10 Horrible Gimmicks That Wrestlers Pitched THEMSELVES
A world in which Lloyd Boner/Buddy Peacock headlined WWE WrestleMania.
It's easy to blame creative teams for everything. Bad gimmick? Someone on the writing staff came up with it. Horrible debut promo? Somebody in creative will surely take the flak for scripting that tripe. Often, that's the simple solution to everything - creative, creative, creative. Here's the thing: Sometimes it isn't always their fault.
Wrestlers come up with bad ideas too.
Everyone included here thought these characters would either draw some serious cash, prolong their run in a company or get them a foot on the ladder quickly. Or all three. That's an insane thought when deep-diving on some of the gimmicks they pitched. Sure, someone higher up had to slap a green light on things or bat them away in the end, but that doesn't change the fact workers themselves did the scheming first.
WWE, WCW and TNA all get some attention here. AEW if you fancy being pedantic. Well, a few of the workers analysed did end up under Tony Khan's watch eventually! Clearly he and The Young Bucks are to blame then. Only joking (obviously).
Check these creative horrors out.
10. WWE’s Very Own Surfing Werewolf!
Justin Gabriel almost became a werewolf that's super into surfing, sky diving and other extreme activities. "Almost" is perhaps a little generous, because apparently Triple H was bloody horrified when he learned of this pitch to ex-boss Vince McMahon. Gabriel was serious though, and thought the hybrid would be cool.
Imagine this on episodes of Saturday Morning Slam.
The former Nexus member only revealed his grand plan after being canned by WWE in 2015. Gabriel went on Chris Jericho's podcast to pop a quick, 'Ex-WWE star buries creative' rating, but was remarkably upbeat about taking this surfing werewolf character to the independent scene. Or, perhaps, back to WWE someday.
Yeah, that didn't happen. Pro wrestling was spared the vignettes that would've had our Justin sprouting fur and fangs as he popped off a sweet 360 which might've made Kelly Slater proud. How rad, eh? This definitely sounds like something Vince would've been into in the 1990s.
9. Seven (Or Se7en)
To this day, AEW's Dustin Rhodes bemoans Turner executives who killed his chances of developing the Seven (or Se7en if you're full of late-90s sass and like words with no conceivable pronunciation) character beyond a few introductory vignettes. The former Goldust thinks Seven could've been something special.
It's unsurprising to learn then that he was the one who pitched it; Rhodes based the gimmick on a 1998 movie called Dark City, and figured it'd grab him some attention when he left the WWF for another bash at WCW in '99. Sadly, Turner top brass thought it was too edgy for their networks, so Vince Russo told Dustin they had to squash it.
That was defo a mercy killing.
Dustin still erm...floated to the ring on Nitro before cutting the crap and delivering a scathing shoot promo on everything from the gimmick he'd literally invented (and was playing, albeit temporarily) to the WWF, Goldust and everyone in between.
8. Tommy Dreamer Gets Sniped (For Real)
Kurt Angle was famously disgusted by the original ECW's decision to book a mock crucifixion stunt, so who knows what the milk-sipping Olympian would've thought had Tommy Dreamer been gunned down in the middle of the ring too. Yep, that was something Tommy pitched in the 90s - an actual sniping.
An extreme sniping, if you like. "E-C-DUB! E-C-DUB!".
Seriously though, what the actual hell was Dreamer thinking to suggest something so shocking? At least Paul Heyman had the sense to turn him down flat, and this is the dude who thought sending an inebriated New Jack out to pelt people with various weapons was a good idea!
In short, Tommy's next big gimmick in ECW could've been "Tommy Dreamer: Victim Of A Sniper". The resultant 'whodunit?' would've dominated storylines for a good while, possibly until everyone figured out who the gunman was. This writer's money would've been on Raven.
Just saying. He was always involved with Dreamer bashing back then.
7. Bobby Lashley: “I’ll Just Be Fat”
Body shaming is no joke, and definitely isn't something to be encouraged.
That isn't really what Bobby Lashley was hoping to achieve with this pitch, but you just know it would've backfired on WWE big time. What is "it"? A few years back, the mega-ripped, mega-muscled Lashley wanted to gain loads of weight for real due to "severe depression", then shed it right on time to win some belts again.
MVP would have been enlisted as a master motivator for big Bob. Together, they'd train like never before (or like Lashley is used to, let's be honest) and beat the bulk to turn him back into a lean, mean, WrestleMania-headlining machine. Incredibly, then-overseer Vince McMahon wasn't into it and that was that.
Granted, Lashley was presumably trying to be inspiring with this muscled > overweight > muscled again plan, but there's zero chance WWE's creative nucleus would've handled it sensitively enough to matter. Bobby was never destined to be wrestling's very own Christian Bale.
6. Jeff Hardy Is Willow The Wisp
This writer is prone to randomly reminiscing about the good things TNA has accomplished over the years. If you want one seriously epic blend of excellent in-ring action and some of the worst creative ever, then fire up anything from 2002-2009. Y'know, pre-Hulk Hogan convincing Dixie Carter that he was the answer.
By 2014, TNA was a struggle. That was evidenced on screen by awful ideas like allowing Jeff Hardy to dress up as something from Pan's Labyrinth and become 'Willow The Wisp'. Jeff had come up with that character as a teenager, and it should've stayed put in his youth as something he'd occasionally mention during interviews.
