5 Ups & 5 Downs For WWE Raw (15 Sept - Results & Review)

Becky, Seth, Punk, and AJ dominate Raw while Cena tries to sell a dead end.

By Scott Carlson /

WWE

Heading into the only big wrestling show of the weekend (kidding, AEW fans), WWE clearly is hellbent on controlling the wrestling narrative by stacking the card for WWE Wrestlepalooza.

Advertisement

Monday Night Raw provided them the go-home show to really sell the red brand’s contributions, which they did – with mixed results.

The hottest feud on Raw right now clearly is the husbands/wives feud pitting CM Punk and AJ Lee against Seth Rollins and Becky Lynch. The mixed tag match Saturday should be off the charts, and the in-ring confrontation Monday night only helped build to that showdown. All four superstars brought something to the table, making it easily the highlight of the night.

Of course, that means that because it took place mid-show, Raw’s main event was a significant comedown. Worse, it was an impromptu match between members of The Vision and a combination of Punk/LA Knight/an Uso that was immediately followed by a post-match heel beatdown. Lather, rinse, repeat.

John Cena showed up to do the hard sell for his PLE match against Brock Lesnar, but it’s 2025 and both men are years past their prime and their relevancy to everyday professional wrestling, making this more of an “old timers’ game” than a Clash of the Titans. Throw in the obvious baggage Lesnar carries and the residual vibes from Cena’s wasted half-year heel run and you have a take-it-or-leave-it match.

Beyond those key moments, Raw offered matchups that were more “wrestlers on a treadmill” facing each other multiple times, giving a feeling that WWE is just jogging in place, providing movement but not really moving anywhere meaningful from week to week.

Let’s get to it…

Get 76% off and three months for free when you sign up to NordVPN here: https://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=704&aff_id=3013&source=WCWRE

Downs…

5. Good Wrestling On A Treadmill

Perhaps any week now, Penta will get the backup he needs to take on the New Day and move his rivalry with the legendary tag team forward – and we’re not talking about Erik and Ivar.

Until then, the luchador continued Monday night with his string of entertaining matches that are inoffensive and not without charm. There’s actually a lot to still like about Penta and the comic stylings of Kofi Kingston (who fell to a springboard Mexican Destroyer Monday night), Xavier Woods, and Grayson Waller.

However, they’ve been singing from the same hymnal for the past several weeks now. Case in point: this writer missed two episodes while traveling, and other than learning that the War Raiders have aligned with Penta, nothing really has changed. Waller is still hawking a petition to get the Mexican Destroyer banned, while Kofi and Xavier mourn the tag titles they lost nearly three months ago.

That doesn’t mean any of this is bad on its face, but it’s hard to give passing marks when you see the same wrestlers essentially running in place with each other week after week, and wondering when they actually will take a few steps forward.

Let’s call this the mildest of “downs” with a likely pivot to the positive as soon as they start driving this story ahead.

4. ‘The Future’ Stuck In Neutral

For a wrestler dubbed “The Future of Lucha Libre,” Dragon Lee has sure spent a lot of time mired in a WWE time warp.

The masked superstar lost Monday night to El Grande Americano – who was helped by two more masked Americanos – marking another in a long line of battles against Judgment Day (or their ally El Grande) or American Made, most of which have ended in defeat.

Losing to Americano for the second time in two months, Dragon has managed just one televised singles win in more than 10 months. He’s seemingly nowhere close to even advancing to a successful midcard run, and his LWO stablemates have vanished from television exactly when he needs backup (seriously, an LWO/El Grande Americanos match is so stupid that it might actually work).

Instead, Grande and Dragon had a perfectly professional wrestling match, with some good spots and then a bunch of foolishness with the imposter Americanos (Dos and Tres). Probably the only redeeming thing was seeing all three Americanos do the “two Spider-Men pose” afterward.

If you’re into this story with Ludwig Kaiser and company, then you probably enjoyed the match. But if you’re looking for something off the hamster wheel for these characters, this was just another spin in place.

3. More Impromptu ‘Goodness’

Another week, another incomplete WWE card that got filled after Raw went on the air – including the main event.

LA Knight and Jey Uso had a run-in during the arrivals at the opening, and while they were in Raw GM Adam Pearce’s office later, Knight begged for a match against the two Bronnys. This led to the main event between Bron Breakker and Bronson Reed versus Knight and, eventually, Jimmy Uso.

Even later into the show, Stephanie Vaquer got into an argument with Asuka, who volunteered Kairi Sane to face her on Raw. Just like that, we had our second impromptu match of the evening.

Stop. Doing. This.

