5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE NXT (Aug 12)

Big Keith's on fire. No, seriously...

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com
"Guess who's back? Back again".

Whilst it might seem odd to begin a recap of 2020 NXT by including lyrics from a 2002 Eminem song, there is a purpose to it. NXT has some old-school vibes (yes, 2002 is old-school - no, nobody should be fine with that) and likes to follow the same, straightforward beats that 'Without Me' favours.

Advertisement

Also, much like Shady's track, it can be a little annoying.

This week's show gamely pushed some stories ahead in time for TakeOver XXX, but you'll notice there was an almost equal number of 'Downs' to 'Ups'. Again, there's a reason for that. The broadcast occasionally hit highs that reeked of classic NXT, then it dipped and started to show flashes of the same crummy hiccups one can see on Raw or SmackDown beneath that black and yellow exterior.

Advertisement

Obviously, no wrestling show is perfect, and the Wednesday night delight is a perpetual easy watch that's hardly ever awful. However, some key characters feel like they're being totally wasted right now, and the brand's presentation has just become less interesting thanks to one commentary addition...

Downs...

4. Cruiserweight Complications

WWE.com

Breezango are awesome, Isaiah 'Swerve' Scott is perfectly fine and Legado del Fantasma have been booked as a dominant, all-for-one faction built to protect Santos Escobar's Cruiserweight Title. So, if everything is solid, then why is this the first negative?

Advertisement

Allow yours truly to elaborate.

Neither Tyler Breeze, Fandango nor Scott come across as credible threats to Escobar's belt. That's weird considering commentary did a fine job of putting over the fact that Isaiah has beaten Santos before, but it's true. Next week's six-man tag should reveal the next man to challenge for the gold too, and it'll be underwhelming.

Advertisement

Escobar vs. any one of this trio doesn't sound good enough for TakeOver XXX. Breezango are comedy guys and 'Swerve' just hasn't been given enough promo time to justify this sort of position or make fans care about his character.

3. Rhea Ripley's Plight

WWE.com

Speaking of which, what has happened to Rhea Ripley?

Advertisement

This angle with the Robert Stone Brand feels like a total waste of her star power, and it oddly isn't helping anyone else get over either. That'd surely be the only point to it. Instead of that though, the story is sucking the life from Ripley and is another misstep for her in 2020.

It's pretty clear that Rhea's time on NXT has come. She can talk up her love affair with the brand all she likes, but she has nothing left to do there. Ripley isn't in the Women's Title scene right now, hasn't got a top-tier opponent to battle outside it and has been reduced to warring with a manager who gets run over by toy tanks.

Advertisement

Perhaps the only silver lining is that a straight-up one on one match between Rhea and Stone client Mercedes Martinez could be a breakout moment for the latter. That doesn't soothe Ripley's worries though - it's clear she needs a change of scenery.

2. Vic Joseph

WWE

Poor Vic Joseph.

Advertisement

The lanky announcer did precisely nothing wrong during his short stay as Raw's lead commentator, but he was bumped back down the pecking order in favour of Tom Phillips. Now, after landing on 205 Live, big Vic has come to NXT, and...well, the brand didn't really need him.

This might sound controversial to NXT's long-time audience, but the show has never needed a third wheel behind the commentary desk. Mauro Ranallo and Beth Phoenix work well together, and they're in a good groove; they recognise one another's speech patterns and rarely step on their partner's toes.

Advertisement

Nigel McGuinness did, and Phillips was wasted as a third analyst too. Joseph is exactly the same, so much so that it's hard to see this working out in the long run. His corny style ("Oh no!") doesn't lend itself well to NXT, and he didn't complement Ranallo or Phoenix this week.

1. A Wasted Comeback

WWE.com

Problems arise when major stars are brought back for mystery surprise moments that outright fail to be major. That was the case with Velveteen Dream on this week's NXT. The lustre he once exuded with stunning ease gave way to an awkward sense that Dream has gone.

Advertisement

He returned to play prop in the main event, and the match never really got going before Cameron Grimes bagged a win that takes him to TakeOver XXX. Then, Dream appeared to move further towards a heel run by attacking Kushida and generally acting like a spoiled brat who runs this here show.

It might've been better had WWE kept their Velveteen prince (ahem) on the shelf for now until they had a better reason to bring him back.

Advertisement

Ups...

5. Son Of A Burch

WWE.com

Squash matches don't need to be useless.

