6 Ups & 1 Down From WWE SmackDown (22 Nov - Results & Review)
Paul Heyman returns! CM Punk joins the OG Bloodline! WWE nails SmackDown again!
Paul Heyman returned to dig Roman Reigns out of a hole by revealing CM Punk as the OG Bloodline's trump card heading into a largely family based WarGames showdown.
That was the biggest story coming out of another tidy episode of SmackDown. WWE boss Triple H hasn't quite stuck to his guns in terms of trashing Vince McMahon's tired 'book to the calendar' style for PLEs, but the top billed match at Survivor Series is a winner regardless. There are multiple layers to it that the writers can use marching into the new year too, which is a real bonus.
Sadly, the women's WarGames match doesn't feel anywhere near as intriguing. It's rather forced, being honest, and there are a few annoying plot holes that wreck the idea of trust and story needed. These ladies are teaming together because it's November, not because it's the right thing to do and fans demanded them in the double cage. That comes across loud and clear.
Last week's SmackDown was one of the best of the modern era. Friday's edition ran it close, but there was one negative to talk about. Hence the solitary 'Down'. The 'Ups' are cheerier though - there are some really great dramas going on across WWE's programming right now.
WarGames looms, Cody Rhodes and Kevin Owens are cutting sensational face to face promos, Shinsuke Nakamura is stalking LA Knight like some warped version of 'Crow' Sting stalking the nWo, and even the tag-team scene has some developments worth keeping a beady eye on.
Here's all the good and not a lot of bad from another well-produced and easy to watch two hours of WWE TV.
Down...
1. Women’s WarGames Feels Too Rushed
Best to get this out of the way ASAP.
It’s pretty hard to get hyped up for the women’s WarGames match at Survivor Series next weekend, to be honest. Everything about it feels lumped together just because it’s November and WWE wanted another excuse to use the double cage. In short, they should’ve kept WarGames exclusively for the OG Bloodline vs. New Bloodline story. That's a far-reaching tale with considerable depth, and it's worthy of the gimmick.
Bayley will presumably replace Jade Cargill in the match due to her mystery attack injury plot, but that also stomps all over Bianca Belair not trusting the ex-Damage CTRL leader since their run-ins as rivals. To that point, why is Bianca suddenly content to team with IYO SKY then? Nothing about that makes sense. It spits in the face of consistency WWE often fights so hard to champion.
Thrown together, illogical stuff like this is what Triple H should be avoiding, not writing. Survivor Series will be the second PLE in a row where top female champs like Liv Morgan and Nia Jax have been in so-so situations too. That's pretty annoying, and it doesn't exactly bode well for another female belt on the midcard if champs are spat out into scenarios like this just because it happens to be a certain month.
SmackDown's tag match with Bayley and Naomi vs. Tiffany Stratton and Candice LeRae was also lacklustre from a technical standpoint. It was a step down for all of those women from what they've been doing lately. Gee, can you tell this writer isn't high on the women's WarGames feeling so rushed?!
Ups...
6. Short But Sweet Solo Setup
Solo Sikoa and his own Bloodline came out early for a quick promo offering Roman Reigns and his troops the chance to surrender before WarGames next week. Nothing especially fancy here, people, but it did portray Solo as a smug would-be ’Tribal Chief’ who thought he had the OG Bloodline backed into a corner before the end of the show changed everything.
His mic time was very short, but also very essential for what was coming later on. The loudest word Solo said was “surrender”. His character figured Roman, The Usos and Sami Zayn would have to see sense and concede that there's no way they're beating him, Jacob Fatu, Bronson Reed, Tama Tonga and Tonga Loa 4v5 inside the double cage.
Sometimes, the shortest segments also turn out to be the most necessary. Solo's brief speech gave the OG Bloodline a thread they could chase throughout the entire episode (once they arrived at the building), and it added context to why they'd be in the ring to have a little meeting with the New Bloodline right at the end of the show. Further, Sikoa did well to palm off boos and get the "surrender" bit over.
He's starting to come into his own as a heel on the mic, which is great to see. Some have been hard on him here or there, but loosening up and showing a little more personality has been good for Solo. It speaks volumes that he's still WWE's main man in the group despite heavy fan interest in both Fatu and Reed.
Their time to shine is coming. Bronson has already tasted a bit of that over on Raw.
5. All About Story More Than Match
Here's the deal: Montez Ford vs. Tommaso Ciampa was hardly bad, but it’s clear these two are capable of so much better. That'll hopefully come down the line in the future when moves are more important than story. Or on PLE when they can marry both. Often, on TV, segments lean more on narrative drive than in-ring quality. Fair enough. It's better that these dudes have something going on week to week that fans can follow.
On Friday, their bout was more about the story of Ciampa losing it over the thought of Johnny Gargano being all buddy buddy with the Motor City Machine Guns. Toss The Street Profits into the mix and you’ve got a three-way tag waiting to happen…if Ciampa and Gargano even remain together as DIY. WWE want you to believe that it's only a matter of time before Tommaso does the dirty on 'Johnny Wrestling' again; just like he did years ago down in NXT.
There could be a plot twist coming though. Perhaps Gargano will be the one to cut Ciampa loose and start some sort of faction with Chris Sabin and Alex Shelley. Or, hell, maybe all four guys will come together eventually as a brand new group. Anything is possible, and that's what makes this story so much fun.
It's just sweet to add in something more than 'they're fighting for the titles'. Belts should be important, but the casual audience gravitates more towards human stories they can relate to. Ciampa warning Gargano to pick a side and keep his eye on their ambitions is simple, believable and relatable.
There have been loads of heartbreaking tag breakups in WWE history. DIY's would be right up there, if it happens again.
