10 WWE Breakups You Forgot Were HEARTBREAKING

Forgotten heartbreakers from WWE history. Get your tissues at the ready!

Faarooq Bradshaw APA 2002 Split
WWE

Follow-up is vital to any wrestling angle's success. If promoters can't come up with a satisfying second chapter, then the first's impact tends to be forgotten, and that's a real shame when it comes to some of the beauties explored here. You might not actually remember much about them at all - either that or this will be one of those 'core memory unlocked' moments the cool kids talk about. 

WWE split tag teams, factions and on-screen relationships a ton. It's a go to trope for creative, joined by others like "dumb" returns. Need something to plug a hole for the next month? Put someone in a short-lived team then spin out into a feud. Voilá! Instant (albeit short-term) story). Boy meets girl > boy and girl fall in love > another boy steals girl > original boy has to fight for her affection was another oft-repeated story back in the day.

That sort of love-in isn't the main focus here. There are only three romantic relationships on the list, but they're worthy additions to this tear-jerking memory jog. Others concentrate on teams that grew close, or siblings who were always close but had a dynamite split. Sure, things went wrong for their storylines after that, but the initial emotional stab cut deep with fans.

Again, poor follow up can explain why so many people ignore these WWE breakups today. Admittedly, remembering absolutely everything the company has committed to tape is a challenge anyway. They've produced countless hours of footage, which means countless hours of splitty goodness!

Get the tissues ready, because those tears will fall.

10. WWE Splits The IIconics

The IIconics WWE Split
WWE.com

There's no better way to start things than by looking at genuine emotion bubbling to the surface.

Billie Kay and Peyton Royce were real-life friends who lived the WWE dream. They did everything together, but poor creative choices squashed their potential as a tag team all too quickly. That kind of rubbish was an annoying trait towards the end of Vince McMahon's run in charge. Sometimes, it seemed like the old boss was actively going out of his way to be rotten to his roster.

On the 31 August 2020 Raw, McMahon decided to split The IIconics as part of an angle. A month or so later, Kay and Royce went their separate ways by being placed on different shows during the Draft, and that was that. They must've been emotional about it, but surely no more emotional than they'd been in late August. WWE's cameras captured quite the moment for .com and YouTube.

It showed things sinking in for the attached-at-the-hip pair. They realised that they'd be apart for the first time since putting pen to paper on their WWE contracts, and admitted to feeling scared about the future. At one point, Billie even told Peyton: "I'll miss you", and the pals burst into tears all over again.

Cameras captured real human feeling here, and it was difficult not to get swept up in everything. Remember saying goodbye to your old school mates when everyone went off to college or university? Yeah, that. There's never any guarantee you'll see your best mates again, and that stings.

Everyone could relate to The IIconics as they poured their hearts out.


9. Kevin Owens Attacks Chris Jericho

Chris Jericho Kevin Owens
WWE

Watch episodes of AEW Dynamite today and you might find yourself longing for a Tony Khan product without one Chris Jericho. The legend can hide behind his current heel guise all he likes, but that doesn't tell the full story. Some wrestling fans are plain sick of him, and it'd be for the best if absence was allowed to let hearts grow fonder. If that's even possible. No, it would be - people just need a break.

"Break" was appropriate back on the 13 February 2016 Raw. Heartbreak, that is. Mere hours before Valentine's Day hit and love was in the air, WWE booked a masterclass in sympathetic babyface work and heel viciousness all at once. Kevin Owens shoved Chris's "Festival Of Friendship" right back in his face by gifting him a new 'List Of Jericho'. The first name? Jericho's.

Cue a heel beatdown that put maximum heat on KO and ended a popular (not to mention lovably comedic) alliance. Jericho being one of AEW’s least-wanted stars in 2024 makes it easy to forget just how endearing he was with his, “You just made the list” cries in 2016-2017. Fans were legit gutted when Owens turned on him. They weren't ready to say goodbye to such obvious chemistry quite yet.