Advertisement

They really don't, and this Danny Burch vs. Karrion Kross opener was proof of that. Burch, who was attacked by the crazed Kross last week, called for the bell to sound immediately and then showed some great fire early on. That made sense, but so did Karrion's submission win.

This was a nifty piece of business that made Burch look like he had something to offer without being able to go toe-to-toe with the NXT Title's top contender in a lengthy match. Their bout was kept short, punchy and ended with a satisfying heel victory that sets Kross up nicely for Keith Lee.

Advertisement

One could perhaps do without Karrion's smack talk mid-match though. That was unnecessary, doesn't fit his machine-like, laser-focused gimmick and almost raised a laugh when he shouted, "Come on, Danny boy!". Less of that, more of the beatdowns and he'll be fine.

4. The Fireball

WWE.com

Controversy time.

Advertisement

There are some fans who'd have this fireball lunacy as their main 'Down'. Some folks just despise angles like this, but your writer isn't one of them. This is a dude who grew up watching The Undertaker shoot lightning out of his fingertips, after all, so OTT, superpower nonsense is welcome provided it's sparse.

Keith Lee's oversell, whilst predictably cheesy (what else was he supposed to do?), did get enough focus from the cameras to make it meaningful. Mauro Ranallo seemed legit shocked that Karrion Kross and Scarlett would stoop that low, and the fiery stunt added some menace to the latter's importance to her man.

Advertisement

One thing WWE must be careful of is moving swiftly on from this next week. If Keith isn't still selling the effects seven days later, then this will seem pointless. Also, he could've done with some instant scarring to sell the heat of the thing.

Still, it was good fun.

Advertisement

3. Mia Yim's Concern

WWE.com

Above, you'll see Mia Yim flashing a brief smile after overcoming Indi Hartwell. That grin didn't last long - WWE's official photo gallery from NXT didn't show it, but Yim quickly went back to wearing a depressed, concerned look for Keith Lee. That's an expression she bounced into the match wearing.

Advertisement

It made sense.

Yim came out looking like a pure pro who was able to put personal stuff to one side, get through her business and then return to real life. Credit must also go to Beth Phoenix for tying in her own worries for Edge earlier this year, and for sympathising with what Mia might've been going through.

Advertisement

Of course, the Lee stuff was never presented as career-threatening, but a fireball is a fireball and should be treated as dangerous. The only minor regret here is that WWE's producers didn't follow up with Yim tending to Lee back at the hospital, or something like that.

2. The Vignettes

WWE

WWE did, however, produce a number of fine vignettes.

Advertisement

NXT does this sort of thing way better than both Raw and SmackDown. Throughout the two hours, there were short vids for Adam Cole vs. Pat McAfee, Kushida, Cameron Grimes, Dakota Kai vs. Io Shirai, Finn Bálor, Johnny Gargano/Candice LeRae, Ridge Holland and Timothy Thatcher.

Every single one had purpose, didn't kick the arse out of things in terms of length and either pushed forward a character's motives or their TakeOver XXX involvement. This is definitely something Bruce Prichard should start doing on Monday and Friday nights. He's guilty of ignoring certain workers when they don't have an in-person match or segment.

Advertisement

Prichard has been around the horn, so he knows how valuable these vignettes can be. It'd be nice to see more on them on Raw and SmackDown, especially if they're kept simple like NXT's ones this week. This is a tried-and-tested way of developing talent.

1. Match Of The Night

WWE.com

If you enjoyed Keith Lee vs. Dominik Dijakovic at TakeOver: Portland this past February, then you must've liked Bronson Reed vs. Damian Priest on Wednesday night. It was another clash between big boys who can move, and was a fine showcase for both before they work TakeOver XXX's ladder match.

Advertisement

Reed's rise continued with a win, but Priest hardly looked weak due to the roll-up finish. It was in WWE's best interests to book a surprise conclusion to this one anyway - the North American Title scene needs to look competitive before TakeOver. Being honest, the set up for the ladder six man hasn't been smooth, so what happened between Reed and Priest was a step in the right direction.

Here's hoping next week maintains the same kind of oneupmanship.

Advertisement

These guys had the best match of the episode by far. It was marred slightly by the commercial break, which is admittedly unavoidable, but did show that there's a market for more of the hard-bumping, slick action Lee and Dijakovic worked previously.

What did you think of this week's NXT? For more, check out 7 Ups & 8 Downs From One Year Of Bray Wyatt’s Fiend In WWE and 10 Great WWE Feuds That Never Got A PPV Match!

Advertisement