The occasional situation with two wrestlers needing to settle their differences in the ring immediately is completely plausible and acceptable, but when it comes on the heels of weeks or months of WWE GMs booking their shows on the fly, there’s no benefit of the doubt to be given.

If they did this once every two or three months, it would be barely noticeable. But half of Raw’s card is booked after the show goes live these days, which is embarrassing even as an emulation of sport or (as Triple H called it) a “movie about the sport.”

2. Rolling On Repeat

Stop this writer if you’ve heard this before: Monday Night Raw was main-evented by members of The Vision facing some combination of LA Knight, CM Punk, and an Uso, and the match shockingly was followed by a heel beatdown that became more of a focus than the result.

For the eighth consecutive week (and 11th time in 12 weeks), Raw wrapped up with that familiar cast of characters facing off in the ring, with most of those matches ending in a disqualification or with some shenanigans, and/or followed by a post-match heel attack.

That is the height of lazy, unimaginative booking, as nothing really has been advanced in these matches. Sure, Knight and Jey Uso have fallen apart as allies, but that has been the result of the extracurriculars after the main event. The match – which sometimes is booked during Raw – is just a vehicle to get to that angle, rendering the match itself and the result meaningless.

And once you realize that, it becomes extremely easy to tune out action, even when it’s good. At this point, it’s hard to remember the last time a Raw main event felt like the match itself carried any significant weight. It’s just the last match of the night, booked midway through the show and pitting a limited cast of characters against each other in slightly different groupings with no real stakes attached.

1. Selling Ice To An Eskimo

John Cena’s appearances are dwindling, and one would think that, knowing there are only about a half-dozen episodes left featuring him as an active performer, there would be more emotion and heft at this late stage.

But Cena’s show-opening promo on Raw Monday night was the typical John Cena go-home promo to sell a PPV/PLE match. He spoke about his opponent, tried to frame the match as a huge mountain to climb, refused to back down from a challenge, did a hard sell for Saturday's match at WWE Wrestlepalooza, and left after a 10-to-15-minute monologue.

Perhaps the problem is that it’s hard to be invested in this match for multiple reasons. Brock Lesnar has no place on WWE programming in 2025, even absent of the Janel Grant sex trafficking lawsuit against Vince McMahon that names Lesnar 44 times. Simply put, wrestling has passed Brock’s brand of sports entertainment by. His return has seen the Beast “play the hits,” crystalizing how outdated the mid-match “Brock ruins everything” trope really is. His segment with R-Truth on SmackDown was abysmal.

Cena’s promo on Raw wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t anything different than what we’ve heard 100 times during the past 20 years. And when you’ve got two part-timers who are giving about 50%-75% effort in the ring while playing the hits, it’s just hard to warm up to this stuff. Maybe the match will deliver on the night, but it won’t live up to their 2012 and 2014 matches, so lower your expectations.

This entire feud is a waste of Cena’s limited dates. WWE could have gone with a fun, new matchup, like Cena versus Bron Breakker, Montez Ford, Rey Fenix, Penta, Carmelo Hayes, or some other out-of-the-box opponent, but instead, it’s Cena/Brock. Again.

Ups…

5. Bayley Translates On Television

Throughout the weeks of painful vignettes featuring Bayley’s inner thoughts becoming audible to fans, the prevailing comment here was that this needed to make its way to live television with Bayley to see how it played out in person, versus confusing prepackaged videos.

Monday, Bayley returned to Raw to save Lyra Valkyria from a Judgment Day beatdown. She took out both Raquel Rodriguez and Roxanne Perez with a flurry of offense that she used to utilize when she was the Huggable One in NXT. She appeared to struggle with how to react to Lyra, then rolled out of the ring and began hugging everyone at ringside – the announcers, the referee, fans – like an overcaffeinated circa-2015 Bayley.

Later, Valkyria went to thank Bayley, only to overhear her having a loud argument in her dressing room. When Lyra entered, Bayley was alone, dressed in a Two-Face-esque jacket. Lyra tried to apologize for what she said to Bayley a couple of months ago, and Bayley snapped at her, calling her an idiot before storming out.

While not great, this was certainly much better “in the room” than it was on pre-tape. It still might not fly, but this was a much better week for Bayley than the past month or so.

4. Heavy Is The Head That Wears The Crown

Dominik Mysterio might consider himself the King of the Luchadores after winning the AAA Mega Championship at Worlds Collide this past weekend, but he found out Monday night that not only did he double his titles, but he increased his problems.

The Judgment Day was celebrating with champagne when Finn Balor threw cold water on the moment by noting that the women had had a rough night. When they demurred, Balor turned to El Grande Americano, as Finn and JD McDonagh asked what the ridiculous German luchador would want in return for constantly helping Dom.