WWE ripped the wound open with one segment anyway, and Jericho vs. Kev was the feud on everyone's lips. OK, so they didn't get the Universal Title rivalry both deserved, but the ex-partners can still look back on one hell of a split. It had everyone begging to see Jericho get some revenge. KO's heel behaviour has been justifiable on occasion, but this wasn't one of those occasions!


8. Daniel Bryan Blames AJ Lee

Daniel Bryan Danielson AJ Lee
WWE.com

Watch enough wrestling and you start to see things happening before they've even been booked. After all, there are only so many different directions writers can take the simple storylines this biz throws up. Case in point: Daniel Bryan growing increasingly exasperated by AJ Lee's attempts to help him in 2012. Everybody could see what WWE had planned for this. They just didn't know when the bullet would be loaded into the chamber.

Bryan was humiliated by a shock 18 second loss to Sheamus at WrestleMania XXVIII. Pre-bell, AJ had smooched her man with a good luck kiss, so naturally Dan blamed her for taking his eyes off the prize. That was one "mistake" too many. After 'Mania, Bryan berated Lee then dumped her on an episode of SmackDown. Meanwhile, AJ turned on the waterworks and desperately tried to salvage something from their relationship.

This was top tier drama. Lee's selling of everything ridiculous Daniel fired at her was fabulous. Later, she’d get her revenge by leaving Bryan standing at the alter. WRESTLING! WWE were always going to try squeeze a little more juice from the story. Bryan needed his ultimate comeuppance, because he was the one who pushed AJ to the mental brink with his gaslighting behaviour on-screen.

Look, fans knew the score here, and some even revelled in how OTT Daniel's promos were, but Lee produced such masterful facial expressions and realistic tears that it was impossible not to side with her. Really great character work from both, although AJ nods slightly ahead because she had the harder gig. Her distraught puppy dog eyes were outstanding.


7. Dusty Rhodes Loses His Sweet Sapphire

WWF WWE SummerSlam 1990 Gene Okerlund Dusty Rhodes Sapphire
WWE

Here's one you likely weren't expecting.

Don't look over here all nimbly bimbly with your jaw flip-flopping all over the place like WCW Cruiserweights on Nitro in 1997. Shout out to Dusty on commentary, by the way. He rarely made much sense beyond meme-worthy soundbites, but he added a lot to WCW's best moments and the way he called Bobby Heenan "pumpkin head" lives long in the memory. So, mind you, does his range at SummerSlam 1990.

There, Rhodes launched a backstage campaign to find his "Sweet Sapphire". She'd gone missing, which was especially worrying considering she had a match lined up vs. the devious Sensational Sherri. Dusty enlisted the likes of Jim Duggan (their backstage promo is must see silliness) to help him find her, but no dice. Nobody could spot Sapphire, then she no-showed the match itself.

Later, it was revealed that Sapphire had sold out to Ted DiBiase's 'Million Dollar Man' character and turned her back on Dusty. The 'Dream' was shattered, so much so that he couldn't get his head in the game for a match with Randy Savage on the same card. This was some lowkey excellent emotional work from Rhodes during a largely cartoony era. It was unexpected for a bubbly dude in polka dots.

Sapphire ripped Dusty's heart out live on pay-per-view, and traded his values for cold hard cash. That instantly put heat on DiBiase, but it might've turned her into a killer heel gimmick too if she'd stuck around long enough. Still, unreal levels of affection, concern, distress and then anguish from Dust across the entire show.


6. Matt Stabs Jeff Hardy In The Back

WWE Royal Rumble 2009 Matt Jeff Hardy Edge
WWE.com

There's been a lot of talk about how far Matt and Jeff Hardy were willing to go when bidding to sell their split as real in 2009, and their WrestleMania XXV scrap routinely pops up when people reminisce about disappointing bouts from the biggest night(s) on the WWE calendar. All of that is fair, but do you recall the sudden shock value of Matt's turn at the '09 Royal Rumble?