Willow wasn't what wrestling fans wanted to see from the daredevil this deep into his career. The fact ol' Wispy popped up several times after 2014 (and almost made it onto AEW programming) suggests Hardy holds it close to his heart. Unfortunately for the high-flyer, it has never actually clicked with people.
Hit the bricks, Willow!
5. Erick Rowan’s Tiny Woman In A Cage
Remember late-2019/early-2020 when Erick Rowan carried about a mysterious cage for a while? Then, unless you've successfully blocked it from memory, one Drew McIntyre found out there was a giant spider inside and squished it. Man, latter-day Vinnie Mac WWE creative really was the drizzling sh*ts.
The spider end game was on par with Rowan's own crappy plan though.
Y'see, the ex-Wyatt Family man wanted to put actress Jyoti Amge in there and carry her around instead. If you're not familiar with Jyoti, just know she's the world's shortest living woman. Some readers might remember her from episodes of American Horror Story around a decade or so ago too.
Erick thought it'd be heartwarming if he cared for Amge and protected her from harm. Fair enough, but where would things lead from there? Hopefully, a burly, sword-toting Scotsman wouldn't have squashed her like he did with the fake spider. It's safe to say things like that in 2024; the angle is old news, so nobody's giving WWE's writers any ideas.
4. Bryan Danielson Is Lloyd Boner
Let that subheading sink in for a while.
Oh wow, that was unintentionally tragic wording considering what's coming next. ARGH! Can people say anything anymore without it sounding like innuendo?! Sorry, let's start again. In 2009, celebrated technician Bryan Danielson inked a deal with WWE and started pitching names to the writing team.
Amongst others, Bryan pitched "Lloyd Boner" and "Buddy Peacock". Both sound right up WWE's street, but it was William Regal who stepped in and warned Danielson he might want to be taken a bit more seriously. Thus, Daniel Bryan was born, and the ex-ROH man's dreams of hearing sold out arenas chanting, "BONER! BONER! BONER!" faded.
This entry was included for one reason and one reason only: WWE would've taken the "Boner" surname and run wild with it. There's no way they could be trusted to book a guy called "Lloyd (f'n) Boner" as a serious, boots-n-tights professional wrestler, put it that way. He would've been a walking penis punchline.
Lloyd is Danielson's real middle name, for the record.
3. “This Is…Stang!”
Even bringing former WCW enhancement worker Hardbody Harrison up is depressing. He was arrested in 2005 on charges of sex trafficking, and was eventually found guilty of those charges in 2007. That's awful. Before revealing himself to be a terrible human being, Hardbody revealed he had terrible instincts for wrestling creative.
Chris Jericho wrote about some of Harrison's pitches in his first book. At one point, Hardbody wanted to steal a giant gem from DDP, drop it in a piranha tank and watch the 'People's Champ' swim with the fishes. Yeah...OK then. Another time, Harrison pitched becoming Sting's protege/arch nemesis (depending on who's telling the story).
His name? "Stang". STANG! Surely this was the only thing capable of besting the Starrcade '97 buyrate.
One can almost hear the entrance track now. "Man called Stang! He's a man called Stang!". Or, how about his signature move the Stanger Splash? It'd be a shocker if Hardbody wasn't laughed out of the room for this nonsense. Even WCW's braintrust must've thought it was garbage.
2. Big E Wants To Be “Mel Mann”
From a horrendous human to a wonderful one.
Bless Big E for confessing to this creative awfulness via social media years ago. According to the New Day man, he lobbied to become a wrestler called "Mel Mann" when he was signed by WWE in 2009. You're reading the play on words correctly - E wanted to become a wrestling postal worker.
1995 called, and it wants that gimmick back. A grappling postie would've been in line with characters like Duke 'Dumpster' Droese (a garbage man), TL Hopper (a plumber with sh*t stains all over him), or Isaac Yankem (an evil dentist with horrible teeth). Actually, had Big E agreed never to deliver when promised, he could've called himself 'Hermes/Evri' instead. Ahem.
Predictably, WWE shook their head and "Mel Mann" was consigned to the dustbin of history. Or, should that be the postal chute? Right, enough rubbish puns. E wanted to be a wrestling postman, but it wasn't going to happen. That was a blessing in disguise.
1. Mr. Hole In One
It's really hard to get a picture of Barry Darsow's golfing gimmick that doesn't look like it was churned out by a Game Boy Printer. There aren't too many promo snaps of "Mr. Hole In One" around, and that's probs 'cause Baz only lasted a few weeks in the role. It was so crummy even late-era WCW wanted nothing to do with the thing.
This questionable character debuted on the 18 September 1999 episode of WCW Saturday Night, and paused matches to putt a few balls before smashing some skulls with a pitching wedge. A links-loving wrestler got about as much attention and heat as you'd imagine, but things got even weirder from there. Firstly though, why did Darsow pitch a golfing gimmick?
He really liked golf. Simple as.
Bizarrely, WCW started changing "Mr. Hole In One's" name weekly. One minute, he was that. The next? Barry Darsow? The next? He was going under his old Krusher Khruschev moniker despite wearing Pringle sweaters and carrying golf clubs to the ring.
Stunning levels of absurdity.
What other shockingly bad gimmicks did wrestlers come up with themselves? For more WWE, check out 10 Things That’d RUIN WWE’s 2024 and 10 Secret Wrestling Retcons You DEFINITELY Don't Remember!