4. Another Tidy Women’s Triple Threat
That first three-way in the Women’s United States Title tournament between Bayley, B-FAB and Candice LeRae last week was a blast. Everyone involved had time to shine, and B-FAB rightly earned rave reviews behind the curtain for matching more experienced workers all the way. Ready for more good news? This week’s effort matched that success.
Bianca Belair, Blair Davenport and Chelsea Green all meshed well together and did everything they could to keep things motoring along. Jade Cargill being laid out backstage distracted Belair and gave her an excuse to leave in a panic, which left Chelsea alone to pin Davenport and advance in the tourney. One just can’t argue with slick ring work, a slightly surprising winner and some story intrigue for the Women’s Tag-Team Champs along the way.
That's solid television. Well done, Hunter. Take a bow, son!
Seriously, this fan was hard on WWE for introducing another belt. They've had a tough enough time giving Nia Jax and Liv Morgan suitable opponents, so adding even more gold sounded risky. Shockingly, this fan also doesn't have all the answers, and it's pretty neat to be proven wrong. Thus far, the Women's US Title tournament is letting a few overlooked workers grab some spotlight and improve their standing on the roster.
That's a huge plus. Long may it continue. These zippy triple threats are perfect for weekly programming too. Neither one to date has outstayed its welcome (both have been around the 10 minute mark), and even the losers have been bolstered and/or received some story context to spin out onto afterwards.
3. That Whole Shin Stalks LA Knight Package
Everything worked here.
LA Knight was literally looking over his shoulder from the moment he walked through the curtain, then Shinsuke Nakamura cut a cool pre-taped promo in Japanese on him before the match with Santos Escobar. The crux of Shin's mind games talked about how Knight is riddled with insecurities and needs constant reassurance from the audience to keep going. If he doesn't get that, then he'll fall flat and fail.
There's no denying that Escobar has slipped down the pecking order lately, but he was a solid opponent vs. LA for this outing. These lads have been around the horn together before, so they were always going to come up with something watchable amidst Naka's psychological warfare routine. Shin ambushing LA again post-match gives him an edge and makes him look dangerous - he’s inside the champ’s head, which is something a little different for LA because his character doesn’t normally get rattled.
Personally, this writer has always preferred Nakamura as a vicious heel, so this is all super enjoyable to watch play out. WWE has found Shinsuke's style on the mic. He's much, much, much better in pre-tapes than he is with a live mic inside the ring. Letting him speak his native tongue and using subtitles was another inspired choice, because everything about him feels more natural these days.
This will be a high quality midcard title match whether it happens at Survivor Series or at the upcoming Saturday Night's Main event show in mid-December. The next question is this: Should Nakamura be the one to end LA's title reign, even if it's only temporary?
Answers on a postcard.
2. Cody & KO Cut Killer Promos
Sometimes, it's difficult to know what to expect when WWE advertises these "Face To Face" showdowns. They typically close with a wild brawl, but Triple H knew he'd be running with that for the OG Bloodline vs. New Bloodline stuff later in the show. So, Cody Rhodes and Kevin Owens had to wage war with words and get cerebral when seeking ways to keep their skit intense.
They went above and beyond to sell their friends-turned-enemies story.
Owens blamed Cody for everything that’s happened, and said he fought The Bloodline for four gruelling years only for Rhodes to turn around and team with Roman Reigns first time he was asked. Cody cut through that logic by pointing out that Randy Orton didn’t deserve to become collateral. If Kev had a problem with Rhodes, then take it out on him not someone else. Cody also said Owens couldn’t pull the trigger when he had an injured knee at Bash In Berlin, which was fun and made that PLE seem more important than a glorified international house show with cameras.
Kevin closed the segment by saying he hates Cody, but Rhodes reckons KO hates himself. Strong stuff all round from both men, and it's even better that they didn’t even need to come to blows. Wrestling's best heels have some reasonable justification in their minds for bad actions. They think they're right! Owens has that air to him, but also wears guilt on his face whenever he's pinned down and ranted at for hitting a nasty piledriver on Randy.
This was must see. Speaking of which...
1. Paul Heyman Comes Through
His name is Paul Heyman, and he just silenced Solo Sikoa by revealing CM Punk as the fifth member of Roman, The Usos and Sami Zayn's OG Bloodline team at Survivor Series. That's such an interesting pick on many levels, not least because Heyman's evil glare from the ring apron teases he could turn on Roman eventually. The 'Advocate' has previous when it comes to doing that, let's not forget.
OK, so Heyman bringing Punk out suggests they've be aligned on screen again (which could irk Reigns). Also, there was always a chance Seth Rollins would've reconsidered knocking Roman back just to get a shot at revenge on Bronson Reed now he's part of Solo's crew. In effect, whether by accident or design, Punk stole his thunder there. That'll keep bad blood between Seth and CM rolling into next year. Finally, the thought of Punk tangling with Sikoa and Jacob Fatu in singles bouts going forwards sounds rather tasty.
There's so much to work with between Punk and both sides of the Bloodline divide.
Simply seeing Roman and Punk have a short staredown mid-ring was worth watching SmackDown for alone. Everyone knows they'll have a money match someday. For now, they're partners, but trouble in paradise is one miscommunicated spot away. What a genius decision to have Heyman bring Punk to the party. Roman's wise man took the plunge seemingly without consulting his 'Tribal Chief'.
Remember that as the plot thickens. However, bask in the knowledge that Punk is about to work WarGames one year after re-debuting in the company immediately following the last one.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 10 Wrestlers Who Became Everything They HATED and 10 WWE Breakups You Forgot Were HEARTBREAKING!