3 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (17 May - Results & Review)

Jade Cargill tastes defeat; Logan Paul gets to Cody Rhodes; Bayley is STRUGGLING.

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com

This week's SmackDown was functional and more about prepping King & Queen Of The Ring than anything else. That's understandable considering the PLE is next week, and WWE did still find time to make The Bloodline look strong whilst letting a main roster newbie shine against an old favourite.

Advertisement

Sadly, the Queen side of things sagged a little. Triple H might've booked himself into a corner with several matches in the women's brackets, and now the tournament looks a bit less exciting as a result. Can the same be said for the men's one? Not yet, because heavy hitters like Randy Orton and GUNTHER are still involved.

A contract signing skit between Cody Rhodes and Logan Paul proved to be another of SmackDown's highlights. LP remains inconsistent on the mic, but the dude has enough heat from fans who can't stand him to offset any weaknesses. Besides, Cody was there to help things along anyway.

Advertisement

WWE clarified the terms for their title showdown in Saudi Arabia and busily set about the task of giving Cody some much-needed edge. Here's all the good and bad from the blue brand's penultimate effort pre-King & Queen!

Advertisement

Downs...

4. You’ve Gotta’ Be Worried For DIY

WWE.com

Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa are clearly on track to challenge A-Town Down Under, but fans of the DIY pair should be slightly concerned. They're barely getting reactions from live crowds, and WWE hasn't bothered to give Gargano or Ciampa any kind of character to speak of beyond being hardworking.

Advertisement

It isn't enough.

DIY's match vs. Legado del Fantasma was hardly horrible from a technical point of view, but it never had any steam behind it either. If Triple H can't book Johnny and Tommaso well on the main roster, then what chance do they have?! It's worrying, 'cause they're a duo WWE probably figured they could depend on to bed in nicely.

Advertisement

Actually giving the lads a chance to show off their personalities would help massively. Currently, they reek more of an ROH team Tony Khan occasionally books on AEW Rampage or Collision, and that's not meant as a compliment. DIY might get shredded on the mic by Austin Theory and Grayson Waller.

3. Swing And A Miss

WWE.com

Look, it's obvious what WWE were going for here, but it didn't click.

Advertisement

Jade Cargill was DQ'd for using a chair on Nia Jax following their short, family-infused brawl. Nia trolled Jade's daughter (who was cheering on mother dearest from ringside), then tried to use the chair on Cargill first before that backfired. So, eh...shouldn't Jax have been disqualified? She did swing for the fences with that chair, after all, and connected despite the block.

This was a cheap way to get Jade out of the Queen Of The Ring tournament, but yeah - not sure Jax would be considered the right opponent if Triple H ever fancied a return leg. Things could get awkward if Nia is tasked with carrying someone as green as Cargill to a lengthier showing.

Advertisement

WWE would've been better-served adding in some sort of stip that excluded current champions from these tourneys. That way, they wouldn't have been forced to come up with a quickfire exit for Jade. Creative only had to go this route because of their own booking.

2. The Excuse Was RIGHT THERE!

WWE.com

Bianca Belair vs. Tiffany Stratton is a match WWE will come back to in the future, and the opener was a much better showing than Nia vs. Jade from the prior entry. Sadly, it's a bit of a downer to see Stratton get ousted from the brackets considering how handy becoming Queen Of The Ring might've been to her cause.

Advertisement

Is it disastrous? No, but Bianca Belair's knee injury was right there! The 'EST' even spoke about her pain post-match, so it's amazing that WWE didn't have Tiff blow out Bianca's wheel and march on with an evil smirk. That seemed like the easiest play, especially when it became part of the story anyway.

Oh well.

Advertisement

This match almost scored an 'Up' because twin performances from Belair and Stratton were so strong and they did exhibit bags of chemistry. That wasn't enough in the end; Tiffany moving on by beating someone the standing of Bianca would've been huge for her, so this was an opportunity wasted.

1. This Title Reign Is Sputtering Along

WWE

Man, what's going on?