Mysterio blew them off and suggested El Grande might just want to help him because he’s the King of the Luchadores. This set Balor off, who bluntly told Dirty Dom that maybe next time the Judgment Day wouldn’t be there to back him up.

As if on cue, Rusev showed up to introduce himself (with a fun moment of Dominik saying he couldn’t shake his hand because Mysterio’s hands were full with the titles) and declare that he was going to be the next Intercontinental Champion.

Poor Dom is in for a rough ride. It will be interesting to see how all of this plays out for Dominik in the coming weeks – will Judgment Day finally fracture, could Dominik turn babyface, will Americano become the latest member of the group?

3. Side Quest Uploading

Stephanie Vaquer is going to be a fantastic women’s world champion in WWE soon enough, though it likely won’t happen until WrestleMania 42. Assuming she loses to Iyo Sky at WWE Wrestlepalooza, Vaquer will need to find something to occupy her time this fall before building up to a 'Mania challenge.

Enter, Asuka.

Raw provided the clearest glimpse into the depth of the Raw women’s division, with Rhea Ripley vowing to come after whomever is champion, Iyo and Asuka’s relationship fracturing, and the Empress confronting La Primera while throwing Kairi Sane in her path.

Kairi put up a good fight – though her attempt at mutual respect earned Asuka’s scorn – but she ultimately fell to Stephanie in a modestly good match. Sane is still straddling the line, loyal to Asuka but clearly conflicted between her friendship with Iyo and being a generally good person, and following Asuka down a darker path.

Meanwhile, Asuka clearly views everyone as inferior to her (including Iyo) and will likely view Vaquer as a threat post-Wrestlepalooza. It’s not hard to see the two facing off later this fall, perhaps in a small series of matches, as Asuka continues her descent into villainy.

2. Lyra Overcomes Roxanne

This might surprise some of you, but Lyra Valkyria and Roxanne Perez are both very good at this wrestling thing, so when they got in the ring together Monday night, they put together a pretty good little match.

Clocking in at under 10 minutes, the singles bout didn’t overstay its welcome. Lyra carried her back injury through the entire match, with Roxanne targeting it but ultimately coming up short. Along the way, both women had some nice moments, with Perez yanking Valkyria off the top rope and driving her knees into Lyra’s back with that cartwheel splash, and Valkyria hitting a gutwrench powerbomb for a close two count and turning a crossface into a Nightwing to pick up the win.

As has been mentioned here numerous times, Lyra is a rare WWE character who connects with the fans more in the ring than she does in backstage segments or in-ring promos. Letting her wrestle is the best way to keep her in the fans’ good graces. And Roxanne is going to break out in the next year or so as she continues to impress every week.

1. Mixed Tag Face-Off Delivers

The build to WWE Wrestlepalooza's mixed tag match pitting Seth Rollins and Becky Lynch against CM Punk and AJ Lee has been pretty simplistic by some wrestling booking standards, but it’s been magnificently effective: Rollins enlisted his wife to help retain his world title, so Punk brought in his wife to balance the scales, creating a massive moment with AJ’s WWE return after a decade-long absence.

Monday, the four wrestlers squared off in the ring with a hot crowd constantly letting Seth and Becky know what they thought of them, and the heel champions were only too gleeful to play off that raucous atmosphere, with Lynch telling fans to “Show my hot husband some respect” when they chanted, “Shut the f**k up!” When they yelled, “No one likes you!” to Seth, Becky responded that she did. And Rollins declared the crowd had “gone too far” when they chanted that Becky was “constipated” (AJ said Lynch made that kind of face on SmackDown).

Beyond the interplay with the crowd, all four clearly knew their roles and delivered perfectly, including AJ, who ratcheted up the “unpredictability” - well, she did say she makes rash decisions because she’s a Puerto Rican from New Jersey, and sometimes you just have to “shank a chick” - before ultimately slapping Rollins.

Rollins and Lynch played the first couple of Chicago nicely when Seth mirrored Punk’s SmackDown line about having someone to put their hands on a woman (meaning AJ). Becky balked, and she and Seth argued before Lynch walked out. This led to Rollins pie-facing Punk and setting off a chase, leaving AJ alone for Becky to hit a sneak-attack Manhandle Slam – the first bump AJ’s taken in WWE in a decade.

There was more goodness in here, including Becky questioning AJ’s health, Rollins taunting Punk about restraining himself when his wife was in trouble, and Punk calling himself “AJ’s husband” and then mostly taking a backseat to his wife to carry the promo for their side.

Solid go-home angle that ensured this match is a must-watch for anyone still on the fence.

Get 76% off and three months for free when you sign up to NordVPN here: https://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=704&aff_id=3013&source=WCWRE

Advertisement