3 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Rampage (Nov 5)
CM Punk and Eddie Kingston deliver; AEW references WWE releases; Adam Cole is...healthy?
The stark contrast between what constitutes a "good" shoot-style comment and what constitutes a "bad" one aired on this week's AEW Rampage. First and foremost, as the images splashed all around here suggest, you need to see the face-to-face confrontation CM Punk and Eddie Kingston had on the show.
No, seriously. That was essential pro wrestling drama.
Their fiery exchange was the main hook for Rampage, but it wasn't all the weekly had to offer. Bryan Danielson was on hand to tune-up before his Eliminator tourney final against Miro at Full Gear, and AEW handed Adam Cole a singles match with John Silver - this was a chance for the Dark Order man to break out from that group's shadow.
AEW have been doing a decent job with Rampage since the show debuted a few months back. It's a ridiculously easy watch most weeks. Even when something doesn't quite hit the mark (or outright sucks), it's often short enough that something else will make up for that.
Here are all the 'Ups' and 'Downs' from 60 minutes that, if nothing else, boasted a must-see segment.
Downs...
4. Too Soon?
This writer doesn't want to turn this into some "I'm offended" thing. That's not the case here. Max Caster's comments about John Laurinaitis being Bryan Danielson's father in law who kills careers was close to the bone, but it's hardly the first time someone has said a shoot-style, off-the-cuff comment like that.
Nah, this guy has more of a problem with AEW mentioning WWE.
Taz heaped fuel on the fire by saying that Tony Khan might even start liking The Acclaimed if they kept that sort of thing up. What, because they took a smart-arsed verbal dump on the competition about recent releases, Tony (who is feuding with Caster and Anthony Bowens) might become friends with them?
Jesus, that mentality makes AEW look so small time. Sorry, but it does. Bareknuckled comments are one thing, but suggesting that the owner will ditch his kayfabe vendetta against a tag-team because they're shooting on another real-life promotion is messy and unnecessary.
3. Questionable Pairing
Neither The Bunny nor Red Velvet are really capable of carrying the other to a worthwhile match, so it's puzzling that AEW thought it was the right call to stick them in there against one another in the TBS Title tourney. This was always going to be bang average.
Maybe that's too harsh, but this short bout never really got going before the finish.
Jade Cargill's involvement was the highlight of this segment, which perhaps says it all. She oozes star quality, and it was nice to see All Elite reference her past with Velvet. Even that couldn't save this one from total mediocrity though - it wasn't the best.
It might've been nice to see Bunny or Velvet in there with Serena Deeb, or somebody like that who could bring the best out in them. They're not horrible, obviously, but they're a little raw. This first round effort needed a bit more experience.
2. Weird Follow-Up
Jungle Boy, Luchasaurus and Christian Cage fired out a challenge to The Young Bucks and Adam Cole for a 'Falls Count Anywhere' six man at Full Gear. That, dear readers, could be a show stealer on the undercard. Excitement for it faded a tad when Cole went one-on-one with John Silver later.
It was hard to get invested or care about that.
Being honest, there was no way Silver was going over here anyway. That came across loud and clear; Cole did everything in his power to add a bit of doubt (more on that later), but it was a struggle because...well, The Dark Order sucks. They've outlived their usefulness really.
As much as Silver tried, he never felt like an ideal opponent for Cole after a major pay-per-view announcement like that one. There was also something totally weird that felt at odds with AEW's usual booking style. It was like Dynamite hadn't happened the way fans remembered...
1. Psychology?
...this.
Cole took a 'Con-Chair-To' from Christian Cage on Dynamite, right? Yes, so why was he wrestling a back-and-forth match on Rampage 48 hours later? Some fans are already excusing AEW for this because Cole remembered to sell the after effects, but the guy was literally twitching on Wednesday.
Tony Schiavone had also barked out questions about whether or not Cole would even make it to Full Gear. Don't worry, Tony - the Superkliq member made it to Rampage! This was a bit of a missed opportunity. If anything, Cole's match with Silver should've been cancelled, or AEW should've put one of The Bucks in there as a late replacement.
Credit to Cole for selling his head and neck a little though. At least he had the smarts to do that, but this match didn't need to happen. The 'Con-Chair-To' should've been protected way better than this. Did Christian use plastic chairs, or something?
Ups...
3. Bryan Danielson: AEW’s Giving Wrestler
Once Max Caster had smart-arsed his way through the opening rap, Bryan Danielson dusted himself down and put on another clinic against Anthony Bowens. Perhaps the best thing about this match is that Danielson made Bowens look competitive without shedding his own star power.
That can't be easy to do.
The announcers did a good job of putting across that Bowens would need Caster's help if he had a hope in hell of beating someone the standard of Bryan. That's the way it should be. Ant is a tag-teamer, after all, and he was in there with one of the best pro wrestlers in the world.
As far as tune-up matches for pay-per-views go, this was a good 'un. Bowens, like Miro, also works a power-based style, so it made sense visually to see Danielson tearing a musclebound dude to pieces with his technical wizardry.
2. Emotion Sells
This was shooting done right.
Eddie Kingston was a man possessed as he ripped CM Punk apart for seemingly dissing him when he was a young up-and-comer. The story has believability on its side, which helps, and there's an intensity to Kingston's work on the mic that carries an air of real danger - you never know what he might say next.
Who does that sound like? It sounds like Punk during his 'Pipebomb' run in WWE. Now he's in AEW, Punk is much more of a grizzled veteran who doesn't take any sh*t, and that worked for this nose-to-nose. He himself suggested that Full Gear (where the pair will meet) is too big time for Eddie. Punk's line about wrestling on Dark or Elevation instead was clever.
There's a borderline condescending tone to Punk's words too. He's touching a nerve with the hardcore AEW fans for being so needlessly cruel to Kingston, and that could be useful for a possible heel turn (imagine) somewhere down the road.
Watch this. Drink it in. Enjoy it.
1. Setting It Up On Rampage
The face-to-face gets a second 'Up' just for the platform it happened on too. Rampage hinged on this confrontation, and that meant it stood out as something impactful. Would that be the case on a jam-packed Dynamite? Maybe/maybe not, but it didn't hurt that Kingston and Punk had the floor to themselves on Friday.
They definitely made Rampage feel important.
Seeing a pull apart brawl erupt between stars like Punk and Kingston made this week's program must-see stuff. That's not something people will say about Rampage every single Friday, but AEW got it right this time. This showdown made Rampage the ideal accompaniment (or extension) to Dynamite, which is what it should be.
Nobody phoned it in, put it that way. This was one of the better verbal duels AEW has ever produced, and that's a credit to Kingston's fire and Punk's star power. These guys are brewing up something memorable. Hopefully, they deliver the goods come Full Gear.
What did you think of this week's AEW Rampage? For more like this, check out 10 Things We Learned From Jon Moxley On Talk Is Jericho and 4 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Rampage (Oct 29)!