3 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Rampage (Jan 12 - Results & Review)

Cracking wrestling, questionable decisions and birthday cake collide on AEW Rampage!

By Jamie Kennedy /

AEW

There's a heartwarming image that'll put a smile on even the most negative pro wrestling fan's face. "Negative" is actually the key word here, because -1 was in the house for this week's Rampage, and that kid is growing. His father would surely be proud, and big Brodie Lee would've been smiling himself when his son nabbed Jake Hager's hat.

Advertisement

Not even those hijinks could save Friday's headliner from feeling a tad mediocre though. AEW returned to Daily's Place hoping to rekindle some of the old fervour from events of yesteryear. The place certainly has a unique atmosphere, and Jacksonville loves it some All Elite Wrestling, but the main was a bum note in-ring.

There were similar struggles elsewhere on the card. However, two matches stood out from the rest - one was a "competitive squash", and the other a reminder of everything right with Eddie Kingston's rags-to-riches story during and post-Continental Classic. Kingston is loving his wrestling right now.

Advertisement

You might view some of the 'Downs' on hand here as a little harsh. That's fair enough, 'cause everyone's entitled to their own opinions. This writer just wants to see a little more in some places from AEW, and he expects Tony Khan to iron out some trope-related wrinkles.

Here's all the good and bad from Rampage!

Advertisement

Downs...

4. Veering Towards Down

AEW

There was an upside to Hikaru Shida vs. Queen Aminata. It was competitive, at least, but the match suffered because neither woman particularly feels like they're building towards anything right now. That's particularly troubling in the case of Shida. Does anyone else just find her so uninspiring these days?! Woman needs some character.

Advertisement

Personally, this fan could've done without the stupid extended spot that saw both women willingly turn their backs and take some punishment. That looked daft, even more so because none of the announcers called it out or tried to discourage what they were seeing. Sure, just take punishment mid-match for no reason.

Aminata being all smiles post-loss as soon as Hikaru went for the hug was a bit off too. Admittedly, this could be one of those 'internet writer got up on the wrong side of the bed this morning' moans, but dunno...something just didn't click when watching the bout.

Advertisement

It was a bit bland.

3. Wasn’t Feeling The Main Event

AEW

Here's that main event moan for good measure.

Advertisement

This writer is no fan of The Dark Order generally, but Alex Reynolds and John Silver can work some solid matches when they're in there with the right opponents. Sadly, the blend of those guys and Evil Uno with Jake Hager, Matt Menard and a cake-covered Angelo Parker didn't really cut it.

For reference, Parker was covered in birthday cake because Ruby Soho apparently saw him smooching Harley Cameron (against his will, as later footage revealed) and smashed the marzipan right in his chops. That didn't really play into this trios headliner though. Just as well, because this was not a celebration of everything right with AEW's six-man dynamic.

Advertisement

The match didn't add much to the episode, and could even be considered the wrong main event. Eddie Kingston vs. Wheeler Yuta was right there, Tony! Obviously, it was heartwarming to see -1 again, but AEW needs to get over The Order eventually. The group totally drags.

2. Someone Needs To Have A Word

AEW

Right, there must be some sort of inside joke going on with Jeff Hardy being p*ssed about being on Rampage. It's either that or he's going into business for himself and trying to bully Tony Khan into a regular spot for The Hardys on Dynamite and/or Collision. Either way, Jeff's promo line on Friday was unnecessary.

Advertisement

Hardy dissed Collision's ratings. He was kinda/sorta saying that Rampage delivers better scores in key demos than the Saturday night show because he and Matt are showcased on it, but that's not what Jeff made this sound like. No, he made it seem like Collision is a pile of rubbish and pales in comparison to the 'C' show.

Oh dear.

Advertisement

That's hardly a good idea. In fact, bringing this sort of thing to TV isn't a great idea full stop. If this is just Jeff being a whiner, then someone needs to have a word behind the scenes and remind him not to badmouth AEW programming on other AEW programming. Pretty simple, really.

1. Kinda Sick Of These One-Offs

AEW

Private Party interrupted Top Flight and Action Andretti backstage, and the segment was clearly booked to set up a match between both squads. OK then, but...for what? Yeah, AEW wants to find stuff for everyone on the roster to do, but there also needs to be more thought put into these run-it-back intrusions.

Advertisement

They happen far too often.

You know the deal: Wrestler A and Wrestler B walk in on Wrestler C's promo time > they tease a match > said match happens > AEW barely mentions it again. Then, it's onto the next rinse and repeat situation with other workers. That isn't storytelling - it's painfully dull.

Advertisement

Things might be different if these skits ever actually led to anything (like a sustained push), but that's becoming increasingly rare. Is the world crying out for a one off Private Party vs. Top Flight match, or something? These teams don't even have beef with each other.

Ups...

3. JR’s Commentary

AEW

Listen (cheers, Max Caster), hearing Jim Ross on the call is a luxury these days.

Advertisement

It's never a given that JR will be involved on TV due to serious health problems the legend has going on off screen. Being brutally honest, some of his AEW work over the years has been rough, but the iconic announcer was perky and well up for some Rampage this week. That's good news.

Jim wasn't there to phone it in either. He added a ton to the broadcast, and especially seemed to enjoy the opener between Eddie Kingston and Wheeler Yuta. That's likely because those guys paced themselves and left gaps for commentary to fill fans in on key facts and analysis about them, their recent work and what's coming next.

Advertisement

JR thrives in such situations. Few announcers have as keen an eye for when to add context and when to let others take the lead. Health issues and clear product grumbles aside, Ross remains a joy to listen to when he's on form like he was this week.

Long may that continue.

Advertisement

2. Swerve’s Showcase

AEW

Nobody should have any problems with this kind of bout. It wasn't an out and out squash despite future World Champ and all-round thoroughbred Swerve Strickland being involved. Everyone knew Swerve was winning this one, but he gave Matt Sydal just enough to maintain interest and make the match worth seeing.

Advertisement

Sydal bounces around nicely for workers like Strickland too. Matching the tempo his smaller opponent sets, Swerve is also capable of upping the pace when it suits as well. That made for a nice blend as Strickland realised he should just overpower the smaller man and hammer home his strength advantage.

Lovely stuff here.

Advertisement

There's no stopping Swerve in 2024, man. He will become AEW World Champ, and deservedly so. Cutting some of the hangers on in the Mogul Embassy (but maybe keeping Prince Nana by his side) will be key to a successful, lengthy reign. Strickland is his own man.

Time for him to fly.

Advertisement

1. Another Workhorse Winner

AEW

Looking back, Eddie Kingston's rags-to-riches story in the Continental Classic is one of the best things Tony Khan has ever booked. Starting 0-2, then rallying to come out on top and seize the Triple Crown made Kingston even more endearing to fans than he already was. That took some doing, but AEW did it.

Advertisement

On Rampage, Eddie worked another fab outing vs. Wheeler Yuta. Anyone watching closely would've surely appreciated the overall pacing, and the work Yuta did on Eddie's arm throughout. Kingston had to grit his teeth, fight through the pain and scrap his way to a tough win. He's really good at that sort of thing.

This opener probs should've been the main event, being honest, but everyone should just be thankful it happened at all. It's the kind of match Rampage is perfect for, and the quaint surroundings of Daily's Place gave it a unique atmosphere too. That shouldn't be overlooked.

Advertisement

Go watch it if you haven't already.

What did you think of this week's AEW Rampage? For more wrestling, check out 10 Moments Wrestlers NEVER Recovered From and 10 New Directions For WWE In 2024!

Advertisement