Few can grumble about that. It's been buried beneath all of the sensationalistic stuff like Matt claiming he burned down Jeff's house and murdered his dog, which played off real-life tragedy, but the initial moment was heartbreaking for those who loved the brothers and considered them a team for life. Nobody thought The Hardys would have their Rockers moment.

That was an unfavourable, although perhaps unavoidable, comparison too. Critics dubbed Jeff the Shawn Michaels and Matt the Marty Jannetty of this breakup overnight. More attention was put on that and the dreadful house fire/dog death combo than there was on a beloved sibling tag team splintering apart. Don't forget that Matt also cost Jeff the WWE Title by stabbing him in the back.

Edge was there to scoop the glory for himself and launch into another championship reign.

Jeff was depicted as crestfallen and disconsolate on TV afterwards. That would've been enough to get fans onside without mixing in real-world misery for the sake of it. The audience's heartache over Matt's snap decision at the Rumble should be remembered fondly, not everything that came next.


5. Otis & Mandy Rose Separate

Mandy Rose Otis
WWE.com

It's been a thing since 2002, and is hyped up annually as a game-changing must-see shake-up, but 99.9% of fans see right through WWE's Draft these days. That 'genie is out of the bottle' realisation has blighted every Draft with the exception of those earlier ones and possibly 2016's brand split. There's no going back now, put it that way. 2020 suffered from familiar Draft problems WWE may never fix.

Creative needed some shocks to give the Draft purpose, so they split Otis and Mandy Rose for no rhyme or reason and put them on separate shows without exploring the happiest side of their unlikely relationship. That left a sour taste in the mouths of fans, not least because it sent Otis into an on-screen tailspin that bottomed out when he lost his Money In The Bank briefcase to The Miz.

Miz was blamed for meddling in the couple's love life and causing Mandy to end up on Raw. Being honest, that didn't make much sense - how did Miz have the power to do that anyway?! WWE clearly needed some sort of flimsy excuse to justify their decision. They didn't have an end goal in mind for Rose and Otis, obviously. Thus, they decided to string everyone along until the Draft.

This sucked for anyone who had invested in Otis winning Mandy over despite her "being out of [his] league". WWE told that tale for months, then dropped it like a bad habit without any closure. That was another hallmark of latter-day Vince, sadly. He didn't seem to think that viewers would notice or care.

They did.


4. Big E Watches His Friends Go

WWE Draft 2020 New Day Split
WWE.com

One more 2020 Draft recollection then you're free to live your life never thinking about it again...until Triple H yells about how important it is in 2025, that is. You know that's coming.

On the 9 October 2020 SmackDown, Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods beat Cesaro and Shinsuke Nakamura in a predictably fun tag bout. Post-match, all three members of New Day looked on in horror as Stephanie McMahon announced that Kofi and Xavier had been drafted to Raw. Big E would be staying put on SmackDown, which meant New Day wouldn't be on the same show for the first time since forming.

Technically, this wasn't an official split 'cause they all maintained their friendships without much incident, but it did feel like the first big sea change moment for New Day as a group. Things were arguably never really the same for them post-2020 Draft. The company began properly exploring what E was capable of as a singles star, and then a life-threatening neck injury benched him. Maybe permanently (people are still holding out hopes that he'll be able to wrestle again someday).

E's depressed state following Stephanie's announcement summed things up. He watched his friends stick together with at least one mate over on the flagship, whilst he had to stay on the blue brand and try to pick up the pieces solo. It was a nightmarish thought to think that New Day would be split up for good.

They're one of WWE's most cherished acts for a reason. Fast forward to 2024 and everyone's fearing an official schism all over again. WILL THE PAIN NEVER CEASE?!


3. Bray Wyatt Sets Luke Harper Free

Luke Harper WWE
WWE

Erick Rowan was involved in this moment too, of course, but his story hasn't been beset by the same personal tragedy as his stablemates in years since. Back in 2014, WWE fancied temporarily moving away from The Wyatt Family. On the 29 September Raw, they had Bray Wyatt set Luke Harper and Rowan free. It's Harper who tugged at the heartstrings most.

