50 Ups & 50 Downs For WWE's Decade: The 2010s

By Michael Hamflett /

41. AJ Styles & Shinsuke Nakamura: A Load Of Balls

WWE Network

The "Dream Match" that became a nightmare programme, Shinsuke Nakamura's failed efforts to claim the WWE Championship from AJ Styles brought the 'King Of Strong Style' to his knees...about a dozen times, to punch him in the d*ck.

Advertisement

Styles' entire second reign in a...ahem...nutshell, this feud delivered disappointment after disappointment with the perplexing post-WrestleMania direction only marginally more interesting as a result of Nakamura's quirky testicular fixation.

A deathblow to his topline hopes, the lack of a simple banger between them was more disheartening than the constant low blows. AJ's run was boringly f*cking passable at that point that there's probably a picture of him getting rattled in the plums next to the word in the dictionary. Little was good, little was bad, and for somebody supposedly 'Phenomenal', this was as big a problem as the endless ballshots.

Advertisement

40. Evoking Reid Flair

WWE

Horribly effective at causing needless offence this one, mostly because it would have been so simple to avoid. Ahead of a Survivor Series 2015 clash with friend-turned-rival Paige, Charlotte Flair spoke at length about life as a wrestler's daughter as well as mentioning her late brother Reid, who had tragically committed suicide two years earlier.

Advertisement

'The Queen' suggested she would fight "as her family always had", Paige spat back "your little baby brother didn't have much fight in him did he?".

It was a tasteless response on the surface, let alone when reports emerged that the extended Flair family including WWE cheerleader Ric weren't given prior warning of the callous reminder of the 25-year-old's passing.

Advertisement

39. Roman Reigns Vs Samoa Joe, Backlash 2018

WWE.com

Fans headed for the exits early as Roman Reigns and Samoa Joe chinlocked their way to one of the most disappointing pay-per-view main events of the decade, but was the abysmal assemblage down to the men in the ring or the ones pulling the strings from the safety of the backstage area?

Advertisement

In every possible sense of the phrase, the New Jersey fans didn't care and had literally had enough.

They'd had enough WWE - Backlash 2018 was just a week removed from the ultra-controversial Greatest Royal Rumble in Saudi Arabia, and only four on from yet another controversial WrestleMania. They'd had enough Roman Reigns - the 'Big Dog' was a two-time loser against Lesnar and wasn't wrestling here like his future trajectory depended on it. They'd even had enough Backlash - the show was the worst pay-per-view of year and foreshadowed possibly the most disheartening post-'Mania slump in recent memory.

Advertisement

Beating the traffic meant so much more than witnessing Roman Reigns beat Samoa Joe. The product's value had never felt lower.

38. Bret Hart Vs Vince McMahon, WrestleMania XXVI

WWE.com

A soul-crushing disappointment for those that had waited over 12 years to see it, the WrestleMania scrap between Bret Hart and Vince McMahon featured so much more than anybody could have expected yet couldn't have delivered any less.

Advertisement

A generation of fans just wanted to watch the Chairman absorb a punch in the face similar to the IRL one he took in a Montreal locker room and scream in agony thanks to one cathartic Sharpshooter. Instead, WWE served up an awkward 11-minute beatdown from 'The Hitman' and the entire Hart Family that almost babyfaced the evil billionaire by the end.

There were few can't-miss Attitude Era hold-offs left to address by 2010. After this, Bret Hart's legacy was yet again left screwed with.

Advertisement

37. The Authority Vs Daniel Bryan

WWE

It'd be easy enough to classify this as a Down if simply viewed the prism of the Daniel Bryan/Randy Orton singles matches that dragged on and on in 2013's post-SummerSlam rot, but that series of encounters was simply reflective of a company stubbornly refusing to book in line with fan expectation.

Advertisement

More on the Yes Movement later, but so much of that ungainly groundswell was inadvertently driven by WWE themselves.

