run Raw?

By Scott Carlson /

It’s the first PPV of the new era in WWE… and it could quite possibly be the last.

Advertisement

That’s more or less how WWE is selling the first PPV after WrestleMania XXXII, with a completely fresh main event in the form of Roman Reigns versus AJ Styles for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. Additionally, two NXT callups are battling for the #1 contender’s spot for the Tag Team Championships. And a resurgent Cesaro is competing for the Intercontinental Championship. Throw in the first WWE bout between Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens, along with Dean Ambrose taking on Chris Jericho, and you have a different kind of PPV.

But unfortunately, that is not necessarily what WWE means by “new era.” Instead, the branding more accurately points to the person in charge of Raw right now. For the first time in nearly four years, the McMahon “running” WWE’s flagship program is not a heel character. Rather than the Authority (Triple H and Stephanie McMahon) or Vince McMahon, prodigal son Shane McMahon has been in charge of the past four episodes of Raw.

Regardless of WWE’s branding, this PPV does reflect a new era in terms of stars at the top of the card. There’s no John Cena, Randy Orton, Triple H, Brock Lesnar, Undertaker, Seth Rollins, Kane or Big Show. That’s a surprising development, but it also makes for interesting TV.

So let’s look at some of the big questions that needs answering this Sunday at WWE Payback…

12. Does Anyone Care About Kalisto/Ryback?

It hurts to write those words about two men who clearly care about their work and are trying to put together an interesting program. Ryback has been walking a fine line between face and heel, acting like a condescending big man rather than a straight-up bully, while Kalisto has been the underdog champion for several months, but he’s been given little to do as champ.

Advertisement

The result is a United States Championship match that was added almost as an afterthought last week and taking place during the Payback kickoff show. That match itself is a rematch from the WrestleMania kickoff show. That means that for two straight PPVs, the U.S. title will be defending in a pre-show match, after being around the waist of John Cena for much of 2015.

That’s quite the fall for a title that was defended in the main event of a PPV less than a year ago.

11. Is Dolph Chopped Liver?

Remember when Dolph Ziggler cashed in his Money in the Bank briefcase the night after WrestleMania XXIX and defeated Alberto Del Rio. Remember the thunderous ovation from the crowd?

Advertisement

That was just a scant three years ago, but now Dolph is poised to be a stepping stone for newcomer Baron Corbin. The Lone Wolf debuted at WrestleMania this year and won the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal, and it looks like WWE is trying to make that mean something this time around. Corbin immediately targeted Ziggler the night after Mania, and the two have been feuding since.

Dolph finally got one up on Baron on Raw last week, but is that just a last gasp before Corbin steps on his head on his way up the ladder?

10. Who Will Challenge New Day?

Having run through all of the teams in WWE, New Day needed new challengers to the Tag Team Championships they’ve held since SummerSlam. So it’s only fitting that the final two teams in an eight-team tournament to crown new #1 contenders are recent NXT call-ups.

Advertisement

Enzo Amore & Colin Cassady are probably better suited to continue their feud with the Dudley Boyz, while the Vaudevillains are rumored to already be on the outs with WWE brass because their NXT gimmick doesn’t seem to resonate with them. (Shocker.) Still, these are two pairs who have competed as units for some time and have some good chemistry, not just with their partners, but against each other. That should make for a good little match here.

But who should emerge as New Day’s next opponent? Could the Dudleys cost Enzo & Cass a shot at the titles? Or will the Vaudevillains be silenced and sent back in line?

9. Will Bret Put Flair In The Sharpshooter?

Oh come on, like you aren’t sitting there and hoping that this will happen. Why else would you have both of them there?

Advertisement

Sure, when Natalya and Charlotte battled for the then-vacant NXT Women’s Championship a couple years back, Bret “Hitman” Hart and Ric Flair were there to cheer on their respective family members, and no shenanigans ensued. But in Sunday’s match, we have a very clear heel in Charlotte, and her father has been involved in several of the decisions. Bret being there is not just for moral support, but to counter the Nature Boy’s presence.

Hart defeated Flair for his first WWF Championship way back in October 1992. Wonder if the announcers will drop that bit of knowledge during the PPV.

8. Does Nattie Stand A Chance?

As great as it is to see Natalya getting a push like this and a spotlight on television again to showcase her talents, does anyone think she’s going to walk out of Payback with the Women’s Championship?

Advertisement

Many fans assume that Charlotte will eventually drop the title, but it won’t be to Nattie, it will most likely be Sasha Banks who takes the title from the Queen. Natalya, for better or worse, is likely just filling a spot as a challenger for a month or so until a program between the two former NXT champs can begin anew.

That doesn’t mean we shouldn’t enjoy Sunday’s match. And who knows? WWE seems to love pulling a surprise every now and again.

7. Will Ambrose Topple Y2J?

Dean Ambrose has not had much success when it comes to winning feuds.

Advertisement

He lost feuds with Seth Rollins over the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. He lost a feud with Bray Wyatt. He lost a world title match against Roman Reigns when the title was vacant, and lost a triple threat title match at Fastlane. He was the last man eliminated in the Royal Rumble this year. And of course, he lost to Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania.