Advertisement

Bayley had some fire coming out of WrestleMania after vanquishing old Damage CTRL stablemate IYO SKY, but her title reign hasn't been as epic as people hoped it would be thus far. Now, she's warring with Chelsea Green in a scenario that screams 'B-tier mini story'. Things don't look great for babyface Bayley.

OK, so it's far too soon to properly spit the dummy just yet, but concerns are valid. Look at the facts: Bayley was handed a friendly situation vs. Naomi, then Tiffany Stratton got involved to third wheel and now...it's Chelsea. That's a step down. Green is entertaining, but she can't be taken seriously as a threat to the gold right now.

Advertisement

Bayley is set to skip King & Queen Of The Ring (unless something changes late on), and doesn't really have any viable foes on the horizon generally. Stratton seemed like a goer, but WWE has moved on from that for the time being. Also, seeing Bayley revert to the cackling had this fan palming his forehead.

No more of that, please!

Advertisement

Ups...

3. Preferring To Look On The Bright Side

WWE.com

LA Knight dropping to Tama Tonga will surely anger some out there, but yours truly is choosing to look on the brighter side. WWE surely has alternate plans for Knight, and there's no real difference between losing to Tama here or failing in another match later on. The writing team will have to cash in on LA's popularity at some point though.

Advertisement

He's screaming for success.

Man has options, to be fair. Knight worked some backstage business with Carmelo Hayes this week, and his issues with The Bloodline could lead to LA teaming with Randy Orton and Kevin Owens vs. Solo Sikoa, Tama Tonga and Tonga Loa. That'd be a fine bit of padding for Clash At The Castle over in Scotland.

Advertisement

Of course, what people really fancy seeing is Knight beating Logan Paul for the United States Title. Stay tuned until SummerSlam for that, which means LA will either get involved with Bloodline battering or work a mini-feud vs. Hayes in the interim.

2. Carmelo Hayes Shines Again

WWE.com

Sure, Carmelo Hayes has lost to both Cody Rhodes and Randy Orton since jumping up from NXT to SmackDown, but one of those men is WWE Champ and the other is Randy f'n Orton. These are hardly damaging defeats for Hayes, let's be real. Fans aren't exactly going to give up on him just because he's staring at the lights for the best.

Advertisement

A loss to Baron Corbin last week would've been far more alarming.

It'd be smart to show patience with Carmelo. He was clearly a pet project of one Shawn Michaels on NXT, and that'll continue with Triple H on the main roster. Here, Melo entered another sparkling showing vs. one of WWE's most respected veterans, and that'll stand him in good stead going forwards.

Advertisement

Don't be shocked if he goes on a winning run soon, then finds himself in the running to win Money In The Bank. There's time for him to do the honours for LA Knight before that though (assuming that's the plan). Yep, Hayes will be absolutely fine coming out of this loss to Randy.

1. One Of The Better Contract Signings

WWE.com

WWE's contract signing segments tend to be a chore, so it was great to see Cody Rhodes and Logan Paul make the best of things on Friday. The added wrinkle of LP saying he didn't fancy putting his United States Title on the line over in Saudi because Cody hadn't earned a crack at him was fun and typical heel arrogance. It worked well.

Advertisement

Being honest, everyone knows Rhodes is winning, so putting both belts on the line didn't seem logical from the start. Booking Cody as a double champ this soon into his cherished WWE Title reign would've been daft. He doesn't need to pull double duty, and the US strap wouldn't look great in the shadow of a more important championship anyway.

The crowd were red hot for this skit once it got going, which is a positive sign. Nick Aldis stormed away fuming at Paul for his legal loophole antics, then Cody showed some much-needed aggression to fire back at Logan's entourage. Mark this segment down as a winner.

Advertisement

Next week's match will be scorching in-ring too.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 10 Times WWE Got Their Own BAD Ideas WRONG and 10 Horrible Gimmicks That Wrestlers Pitched THEMSELVES!

Advertisement