The company reframed the narrative in the intervening years, noting that Triple H and Stephanie McMahon's storyline crusade against Bryan's success was a necessary mountain for him to climb ahead of a WrestleMania triumph, but the real story exists within the bowels of the WWE Network. The truth is all there - they were actively working to drain the life from an organic entity far stronger than any of them had realised.

Advertisement

36. The Old Day

Advertisement

Go easy on this one as light and utterly f*cking stupid WWE comedy, or kick them a YouTube view on their official account and let the horrendously misused performers do the talking?

Enjoy this, Part One of a three-part series.

Advertisement

35. John Cena Vs John Laurinaitis, Over The Limit 2012

WWE.com

A spiteful and predictable piece of sh*t that found WWE wilfully stewing in its own juices, John Cena's destruction of John Laurinaitis was charmless garbage that wasn't even his to have. The Raw and SmackDown GM's actual rival CM Punk was way too busy having a midcard (WWE Title) banger with Daniel Bryan to concern himself with this.

Advertisement

Obnoxious to a teeth-gnashing degree, Cena played not to the crowd in attendance but to the hyenas on the announce desk that clearly enjoyed watching their irritating colleague take a sh*tkicking. Or were told to if Vince McMahon happened to be popping half to death at ringside.

'The Champ' lost thanks a Big Show turn absolutely every f*cker in the audience and watching at home could see coming, and not just because the 7-footer was so massive. That getting to the finish took 17 minutes may be the biggest crime of all.

Advertisement

34. 18 Seconds

Youtube

When a World Title match between champion Daniel Bryan and Royal Rumble winner Sheamus was announced for WrestleMania XXVIII, it was thought as much to be an atonement for some poor treatment the pair were given on the pre-show the prior year. Having had their United States title clash dumped to the dark match slot (and then converted to a battle royal won by the Great Khali half way through) in 2010, the rematch a year later looked to vindicate their pair for the previous mistreatment.

Advertisement

Fans knew it, and thus uttered their incredulous indignation when, after just 18 seconds, Bryan had been defeated. Part of a bigger storyline involving the crumbling relationship between Bryan and AJ Lee, it served merely as a backdrop to their inevitable collapse. Overbearing douchebag boyfriend Bryan demanded a kiss, then had his lights knocked out with a Brogue Kick.

The sentiment from the "Yes" chants that followed birthed an entire moment and the match itself can now be viewed through that. On the night at least though, the anger and fury was very, very real.

Advertisement

33. The Anonymous Raw General Manager

WWE.com

There were two payoffs - if you can even really call them that - to this confusing and uninspiring take on the Authority figure trope. In keeping with this angle in general, neither of them were remotely satisfying.

Advertisement

In 2010, a gradually-turning Michael Cole became the voice of a GM who only communicated through a laptop. This had intrigue...until enough weeks passed that it became clear WWE hadn't figured out the end of the story. After meddling with heels and babyfaces alike, the machine sent Edge off a cliff before disappearing entirely right around the time lesser-of-two-evils John Laurinaitis took the reins of Raw.

A one-note joke years later revealed Hornswoggle as the man behind the decisions made, because by then everything was a joke, and Hornswoggle was always the punchline.

Advertisement

32. Jerry Lawler Vs Michael Cole, WrestleMania XXVII

WWE.com

A chronic encounter that foreshadowed a decade of sending tap-ins miles wide, WWE conspired to take the easiest booking task of 2011's WrestleMania and make an almighty f*cking hash of it.

Advertisement

Michael Cole was due a sh*tkicking, and he was due one from company icon (but WrestleMania debutant) Jerry Lawler. Instead, WWE stretched it out to an astonishing 13:45 and booked a dusty finish in order to put Cole over and stretch the programme out for two more pay-per-views.

The 'Show Of Shows' may still have been the company's 'Grandest Stage', but it permanently ceased to be WWE's final destination from that point on.

Advertisement