Yes, that has a lot to do with the premature deaths of Brodie Lee and Bray in 2020 and 2023 respectively. Promos that aired on the flagship showing Wyatt discussing how proud he was of Harper and how much he wanted to see him succeed have become particularly poignant in recent times. Perhaps it wasn't too earth-shattering at the time (the split was more sudden than anything else), but it's become so in retrospect.

The Wyatts were firmly in the heel camp, and yet they clicked so well with fans that people began to take note. Pretty much everyone agreed that Bray was one of the most creative souls in company history, and those same folks felt Harper and Rowan could be something special as a tag-team if they were treated well. Hell, Luke might've even become a breakout singles success story if the booking was solid enough.

Harper, Rowan and new monster Braun Strowman were back by Bray's side come the following year. That shouldn't take away from the heart wrenching concept of drastic change WWE kicked off in late-September 2014. Waving goodbye to The Wyatt Family was painful. No-one knew how touching their connection would become though.


2. APA Close Business

APA Faarooq Bradshaw 2002 Split
WWE

Remember that claim about never making people think about the WWE Draft again? It was a little lie. Oops. There's no escape from the Draft. Everyone knows that by now! Seriously though, a long-forgotten moment during the original back in 2002 deserves your tears. It brought the curtain down on some iconic backstage segments for the era, and ended one hell of a party for Faarooq and Bradshaw.

On the 28 March SmackDown, William Regal not so kindly reminded the APA that they'd been placed on different brands. Their run as a mercenary tag team for hire was over, but the pair didn't want to admit it. Being fair, some probs thought Ron Simmons was finished once the Nation Of Domination run ended in 1998. They'd be dead wrong about that - like others, he had more gas in the tank.

Simmons/Faarooq and Bradshaw had one more brawl in their office before closing it for good. Not even Jerry Lawler palming off their emotion by asking if Torrie Wilson ever got naked during a game of strip poker could ruin things completely. Tears fell when Bradshaw turned the, "Come In. We're Open!" sign around to one that said: "Sorry, We're Closed!".

This wasn't a full-time end for the APA. They'd reunite for another run before Bradshaw turned into JBL in early-2004, but it was the end of an era for their hilarious office-with-no-walls skits. The way Faarooq and Bradshaw got ticked off at wrestlers walking in without using the door? Timeless.

There was also a legitimate crack in Bradshaw's voice when he thanked Ron for everything before they went their separate ways.


1. RybAxel Get Shockingly Emotional

Curtis Axel Ryback RybAxel WWE Split
WWE

Some events should be recorded in human history forever. The moon landing, the advent of the internet, RybAxel splitting up. You know, real life-changing stuff. Not many could've been predicting that Ryback and Curtis Axel would top this list, especially given the topic at hand, but here we are. What's more, they really deserve it for the promo both worked on the 6 November 2014 episode of Superstars.

RybAxel worked their final major match as a team on the 18 August Raw. After that, WWE went with Ryback as more of a singles star again, but that didn't mean they had to ignore Axel. On the 'C' show, creative handed the duo some time to explain why they weren't teaming up together anymore. Throughout, they came across as partners of convenience who had become real-life friends.

This is rarely, if ever, brought up as a sad tag split. That might be due to Ryback meme-ing himself post-WWE, or the fact that Curtis was never going to bother the main event spots full time, but it defo deserves a little love in these pages. One could practically feel the friendship these guys had bouncing off the screen. It was one of the most human and relatable moments of the era.

Few will recall it by default because, y'know, Superstars. The ship had sailed on that being an essential part of any wrestling fan's week long before RybAxel called it a day as a unit. Pretty cool to be able to give the team their due though, can't lie.

At least WWE saw fit to give them this moment.

What other WWE breakups were shockingly emotional? For more wrestling content, check out 10 WWE Title Moments You DEFINITELY Can’t Remember and 10 Wrestlers Who Became Everything They HATED! 


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.