That’s not to say that Ambrose is in danger of being a glorified jobber by any stretch. But when you’re regarded as the #2 babyface on the roster, constantly losing feuds and big matches doesn’t help your standing. Eventually, you have to start winning feuds and big matches, or fans are going to tire. No one wants to root for a loser.

With Chris Jericho, Ambrose has someone who he should (theoretically) be able to defeat and get a little momentum, right?

6. Who Wins First Round Of Zayn/Owens?

One of the more hotly anticipated matches on Payback’s card among fans isn’t a title match. It’s the first WWE singles match between Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens.

Advertisement

The two former best friends and now bitter rivals have battled since Owens’ debut in NXT late last year, and WWE has not hesitated to play up their real-life friendship on the independent circuit. A video detailing the friendship/rivalry shown on Raw was really well done, giving fans some good perspective into why this is a personal feud, not just your typical WWE feud of the month.

Given that, it’s pretty clear that this is just the first match between Zayn and Owens, and many more will come throughout the coming months and years. So who will strike first in Sunday’s match?

5. Is The IC Title Better On Miz Or Cesaro?

At a glance, it might seem like a no-brainer for the result of the Intercontinental Championship match between Miz and Cesaro: The Swiss Superman will obliterate Miz and capture singles gold for the first time in more than three years.

Advertisement

But is that necessarily what’s best for both men? Cesaro returned after WrestleMania and was initially inserted into the world title picture before moving on to feuding with Miz over the Intercontinental Championship. Miz, on the other hand, has seen his career get a shot in the arm thanks to the return of Maryse, his wife, who is now serving as his valet. Carrying the IC title has helped the duo with their Hollywood A-list routine.

So who’s better served having the Intercontinental Championship? Cesaro could theoretically be a strong, fighting champion who defends the title – but we’ve discussed that before with plenty of other title-holders. And Miz could become something of a hated heel who holds the title for a while until someone comes along and gets a big moment by finally defeating him.

4. Who Gets To Control Raw?

Just in case there wasn’t enough intrigue for Payback with the world title match, WWE decided to throw a non-wrestling segment onto the PPV, and it’s a McMahon-filled one at that.

Advertisement

Vince McMahon will finally end the charade of Shane McMahon running Monday Night Raw because of “popular demand” and either make it permanent or end it and return Stephanie McMahon (and Triple H) as the head of Raw. Regardless of the repeated criticisms of the poor storytelling with Shane running Raw, it has been refreshing to have a babyface authority figure for a change, and it would be a shame to see it end.

Also, having Stephanie and Triple H back to pontificate and brag for 15 minutes at the opening of every episode is not exactly an upgrade. Considering that WWE is branding Payback as the first PPV of the new era, one has to wonder if they’d pull the plug this quickly.

3. Will Bullet Club Interfere?

Well, now we’re down to the WWE World Heavyweight Championship title match and everything that surrounds it. Roman Reigns will face AJ Styles for the title in a match that no one would’ve thought possible four months ago.

Advertisement

But one of the biggest questions surrounding this bout is whether Styles’ buddies from New Japan, Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson, interfere in the match. The former Bullet Club members have attacked Roman on multiple occasions while espousing their allegiance to AJ. So it would only make sense if they do something to help their friend win the world title and end the Roman Empire before it can even get started, right?

Not necessarily. The first thing that has to happen is Anderson and Gallows have to interfere. Many are assuming it, but WWE has not exactly been wont to give fans exactly what they’ve assumed to be certain.

2. Will Finn Balor Be With Them?

So the big sticking point with the Bullet Club coming to AJ Styles’ aid is that there’s another person under contract with WWE who has a longer-standing relationship with Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson, and that man would be former NXT Champion Finn Balor.

Advertisement

Balor founded the Bullet Club in New Japan, and when he left for NXT, Styles took his place as leader of the group. That is a big reason why it’s even a question of whether Anderson and Gallows help Styles. It’s entirely possible that they cost him the title and Balor debuts on the main roster at Payback, kicking off a Bullet Club stable in WWE.

If that happens, fans could be in for an interesting ride. If Balor doesn’t debut and it’s just Anderson and Gallows, then it still could make for an eventful title match.

1. What Does Ending Mean For Roman’s Title Reign?

Regardless, it looks like there are going to be some shenanigans during the world title match. It’s doubtful that we’re going to get a completely clean ending to the match, with either Roman Reigns spearing AJ Styles or Styles hitting the Phenomenal Forearm on Roman.

Advertisement

Depending on how many extracurriculars there are during this match, one has to wonder what message that sends about Roman’s title reign. If in Reigns’ first title defense you have interference, a former NXT champion debuting (Finn Balor) and potentially a new stable forming in the aftermath, does that make Roman as champ secondary? Is that a sign that WWE could be acknowledging that Reigns as champ is not the big draw to close a show?

This is a tough question to answer – or even ask – without having seen how Payback will end. But if things end in disarray with interference from a reformed Bullet Club, then the question will have to be posed and considered over the following weeks.

Sunday is Roman’s first PPV world title defense (unless you count Sheamus’ Money in the Bank cash-in at Survivor Series). It’s hardly an empire if your first defense is overshadowed by outside forces.

Advertisement